BEWARE!! I found what appears to be mouse droppings or mold in my carrot cake. It was certainly some type of foreign object that would need to be carefully researched in order to determine exactly what it is! This discovery was so alarming and obviously jeopardized the health and safety of my family that I immediately called the store. No one picked up. I sent an email on Saturday, April 5th and realized on Tuesday, April 8th almost 4 days had passed with no reply. I decided to forward my email again and finally received a response that they did not receive my original email although the same email address I received the reply from was the exact same email address I originally emailed. Interesting.... Not to mention the forwarded email had a timestamp on it. Nevertheless, I expressed my concerns along with resending the photos. Here's where the situation gets worse .... I advised the email respondent that I saved the cake and would be more than happy to drop it off for them to have it carefully inspected. Instead, they decided to email me back and advise me that they had "carefully inspected the photos", and determined it was a carrot that underwent a chemical reaction and not a concern. SERIOUSLY!?!? Firstly, I read through the ingredients list and there isn't anything listed that should be green. Secondly, I watched the videos of at least 8 vloggers who bit into the carrot cake and turned it towards the camera and NEVER once did I see anything green. So let me guess... this "chemical reaction" just so happen to ONLY happen to my cake? Lastly, and the most disappointing part of the email stated, as a "gesture of goodwill", I would be happy to offer you a "complementary replacement cake." Complementary as in 'Free', haha! How in the world could something be 'complementary' when you already paid for it?! Which is exactly what I asked them in my response. At the bare minimum, I should've been offered a refund. And asked to bring in the piece of cake so they can carefully inspect it to protect the health and safety of ALL the North Haven, CT Crumbl patrons! UNBELIEVABLE, the way this matter was handled! Of course, I respectfully declined the cake and let the respondent know that I would never step foot back into the North Haven Crumbl again, except to drop off their contaminated product. This type of customer service is extremely poor and shows a clear picture of the type of person/persons running the North Haven establishment which I found out are two brothers by the names of Scott and Justin Cinnamon. Certainly a missed opportunity to right a wrong. And by the way, my daughter and I are Pink Status Crumbl members. For those of you who don't know, that is the highest status you can get. The way you become Pink Status is by patronizing Crumbl regularly and earning points. So No - I am not some one-time customer complaining. We actually love their product and enjoy reviewing them. North Haven Crumbl has certainly loss at least one customer due to this. Photos are below...See for yourself! read more

See all

I'm a sucker for cookies. Every time I go to crumble I find another flavor that I absolutely love.

Fast and friendly service . Clean store. Cookies were fresh and nice . I got a pink velvet cookies ... it's amazing

The reason I chose one star was because of the lack of customer service and cookie quality. When I received my order, everything looked great at first, but two cookies were missing their key components. The Strawberry Milkshake cookie was supposed to come with a chocolate pirouline, which was absent, and the Rocky Road cookie was missing the essential marshmallow topping. Neither cookie matched their descriptions or pictures. Additionally, the staff was somewhat rude, and it took only one person to address the issue. Spending over $30 on cookies that weren't made correctly was disappointing. Although I eventually got what I ordered, it wasn't prepared properly. The North Haven location needs better leadership and a working manager to ensure quality and service. This was taken on July 8th, 2024. First day of the new flavors for the week of 7/8-7/13 read more

Crumbl - North Haven - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

If you're looking for a quick sugar fix, this is the place. The cookies are absolutely tasty treats they are always fresh, warm, and perfectly baked. On top of that, the staff was super efficient, providing really quick service so I didn't have to wait long at all to get my order. I'll definitely be back! read more

I'm gonna go with a just okay. Stopped in mid-April with my oldest son to grab 6 cookies. Placed the order on the touch screen upon entering. One of the options was peanut butter related so we avoided that due to my youngest son's allergy....which led to use having to hide the box of cookies from him as we feared the nut exposure could have been cross contaminated. The sugar cookie, pink frosted one, had an almost anisette (licorice) sort of taste to it which I was fond of, but the rest of my family wasn't. The strawberry cheesecake one was good and gooey. Were we supposed to keep that one refrigerated? The rest were alright. Not sure really if they were worth the price? Would we try here again? I mean, maybe. The flavors I believe kind of change daily. read more

