I've been coming to Costello Jewelry in Naperville for years from purchases to repairs and cleaning. I love that my jewelry does not leave the store when being repaired. This is the first time I had an original ring designed, though. I worked with Marino Costello on the design process. As an anniversary gift, my husband wanted to buy me a ring, but I decided that I couldn't give up my original engagement ring and wedding band so I had a new ring designed utilizing the diamonds. The process was interesting. I looked at rings in the jewelry store to get an idea of what I wanted and then we proceeded to the design process, Marino sending me CAD drawings and then a wax ring was made where I tried it on to get an idea of the design and dimensions. My new ring is gorgeous! Marino is a fabulous designer and so easy to work with. I appreciated his attention to detail and his quick responses to my emails. The design process was fun. I love that Marino designed such a special ring where I still have the original diamonds that my husband gave me 20 years ago. I highly recommend Costello Jewelry! read more

Costello Jewelry - Jewelry Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

Costello Jewelry in Naperville never disappoints! Today I brought an item for repair which RALPH handled with professionalism and competence. He even went the extra mile with suggesting a resource for me going forward. I left the store smiling once again, as always. In these times when most merchants are in a hurry, Ralph took extra time with me which I very much appreciate. Thank you, Ralph and Costello! read more

Had a great experience recently when I wanted to give my moms band some TLC. The woman inspected it and informed me I don't need any serious adjustments, just a polishing & a good clean. It came out beautifully! Dropped it off at 10 am and was able to pick it up any time after 4. She charged $75 and including cleaning my other rings. 20 year old ring looks brand new! read more

Everything from start to finish, Jennifer and Alicia were great. They were both so helpful and showed us everything we wanted to see and more. Very knowledgeable and my friend carolyn and I walked out of there planning our next trip to Costello's. I would highly recommend shopping here . read more

Costello Jewelry Co. is amazing. Jennifer has assisted me in going through jewelry and recreating pieces for my family. She is patient and has great knowledge. She is always kind and accommodating. Also, I brought in a watch in, and she put a new band on right away. I would recommend going to Costello's and asking for Jennifer. She is wonderful!! read more

I've been going to Costello Jewelers in Naperville for over 15 years, and I can't imagine trusting anyone else with jewelry. Joe has a rare gift for explaining complicated details in a way that makes me feel comfortable and confident, like a trusted family member guiding me through my options. His son Marino has really branched out and built his own identity in the industry--winning awards, opening a new storefront in Western Chicago, and becoming an expert in men's watches. It's been great to see his passion and knowledge grow alongside Joe's. Between Joe's experience and Marino's fresh perspective, this family truly sets the standard for trust, quality, and care. They've earned my loyalty for life. read more

Highly recommend this jeweler! One of my necklaces broke and they fixed it same day. Thank you so much!

Waited forever to find did not have what I wanted. Several people working in back that saw me only came from back when their female salesperson going help me. Sadistic to see how long they could get me wait . It's also that in old shop had no ventilation . Ihhh! read more

I'd been searching for a mid-range luxury timepiece for years, often finding the perfect watch online then having the deal fall through at the last minute. One marketplace had a listing for a Rolex watch (Day-Date 18078) which I noticed was in the Chicago suburbs at Costello Jewelry. Relishing the chance to actually view a watch in person, I visited Costello Jewelry. I purchased the watch without a second thought. My end-to-end experience was phenomenal. The team answered every question, researched what they didn't know, rushed no aspect of the process, offered a totally-fair market price, and didn't charge an extra fee for using a credit card. A lot of secondhand watch dealers have attitudes and business practices that are more fitting for used car salesmen. This was a well-curated experience where the integrity of the business and staff was frequently made evident. Even though Costello isn't a Rolex AD or high-volume secondhand dealer. I'd recommend picking up the phone and giving them a call--I have a family heirloom to show for it. read more

I would not recommend this jeweler. They want this pristine reputation on overpriced jewelry; however, once you wish to trade in or buyback, the owner insults you with a trade-in price and states that the gold and diamond market is terrible. Mind you, I have been buying for them for 20 years on and off. Then, when promised a price in April, they would buy back a set amount. Now, in July, they even offered me $800.00 less. Then I get a call stating they are going to pass. Really??? This pristine "jewelry " is from your store! It's Sad, like all companies. They want your business and kiss your @$$ for a purchase, but when it comes to taking care of you when it doesn't benefit them, they make you feel like your belongings aren't good enough anymore. But how about a store CREDIT??? read more

Needed to get a Raymond Weil watch battery replacement and found that Costello in downtown Naperville is literally the only store in the area who actively services these watches. Went into the shop and was warmly greeted by the staff. They told me that it would cost $20 to replace and would take ~15 minutes since there were a couple of others in front of me. However, it was finished under 10 minutes and they adjusted the watch to display the proper time/date. Great, quick service--highly recommend! read more

