Phenomenal pizza!! We've eaten from there twice and both times have been a stellar experience. The…read morefirst time, we got The Supreme Leader and as someone who generally doesn't care much for most retail pizza... I was sad when this one was gone. From the pepperoni to the sausage, to the wild mushrooms, to the cheese, sauce, and dough, the quality shines. In a world where Pizza Hut and other fast food pizza places are charging ridiculous prices for sub-par products... I wanted to shout at this place and tell them to take ALL my money!!! The second time, we decided to do a half and half specialty of both the Supreme Leader and My Honey is Hotter than Yours, which featured pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, Calabrian chilies, basil and cilantro, as well as local hot honey. Best. Of. Both. Worlds. My only negative would be that I wish they offered larger than a 16 inch so there's leftovers for lunch the next day. 10/10... I'd absolutely recommend this place if you're looking for wood fired pizza that's worth what you pay for it.

Great spot for wood fired pizza, chicken wings were incredible in the Alabama white sauce. Poxza…read morewas tasty, thin crust, good flavor. Atmosphere is low key, laid back on the square.

All I can say is WOW! My daughter and I came here on the recommendation of an employee at an…read moreantique shop nearby. We were told that there is sometimes a wait for tables and I can understand why! We arrived around 3:30 pm so we were able to get in right away. Our server was attentive and friendly. We both got sandwiches rather than pizza and they were soooooo good! I got the BBQ turkey sub, which included turkey, bbq sauce, caramelized onions, cheddar jack cheese, and bacon on a hearty, tasty French bread sub roll. The flavors went together extremely well, with a touch of sweetness. My daughter got the meatball sub and was over the moon with the size and taste of the meatballs. It's a fun place with local art in a historic building. I highly recommend it!

Went for a quick lunch date on Saturday. Staff were super friendly and we were sat immediately! The…read morefood came out fast and was so good! It all tasted so fresh! Would definitely recommend!

Everything was great. Very nice atmosphere and always greeted by the host/hostess entering the…read morerestaurant. Where I sit at their comfortable bar or one of the tables I always get great service. The food is prepared quickly and always delicious.

We heard it was the best pizza in Gainesville so we had to try it. Nestled downtown on a block of…read morecolonial style buildings occupied by various businesses. The atmosphere is welcoming and casual with abundant seating indoors and outdoors. I love the different seating areas, the bar, dining room, booths. We were seated right away and our server Olivia was very friendly and accommodating. She recommended the Holy Shitaki pizza and we added the Mighty Meat & Pacific Rim to complete our order. The flavors of the pizzas were fantastic and the dough delightful. We also enjoyed a chocolate cookie for dessert. My daughter's favorite was the Holy Shitaki and we did regret not getting a large order. We will definitely be back for it. Overall 10 out of 10 recommended. If you're ever in Gainesville stop by Mellow Mushroom. It will not disappoint!

If I could, I would give Cotto 6 stars. Located in the historic square in Gainesville, GA, Cotto…read moreModern Italian restaurant was one of the best dinners we've had in a long time. Compared to south Florida's cost of living, the pricing is surprisingly inexpensive for the quality and service. We brought our standard poodle with us, since we were on vacation. We enjoyed their outdoor seating, which was spacious and relaxing. We were welcomed and really made to feel at home. For my south Florida friends, if you are passing through north Georgia, Cotto's should definitely be on your itinerary.

Atmosphere is beautiful! My husband and I have been there several times celebrating special events…read moreand taking guests and friends as well... only disappointment is the hit or miss service. Starts out great and then declines:(

Peyton's Pie Company is a must for anyone wanting a delicious pie and pie options that are familiar…read moreas well as different. Although all are great, our favorites are the Supreme Leader as well as My Honey is Hotter Than Yours. With all the pizza options around, Peyton's Pie is by far the best of the best!

Fun small town pizza shop where you can customize your pizza or choose their curated menu. Pizzas…read moreare cooked in a wood fire own! Service is fast and friendly.

Stopped in recently and had a really solid experience overall…read more The staff stood out right away--friendly, attentive, and made everything feel easy without being overbearing. The appetizers were a great start--everything we tried was fresh, flavorful, and set the tone for the meal. The smash burger was a highlight. Great flavor, well-cooked, and had that perfect balance of crispy edges and juiciness. The pizza was also impressive--fresh, well-prepared, and clearly made with quality ingredients. Good texture on the crust and consistent flavor throughout. Overall, a strong spot with good food and great service. Definitely worth checking out.

So I've been to a few different Johnny's locations and it is usually pretty good pizza. They have a…read morefood vendor truck at a local race track and honestly the pizza you get there is phenomenal either because we're starving or it's actually just that good especially being from an event vendor. Now, my main reasoning for my score here is the "Pizza Margherita" I ordered. To me this is a cheese pizza with a few lazy slices of basil. It is an insult to the Italian flag calling this a Margherita but to be fair it does say New York Style so maybe this is their take. Any "The Office" fans? Anyway, overall not bad but for the money I was hoping for a more traditional version. It did have good tomato flavor and the ratios seemed well. I ordered a side of the mozzarella sticks and garlic cheese bread I think it is called. Both highly underwhelming and would not try either again. The sticks tasted frozen and the bread seemed like a loaf was sliced, "Jarlic" and butter added with a foot of cheese melted on the top. Not really anything I couldn't do better and easier at home. As for the pizza itself, we will return, I just won't opt for the Pizza Margherita next time. It's still better than any of the major delivery chains. The thing is Gainesville has so many competitive pizza options I won't name drop here because you already know them and the competition is fierce. So to stay in the fight, you they may need some additional commitment.

I ordered a deep dish Spinach and Goat Cheese pizza and a regular build your own original crust…read more(sausage snd mushroom) from Manhattan Chicago Pizzeria. The build your own wasn't much better than a frozen pizza I could've bought at the grocery..however, the deep dish Spinach and Goat Cheese was unique and tasty. Although I could not taste the goat cheese, which is odd given the strong distinct taste it normally has, this pizza was good. If I ever go back, it's definitely what I would order.

I never received my three garlic rolls. The caesar salad was brown and translucent from being…read morefrozen. Inedible. I didn't know that pizza crust could be burnt and soggy at the same time but this one was. The pasta was overcooked and under seasoned. I order delivery about twice a week every week and this was by far the WORST food I've ever received. When i reached out to them they refused to give me a refund on any of it.