I need a sixth star to rate my experience. Shamara and Maurice went above and beyond to get me a lobster roll even though I unwittingly missed the 6p cutoff. What they didn't know is that I just had a tough meeting with a client and came in later than I'd planned. They made my evening. Caring so much about my experience guarantees that I will recommend this store to others. read more

The original recipe steak tips are the best I have had anywhere and are easy to barbecue . We enjoy the pre seasoned meats and the seafood. All of the meat and seafood is very fresh. They also have sushi here made to order. They have lots of condiments to choose from for snacking while you prepare your meal, a nice wine selection, vegetables and desserts as well. Everything you need for a home cooked meal is here. Always fresh. read more

Edgartown Meat & Fish - customers at the counter - Seafood Markets Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

All I wanted I was a crisp soda after a day at the beach. I thought that surely this establishment would have coke or sprite but imagine my surprise when the only sodas they offer are Mountain Dew and Pepsi. Disappointed to say the least. read more

Very disappointed in the service. Employees were rude and very disorganized. We waited 20 minutes for our order only to find out that it had been sitting there for 15 because someone could yell out a name. I fully understand that it is the busy season and it can be very stressful however would it kill you to slap on a smile speak up and say hello! The food was only good because we where starving. I would highly recommend customer service training. Overall the store has great choices it's very convenient. Pricing is a little on the higher side. read more

Stopped in to grab a couple pre-made 6 inch Italian-mix subs for my wife and I - no price marked or signed. Was shocked when I got to the checkout and was charged $16.95 EACH for the subs! The taste was all-right but certainly not the best I've ever had and definitely not worth the price. read more

GREAT STAFF!! Excellent market if overpriced. They don't really have an option as I'm guessing their rent is really high, but the bagels and coffee are OUTSTANDING and they ALWAYS SERVED WITH A SMILE!! read more

This is a wonderful place. Great variety of absolutely fresh fish for reasonable prices.

Go-to for groceries in Edgartown for me. They have a large selection of meats, seafood, organic and fresh vegetables. They offer meats that are pre-seasoned and marinated that are delicious as well. They have gluten free and many organic options. There is pre-made options: sushi (though the person that makes it does truly stare you down when deciding - this makes me laugh every time), a sandwich (both breakfast and lunch) counter, a coffee bar (they serve Starbucks), and a nice variety of wine and beers / ciders (both local and otherwise). Definitely a great place to stock up for your Edgartown adventure, or trip back home. read more

Amazing staff and high quality products. The Starbucks counter also has very friendly and hard-working employees. The meat and fish is more expensive than elsewhere but is good quality. Definitely recommend! read more

Great selection of just about everything! I didn't like my experience with Sushi, I selected The Shrimp Rolls only to find out that were fake crab. Very disappointing! The Starbucks coffee is a nice touch but the staff is not always helpful. The Meat Counter had a great young man, very knowledgeable about what was in the cases, even had a tie on!!!! Very impressive! Parking is difficult, but that's MV for you in the season. Overall I love this market and will continue to frequent it . read more

I have been a loyal and frequent customer (almost daily) since their opening. My wife and I love getting espresso coffee and often lunch as well as other grocery items. In the past we have always thought you folks has some of the best Lobster Rolls. Tonight we ordered two lobster rolls ($30.00 each) with Gratuity I paid $70.70!!! When we got home, the lobster roll was so bad I couldn't eat it and threw it out. I think this lobster salad was several days old!!! No chips included, I should add. This may have been a "one off" problem but I will never, ever get a lobster roll here again. In fact, I have gone from a big supporter of this business to being disappointed. read more

