Great, honest, local diner spot. Solid prices, they have unique items that are near and dear to their customers. Great history on the walls and you can tell it has great bones. Staff is experienced and friendly, super clean and comfortable. Highly recommend and will be a new go to. read more

First time there and had very good service. The French Dip meat was so tender and was excellent with the horseradish mayo. Homemade potato soup was thick, creamy and delicious! The sangria hit the spot! We will definitely be back! read more

I was so disapointed that there isn't better handicap accessible features. I love the food and service but with handicap issues won't be back. Yes, after entering from side door we were told the front door could be opened for us however, we parked in the lot behind the facility. Also, steps to sit in booths... steps to enter side dining area (?(hand rails would be helpful) and steps to go upstairs. It wouldn't take much to correct these issues but until then won't return. read more

Best place to get drinks with food as far as downtown Decatur. Coney McKane's has things like burgers and hot dogs as well as some fancier items. It also has a few options for vegetarians. A kind of cramped place so it always has a crowd. The prices aren't that bad for the quality and service. A lack of fancier restaurants around here in a town that mostly has chains. It's more of a kind of classier sports bar and grill. The atmosphere is pretty good because it's one of the few happening places around here. A place where one can watch a game and get craft cocktails as well as well cooked burgers. There's also plenty of meal sized salads for healthier options. It's about $12 for a basic cocktail. They have a pretty okay amount of spirits including whiskeys. It's about $10 for an Impossible Burger. We got these and had to choose our toppings. Also these come with a side such as fries. Pretty good amount of food for an okay price. Among the other items on the menu is fish. They have plenty of burgers as well as Po Boy sandwiches. Also there's soups and plenty of shareable appetizers. They also have desserts such as pie. For sure it's one of the nicer restaurants in the area. It's closed Sundays and Mondays. There's lots of meaty options and some things for vegetarians. read more

Coney McKane's American Eatery - Whiskey And The Impossible Burger - Burgers Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

On our cross-country road trip Diane and I ate here for lunch, meeting her best friend while a student at McArthur High School in Decatur many years ago. It was our second time at Coney McKane's. Known for its Chili that is only served in a cup size, I ordered two. It was uncharacteristically Pinto Bean centric, very heat hot, and very good. Then I shifted to a cool, very good Medium Chicken Pecan Salad with pieces of tomato, cubes of chicken, and small bits of pecan. My tablemates ordered Coney's Lunch Combo of a Lindy (half-Monte Cristo sandwich), Homemade Potato Chips, and a cup of Potato Soup; and a Lonely Horseshoe. The Horseshoe was invented in Springfield, Illinois and is an open-faced sandwich that usually consists of toasted slices of bread covered by a beef patty, French Fries, and Cheese Sauce. We were all pleased with our selections, and service by Greg B. was very good. read more

See all

One of the best eating places in Decatur, especially if you order coconut cream pie. Highly recommended. Cccccccccccc read more

We had lunch here, Prices are very reasonable & nice atmosphere. Well worth stopping in. Haven't been downtown in long long time. It's very nice area.. read more

Coney McKane's American Eatery - Todays lunch special Meatloaf - Burgers Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

ordered a Cubano sandwich. Served on a Ciabatta bun, which crumbled in my hands.....what a mess. not worth the time to revisit. Mentioned to hostess the disappointment of the "so called Cubano", her response.... That is the way we make it. I thought "Where is my panini press when needed". by the way, not much meat or good sauce from my experience. read more

My "must-have" when I visit my hometown. From quesadillas to salads, they do not miss. Definitely a great lunch option. My faves: southwest egg rolls, buffalo chicken salad and chicken bacon ranch quesadilla. read more

This is my absolute favorite restaurant in Decatur! Everything I've ordered has come out delicious and I've eaten the whole thing! They have a whole vegetarian menu, with a really good fake chicken sandwich and everything. The service is great and food comes out fast. There's a lot of different places to sit and it's a nice vibe inside. They also have a wide variety of pies to choose from for dessert! read more

Have wanted to try this restaurant for some time. Finally got the chance yesterday. The lunch special was Fish and Chips, so I quit looking at the menu! Food came out quickly and was piping hot! The fish was very tasty. The fries are from the freezer...if they used "real" potatoes, this would have been perfect. Dessert was coconut cream pie...so YUM! The crust is flaky and delicious. I'll definitely go back even if just for pie!! read more

