Wonderful, clean hardware, well laid out hardware store in Edgartown. The staff, all of them, were…read morevery friendly, which was a nice change of the experiencing I have been having around the island lately. They carry Benjamin Moore paint, which was why I went in; they do samples and will paint match for you. I will definitely be a return customer while we renovate our home.

I came in for LED replacement lightbulbs. Extraordinarily stubborn short-tempered manager refused…read moreto accept that she didn't understand my question. She was extremely rude and then she walked away. Never going back to that place. Not at all the MVY I know and love. LED bulbs have two factors: Kelvin AND Lumen output (i.e. color temperature and wattage). She refused to listen even after I told her I deal with lighting in my profession. We kept going around and around.. then she stormed away.

Been going to Shirley's before they moved up the hill. I've never been disappointed. Service is…read morehelpful and knowledgeable. If Shirley's doesn't have it you don't need it. I wonder if Jessie is still cutting keys?

Shirley's is an independently owned all purpose hardware store with everything you need to keep…read moreyour life in order except a personal assistant. Batteries, beach towels, measuring cups, paint, trash cans, watering cans, you name it. They will make copies of your keys in just a few minutes. The ladies who work here are right out of Comedy Central. They never crack a smile but deliver some downright memorable one liners. The island gossip can all be heard here at Shirley's. The best place on the island for last minute mass-produced Halloween costumes. It's a lot cheaper buying light bulbs and dishtowels off island, but then you knew that already.

Called to speak with their custom woodworker. He said he didn't have time to take on my…read moreproject...much less to eve speak about it. I tried to explain how small my need was and he didn't have time to discuss it. He talked over me not allowing me to even ask if there's someone else on the island he could refer me to. Perhaps if he's so busy, he shouldn't take phone calls because he surely doesn't put forth a good impression of the company as a whole.

Such helpful and friendly service and staff. Despite being super busy, employees were there to help.read more

DO NOT RECOMMEND. I went to the store to pick up supplies for my husband and asked an employee for…read morehelp locating the items. He told me the process was to go find them myself and bring them to the counter to pay. When I pushed back and asked again for help, he said, "If you can find someone, you can get help, but there is only one guy working out here." Meanwhile, I was trying to track down 50 lb bags of quick concrete, 4x4x8 pressure-treated lumber, and other heavy items. There was no offer to help and no concern for me as a customer. I am in my 60s and could have seriously injured myself trying to lift these items, especially after spending so much time just trying to locate them. The service was terrible, and it is clear they do not care about their customers.

Quality service matches quality products especially lumber. Delivery or at the store, easy peasyread more

Every time I go to Mahoney's I know they have quality merchandise and employees. Great combo every…read moretime! Clean. Well stocked. Knowledgeable and friendly.

Mshoneys is Yankee hard work meet savvy business people. Great inventory, competitive price…read morematching, and wonderful customer service!

Great lumber yard with excellent stock and very friendly, helpful workers. Good selection of…read morematerials and quick and inexpensive delivery.

As a hobby, I like to build solidbody guitars and other small woodworking projects. I decided to…read morecheck these guys out, because they are close to my house.... WOW! Now that's a lumberyard. Not much in the way of exotic hardwoods, but they had suge a huge selection of mahogany that I spent almost an hour deciding what I was going to take home. Jim, a salesman/lumberman/singer/veteran, was extremely helpful- not only getting the mahogany I settled on, but cutting it, and answering some other questions about the properties of some of the woods they stock. I also learned that they can get any of the exotics I usually get.

Terrible business, we have waited for over 6 months for a cabinet that was promised "next week." I…read morewouldn't recommend it to anyone! Zero care for their customers and not honest people!

Grossman's Bargain Outlet in Plymouth...what a find! Not what I thought it would be, check it out…read more It's a little hard to find, it's in the old Kmart next to Shaw's. The place is loaded with good stuff and the prices are better than any other home improvement retailers in the area. Just purchased everything I need to update a bathroom... plan to go back for more!