Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Crooked Creek Lodge

    5.0 (1 review)

    Crooked Creek Lodge Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Crooked Creek Lodge

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    15 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hotels 1,494 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Marienthal Country Inn - The Brick House

    Marienthal Country Inn

    (7 reviews)

    While we await a vaccine, don't overlook the power of really good comfort food in combating an…read moreinternational pandemic. We called ahead and picked up our order at 11 - Pepperdew cheese bread, breakfast sausage strudel, and two romaine salads with chicken. As we drove home, the food smelled so good that we couldn't resist starting before our arrival. The bread was incredible - pockets of cheesiness in each buttery, savory chunk. The sausage strudel was similarly scrumptous - a savory salvo of brunch fare's best. Finally, the romaine salads provided a healthy palette cleanser - tender chicken, pear, blueberry, walnut, and blue cheese crumbles with spiced pear vinaigrette... every mouthful came together perfectly. Saturday brunch takeout is well worth the drive, from the Southtowns or even the city. Enjoy! Menu at - https://www.facebook.com/RetreatInEden/

    We're no strangers to B&Bs - it's our favourite mode of weekend getaway, and when we booked a room…read morelast minute on a long-weekend, we didn't really know what to expect. We even drove right past it the first time - when they say it used to be a church, they aren't kidding. Marienthal itself is three different pieces - the church is absolutely beautiful, and has been converted into a large reception hall. Behind the church is a beautiful little patio with a fireplace where we were able to have breakfast the next day. The parsonage next door was renovated into a number of guest rooms - the room we were originally in was the smallest of them, but had a beautiful attached bathroom, TV and was still plenty of room for two people. Lastly, there was a building (which I believed housed nuns originally), that has been converted into a bit of a retreat centre. There were a half-dozen or so double rooms with a full kitchen upstairs, and a large meeting area downstairs with another great kitchen, big screen TV with satellite, and lots of couches. We even had access to a great little jacuzzi in the back. This place is an absolute gem in the middle of nowhere. There's a little grill next door if you want to grab some food, but otherwise there is almost nothing in the immediate vicinity. You can drive about half an hour if you're looking for things to do, but if you really want to just get away in peace and quiet, where you know you won't be disturbed, this is absolutely the place to do it. Location and buildings aside, the hosts are really what makes this place special. Both of them go way out of their way to be accommodating. Louise's breakfast was very likely the best breakfast I've ever had in my life. Homemade apple turnovers, local sausages, and the fluffiest, cottage-cheese pancakes that still make my mouth water. And Vinnie is a very entertaining fellow to talk to - he has absolutely no shortage of hilarious stories to tell. The two of them were great to have as hosts. The next time we need a quiet getaway, there's zero doubt about where we'll end up.

    The Wilson House - Broiled haddock

    The Wilson House

    (10 reviews)

    The Wilson House is under new ownership this year, and hopefully this time it sticks because it's…read morethe best effort yet. The burgers are great. Love the truffle fries and the giant pretzel, especially with the loganberry cream cheese. Our pickier son really liked the chicken fingers when I brought him. Usually he barely touches his food, but finished most of his dinner and even the leftovers, which almost never happens. Still need to try dessert. Drinks are great. They just added a specialty French 75 that's great. There's a spacious bar area with seating and a separate dining area if you want something brighter and quieter. Great service.

    We had a reservation for 8 on a Friday night at 645. There is bar seating, some tables within the…read morebar area and a dining room area to the right of the bar. The service was friendly and attentive. Unfortunately, due to the kitchen not being able to keep up, they had to stop taking orders for about 30 minutes; so, it was a bit of a wait to order our food and then receive it. We ordered some apps and main dishes including colossal mozzarella sticks (that naming is an embellishment as they were only slightly larger than standard), buffalo pockets, Pittsburgh salad, broiled haddock and opened fade steak to name a few. The apps were good, but nothing special. The waitress was helpful in making sure my mother was able to the have a gf meal; she had the Pittsburgh salad with honey and mustard brought to use as a dressing. My mom enjoyed it. I had the baked haddock with sweet potato fries. It was cooked nicely and the fries were good; crisp outside, soft inside. Three people ordered the open face steak and they all liked it, though not all the steaks were found to be cooked as ordered; they were overcooked from what was requested. I found the bathroom to need some more attention to detail with cleaning; the chair rail, baseboard, handicapped bars and top of toilet tank were all very dusty.

