I never received my three garlic rolls. The caesar salad was brown and translucent from being frozen. Inedible. I didn't know that pizza crust could be burnt and soggy at the same time but this one was. The pasta was overcooked and under seasoned. I order delivery about twice a week every week and this was by far the WORST food I've ever received. When i reached out to them they refused to give me a refund on any of it. read more

Manhattan Chicago Pizzeria - Rotten lettuce - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Georgia

I ordered a deep dish Spinach and Goat Cheese pizza and a regular build your own original crust (sausage snd mushroom) from Manhattan Chicago Pizzeria. The build your own wasn't much better than a frozen pizza I could've bought at the grocery..however, the deep dish Spinach and Goat Cheese was unique and tasty. Although I could not taste the goat cheese, which is odd given the strong distinct taste it normally has, this pizza was good. If I ever go back, it's definitely what I would order. read more

Manhattan Chicago Pizzeria - Spinach, Goat Cheese and Mozzarella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Georgia

Great pizza, reasonably priced and served in a timely manner. Highly recommend. The folks who run it seem kind as well. read more

Manhattan Chicago Pizzeria - a deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Georgia

Sauce and meat was great! We order a Chicago style pizza expecting a true deep dish....pic below??? The crust was still raw as was the pizza pinwheels and the regular pizza as well. I would hope this means their oven is going out but pizza was horrible and a waste of $53!! read more

Manhattan Chicago Pizzeria - Chicago sytle??? - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Georgia

Very good pizza. Will definitely recommend and eat there again. Really want to try the deep dish. Subs look amazing as well.

We have ordered food a few times and are very happy with their food and service highly recommended. Support local biz its owners and employees. read more

The worst pizza I've ever been served. We picked up a large with mushrooms and sausage . When we got home and opened the box it was burnt, dried out with shriveled up mushrooms. We took it back and they refused to issue me a credit. First time trying this restaurant and will never again. Don't eat here!!! read more

Good pizza, my only comment... sauce was a bit salty... but was good Chicago pizza...

This would have to go up a couple of notches to be awful. We ordered a Chicago style pizza and the website said it would be ready in 45-50 minutes. When we arrived, 50 minutes later, they said it would be ready in about another 10 minutes. After going to the grocery store, we came back and it was STILL not ready. When they did give it to us, it was not hot and was basically just an overcoat of Mozzarella. I have been to New York and Chicago and this was not as good as a walk-up pizza place there. Never, ever again. read more

Very disappointed. Ordered grandmas pizza, after waiting over 1 jr to be cooked, still raw. Airfry wings were more like microwaved inedible. Caprise Salad had soggy tomatoes, barely any mozzarella, and moldy basil also inedible. Chef offered us chicken Parm for our wait and it was ok but spaghetti had no sauce. Overall we will put this Restuarant on the no fly list. $45.90 later. Told Manager I would bring back food and show what his staff put out and all he could offer was another pizza. Gave you four trys and you failed no thanks. read more

Service was good. We ordered one regular pizza with pepperoni and sausage as well as a Chicago pizza. We really didn't care for either one. We felt the crust had no flavor. Toppings were good and sauce was ok. For me the crust needs to have flavor and this was lacking. read more

Don't bother listening to other folks talking about customer service and what not. This is the only Chicago style pizza in the area and it is bomb read more

I tried to order a pizza here on Saturday Feb 23rd but was told that it would be 3 hours, so I left. On Sunday the 24th, I called at 5:30 PM and ordered a 16 inch pizza and garlic rolls. Mind you, I did not order a Chicago deep dish, just a regular pizza. I was told it would be 40-45 minutes. I got there at 6:25 PM. Waited, waited, and finally after asking, was told at 7PM that I would have my pizza. The owner had to make it as it was him, a lady working the front, and a guy making pizzas. They also almost forgot my garlic rolls. Two hours after I first ordered, at 7:30 PM, I was out the door with my food. The garlic rolls had too much garlic and were bitter. The pizza was okay. The next day, my wife and I both had stomach issues. I blame the garlic rolls. I know they just opened but I don't know that I can eat there again after getting sick. read more

Well I can't review the pizza because I never received the pizza I ordered and they charged my credit card anyway. Don't order a pizza for delivery here if you actually want to receive an actual pizza! What a rip-off!!! read more

