Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cookie Dough Creations

    3.9 (323 reviews)
    Open 12:00 pm - 11:00 PM
    Updated 2 months ago

    Order Cookie Dough Creations Takeout or Delivery

    Cookie Dough Creations Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Cookie Dough Creations

    Recommended Reviews - Cookie Dough Creations

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Tricia D.

    I think I'm behind in my cookie dough comas because it's been almost a decade since I've been here! I'm back though, 2 kids later, and got the mini mes hooked on the magic that is the combo, cookie dough on top of ice cream. Their minds were blown when I told them they could have both... ... so thank you for having the mini size! Great for kiddos and adults. It's $5.75 and the perfect serving if you don't feel like eating your day's worth of calories in sugar and more sugar. The cookie jar ice cream flavor was right up my girls' alley, with Mother's frosted animal cookies, chocolate chips, and other cookies mixed into the base. Note there's like 16 flavors of ice cream and 8 kinds of cookie dough, so plenty to choose from and in whatever combo you want, one or the other, both, an ice cream cookie sandwich or cookie dough sandwich, just the cookies... I loved the cappuccino chip ice cream and was torn between fudge brownie cookie dough and chocolate chip cookie dough but went with the CCCD. Flavors were spot on, and the cookie dough has that granular sugar texture. Fun fact: the cookie dough is egg free, so totally safe to eat. More fun facts: - there's a wall of candy when you walk in, in case you need more sugar in your life. - walk past the register to the back for ample seating and ARCADE GAMES! This is totally new since my last visit. We enjoyed pinball, Pac-Man, and a couple disappointing rounds of the claw machine. Not my 5yo over here who cried dramatically when she didn't win a stuffy. - open til 11pm or midnight, depending on the night! So fun! If it's the stuff your dreams are made of, you can go out and do something about it! The staff is friendly and as sweet as the products! Cheers to many more years on the streets of Naperville, Cookie Dough Creations!

    Pam H.

    Family Owned Business, this ice cream place has been around for years! The concept is cookie dough and ice cream ! Different than the rest in Naperville and very unique. Many flavors to choose from but I went with the pecan praline. You have an option to add cookie dough to your ice cream, pretty cool right ? The place has a special surprise in the back ! Can you guess what is it ? An arcade room in the back with seating. The games to play are literally .75 cent to a $1 . Unheard of . The owners from this place are super cool and very friendly ! Thank you so much for the hospitality. If you're in Naperville and craving something sweet , look no further.

    Front counter with coolers
    Neal M.

    A classic downtown Naperville staple! Nice staff who let you try samples at your liking! They currently have 8 cookie dough flavors and 16 ice cream flavors to choose from. We tried the original Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough which was excellent. Light and the right consistency without those grainy textures in your mouth that you'd get with lower quality cookie dough. Some might say it melts in your mouth! Not to mention the portion size... the small felt like a large (not that I'm complaining though)!! They also have a large wall of candy to satisfy everyone's sweet tooth. Some single row seating along the side of the restaurant (see photos), but otherwise sort of reliant on the grab-and-go style or eating outside of the shop on a nicer day. Not the best cookie dough we've ever had, but definitely up there. We can tell why Naperville hasn't been saying "no to cookie dough" for 25+ years! Rating: a very solid 4/5 for the whole experience, would like to have seen more unique "cookie dough creations!"

    Candy candy candy
    De'Laka B.

    Perfect late night treat to end my night in downtown Naperville. I was torn between confetti and moose tracks ice cream. I settled on the latter. Speedy service to the long line of tourists. Next time I need the confetti scoop. Nostalgic vibe from the candy wall. I left happy :)

    Sheilisa D.

    Great service & great sweets :) super cute place in Naperville for those with a sweet tooth.

    We got cookie dough!!!
    Leo S.

    The cookie dough was awesome sauce! Great texture and flavor. The service was good and they were very kind and respectful to me and my friend. Got it for a great price too!!

    Ice cream: Moose Tracks Cookie dough: cake batter
    Serena D.

    This is my go-to ice cream place! Plus there's also cookie dough! The ice cream isn't freezer burned and it is very creamy and flavorful! The cookie dough also was very good! You should definitely try out this spot!

    Chocolate chip and Oreo
    Ali B.

    This was really fun to visit! I had always wNted to try a cookie dough shop so my sister and I basically forced our family to go as soon as we drove past it. It was way too cold for ice cream but I saw they had blue moon which was incredibly tempting! My sister and I shared a small with chocolate chip cookie dough and Oreo cookie dough. I'm sad to say I didn't like it, just a weird flavor and texture for me. But my sister and dad liked it. There were awesome retro games in back, it was a lot of fun! Next time I'd just get ice cream but this is a cool place!

    Mini Chocolate Extreme Ice Cream with Choc Chip Cookie Dough!
    Amanda M.

    What a fun idea! Come get a scoop of ice cream topped with everyone's favorite...COOKIE DOUGH. Today I got the chocolate extreme ice cream with the basic chocolate chip cookie dough on top. I got the mini size because the small is always too much for me! The mini combo cost $4.50. I think that's a steal! They offer a wide variety of ice cream flavors and dough flavors. I wish the ice cream was a little better, but hey...it's still all delicious. Delicious delicious delicious. The cookie dough (FYI) does not have eggs in it. So it's completely safe. In case you're one of those people who has the willpower not to eat the cookie dough at home....ha!!

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    See all

    Photo of Efa F.
    0
    37
    0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 9 of 9

    Ask the Community - Cookie Dough Creations

    Do they let you sample?

    Yes, they do give samples if you ask.

    View All 2 Questions

    You might also consider

    Cookie Dough Creations - icecream - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...