Great food! Fast service! Cool eatery! Will go again! Chicken salad croissant was AMAZING ! read more

I travel for out-state to Decatur for work several times a year and I always eat a meal at Coney McKane's. Today I had the El Paso salad which was excellent. The freshly made avocado ranch was especially good. The large size salad was almost too much but of course I ate every bite. The peanut butter pie was the perfect finish. Only reason not 5 stars? I'm particular about iced tea. Every time I forget that the tea is not good. Too bitter and not smooth; strong in all the wrong ways. My first time I thought someone hadn't cleaned out the container. read more

went there a few years ago...food was memorable. now? poor quality...patty melt had 2-3 onions...my guest: had the Cuban. the mayo-mustard was insufficient...the bread crumbled in his hands, swiss chz? very little read more

We truly enjoyed our lunch here. The waitress explained the lunch specials and they sounded great so we each ate a special. I had the fruit plate, the fruit was ripe and delicious and served with chicken salad and crackers. One of the other specials was a taco plate. My hubby enjoyed that. Our waitress even cleared our table and took our picture with our friends. Great time. read more

Most amazing lunch! Excellent service food was delicious. Shout out to the potato soup, the Lindy sandwich and the house made chips. Will definitely return!!! read more

mashed potatoes were instant with cold margarine in the middle of it. They could've had real mashed potatoes for the price. Meatloaf was supposed to be amazing but didnt wow- it was loaf without the meat. Flavor of the hot dog was okay. I don't like any restaurant that likes to tag you over 7 but I understand it, but should be 18% not 20%. Were a little rude to me at the bar but the waiter James was nice and a good waiter. Bosco sticks were good but the sauce was not special. Probably Ragu. Budweiser adequate, but not the coldest ever. French Dip sandwich good. others were impressed with their Gluten Free roll. Green beans had probably sat in the cauldron all day and we got the mush- though they did try with those- had chopped up some onions and had a bit of fat. Sweet tea was good. Carmel Apple Pie was Amazing and the coconuts cream pie also delish. Would go back just for the pie. Not enough to make up for the rest of the sub par pricy meal. Left hungry too. Stoffers meat loaf would've been just as good. read more

See all

I was really hopeful about this restaurant after seeing reviews and getting recommendations from locals. I was quickly disappointed. Not that this place was bad, it just wasn't nearly as good as everyone made it out to be. I ordered a bacon burger. I asked if they're able to make it medium rare and the server said, yes. This was inaccurate- it was a super well done smash burger. The only redeeming factor was the maple bacon on top. The food did come out for promptly though read more

Really nice outdoor seating and lots of menu options. I can see why this place is always busy. Honestly this place is really a 3.5 star re: good but the atmosphere bumps it up to 4 stars. Really nice owner (?) that is checking on diners, especially the regulars who seem to know him. I would def come back as prices are fair - I probably just should have sucked it up and ordered a burger instead of a salad :) read more

Coney McKane's American Eatery - Spinach salad, large size. Was nice but I was kind of still hungry when done (may have been wiser to order something more substantial!) - Burgers Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

See all

Amazing oasis of gourmet American Midwest favorites! You have to try the pie!! Baked Potato SoupLandry 's Sandwich Honey Ham read more

Good for gluten free crowd! Limited gluten feee alcohol :( But the food is great and nice staff! read more

Coney McKane's American Eatery - Burgers Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

Come for the desserts as they are worth it and reasonable. Eat the food but the cookies are special.

Food was excellent and service and ambiance were surprisingly good. Flo's meatloaf was delicious and the pork chop sandwich was juicy and wonderful. We sat outside and enjoyed the charm. Brought our pie back to the hotel for later. What a nice stop I. This cute little town. read more

Worked in the kitchen and can say that they keep the place immaculately clean. I'd recommend the food to anyone wanting a good hearty meal.