You know that saying, 'like a kid in a candy store'? Well for me, henceforth, it will be 'like Hilary in Edgartown Meat & Fish', because I went completely and totally bonkers with glee upon entering this shop. Totally. Completely. 100% Bonkers. My sister, resident of Edgartown, MA very casually and breezily said, "Oh, we should go to the new fish market..." when I asked what we were doing for din-dins that evening. I had no frigging clue what the new fish market meant and what joy was in my future. See, being from New England, I am used to the cement-floor, stanky-air, humid, sweaty, gritty markets that sell the good stuff right off the boats and out of the fishermens' hands. 'It ain't pretty, but it sure is good' kind of stuff. Not that I mind that - not at all... ... But I digress. This market is beautiful. Pristine, even. The wood floors glisten with fresh polish, the counters sparkle with cleanliness, and the fish... the FISH!!! It was a thing to behold, that fish. Slabs of tuna, perfectly pink and slightly translucent. The striper, the bluefish, the oysters... I could go on forever, but I will just tell you this: it was all gorgeous. The meat counter was equally as impressive. I wanted flank steak, and boy did I ever get it: almost 5lbs of it for under $40. Where does that happen anywhere, let alone on Martha's Vineyard? It was quality, too - grass fed right there on the island. Amazing. Delicious. Fresh. Go get some. Go get some right now. They also have a fantastic selection of condiments and snacks here, too - everything from Cholula to Cape Cod 'tater chips. You can pop in and get lunch on your way to the beach from the deli foods section - containers of salads, sushi, even sandwiches and drinks. They've got a liquor license, so there's a substantial wine and beer selection, too. Oh - and cheeses! Do you understand why this is now my favorite shop on the Vineyard? This shop is going places, kids... read more

Edgartown Meat & Fish - Seafood Markets Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

A one stop shop for many things like sushi, Starbucks -- yes Starbucks -- meats and wines. I tried what looked to be Starbucks and guess what it has the same taste as on he mainland. The sushi is made in house and is really good ( there is a guy with a sushi counter making more as things sell) I sat on one of he sofas and watched as sushi and Starbucks were going one by one. There was a large selection of wines and drinks. Also the meats that were out looked very fresh and had a range in price. I have never seen a more shiny hardwood floor! This place is in a good location and so many things to choose from! read more

Edgartown Meat & Fish - Seafood Markets Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

The Edgartown Meat and Fish market will spoil you forever...The best swordfish you will ever have...Steaks , Chops , and Hamburgers ...Amazing.. Everyone who works there is so helpful and polite always.. We spend our Summers on the Island and this market is everyones favorite go to .. Thanks for being in Edgartown Shellie Johnson Marblehead, Mass. read more

The meat and seafood are superb, and the prices reflect that. Even though I need to transfer funds from my HELOC to cover purchases here, I am a loyal and frequent customer here. read more

With many memories of this space's former incarnation as a video store, I viewed its new identity as a fish and meat market, plus a cafe on the side, with some trepidation. But after carefully going in to soak up the new environment and try a few items, I could see myself coming back here on a regular basis. Special kudos for it being MV's only Starbucks outlet, a careful attention to a tasty and wide variety of craft beers, and what appears to be a healthily diverse range of meats, cheeses, and (yes) fish. Worth checking out! read more

Returned to MV for the season and went to EM and F Bought my favorite sirloin burgers and potato salad and went home to cook Delicious Excellent meat and fish Can not be beat Going back for my n y strip this weekend I spend a fortune in store and well worth it Happy to be back to MV again read more

I help run a writers workshop on Martha's Vineyard every fall, and was delighted to find Edgartown Meat & Fish. We feed 40 people a day for more than a week, and serving fresh, local food is one of our priorities. They've been terrific to us since we discovered them. I simply call in the meat order, and send someone to pick it up. They've always had our order ready to go, carefully wrapped, and quite reasonably priced. The meat and chicken we've used has always been fresh, flavorful, and selected with obvious care. The Italian sausages are amazing (both the sweet and the hot varieties) and the burger is fresh and ground to order. We'll be back every year. I just wish I had an Edgartown Meat & Fish in my own hometown. read more

