Came home to visit from TN and this does not do NY pizza justice. Do not order the pizza. The chicken tenders and blue cheese hit the spot but the pizza was terrible. The white pizza was just cheese. Anywhere else it has garlic sauce, onions and tomatoes. This was just cheese breadsticks no sauce just dry ass pizza. read more

4.5 star overall experience! Wow! Yummy! $36 getting the $29.99 14 inch pizza 12 wing special adding on taxes, extra cheese, and an extra ranch. 5 star wings! You get 12 perfectly cooked crispy extra saucy delicious wings with a large Delicious ranch or blue cheese. Top notch. Literally finger licking good. 4.5 star pizza! Really great sauce, cheese, pepperoni, and dough. Only slight complaint was it wasn't cut very well and we were eating it as a picnic at the lake with no silverware or napkins so we were just tearing it with our hands. Messy haha. 5 star service from guy. Super friendly knowledgeable guy helped me order on the phone without a menu and it being our first time there. 4.5 star service from girl. She first accidentally rang us up for the wrong special ($50 something) which is an easy mistake, we corrected her and she fixed it. We didn't get any napkins, wet wipes, or plastic silverware in our to go bag which made a picnic eating wings and pizza not cut all the way through in some spots very tricky to eat haha. We were literally sucking the amazing sauces off of our fingers. 5 star cleanliness 5 star location in a plaza downtown(4 1/2 min easy drive from Barcelona lighthouse) 4.5 star prices (pretty fair, especially for 12 wings and large ranches) read more

See all

Aside from the server being efficient and friendly, and the place being clean and welcoming, the pizza and garlic knots here are perhaps the best we've ever had. My husband had the meat loaded pizza and I had the bbq chicken (and at my request, some pineapple as well). The pizzas were so delicious with the house made pizza dough and loaded with toppings -- especially the cheese! Our only complaint is that we are about 500 miles from CJ's, so a bit far for us to go often. read more

We love ordering pizza from here. Excellent pizza and the customer service is amazing.

Great food here and the service was top notch. So happy after our visit and our 5 mile morning kayaking trip on Lake Erie. What a nicely done place with fair pricing and excellent food. The woman serving was excellent and very positive and so nice. Thanks for making our visit to your area extra great with your cool restaurant. We ended having a small sub, a bbq chicken wrap and then later a small pizza to partially eat and save for later dinner since we had a 1.5 drive back to Ohio. It was all great food and excellent service! And the decor and finishings of the restaurant were really nice. Looks like the building may have had town history but this place was so well done. Highly recommended. And will be back if in town again. read more

As I sit here waiting on 2 subs and a small pizza, I'm wondering why I even bothered. It is now 7:01 and considering I called it in at 5:55!!! My husband is home waiting on supper and I used to love the food and people of this place yet I have to say this is downright ridiculous when u sit here n here orders been called in and u watch them arrive get their food pay their bill leave and u remain sitting here!!! Never again for $40 nope not me so good luck to all who have the time because I don't! read more

I 10/10 recommend eating here. I am always nervous about ordering a non pizza item at a pizza place but I was pleasantly surprised by my chicken chipotle wrap. It was fulled up with all the ingredients and tasted amazing. the chips provided on the side are light and crispy and delicious! read more

I love CJs but I hate their hours on the weekends. I do not live in Westfield and I only come on the weekends. They don't open until 3 on Saturdays and they don't open until 3 I believe on Sundays and I am already gone by then. I am an early riser and 3o'clock is too late to have to wait to go get something to eat, most places are open at 11. This disappoints me because I love their food. My favorite of course, is their pepperoni balls. They are soft and warm and fresh and the pepperoni is perfectly mild. It is exploding with gooey mozzarella and I usually pair them with a side of ranch. Its hard for me to just get one order because I know that later at night I will be craving them again. They also have very good pizza. Their sub sandwiches are a little small but fair for their price. I wish upon wishes that they had real honey mustard, the honey mustard they have is orange and a little tangy . Honey mustard is supposed to be a beautiful, golden, light yellow with the perfect blend of mustard and honey. It keeps me from ordering subs here because I like to dip my subs in real honey mustard. They have an option of a pretzel rolls which I've never had but my girlfriend gets all the time, she loves it. I will continue going to CJ's but I wish they did a couple things differently specifically being open more! Keep up the good work CJS :-) read more

Cj's Pizza & Subs - Balls for all! - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New York

Really like the woman owner but boy the guy is a DICK. The food is ok for the price and the ambiance is family. I wouldn't waste my time here cause the owner is RUDE. read more

Excellent pizza. Best I have had in a long time. Generous toppings. Asked for crispy crust and they did it very well. Only problem is I ate too much! read more