    Edwards Waterhouse Inn

    Edwards Waterhouse Inn

    (13 reviews)

    $$

    My husband and I stayed at the Waterhouse Inn earlier this month and attended a celebration one…read moreafternoon. We couldn't have been more pleased with the ambience, comfort, food, and hospitality offered by Martin and Phillip. This is an elegant, first class, traditional Bed & Breakfast with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The mansion is less assuming on the outside than the White Inn, which I've stayed at many times before, but is much classier, far more comfortable, and much higher quality. Martin and Phillip create a peaceful and cozy home away from home with glowing fireplaces, soft music, bottomless cups of tea/coffee, and impeccable and creative Farm to Table meals that alone make the stay worth your while. If you are looking for an elevated experience to rest your soul and lift your spirits, you need not look any further than this quaint and charming treasure.

    Philip and Martin have taken over the Inn and by reviews of the previous operators it seems they…read moreare continuing to maintain the level of elegant service. We stayed in the Bombay room. The beds were comfortable and soft. The shower water was super hot. The entire house is filled with Victorian period antiques. For breakfast she had the included gingerbread pancakes and I had the frittata. Delicious! The coffee was hand-pressed fresh and the juice & muffin were tasty. Downtown Fredonia and its National Registry twin commons has a variety of pubs and eateries an easy three blocks away. Highly recommended for a Fredonia Village stay.

    Wingate By Wyndham Ellicottville - Guest room

    Wingate By Wyndham Ellicottville

    (18 reviews)

    $$

    Our second stay at this Wingate location this weekend was a huge success. Let's talk COVID first:…read morethey are doing a great job with regulations, cleaning, and adhering to policies set forth by NYS. Hand sani at every turn and I didn't see a single unmasked person throughout my stay. I should also note that the hotel was only at a third capacity, so we really didn't see much of anyone other than the staff throughout our one night stay. We felt safe and at home throughout, and this hotel put cleanline at top priority even before the pandemic. Onto more fun stuff! The staff here is top notch. So friendly and helpful and a pleasure to interact with. We brought our dog, Freddy Sue, this time around, and I would absolutely recommend this hotel to fellow dog owners looking to take their pup to a dog friendly town. It is a $70 charge which is steep, but was worth it to us in terms of peace of mind, especially with the off peak rate of this hotel on a Saturday to Sunday being $140. The beds are SO comfortable and I had such an awesome night's rest. Of course, the location cannot be beat. In the non-COVID times, we bopped from restaurant to restaurant drinking our way through the town and it was amazing to be able to come right back to the center of town as home base. For the price and guaranteed positive experience, I doubt we will ever stay anywhere else when we come to visit Ellicottville. Happy exploring!

    First, they are in the middle of renovations so I can appreciate that. But, the room was 450.00…read moreand included breakfast. The room was laid out wrong with a tv above a fake fireplace and a couch about 6 feet away meaning you had to look up to watch tv. As for the breakfast, it is cool food like vending machine muffins and bulk cereal. No hot food or waffle maker. Even the orange juice was little per-filled sealed cups like it came from a hospital cafeteria. They are remodeling the lobby but they should be doing something with the dated rooms. No charging stations and the couch was old and ratty. We will not be back to this place. UPDATE: I complained on my survey and was contacted by a customer service representative and they gave the company response "sorry for your bad experience we will try hard" which I replied, typical response, I don't believe you even read my additional comments. I said that there was a time when customers were compensated for bad experiences but now it is , we got your money, sorry. About a hour later a got a reply that half my money was being refunded. So at least they are trying so I changed my rating to 2 stars for the effort.

    Crooked Creek Lodge - hotels - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...