huge fan of this establishment. hot and cold lobster rolls are both exquisite, oysters are cold and…read morefresh, and the chowder was the best i've had in the island. service was amazing, everyone was so kind, and there is seating outside around the corner which was perfect! this is the kind of place you want to go back again and again to try everything on the menu

This was the worst lobster I've ever had - I seriously didn't know it was possible to make lobster…read moretaste this bad. I wish I could say the only thing wrong with it was that it was overcooked. Had to throw it out after a few bites. Also ordered the "chunky" lobster bisque. There was maybe a few tiny strands of lobster in the entire cup.

The guys running this market are the nicest guys and give you great service. We ordered 16 lobsters…read morecooked and cracked with some steamed clams for a get to together. Everything was cooked to perfection and our guests loved it. Will definitely be back again.

The best mussels ever!! Andy and Jimmy are great so are the other staff always quality food and…read moreservice !! Love my seafood market!!

Stopped here at the end of the Summer on my way out of town. I wish I had known about this place…read moreearlier! They had a wealth of different seafood options to bring home and prepare. They also offer all of the items cooked and you can eat on the picnic tables outside. I was able to grab something quickly as I was headed to the ferry. I had the lobster roll. It came loaded with lobster meat, just a hint of mayo on a perfectly fresh griddles bun. Definitely a delicious last meal on the island. Can't wait to try this place for more when I'm back in Summer 2026.

Got the fish and chips. No seasoning. Very bland. Extremely disappointed. Also had a cod sandwich…read more It was ok.

I stopped by Larsen's Fish Market while visiting Martha's Vineyard, and had to try the lobster…read moreroll. It was loaded with big, fresh chunks of lobster meat, and I loved that the lobster was really the star of the show. No need for a bunch of extras when the seafood is this fresh. I also really enjoyed the casual experience of grabbing my food and eating outside near the water. Nothing fancy, just fresh seafood, beautiful surroundings, and a very New England/Martha's Vineyard kind of experience. Definitely worth a stop if you're in Menemsha and love lobster!

I just don't get what the hype is about. We stopped here before going to the beach. Got two hot…read moreLobster Rolls and an order of Lobster Mac and cheese. The Lobster rolls were just OK. If anything, was disappointed and the bottom of the buns were soggy before even putting on some melted butter. The Lobster mac and cheese was just awful. I would not call that mac and cheese. While I did not order anything from the fresh fish side, it did look very fresh and nice and clean. I would not get food from them again but would purchase some fresh seafood there and go home and cook it myself.

Always the freshest of fish!! Its the only place I buy fish and, no matter what you get there, its…read morethe best

The most amazing fresh fish displayed in an appetizing assortment. I bought 2 lbs of lobster that…read morewas huge steamed perfect and gad that real lobster taste!!!

Sayle's is the real deal…read more Live lobsters in any size you want, cooked to order at prices that are much more normal than you're used to seeing on Nantucket (available without the dinner platter extras). Steamers by the bag, with drawn butter and lemon. Fried whole belly clams and other seafood, done perfectly. Frying is a skill, and these guys do it right. Clean oil at the perfect temperature delivers seafood and even french fries that are crisp and not greasy at all.

I've heard massively good things about Sayle's from my friends who live in the island, year round…read more Well, thing is, it's a take out place. They do have a couple of tables outside, but it was kind of a cool and windy day and not enjoyable to be sitting out. Darn shame. Seafood was alive in tanks. Everything was very fresh. Prices very reasonable. Too bad they do not have a real eating area, not a restaurant, but a place where you can sit, use utensils, and enjoy.

One of my favorite restaurants on the island and a place that I always come back to. If you are…read morevegan, and looking for upscale dining this should be your first stop. Their menu changes every year but they always make sure to have at least one amazing vegan dish. The ambiance is cozy and elevated and the service is truly exceptional.

I'd like to comment on the impeccable guest service. Linda went out of her way to make sure we were…read moresatisfied. It really seemed like a high priority! Hurley (our server) was very attentive and accommodating. We had an overall great experience! The food was out of this world. I had the steak and it was delicious and my partner had the short rib and it was so tender. Amazing meal! Desserts left nothing to be desired. They were just as on point as our meals.

Wow!! This may be the best lobster roll we had on our entire trip to Boston, the Cape and…read more Nantucket! Simply delicious and worth every penny!! They have a beautiful garden area with picnic tables to sit and eat your lobster rolls. We also did the homemade Guacamole and wow that was delicious too! I can't say enough good things to say about the lobster roll and guac from 167. They do have a market on property too for fresh fish, beer/wine and some other small goods. We actually got dropped off at Cisco brewing and walked over here just for that lobster roll. YUM!

Came here after a day at Cisco Beach and WOW was I blown away by their lobster roll!…read more Located on Hummock Pond rd. We came on bikes. Very close to Cisco Brewery and on the way to or from the beach. This is a must-stop. We got two lobster rolls (which come with chips and a pickle) and to drink a sun tea! I was BLOWN away by these lobster rolls. I'm a bit of a lobster roll enthusiast. This was the best cold lobster I've had outside of Maine. They have a slight twist in the classic. Hardy amount of lobster, perfectly cooked, and lightly dressed and topped with chive. I think they drizzle them in a lemon butter too. The bun was outstanding, buttered and then salted, the extra salt is a nice touch. Drooling writing this review and remembering how good they were. They were that good! We also got "Hannah's homemade sun tea", sweet and refreshing. They also have ceviche, guac, and other things on the menu that looked great and I can't wait to try. Staff was friendly and welcoming. They have outside seating with umbrellas for shade. The parking lot gets packed though so come on a bike if you can. A+ 167 Raw, can't wait to come back.