I went to the market for the early morning usual: coffee, orange juice, and bagels. I've been wanting to try this place out since they opened about two weeks ago. This seemed like the perfect opportunity for a trial run, and it was. The bagels were still warm and everything was great and service at that time of day still with a smile! Ok, I thought it might have been a fluke, and I just caught them at a good time. So, I decided to go back for lunch and try out their lobster rolls. I am addicted to lobster rolls and I have tried them everywhere and these were excellent and priced well too. To get five stars, I think the service has to be even better than the food, and they hit the mark. The owner came out from behind the butcher counter to say hello and greet my wife, son and I. They made us feel like we were part of their family. The reason for my initial skepticism was the existing grocery store choices. There's only the Stop and Rob, and that place is really disgusting. Edgartown needed a place like the Meat and Fish Market, and finally got it! We will definitely be here often. read more

Over $59 a pound for lobster salad !!!! Are u kidding me . That is an embarrassment for all involved !!! What a shame that Edgartown has lost its flavor of being an organic quaint arena . read more

Good quality, terrible customer service. Ordered four sandwiches and three were wrong. My wife the next time we went in told the guy at the counter about it he held his hands out and shrugged his shoulders. Keep going back because the have Starbucks cold brew. Won't get another sandwich there. read more

Don't waste your time at any of the disgusting Shop & Stop, Cumberland Farms, Cronigs, etc. EM&F really is one of the few places that offers great options with a very high quality in MV. This is a one stop shop to grab everything you need to cook the perfect meal, also terrific wine options. EM&F truly understands what customers are looking for. Make a stop at Morning Glory Farm for your produce and EM&F for everything else and you will be very happy. read more

If you are searching for quality foods, delicious options, and great staff, look no further!

As longtime summer residents, our family was very happy when the Edgartown Meat & Fish Market opened its doors. They offer a wide variety of quality meat, fish and poultry--some of the meat is already marinated and ready to put on the grill. They also have a small produce aisle and offer organic breads. They carry beer and wine and have a deli counter with salads (famous chicken Caesar) , sandwiches, coffee, muffins and scones. Imagine how surprised we were when, immediately after Labor Day, the once well-stocked deli counter with friendly, service-oriented staff, changed--almost overnight. The Caesar salads, made fresh everyday, disappeared and haven't been back since. The baked goods selection is sparse and items look as if they've been there a while. Ordering sandwiches now is something of an ordeal. The two workers behind the counter appear sullen and unhappy and will barely communicate with shoppers. One can stand at the counter for 5 minutes or longer waiting to be served while the employees chat together. We are disappointed to see this negative change at a store used that used to offer fresh food AND excellent service. Perhaps the Covid virus is responsible for the downturn. read more

After some years here, I was delighted, surprised, and thrilled to find this higher end market with meats, gourmet foods, and carry out services, as well as Starbucks coffee goodies and some cushy sofas. We would have been regular enthusiastic customers!!!! Open 8-8, today we arrived at 6:40 pm to get take out sandwiches. We shopped for a bit and at 6:50 went to order our food. The two Latino workers at the counter said they had stopped making food to go at 7. It was 6:50 pm. Both were standing there with nothing to do, and it wasn't even 7. Nowhere was any such time posted. Both workers were surly and rude. That did it for us...end of enthusiasm, although we are here for 6 months yearly, I would never return. Cronies and Espresso Love, here we come. .good businesses can fail when they have bad service!!!! On October 20 th we decided to try it again. This time they advertised sliced cold cuts extensively on their board, only to be out of most of them, had only one check out for coffee and the whole market, and had a worse slow and rude employee than the first time. Off season, it was depleted of a lot of fresh stock...I predict FAILURE. You have to provide competent service and decent product. Done! read more

Ordered 2 breakfast sandwiches this morning. Had high hopes for them. Unfortunately was disappointed that the eggs were not really edible. It reminded me of McDonald's eggs to be honest. Also ordered avocado and for an extra 1.50 was not worth it. Came as a light spread on the bagel. However, the bagel and bacon were quite tasty. read more

Win! Everything you need to create a yummy meal, and bonus super friendly staff! Pre-marinated steaks, chicken, kabobs, wings, burgers - and the swordfish is amazing - all ready to toss on the grill. Veggies, condiments, and adult beverages. You will be pleased with your stop. read more

This would be a 5 star review if the people working at the sushi stand learned that it's rude to hover over customers while they're choosing their items. It's VERY uncomfortable and makes me feel rushed. It's not like they offer any assistance or say anything, they just stand within inches of you as you're browsing the selection staring you down. Just awful. read more

Great market, but miserable staff. Starbucks would be horrified that such rude people were serving their lattes.