See all

The cookies were amazing and also we pre ordered so it was fast and efficient. Love the minis. Enjoy Chris M read more

If you're looking for some delicious gourmet cookies, Crumbl Cookies will not disappoint! They have multiple locations throughout CT, but I decided to try the one in North Haven recently. It's located on Universal Drive in the Home Depot plaza. Here's the scoop on this awesome cookie spot! The inside is pretty small and there are no tables or chairs. It's strictly a to-go place. The Crumbl menu consists of 6 "Flavors of the Week," which change on a weekly basis. I thought that was pretty cool, because you can stop by every week and have different cookie flavors to choose from! (they also post these on their website and Instagram page). When I went, the flavors were: Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk, Cookie Butter White Chip, Blueberry Cheesecake, Caramel Sheet Cake, Cookies & Cream Milkshake, and Buckeye Brownie. You can order a single cookies, 4-pack, 6-pack, and "party box" (which I believe has 12 cookies). They also have milk, chocolate milk, and water to for drinks. I wanted to try all 6 of the weekly flavors, so I got the 6-pack. All were amazing! They also give them to you warm! The Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk was probably my favorite. One thing to keep in mind is that these cookie are pretty large, and also very sweet! (especially any that have frosting, etc.) I found that I couldn't eat more than a couple bites because they were so sweet. Again, not saying they're not delicious, because they are, but just something to consider when ordering. Speaking of ordering, you do this using a self-serve touchscreen kiosk, and also can pay by credit card here as well. They do accept cash at the counter. After placing your order, the employees will bring your box of cookies to you. I was the only one in the place at the time, so the service was very fast. There was limited interaction with the staff because of the self-serve ordering, but they seemed friendly. Overall Crumbl has excellent cookies, though I still think Insomnia are a little better (smaller, not as sweet, options to add ice cream, etc.). I would definitely recommend though! read more

See all

I got a gift certificate and indulged in six Biscoff cheesecake cookies to share with others. The cookies were tremendously enjoyed. The wait time at the store was amazingly short. The employee at the store was extremely helpful when I asked her about how these cookies would taste. read more

Crumbl - North Haven - Biscoff cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

Always have a great selection friendly staff fast service great location sometimes the cookies are even warm

Crumbl Cookies is a franchise of gourmet cookie bakeries that opened in Logan, Utah in 2017. It was founded by cousins James McGowan and Sawyer Hemsley. After experimenting with a lot of dough and tested recipes, the two cousins felt that they finally perfected the world's best chocolate chip cookie. They opened their first bakery in Logan, Utah, and it was important to them to use high-quality ingredients in every batch. After Crumbl's success took off, so did their flavor offering. Today the franchise has more than 620 locations in 47 states, making Crumbl the fastest-growing cookie company in the nation. A new Crumbl location opened in my hometown of North Haven, Connecticut this past July 2022. My wife and I stopped in to get some of their delicious cookies. The place smelled so good when we walked in. We were happy to see the staff making the cookies fresh right then and there. We decided to order their "Famous Pink Box": a box designed to perfectly fit each cookie side-by-side. The unique shape along with the brand's signature pink coloring make it instantly recognizable. The flavors we ended up ordering included the classic Milk Chocolate Chip, Sea Salt Toffee, Strawberry Ice Cream Bar, Monster, Sugar (Shark), and Mint Brownie. These were seriously good cookies! The Mint Brownie cookie was my favorite. I look forward to seeing what other cool flavors that Crumbl comes up with. read more

See all

I wasn't aware that a Crumb Cookies had opened in North Haven until my wife and I were driving North on 91 in New Haven, and my wife said she was craving cookies. A Yelp search later and I learned about the North Haven Crumbl cookies. I'm guessing it's been open about 3 weeks given the day of the first Yelp review. I've been to the Manchester Crumbl and liked their cookies a lot. I was surprised to see the present 2 Star Yelp rating for the North Haven Crumbl, but with multiple Yelp Elite reviews reflected in that score, Crumbl should take that seriously. I suspect the rating reflects the fact that people don't like to wait in lines, and that this Crumbl crew hasn't worked up the experience to more efficiently deal with the lines and online orders yet. I definitely witnessed some of that while I was there. The process did not seem as smooth as my early visit to Manchester. Nonetheless, I'm not going to grade Crumbl too harshly at this point. Gotta give them some room to grow. The two cookies I sampled were fresh and delicious. They included a chocolate caramel cookie and a strawberry cake sort of cookie. The cookies are so good, I'm sure Crumbl's Yelp score will rise as the initial lines start to die down. Four Stars. read more

