INY Pizza has stepped up their game over the last few months, and they deserve some love. We have dined in and grabbed some to go orders, and the food quality has been much better than in the years past. The pizza crust on their pies is spectacular!! It has just the right amount of chew and body. I have had a few different flavors of their wings, and they have all been great as well. The service is more consistent, and they seem to be more dialed in these days when it comes to trying to grow and make the business thrive. Give these guys a shot! read more

Found this restaurant looking for a lunch spot after my husband participated in an event at Atlanta Motorsports Park. We arrived at 1:30pm and it was empty. Dining area was clean and we sat at a high top table. There is patio seating and I saw a sign advertising another larger dining area for large groups or private parties. Two restrooms, one for women and one for men, while clean it seemed like too few for this size establishment. Our server was young and quiet, almost as if she was inconvenienced we arrived during a slow time. She wrote our order down, didn't make any suggestions or recommendations trying to upsell. Our appetizers came out quickly with the pizzas and calzones following not long after. My daughters loved their white pizza (plenty of ricotta). My husband and youngest each got a calzone. We had plenty for leftovers to take home too. No gluten free pizza options (which was a huge bummer for me). read more

See all

I've had a lot of good meatball subs in my time; this was not among them. Never have I ever seen a meatball sub where the meatballs were cut in half! This is essentially a half a sub worth of meatballs on a full bun. Even the marinara sauce was skimped on, and how much are they saving by being stingy with that? Not only isn't it a good sandwich, because it's basically half a sandwich, it's really priced at twice what it should be. Won't be back here again. read more

This is the place I had no idea I'd been searching for! We showed up on a Sunday afternoon with a party of 12 and they were easily able to accommodate. Nicole was our server and she was pleasant and prompt. Now, the pizza... we had 3 different ones and they were each delicious. This is NY style for sure. Thin slices, crispy crust, not too much sauce... great. They also have a full bar, so you'll be able to get anything there. I was pleased at the selection and everyone was able to find something they liked. There's a pool table, darts and some gaming machines if you want something fun to do. I'll be back for sure! read more

I have never been here before. I asked for a cheese pizza. They gave me a humungous pepperoni pizza. Like really??? Just pick somewhere else read more

I Love NY Pizza - The pepperoni I did not ask for. I hope it keeps you up at night. - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

The food was amazing the service was great and the musician was fantastic will be visiting again read more

I Love NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

If I could leave 0 stars I would. I asked for a slice I got a Tostitos heat up pizza with fake cheese Then I look over to my left and another party has a real pizza with real cheese Hmmm I wonder if it's because of my skin color nevertheless, it's pitiful that you would serve someone this & the live music is absolute deafening to the ear is literal ear rape. 0/10 across the board THEN the waitress said I gave you this because we didn't have slices so I just gave you KIDS cheese pizzas because it's cheaper, who said I needed something cheaper ? Ok strike 1. Why would you not tell me slices aren't available and make a decision for me without telling me when I ordered 3 slices of pizza, Strike 2. I'm just trying to figure out how any of this made sense but ALL I can say is maybe they were racist I hope no one EVER eats here , terrible terrible TE R R I B L E read more

I Love NY Pizza - I asked for a slice they gave me a Tostitos heat up pizza... terrible I guess this a slice - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

Their Department of Health reviews have been reported as consistently low since new management took over.i.e. a few months were a 69 and a 61, in the Dawson News. We "heard" service was slow or not there. We used to go alot under the original owners! read more

We've been getting pizza from here for a few years now. We are originally from New York, so this pizza is the best around. Today we decided to dine in, as we haven't eaten inside the restaurant in a long time. The Atmosphere just felt different. It was empty but very messy. There were less options on the menu than I remember. The food didn't seem restaurant worthy, but more like cafeteria food. I'm not sure what changed, but I don't like it. The bathrooms were also less clean than they used to be. There aren't many options for food in this little town without driving to 400, so you'd think the owners would make it nice enough for people to want to come there. Staff was pleasant. read more

First off, the pizza is good so you won't be let down! Big and cheesey! Taste just like the one I had when visiting New York so that's a plus. The employees were very helpful and gave me that family warm welcoming. Game area for kids and big TVs soooo yep! I definitely recommend if you're in Dawsonville or passing through! read more