Stopped here while driving across I-72 and didn't want to eat at the freeway chains. The building is beautiful the service is friendly and efficient. The menu said the chicken salad was famous. It was way too runny and inedible. The pork tenderloin was decent. It's worth the trip off the interstate to support a small local business read more

Cute little restaurant downtown. Homemade pie 10 out of 10 we tried the peach cobbler and she really has the crust down! Can't go here and not get the pie. Ate it too fast to take a photo read more

Great Food. Excellent Pies and desserts. Always good service every time we've been there. We've eaten there 8-10 times Nice downtown location. read more

We ate here on the recommendation of a local. Apparently they are known for their pies. We got takeout. The process was simple and easy, unfortunately there's no where to eat outside so we made our way to the park. Hubby ordered a Cuban sandwich with sweet potato fries, and I had a pork tenderloin sandwich with regular fries. We both got pieces of pie lemon for him and apple for me. The fries on both ends were a disappointment, clearly frozen and soggy. That may have been a function of take-out, but they were not hand cut, which I would expect from a restaurant that offers up this menu. The sandwiches were both decent. The Cuban sandwich had abundant meat with good flavor. My pork tenderloin was lightly breaded, crunchy and very fresh tasting. I appreciated that it was on toasted Texas toast, which is not always the case. The pies were a disappointment as well. The lemon pie was too sweet - - lemon pie should be sweet and tart, it's lemon after all. On the apple pie, the crust was under done though tasty, but the apple filling consisted mainly of gloppy thickener rather than apples. This also tended to far to the sweet for my palate. Overall we give the sandwiches that we had a thumbs up but we're disappointed in the pies and the sides. read more

Coney McKanes = Just had one of the WORST dining experiences I've had in recent memory. Wife and I had decided to get out of the house and take the boys out for dinner. We went downtown to Coney McKanes and it's safe to say that we will never be returning. -Both my wife's order and my own were the wrong items -Forgot our son's order completely -Very rude server ... not sure if he got embarrassed about messing up the orders and then just doubled-down on making sure it was going to be a shitty experience for us or maybe he was just having a bad day Seriously can't get over how rude and passive-aggressive the server got read more

The pies are delicious. The service is excellent. The servers are helpful and very courteous.

The food was great and the service was top notch!! Everyone was very friendly and welcoming!! I loved the overall atmosphere!!

It's disgusting. My 4 yr old can cook better. Green beans straight from a can with no seasoning at all. Adding old diced ham doesn't do anything. Instant mashed potatoes. The chicken and noodles were the worst I've ever had. Plain..tasted and looked like school lunch food. I remember this place used to be so yummy and decent.....definitely not anymore. All gross and definitely not cooked by a "chef". The pies are usually very good, but on occasion a bit too salty in the crust...just leave the salt out. Find better food and a chef and actually "cook", and it could be fabulous. read more

Stopped in for a late lunch yesterday. Nice atmosphere. Friendly courteous staff with quick service. Very good food. I had the club with turkey AND ham. It was really good. My husband ordered the nachos and we both enjoyed them. Plenty of warm toppings and good chips. He enjoyed the Cuban. There are other items on the menu that we want to try. We will definitely be returning. Overall, it was an enjoyable experience. read more

We were in town for a small event( first trip to Decatur) and tried to get in at 2 other places but due to short staff we had to go elsewhere. Ended up here. I wish we would have just found McDonalds. The Hot Roast Beef sandwich was full of globs of fat and congealed gravy. The meatloaf was tasteless and the green beans were canned. We did not mind the slow service since every restaurant is short on staff. But the food was very disappointing. I had to stop and buy some Rolaids on the way back to the hotel. read more

Decent enough food and good selection. Desserts are quality and homemade. The main dishes are often over cooked and a bit under seasoned. Especially the chicken. Burgers have been ok. Wings decent. An ok go to with above average desserts. read more

Wide variety of food and nice atmosphere. It's a great place to go when you're tired of chain restaurants. My husband is vegetarian and they had plenty of options for him, which was great! read more

Food is pretty good. Nothing amazing. More on the expensive side for basic American food. They do have vegan options which is nice. The staff is great and there is free parking. read more

Love my lunches at Coney's. Great atmosphere. Delicious entrees and of course the pie is my favorite. This is my favorite girls' lunch spot.

If you are looking for a Decatur, IL town favorite....this is the spot. It's nestled in the downtown area. This spot is perfect if you want to get together with a few friends, a couple's date, or go solo in a quiet environment. You will get that simplistic diner experience, with a hint of a small town homely feeling. The menu consists of the regular diner specials,.....sandwiches, soups, desserts, etc. I however, had the chicken fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and green beans, which was good.They also offered evening breakfast. The staff are friendly and highly helpful. So if you go....tell them Large Marge sent ya....lol read more

Coney McKane's American Eatery - Home Diner - Burgers Near Me - Decatur, Illinois

See all

Great place with good food. Ask for Matthew to be your server he does a great job (for a bald guy)! Seriously though Coneys is great for lunch. read more