See all

What to have for dessert? Hmmm. A cookie? Nah. How about a ginormous cake cookie!!! You never know what's on special at crumbl. Always guaranteed some sort of sugar cookie. This week I decided on a full 6 pack. They all sounded so good. Im your basic kind of gal, choco chip, and sugar cookies are a big yes for me. Peanut butter, yup the kiddos will eat that. Brownie, wedding cake and yea fruit pie!! Put them in the box please. So fresh, doughie and baked to perfection. Loved how the brownie cookie' edges had a slight crunch to it! Fruit pie with the cream cheese frosting- reminded me of the fruit tarts I used to make. The staff who presented my cookies, yes they do present them to you, (to ensure your liking), spoke with a smile and genuinely showed she cared if I was happy with my cookies. These cookies are so big and fat, we cut them in quarters. This way we all can try each flavor. Highly recommend, though be prepared to spend a pretty penny. read more

See all

Finally waited in the line, not sure what's going to happen come winter as it's a small place. I got chocolate chip and Banana Cream Pie which is why I waited. The chocolate chip was very good but I didn't care for the Banana Cream Pie. Definitely not something I would order again. I didn't like the texture of the pudding and the cookie base wasn't hitting it out the park either The cookies are huge, about 2-3 portion size. Not a place I will rush back to. Had to at least try it once. read more

Great service. Great cookies. Would go there again. My kids loved it. The cookie was moist and flavorful.

I ordered via uber eats. Big mistake. They sent me someone else's order (even the name was wrong on the bag). They sent me all cakes and a peanut butter cookie that was underbaked. My coworker is allergic to pb. Thank god I checked. When I called to report this to the restaurant the woman on the phone basically told me I was wrong and didn't offer to help or even apologize. I have been told from many that this is the worst location. I won't be going back to this one read more

The flavors are hit or miss! So far i've loved every cake i've tried! Alot of times the cookies are under done, like completely raw in the middle! No one greets you when you walk in the store! Not too much ambiance in the place, it would be nice to have an extra person working just to keep up with the housekeeping since it is an open kitchen! It's usually only 2 people working at a time! I also ordered pIck up service about 24 hours in advance! Got there my order wasn't even ready! So much for ordering ahead! read more

Crumbl - North Haven - Ande's mint Cake, Lucky Charms, mixed berry raw, 3 fruity pebbles raw also cereal flavor wasn't present - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

pretty good the cookies are really good and service is ok. I like this place a lot the ambiance is good

Decent but not worth the money long wait not worth it out the best cookie I came from

Clean. Bright. Energetic. Lines. Broken ordering system, two-ways. Very nice and even-tempered staff. Disappointing. Not a fan. But who doesn't love the smell of fresh-baked cookies? I've been to a couple of locations. They differ in size but are generally exactly the same operation. It's very clean, bright, smells wonderful and a nice greeting typically given to each person walking in the door; " welcome to crumbl". That's about all the good things to be said, at least on this visit, although there was no greeting on this evening. I came her me to get my daughter, who is a fan, a couple of cookies. They have a tablet ordering system each guests orders from on their own. One of the two were broken, which made for extra long lines. When it was my turn they ran out of one of the cookies they have everyday, chocolate chip, as well as the rocky road cookie. I saw many sheets of uncooked dough so someone must have had the cooking times wrong. I ordered the lemon cheesecake cookies for my daughter and two peanut butter cup cookies to make a 4-pack. After about 10 minutes waiting, I was called to the counter to be told they sold out of the peanut butter cup cookies and did I want to wait 15 minutes until they were done or did I want to cancel my order. I said I'd take the two lemon only and was told I had to then cancel my whole order and re-order the two cookies because they didn't have a way to do it through their system otherwise. Hard to believe. The system never should've taken my order for cookies that weren't ready. When I mentioned that they told me they don't pull cookies until people show up to pick up (for orders placed online) so the inventory isn't exactly accurate. Doesn't make sense. Crumbl has alot of fans. I'm not one of them, and for more reasons now than that the cookies don't have much flavor, are typically undercooked and are certainly not worth $5/each. read more