We had to online order through doordash (the only option) and as my daughter was waiting for the pizzas they said doordash canceled the order (doordash showed no such thing) so THEY THREW THE PIZZAS AWAY, and told us tough luck. Will not be back. read more

Great atmosphere! Great pizza and salads. Music is always good and loud. The staff are fun and friendly! read more

See all

I'm not sure why the reviews seem to be mixed here. I had a pickup order and service was friendly and prompt. The restaurant itself was very clean, and there were a few patrons watching sports at the bar. The food was good, a very normal yet fresh neighborhood pizza gig. read more

See all

I'm going to start with the fact we had a large party because of kindergarten graduation. we called ahead of time to reserve spots. we got there put our tables together outside because there was a large poker game going on. for what was going on in the community they were short staffed. Michelle and Brian stepped up and took care of us along with the younger guy bringing out our food. they had big tables inside and they had us outside. they powered through and earned more than a tip! they deserve a raise! if they continue to work there we will be back. I love Michelle and Brian! read more

Hey y'all I love pizza. When I say I love pizza I LOVE PIZZA. This pizza had the perfect crunch, almost melting in your mouth. This pizza had me on my knees crying about how good it was. I have never put something so good into my esophagus. I love NY Pizza. read more

I Love NY Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

Great service, atmosphere and pizza!!! What a nice lady behind the bar!! Clean bathroom and perfect cool temperature!!!

We have always had good service and food from here. My husband likes the calzone but that's way too much for me. I asked for a special order, something not on the menu, and now they make it for me all the time. That's great service. Sauce is good. Not too acidic. They put a lot of toppings on their pizzas and have great crust. read more

This was a great pizza place until the new owners took over. We picked up a pizza to go and when we got home it was not what we ordered. We ordered a veggie and it only had 2 veggies on it and no sauce. It was horrible! The bottom was black and burned and the dough was soggy in the middle. They also rarely answer their phone anymore. Will never go back! read more

Was eating pizza and drinking on a MONDAY night with my boyfriend and my dad. My dad made a joke about getting "a free bucket of beer", pure joke, however this caused the bartender SAMANTHA to turn into a complete witch. After not saying another word to her, or to anyone else, except to apologize for the joke not landing, her and her boyfriend then spent the whole rest of the night constantly threatening to bash a bottle over my boyfriend's head, threatening my dad, degrading me, shouting the "N" word at all of us, turning the music completely up in the restaurant so no one could hear each other talking, etc. Samantha should no longer be employed here after using the language she did to paying customers. Her and her boyfriends' attitude were entirely uncalled for. read more

We have been going to Dawsonville for over three years now every week. prices have just gone way too high. You pay for a large and you get a medium. Too many other joints in the area. read more

Had a Saturday afternoon order and we were not disappointed. Everything was hot, correct, and the crust was great. I haven't had dine in but overall we were happy with our pizzas and look forward to our next order. read more

Well, ever since the new foreign owners have taken over, it's hard to get through on the phone for a pickup order as one of the people stay on the phone in the back. This is the second time it's happened. The first time, I tried to get through until I decided to just drive there (10-15 minute drive there) and showed that I was trying to call and it was still busy, none of the regular workers knew why. A few minutes later, after another went searching, a guy comes walking out of the back dining area, it was obvious that he was the one on the phone as it went through when I tried again. Kind of a strange business strategy as cell phones are pretty accessible. Oh well. Try another place, I guess. read more

Love the bartender and the pizza! Ask for Jess! It's a quiet little bar and they have game nights and live music

Service was great. Ambience excellent. Pizza so-so. Too many onions and a little greasy on my deluxe.

If you1 are looking for real New York style Pizza this is your place!!! Calzone and Stromboli were amazing and the Pizza was the real deal. Our hostess Stacia was absolutely precious!!! read more

See all

Food = yumm Service = pretty guuuud Ambience = cool especially on a calm slow night, and I particularly loved the area by the stage read more

We had a great dine-in experience today starting with the phenomenal host, nice ambiance & lovely music. Wings came out with perfect favor, pizza was crispy and Stromboli was amazing. They have also introduced new menu recently, our kids enjoyed yummy chocolate shortcake. Overall, totally worth the trip! read more