This place is not the most efficient in terms of getting quick pizza. However, it's amazing pizza. It is absolutely worth the wait. The Chicago is great- just call about an hour ahead or so. The owners are super nice. All the dough and sauce are made in house. It's a great pizza place. read more

Wha a disappointment ! Took forever to make then when finally got it I was so hungry that I went ahead and ate the worst pizza I've ever had. The name suggests that you'll get a pizza like up north. I'm not a snooty ex northerner there are plenty of good pizzas in the south. Don't waste your time and money on this place. read more

This is the LAST time I order from here. Was a huge fan when they 1st opened. Tonight was the the last straw. Ordered a side of Meatballs with one of my meals and what was served was still cold (microwaved) meatballs that You can buy at the grocery store. I ordered a large pizza with extra cheese and what I got was a cold ( looked like it had been sitting in the box all day) pizza with was barely enough cheese to call it a pizza. Unorganized, bad food, cold food. This place started on top but is a steady progression to the bottom. read more

Good authentic NY and Chicago style pizza. Hard to find in Gainesville. Will be coming back!

Ordered the "Chicago" deep dish. The flavor was great but in no means was that a Chicago style pizza. It has the tall crust but was not filled. In fact it was only a regular pizza inside the crust all for the amazing price of $28. Won't be ordering from them again. read more

Amazing. I can't believe we have pizza this good in Gainesville. I was skeptical at first because it's located on the side of Ingles across from a retirement center on the quiet side of town...but I am so glad I listen to a recommendation from someone who was originally from CT. They were right...it is JUST like NY style pizza. Haven't tried the Chicago style yet, but I will be back...and often. My gosh it is delicious! read more

Worst. Place. Ever. Make your own pizza, hell, buy some prego sauce and put it over spaghetti and it will be 1000000x better than this excuse of an Italian place. read more

The Chicago style pizza is legit. By far the best pizza I've had in town. Takes longer to make but it's worth the wait.

Yeah , quite a wait but worth it ! They're hiring more people to keep up with the demand and the Chicago Deep Dish pizza will make your mouth water ! They never expected how well it would be received but , I'm sure they will catch up soon ! Highly recommended ! read more

Ordered from here twice now using delivery. Both times we've had issues. First time they forgot half of our order. Second time we ordered at 6:13pm and didn't get our food delivered till 2 hours later. Food is good, service not so great. DON'T do delivery. Not worth it!!! Very slow. And we just ordered the regular NY style pizza. Disappointed!!!! read more

If they didn't forget my extra topping and throw the raw mushrooms on top of my pizza after it was cooked I'd give them a 4, but that wasn't nice. They did own up to it and gave my topping money back, but I shouldn't have had to ask... Cheese was a little salty too, but all in all much better than the typical chain pizza. read more

The Chicago Deep Dish was absolutely delicious!! It was what I expected and more! So long fast food pizza. Manhattans will get all of our family pizza business from here on out! Highly recommended for those looking for pizza for dinner. read more

Best Pizza in Gainesville! We LOVE their NY thin pizza but their Chicago deep dish pizza is also great and very different! They also have great Pastas and the rolls are fantastic. Everything here is delicious! read more

Tried the Chicago style Spinach, Mozzarella & Goat Cheese - easily one the best things I've ever eaten in my life. I'm excited to try more of the menu. read more

Great food if the right people are working. The owner is a great guy, but not the guy working August 9th. I tried to call and order a pizza three times. First call he answers and right after I say I want to order a pizza for pickup *click*. I thought maybe it was a fluke so I called back a second time. When I said I just called and the last call must've been dropped *click*. Now I was mad! Only got him to answer one more time and sure enough the second he heard my voice *click*. After that he wouldn't answer the phone. So I drove over and confronted him about it. His excuse was that the phone line was messing up and dropping calls all day. I know how unlikely that is since it's a landline and I literally heard the phone being hung up. So I decided to hang out, order some wings and see what the deal was. Twice the phone rang while I was sitting in the front and he just walked away and would not answer the phone while I was there. Then I heard some children in the back of the kitchen and some other adult voices telling them to be quiet. Then right when my wings were done another guy just walked on out. No idea if he was an employee or not though. If he was that's just sad that between two people they won't answer the phone and just hang up on customers! You better believe that when I left I called back and sure enough he decided to answer now that I was gone. I returned the favor and hung up on him. read more