Costello Jewelry - Jewelry Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

One of the few places that services Raymond Weil watches. Straightforward people and work was done as promised. Recommend! read more

I received a new watch band with links for my Apple Watch as a gift. Out of the box it was too big, so I brought to Costello's to help take some links out. The staff was so helpful and it took no time at all to have adjusted. Once I left and got to my car, I noticed it just didn't fit right and needed one more link out. I went back in moments later and they didn't even hesitate! They asked me for it back, took another link out and I was out of there in 5 min. The staff is just wonderful and willing to help you without making you feel like a bother! I just love this place in our beautiful downtown! read more

I needed a link removed from a watch bracelet and someone recommended Costello. I stopped in and they were kind enough to remove the link at no charge, even though I didn't purchase the watch from them. And it only took them about 5 minutes. While waiting, I browsed their watches and they had a decent selection. read more

I was first introduced to Costello Jewelry Company (Glen Ellyn) in 1998, when my wedding & engagement rings were purchased. Costello's is a friendly, family-owned business with quality fine jewelry, who are able to customize any piece to your liking. In early spring of last year, my mother found out that my father left behind an Emerald for her. I told her that I hadn't worn my wedding rings, or a tennis bracelet for quite some time, suggesting that we take them to Costello's (Naperville) so that they could customize a ring. Upon arrival, we were immediately greeted by Trisha, a warm, kind-hearted client service associate who openly embraced my request to use the diamonds from my jewelry to customize Mom's Emerald ring. Multiple design options were created, according to my mother's desires; ensuring the outcome would be something that she would cherish. Mom received photos of each to pick from, or modify if she chose to do so. They spent a significant amount of time and commitment, patiently guiding us through the entire process. Costello Jewelry Company were unbelievable accommodating and bent over backwards to make sure she left with a smile on her face. My mother is elated with the outcome! She wears it every day. My wedding ring solitaire has since been made into a drop necklace with several small accent diamonds around the chain. Costello's Jewelry took their time re-designing my jewelry into uniquely designed pieces that we will appreciate for many years to come. Thank you, Costello Jewelry & Thank you, Trisha! read more

See all

Walked in needing a repair on a mens silver necklace clasp and they fixed it on the spot at no charge while I waited. Super friendly staff. Very clean and professional. Will definitely be back when the time is right to tie the knot. Their womens rings and bands look stunning. Highly Reccommend! read more

I wish I could give Costello's 10 stars. My mother lost her wedding ring while in the hospital. It was the original ring that my father had given her 55 years ago. Dad passed in 2020 so that ring meant the world to her. Trish at Costello's worked with the hospital in order to recreate her lost ring. Trish spent so much care, time and attention to every nuance while recreating Mom's ring. We had only blurry photos so the details were difficult to get just right, they actually created a model from a drawing my Mom made. They made sure everything was perfect, even the inscription inside the ring. My Mom was able to pick up her "new" ring right before the holidays. She was overwhelmed with joy and emotion and thanked Costellos for giving her the best Christmas present ever - a bit of my Dad back with her. There are many places to go to get beautiful pieces of jewelry, but it is rare to find a place that cares and understands the way Trish and Costello's did. Our treasured jewelry is much more than beautiful stones and metals, it is a marker and memory of life's special moments and Costello's certainly demonstrated that when recreating Mom's wedding ring. read more

I stopped in Costello Jewelry to see if they could fix my necklace that broke. They immediately took it in back and started working. A few minutes later it was all done and good as new. When I asked them how much I owe them, Debra says no charge. I was a first time customer and they treated me as if I was a regular that purchased the necklace from them. I would highly recommend this place of business to anyone looking for a fine piece of jewelry. Thanks again. read more

Top notch service!!! Ask for Ralph! He gently cut my engagement ring off because I stupidly forced it onto my right ring finger. Ralph sized it and had it fixed in less than 48 hours! Will definitely return. They have gorgeous jewelry! read more

Costello Jewelry - Jewelry Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

This is the best jewelers in the burbs. Two locations, naperville and Glen Elynn . I have purchased nothing from them in 10 years. I get my watch battery changed and water tested every two years and recently got 3 eternity bands cleaned. Every time I walk in I feel like family! I HIGHLY recommend! read more

We have been a loyal customer of Costello Jewelry in Glen Ellyn for decades. Why? Unparalleled service, and dependable and honest advice. They stand by their products, and even those of others. They just repaired a David Yurman ring in four minutes at no charge. Thank you, Ralph!! read more

I have been to Costello Jewelers in Naperville many times over the past 10 years or so. From appraisals so watch batteries to cleaning jewelry. But this last visit compelled me to finally write an overdue review as a way to thank them for great service. When cleaning one of my rings, a stone fell out. They replaced the stone, and the woman I worked with was very gracious about it. An aside, they have beautiful pieces of jewelry, and when I am in a position to purchase something new I will definitely buy from them. read more