I think the excitement surrounding Edgartown meat and fish needs to be tamped down a bit. Their meat and fish are very good, but are by no means exceptional for the island, especially on the fish side. Plus, they are very expensive. What are most disappointing however are the prepared foods and fresh sandwiches. The sandwiches contain very, very little actual meat. I felt as though I might as well have eaten a baguette. Also, we had some pasta that was pretty awful. On top of that, the sandwich service was slow, the people making the sandwiches were rude, and all of this was relatively expensive. read more

Edgar town Meats &Fish - First I would like to say the food looks great. But only if you get what you order. I'm not sure where they get these idiots from but they obviously do not understand English. I called in an order for simple bologna and ham sandwiches. Get there and there is no order placed. The cashier apologizes then places my order with a rush. I end up with roast beef. Totally different from bologna. When I call and ask for a manager I am put on hold. Waited for 15 minutes before I called back to find out my number was blocked. If I could give zero stars I would... read more

Sam at edgartown meat and fish was wonderful! Super helpful, great catering resource and super easy to work with. Will use them again and again! read more

Their house steak tips are out of this world! That is our go-to "we have guests visiting" or "special occasion" purchase. We will choose to go get the steak tips and grill them up rather than go out to a restaurant, they're THAT GOOD. Great beer selection, lots of micro brews and local New England stuff. They have a lot of wine but I don't feel confidant enough in my wine skills to comment on their selection. The grocery side is a little on the pricey side but you are getting really nice, tasty stuff for your $, lots of nice meats, cheeses, breads and crackers and such. They've got great soups (try the broccoli & cheddar!) and for those of you who can't bear being on the island without your Starbucks, they serve Starbucks here. The staff is super friendly and helpful and they have stood by their word to stay open year round, which is great for us island folk but probably not great for their bottom line, it's much appreciated by those of us here in the winter. They have really worked to become a part of the community and have supported several local non-profits in the short time they've been here. read more

Edgartown Meat & Fish has great customer service. Everything I visit for lunch they know exactly how to satisfy hunger and thirst. Some things are a little on the pricey side but it is well worth it. The atmosphere is very clean as well. KUDOS! read more

It was our first stop as soon as we got off the boat. Something for everyone and family friendly. Lots of places to sit inside and out. Impressive and reasonable wine selection; delicious looking meat and fish. Get everything you need at this upscale but casual little place. read more

I love this place. The meats are amazing, the cheese selection is great, and for those of you that complain everything is more expensive on the Vineyard they sell Miraval rose wine for $2 cheaper a bottle than my local liquor store in Newton does. And I can grab a Starbucks on the way out. I will buy chips and salsa at the Stop and Shop, but my meats come from EM&F! read more

This is a great place to pick up some seafood for dinner! The food is always fresh and delicious! Not to mention they have The Oyster sauv blanc- perfect compliment to my seafood dinner, and it restores 100 wild oysters! read more

Edgartown Meat & Fish - The Oyster Sauvignon Blanc - Seafood Markets Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Great shop. We wanted to grill bison for the fourth. They special ordered for us with next day service.

I am in agreement with the service the cleanliness and the food. The meat and fish are super and reasonably priced. The mixed burger flavors are yummy the Steak tips are over the top good. It is great having sushi that is so fresh. The staff is so accommodating and the shopping experience is pleasurable at any time of day. In fact, I am going there right now to get some fish for dinner yet again, and again and again. Also your beach sandwiches are a swell way to beach it on these last few days of summer. read more

Love this place! The only spot on all of Martha's Vineyard to get a Starbucks coffee. Steak tips are to die for, huge selection of premarinaded for grilling. Always go to lunch here, the folks are extremely friendly. Kudo's to the management here, you've got a great thing going. read more