After deciding to improve my dinner salads, I contacted Olive & Well. I wouldn't eat a salad for…read moredinner if I didn't like it, so quality ingredients matter a lot. I love their single varietal olive oils from around the world, and also the balsamic vinegars. There's no need to put them in a jar to shake and emulsify, I just put them on the salad. Delicious!

It's a charming boutique store with a charming cashier and owner. Supporting small businesses like…read morethis is totally, the way to go. I'll definitely be back!! Thanks!

I love the Olive Tap!!! Makes me feel like I'm on vacation picking out a speciality item and I'm…read morelocal! The owner is also super sweet and helpful. He recommended the Strawberry White balsamic vinegar. I made Italian sausage and sautéed my sweet peppers and onions in olive oil and a pinch of the strawberry vinegar, OMG!!! Incredible!!! Will always come back here

Delicious option. The peach balsamic was surprisingly good and I can't wait to toss it in a salad!…read moreThe young lady working was very helpful and made great recommendations.

The sales woman was great! She let us sample and made some…read moregreat suggestions! I understand they moved from Broad st. Should've kept the name. Will be back!!

My husband and I went here for the first time, last Saturday. The staff is super friendly and…read morethere's so many different varieties of olive oil to choose from. The best part is that you get to taste before you buy. Cute little shop amongst the tourist sprawl in downtown lake Geneva. We ended up walking out with the large bottle of garlic olive oil (pictured). It is AMAZING. I used it in cooking shrimp. Delicious! If I'm in the area again I will definitely be stopping in for more. Recommended!

Extremely attentive and helpful staff. You won't feel too overwhelmed shopping here and you will…read morehave so much to explore. All with a friendly face to help guide you

The best olive oil and balsamic vinegar selection in Chesterton!…read moreWe love the evoo infused with rosemary and their very basic, light olive oil. Good to Go has so many other options, too, for cooking and gift giving. Very, very impressed.

Best olive oil and vinegar hands down. I originally found them at the farmers market and have been…read morea loyal customer ever since. Great service, great product and a lovely comfortable and clean store. Highly recommend! I also love that they have a variety of sizes and a small size that work great as a stocking stuffer for adults. I've heard they have classes and events in their space that are really fun too. Can't wait to join one :)

From the owner: 20% of Profits Donated to Charity, Outwardly Focused. read more

I've been to all of the Oro di Oliva locations and all locations are consistent with friendly and…read moreknowledgeable staff. I love being able to taste the different olive oils and balsamic vinegars, always appreciative of the staff recommendations that day. I was surprised how busy it was when I went in but given the quality and amazing prices & service, I shouldn't have been. Everything in the store was clean and the women who work here are so helpful. There are so many flavors to choose from and ways to use the oils & vinegars so it's great having these experts in the store. I went in specifically for the green chili olive oil and truffle salt but also left with herbs of Napoli balsamic (yum!). Customer appreciation sale saved me 20% so how could I not take advantage of that? Checkout was a breeze and I also made sure to get my card stamped because we all know I'll be back for more!

Great service! Jane is knowledgeable, warm and patient. She's lets you try many of the oils and…read morevinegars and helps you understand them more. I've turned into a regular customer. High quality products where you can taste the difference from other oils.

When my mom comes to town, this is a must stop for her. She loves Olive Cart and always walks out…read morethe door happy. Victoria was in the store today and she was super helpful. My mom was able to redeem the promotion of "finish the punch card, get a free item". I don't remember what the stipulations of those cards are but she uses them every time she comes in, so if you think you could become a regular, I would recommend one. If you enjoy cooking and experimenting im the kitchen, this is a fun place to visit to help you do just that. I've come here dozens of times over the years, both with my mom and with my best friend, and Olive Cart has never disappointed. They still have Covid measures going so don't forget your mask when visiting here, or downtown in general. Some stores are allowing vaccinated people not to and others aren't so it's best to keep them handy like we have been.

One of the few tourist traps worth sticking the toes into, I had never been around this tiny fun…read moretown before and was introduced to quaint old fashioned streets the past weekend, colder weather gave us plenty of parking. Trotted over to the main drag of a whole two blocks to check out the game as well as variety stores, both fun tips too, but this place stood out as unique and something cleverly suited to my tastes, literally! I doubt most people would think they need to check out an aged olive extract bottle shop that isn't wine but I'm entirely more for this place than any cellar! The variety, flavors, and quality is rich and endlessly tickling taste buds. We had good fun sampling about ten, any worked for me, but it wasn't until I dropped some Huckleberry into my amount that I realized I would be buying. Tasted like a superior crafted jam, now eager to try it on everything from eggs to meats to salads, prices are a tad high but they offer a rewards program oddly stuck to old fashioned punch cards rather than integrated with the payment like Toast. I can't figure out why these summer centric sellers all along the street haven't banned together to promote a combined loyalty system that builds up for free products and perks for those frequenting this area.

I was looking for holiday gifts for our family and drove past this place so I figured I had to…read morecheck it out! It smells wonderful when you walk in, and the layout encourages you to check out every option they provide. You can taste most of the oils, and they have some pre-bottled options you can grab and go. I also really appreciate that they have gift boxes prepped, including some that provide a recipe you can use the oils to create! We can't wait to give our gifts, and now we have some new bbq sauce to try! The store has a direct supply relationship with a farm in Italy.

I love this place. Their flavored vinegars make THE best salad dressings…read more In case you don't know, the olive oils in the store are cut with other cheaper oils. The oils here are pricey but healthy and delicious