Crumbl - North Haven - Out of half of the cookies. - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

I was not pleased with the food service. the workers were very rude and dismissive and when I received my box passive aggressively, it seemed like the cookies were thrown all over the place. Will not be returning. That explains the 2.5 rating on yelp. read more

This is a really cute trendy cookie shop. I wish I had thought of this idea! There were at least 20 customers that went into the cookie shop in the 15 minutes that I sat outside waiting for my niece. We go in, the staff was friendly and directed us to the self service kiosk. We begin lòoking through the options. My neice was like oooh tasting party. She orders a box of 4. Me, I started with 1 because I read the reviews, which were pretty negative. It's crazy because people were steadily coming in. There is a bright white cookie factory with about 10 employees making cookies. The inside is really pretty with the pink accent color. There is no place to sit inside. We sat outside on the bench to try the cookies. We tried the còokies. They were tasty. Not spectacular or life changeing or the best cookie ever. Just tasty and nicely packaged. read more

See all

I was shopping and noticed they had opened so I waited in line very excited. From the outside looking in everything was amazing the girl at the door was so sweet and helpful. Once I got in I was greeted with a loud welcome from everyone. I ordered two of each cookie and couldn't wait to try. They had mentioned finally getting the recipe right in the line so I was confident I was in for a treat. To my surprise I didn't like a single one! Like chocolate chip cookies have a distinct flavor, not theirs! The peanut butter cookie didn't taste like peanut butter. It was very weird. A house full of 12 kids and all they did was nibble on the pop tarts from the top. Beyond disappointed. My 2 stars were for customer service. I do not recommend and I would not waste my money again. Don't believe the hype! read more

Crumbl - North Haven - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

The chocolate cheesecake was delicious..will definitely be back to try some more flavors!

If you like $16 4 pack of under cooked terrible cookies this is your place. I fell victim to the hype. Terrible selection of flavors. Everyone felt sick after eating half a cookie. Too sugary and too soft. Buy a roll of toll house and save your money The 16 year old employees stare at you but don't speak very weird. I had to place my order on a tablet while the human being stared at me. At least the tablet asked for a tip???? read more

Crumbl - North Haven - Coconut - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

I'm going to give the overall experience 3- stars.! I was not impressed with the employees playing around in the back .! The favoritism to #certain people -&& the dirty looks from the cashier ! I Seen two employees under pressure.! I seen an employee punch the cookie batter on the cookie tray .! SMH - I ordered Three Oreo Cookies-& one Fruit cake Cookie.! The Oreo cookies came warm -& The fruit cake cookie....I think it taste Okay .! #AllCookiesShouldBeBakedWithLove.! read more

Crumbl - North Haven - #Oreo .! - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

ordering process and wait time was good nothing to complain about. NO ONE said "welcome to Crumbl" when i walked in. The worker brought over the box with the top open and just walked away without really saying anything. Bottom and sides of the box were covered with chocolate frosting, got all over my arms and shirt. The cookies will be the death of America. They are so sweet I have a headache now. I guess to each their own but I have many of my peers complain about the sweetness and how the cookie is not enjoyable because of the over powering sweetness. The place looked clean I guess, the smell hits you like a bus I don't know how I stayed on my feet. The prices are outrageous 25$ for 6 cookies and high risk of diabetes. Overall if you like sweet stuff, headaches and spending a lot money, i'd definitely recommend dropping a visit to Crumbl. read more

I loved the warm cookies that they gave. I once ordered a Caramel Apple Cookie or whatever it's called, delicious. The service is really nice, and one time when I went to Crumbl like 30 minutes before it closed, I asked for a 6 pack and the lady gave me 1 extra free cookie. How amazing and nice. read more

Love Crumbl Cookies so we were so excited when the North Haven store opened. Each Sunday we wait to see the new menu. We love all the cookies with peanut butter so it was a must to order cookies this week. The peanut butter blossoms were delicious. The soft center of the cookie was our favorite and then topped with chocolate how could that be wrong. We also tried the chocolate silk cookie. So delicious. The cookie part is a chocolate brownie cookie and then filled with a chocolate filling and chilled. One whole cookie is plenty to share. We split them in half of only trying one. Otherwise a quarter of the cookie is a perfect amount. The service for a new store was impressive. They seemed to have a quick procedure and the staff was very kind. read more

