We were in town on vacation and ordered a pizza and boneless wings to go. The order was ready sooner than expected, the staff was kind and the impressive. It's a small place and cash only but this place is easily now in my top 5 pizza places! And they have good blue cheese. read more

From start to finish, our experience at Cristiano's Pizza was fantastic. We ordered carry-out and were so impressed! The staff was attentive, helpful, and very friendly when taking our order, and everything was ready quickly and exactly as expected. The food was excellent--pizzas were hot and fresh with generous toppings and a perfectly baked crust, mozzarella sticks crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside, and the antipasto salad was crisp and flavorful with plenty of tasty ingredients. There's no skimping on the salad. You can tell they put care into even the small details. Overall, fast service, friendly people, and food that tastes fantastic. Everything tasted fresh and clearly made with care. This little place delivers on both great service and amazing food. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a go-to pizza place! read more

Friendly service, quick take out and the eggplant pizza was delicious. The taste of the sauce was unique and flavorful. We read other reviews about the garlic knots and they also lived up to their reputation. We will be back to try some of the other specialty pizzas. Just a heads up this place is cash only and they do have an ATM inside. read more

See all

While visiting upstate NY, staying in nearby Wells, we needed a pizza place. Cristiano's was the perfect mountain pie! I called and placed our order over the phone - a large pepperoni pizza, well done. The drive over to Cristiano's was about 20 minutes. When we arrived our order was already waiting for us. The staff was friendly and warm. Note their large pizza is 14 inches so order accordingly! It was the perfect size for 2 hungry adults. We had no trouble finishing it for dinner especially because it was super tasty. Very little grease, no shortage of pepperoni slices, terrific sauce, perfectly baked crust. The exterior of Cristiano's was kind of nondescript but the pizza was excellent! I highly recommend giving them a try! read more

Cristiano's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Northville, New York

I'm picky about my pizza as I've mentioned in other reviews. Cristianos make a good pie with a generous amount of toppings. Even though it's not my style of pizza, I really like it. It's not a thin crisp crust but it's not a thick doughy type either. It was crispy and as I said very good. I had a Calzone Grinder for the first time with pepperoni. It was delicious. Generous portion enough for two people. (So good I ate the whole thing). Other friends of ours (more than one) all speak well of the food and friendly staff. I recommend Cristianos for a good takeout meal. Try it I think you will be pleasantly surprised. read more

We visited upstate from Westchester and places close early there. The owner made our pizza the last one for the night. He was so nice and we chatted about living up there. The pizza was hot, fresh, and delicious! We ordered Half sausage and half eggplant. Loaded with sausage!! I wish I took a pic of it. Good people and good food. read more

Great pizza, and they delivered for a weekend gathering on the lake. Don't hesitate to request something special.

Good pizza with quality ingredients. Worth the drive from Wells. Note that yelp/Google maps took us to a Wells address which is incorrect. The pizza shop is located on Rt30 just south of the bridge to Northville. Cash only but atm on site, which was working in late October of 2020. read more

Bomb Ass Pizza! Awesome Sauce! Awesome Italian Dressing! Whatelse do you need? There is only one Con and that is delivery takes way too long so we just go pick it up. read more

We stopped here last weekend, and got a pepperoni pizza, salad, and sausage parm. Everything was awesome, especially the blue cheese!! Love that the salad was not what you usually expect from a pizza place, no big chunks of tomatoes. Very nice staff also. Thank you guys so much for the awesome food. read more

Cristiano's is a great place to get pizza and i love that they deliver.

Best pizza ever! Been to A LOT of places and this is the best one I have tried yet! Their garlic knots are amazing as well. The staff is supper friendly, and it is great to be able to talk to the owner while he is cooking for you! 10/10 would recommend. read more

If you like NY style pizza, this is the place. Take out only. Thin crust with just the right amount of chewiness, properly spicy sauce, and generous genuine mozzarella. Their menu items range from lasagna, to eggplant parmigiana, chicken parm, spaghetti of various types. The usual southern Italian range. All home-style solid. read more

We had a mixed experience. We ordered a variety of dishes. Our two subs were very good especially the bread. The garlic knots were also very good. Jalapeño poppers were ok but the outside was a bit burnt they also came with a side a sour cream which was odd . ( cream cheese filling does not pair well with sour cream). The wings were really disappointing they were over cooked and covered in chopped garlic ( we ordered hot wings). We could not even eat them. The pizza was small and lacked flavor. We were also shorted a side salad from the order. The owner was very pleasant and maybe this was an off night. We have a vacation rental on the Sacandaga and will not be recommending this establishment to our guests. read more

Excellent pizza, very authetic flavor. Pasta dishes have a great flavor and good portion for the price. Prices are average for pizza places. I reccommend stopping by if your driving pass. read more

Amazing pizza. The best in town! The people are extremely friendly. They also DELIVER!

Best pizza in the area! It is a family favorite because of the many different choices.....so many favorites that we have to alternate through the kids favorites. Also love that they offer delivery service for those nights that I just don't want to cook or go out to pick it up! read more