Fantastic spot in downtown, if you didn't know it was there you'd never notice it. Ordered buffalo chicken ranch pizza just to try something new on a whim, it was great. For the high quality of the ingredients it's a much better value than other pizzerias. Definitely a new favorite spot in the north county! read more

Located in Westfield, this has become a staple pizza and sub shop for our family. Just 30 seconds off path, and on main st., we came to know of CJs at the annual craft fair in town. They were selling slices and pizza balls (dough filled with cheese and pepperoni served with a side of sauce) and...well...we were starving. We've been back countless times now, ordering chicken finger subs, wraps and other finger apps for the drive home from Chautauqua. They can be a little weird with their hours but they are the best and only pizza/sub shop in Westfield. I'll be a little generous and give them 5/5 because of that. In a town with better options, they'd still be at least a 4...but it's Westfield and well, it's a small town. read more

Best chicken wings for miles! Pizza is incredible, nothing bad to say, they nailed it all! My Sweetheart Rose loves the Tony's Torpedo sub! Dad says their the best for miles! Mom says when I get done with work we can have extra blue cheese if I rake! Papa says their the best for miles! read more

Solid and friendly and close enough to I-90 for a quick bite. Pizza is doughy but good. Creative subs and sandwiches are worth a try too. A large pizza, two sandwiches, and a 2 liter coke were just over $20 too! read more

I always visit CJ's when I come back to Westfield. I live in NYC and nothing stands up to a CJ's pepperoni slice.

Another great experience and great food. We got the calzone (Leone) and it was amazing. My wife and I split that and it was more than enough. We also split the Tony's Torpedo and it was great. We had to get some more of those homemade potato chips. This has quickly become a favorite for my wife and I to enjoy a meal together. read more

We have now eaten here twice on drives along I-90 from Pittsburgh to Canada. We have enjoyed everything we have ordered. The core of everything is excellent pizza dough (even crust is soft), which they include on pizza, wedges, and 'pepperoni balls' (think of a tennis ball sized pepperoni roll). While we don't make this trip often we always stop in here. The kids love the pepperoni balls. Our lunch for 5 (inc 2 teenaged boys) was $35 which is less than we spend at Wendy's. read more

When I come home to visit my family they automatically know to have CJ's pizza waiting!! I compare all other pizza joints to this place and nothing tops the crust and sauce! I can't even get a pizza sub on the east cost in CT it you can believe that cause they haven't heard of such a thing! God I miss this place! read more

Family owned, everyone was so friendly. Food was great, got a torpedo and pepperoni rolls, both delish!

Great family pizza place. Passed through from out of town. Met the owner and his wife. Very nice people. I definitely recommend this place if you're in the area. And definitely try the chips with melted Bleu cheese and hot sauce. ; ) read more

The pizza was decent. Had fried veggies which were also good. I was a little surprised when we got charged for a glass of water even though we ordered a ton of food and a couple of two liters of pop. Over all, a nice place to eat. read more

Really delicious pizza made by people who really care about their customers. The owner thanked me when I came in to pick up two pizzas ordered to go. Very sweet! read more

Nice little pizza shop. The owners were incredibly nice and really made us feel valued as customers. We had a pizza/wing combo from the menu. Both were good, falling just short of excellent. Our tab (not including tip) was just over $18. Really good, considering three people stuffed their faces for that amount. read more

Was driving home from Buffalo after our sons hockey tournament and found this place on Yelp. AWESOME place, so friendly, make their own chips, pizza was great, salad was great and we had 2 dozen wings, all great. This will be our go to place on all future trips to Buffalo from Northern, VA. Thank you Crazy Joe! :) read more

A W E S O M E F O O D!!! Try the Wedgie! it's a piece of freshly baked flat type bread stuffed with sub fixins - various your choice. A meal for two really. I always order the sweet potato fries. Peperoni balls are great. I heard the pesto pizza was really good. read more

I used to go to cjs all the time before work however they have decided not to open until 3pm everyday now!!!! No where else in westfiend is worth going to and for people who work 2nd shift it makes it impossible. Very upset about this and hope they change it back to normal soon! read more

We stopped here on our way back to Ohio. Delicious pizza and great service! Totally worth a visit.

Great family restaurant! The owners are so nice, and they really care about the quality of their food. The chef Joe is hilarious and really knows what he is doing. My favorite part is the take and bake pizza! It costs less than a frozen pizza at the grocery store and it's 100x's better! Great for party's!! read more

We arrived with 9 people in our party. There were maybe two other parties in the entire restaurant. The owner and waitress complained and told us we should have called ahead so they could have moved tables to accommodate us. Complained and made smart comments the entire time they moved three small tables together. We made several comments about going somewhere else and their attitude seemed to change. Food was average to good. If we had not been on a time schedule, we would have left. Maybe they were just having a bad day. Everyone is entitled to one- but don't take it out on your customers! read more