So to start the pizza was HORRIBLE. All the bad reviews on here hit the nail on the head. It was undercooked and reminded me of frozen pizza, not fresh, and definitely not New York style. (I'm from Jersey so claiming a NY style pizza is a big claim). The Stromboli was not great either. First they gave us a raw one (dough raw in the center and the mozzarella cheese still cold in the center as well). After sending it back they remade it. The flavor was there but in the whole Stromboli (for $11) there was maybe three mini meatballs. The ends were solid dough and it was okay. I wouldn't order it again but we did finish it. The wings were on point though (only reason they got a 2 star rating instead of one star). The server after being the food was not to be seen from again until check time. We actually had to grab another server completely to handle the undercooked food and we never got refills on any of our beverages even though they sat empty for a while. The restaurant itself was decorated cute, and other people orders the Philly and fries (those looked like they had us thinking we made bad decisions). I wanted to like this place but it was just seriously sub par. read more

I Love NY Pizza - How wings - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

See all

Arrived about 5:15 on Wednesday evening. Paid $22 bucks and waited my 30 minutes. 1 gummy, uncooked pizza that's stuck and oozing through the box. Maybe you'll have better luck. read more

I Love NY Pizza - Uncooked and stuck - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

See all

Stopped in today for lunch and was very glad we did. We tried the fried ravioli and lemon pepper wings. The wings was cooked perfect and the flavor was great. The raviolis did not have much flavor and was really crispy. The sauce was very good. It is like southern Italian style, rich and thick with a ton of flavor. The pizza was very good. Crispy crust and light with a good taste. We tried the chicken parmigiana sandwich as well. The bread was fresh and topped with parmigiana cheese and garlic. This was a very good sandwich. The sauce was again very flavorful on the sandwich and paired well with the mozzarella cheese. My favorite thing was the sausage and pepperoni Stromboli. The bread was tender and had the right amount of oven char with a good amount of meats and cheese inside. Service was good and the interior had a nice vibe to it. Can't wait to go back! read more

While the pizza is great subs are amazing don't get the gyro it's garbage. Lamb was Burt (if you could find it ) was terrible didn't even finish it. Called them to let them know the frys where burnt as well read more

See all

Staff is always great, live music sometimes, I enjoy the pizza! Also, there are pool tables and such...it's just cool

Pizza is good when it's not burnt or gooey, Gyros are terrible. Chicken was either old or overcooked, super dry and the tzatziki sauce was not even a sauce. It was a water downed dill liquid, absolutely disgusting! read more

See all

Came in for dinner tonight about 630 and it was horrible!!! The waitress herself was nice and kept our cups full but the kitchen staff is definitely CRAP!! Got my order wrong twice... ordered 20 wings half and half flavor and got all 1 flavor the 2nd order which was suppose to he lemon pepper came out with Buffalo sauce with the seasoning of lemon pepper on it(which i didnt eat, just asked for a box to go home cause i was fed up and ready to go at that point)... I didnt say anything as it had already took forever for the 2nd order to come out. It's sad when you have to go pay for other food thru drive thru after spending 60 bucks at the first place... I won't be returning back here again.... not to mention the staff is very unprofessional and loud.... read more

Great food, the sauce was so fresh! The service was friendly and the ambience was relaxing.

I was truly impressed with my pizza! I ordered a pepperoni, green pepper and onion pizza. The crust was spot on for a New York style pizza. The sauce was tasty and didn't drown out the other flavors of the pizza. I was thrilled to know they use thin slices of white onion on their pizzas. The bake on the pie was perfect with a bottoms crust that was thin but held up well with all of the ingredients. The staff is terrific! Cold beer on tap and they mentioned some drink specials if you're interested. Next time I'm saving room for dessert too. I saw a couple delivered to tables and looked delicious! read more

I'm from NJ and NY where arguably the best pizza outside of Italy is created. I was delighted when NY opened and even more so when the pie tasted like it came from home. We go quite often and almost every time everything is awesome. Every once in a while they miss the mark but overall still 5 stars compared to every other pizza biz around. Wings are great, calzones as well, salads are very large, sandwiches pretty good and service is down south friendly and attentive. read more

Great little place with very good pizza and Awesome salads. The atmosphere is always fun.

Love NY Pizza...it's local and the pizza is great! Full bar inside and patio seating on good weather days. Must try!

Just no. Never.we gave the place 2 chances and not impressed. If you have children, I'm guessing they would love the simple cheese pizza.