I love this place! Their customer service is fantastic and they are very fairly priced as well! I love the fact that they have a jeweler on site so if you need any repairs or touch ups they can usually take care of any of your Jewelry needs right on the spot and you don't have to wait weeks being without your ring (I mean who wants to be without their ring right?!) Thanks Costello Jewelry!!! read more

Went in on a whim to buy a 20-year anniversary gift for my wife with no idea what I wanted. Had never been here before. Was helped by Maureen, who was absolutely fantastic. Took me around the store, showed me a variety of options at various price points. No pressure or stress. Was actually a fun experience. Ended up settling on a necklace per Maureen's recommendation and my wife absolutely loves it. Thanks again Costello/Maureen! read more

My husband has purchased all of my jewelry from this store. Every time we go in to get items cleaned, fixed, or to purchase it is always an amazing experience. They truly know how to take care of their customers. We continue to come back because of their wonderful customer service. Costello's made a custom engagement ring with my families diamonds, that turned out beautiful. They also turned my extra pearl from my bracelet into a beautiful necklace. read more

Wonderful experience working with the Costello family and professional staff on the creation of a simply stunning engagement ring for our future son in law and daughter. Every attention to detail was executed flawlessly and within our budget. I would highly recommend them to anyone. read more

Bent a prong on my engagement ring while I was on vacation. Decided to try Costello to get it fixed. They did it while we waited, wasn't even 5 minutes. Even cleaned my ring too! Everyone was very kind and professional. We will definitely be coming back for future repairs and other purchases! read more

Amazing customer service and the staff couldn't be friendlier. Loved my experience!

I walked into Costellos because my diamond was loose on my ring. They fixed it, on the spot, within 3 minutes free of charge. I was shocked. My previous jeweler would have to send it off and I'd be without my ring for a week, not to mention $$. Costellos is amazing and really cares! read more

Had a wonderful experience working with Costello to purchase a ring. Timely, provided options and suggestions based on what I was looking for and ultimately found the perfect fit. Appreciate their superior customer service. read more

Never have been disappointed in all the years I've been coming to Costello's. They've fixed the prongs on my engagement/wedding rings and did an excellent job; I'm no longer worried about losing a stone. They also sized my husband's watch that I had bought for him and it was done on the spot with not much of a wait. I'd recommend coming here for the selection, expertise and great service! read more

I came in here to get a quick glimpse of their wedding bands. I got here at 5:45pm and they close at 6:00. I was told they put their merchandise away and that I should come back another day. Needless to say I will not be coming back just for that service... if you care about your customers you don't turn down business. read more

Recently I found a very special pair of earrings that had belonged to my mother. I took them to Costello to have converted from a screw back to a post back. They took great care to make the conversion as they knew how irreplaceable they were to me. This is just an example to the great service and attention to detail that I've experienced from the folks at Costello Jewelers. They have a seasoned jeweler on site so I know who will be taking care of my treasures. Deborah knows so much about precious stones and is always willing to answer any question. read more

My husband bought a beautiful gold necklace for me several years ago from Costello jewelry and it is my favorite piece of jewelry. The quality is awesome of course and the personal service is second to none. Since then I have been in for repairs on family pieces of jewelry and they have done a superb job. The other day I stopped in to drop off a necklace for repairs that was from my Grandmother and they were able to repair it on the spot. Costello's is a hometown jewelry store that treats you like family! read more

I went here to make a ring purchase. Michele was rude to me. I wasn't greeted properly. These people are rude! I'm not sure how anyone can shop here. No versatile selection. Why shop here when there are so many other reputable jewelry stores. read more

I have been coming to Costello for years and they have unsurpassed integrity and friendly, thoughtful service! They treat me like family! I have bought jewelry here and have only entrusted Costello to repair my family's most cherished, delicate heirloom jewelry. Costello also does the most accurate jewelry appraisals around. read more

The day shops opened up downtown Naperville during Covid-19, I stopped in Costello. A very special necklace I wear had broken recently and I was in need of repair. I walked into the stunning store and was pleasantly greeted. While I waited to speak with someone, we casually look at the gorgeous collection of jewelry..... I was warmly greeted and when I showed the necklace in need of repair, it was fixed on the spot - when I asked for my total, they laughed and thanked me for coming in. They fixed my necklace for free!!!! I have shopped at Costello in the past and they now have a customer for life! Thank you Costello for treating me like a human being! It is truly appreciated! read more

I always feel comfortable leaving special jewelry with these guys. They fixed a botched repair job from somewhere else. They did a great job. read more

Costello Jewelry in Glen Ellyn is also a great place to shop. Service and repair is excellent too. I have been going there for years and highly recommend them. Very knowledgeable, trustworthy and friendly to work with! read more

This is such an elegant store, steeped in history that elevates the jewelry buying experience. The space as well as the employees are graceful and welcoming. The selection is beautiful. Michele made my day today! I was in for the first time and as a new customer, she resized my watch on the house (and offered to shine my rings)! I believe they offer free ring polishing while you browse! read more