See all

Crumbl Cookie is a case study in very effective marketing, but is not necessarily a "must have" cookie. Right off the bat the one question I have is how does an establishment whose sole product is the cookie run out of the mother of all cookies...the CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE during their grand opening? My wife and I waited in line for about an hour. Every couple feet we would say "The only thing I am really interested in is how is their Chocolate Chip Cookie?" "Yeah, a cookie place really has to have a solid chocolate chip cookie, can't wait to see what this place is all about!" "Hey have you heard anything about their chocolate chip cookie?" When we got to the front of the line..."Sorry we are all out of the chocolate chip cookies?" I mean that's like an ice cream shop running out of chocolate and vanilla and only having strawberry! Who wants strawberry ice cream? It's mind boggling! Here is where the marketing gets you though, because in a week there will be a new set of flavors plus the chocolate chip, so we really have no choice but to return, and when we do there will be a whole new set of flavors that we will have to try. It's frustrating, but you have to do what you have to do right? Now let's talk about the cookies. They aren't awful, but they didn't blow my mind! I wish I would have had the opportunity to try a chocolate chip cookie, but I'm not sure if you heard, they ran out! But don't worry they had this mystery peanut butter cookie. It had a huge question mark on the picture of the cookie. We were so intrigued, what were we going to get? Perhaps a peanut butter cookie filled with Nutella, or the Elvis special peanut butter and banana cookie. Well don't get too excited, it's just a plain peanut butter cookie. You know the one your mom made with the little checker board on top. True cookie lovers know what I'm talking about. There is no mystery. It's about as mysterious 2020 election. All in all I wouldn't wait in line for Crumbl Cookie again even though it did afford me some quality time with my beautiful wife. I would however go again and that's because of the respect I have for the marketing not because I'm dying for another cookie. Because this is a review I will tell you the double chocolate brownie was the best we tried, but I'm not sure if you heard, they ran out of chocolate chip cookies so maybe that one is good or maybe it's not? I guess that's just how the cookie crumbles!!! One last thing...the young lady working at the door was kind, personable, and did a great job! read more

See all

Just went in. Only 2 cookies available. Walked right out. Wish they had more. Maybe this is posted in their website?

The cookies are really good, the girl at the door and counter very nice, after placing my order, after waiting in line outside and inside, I am told they ran out of one flavor I can sub it, I say okay and add chocolate chip instead, wait again, and am told they are now out of another flavor, at this point they also are telling the uber eats drivers they are out of flavors ordered ahead on the app as the drivers wait next to me. The back baking area is chaos to watch. It's only week 2 so I'll try again soon but for now this place is not running smoothly at all which is surprising for a chain that must have processes in place as a general rule. I ordered two boxes of cookies (6) in each and upon getting the cookies home they weren't packed as ordered and had the wrong flavors of what was supposedly then available to order. read more

Crumbl - North Haven - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

I don't understand the complaints about overpriced cookies. The prices are listed. Yes, it is an overpriced cookie spot, thats what you're signing up for when you go to a spot like this. Are the cookies delicious? Yes, the Choc chip is very good, the rest... not so much. If you're in the mood for an overpriced Choc Chip the size of your fist, you won't be disappointed. Its thick, doughy in the middle, and full of chocolate. read more

Crumbl - North Haven - Choc Chic, Twiz Shortbread, PB - Bakeries Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

My daughter was not shown her cookies. Ordered 6 minis- received 5 and the 5th cookies wasn't frosted. read more

Always a good, easy experience. Staff is very pleasant and prompt, and prepares the orders correctly every time.

I enjoyed a cotton candy sugar cookie that was given to me at work. I fell in love and had to ask where the cookies came from. I will be visiting them very soon in addition to ordering some for catering at my events. I see that their hours are late in which I'm sure I'll be visiting for my own cravings. I definitely recommend and guaranteed that you won't be disappointed. read more

If I think my chocolate chip cookie needs extra salt, I can sprinkle it on myself. The crumble chocolate chip cookie I purchased was overly sprinkled in some areas While the rest of the cookie had none. Salt has been proven to be bad for the body, So I think it should be left off of Crumbl cookies. The Oreo frosted cookie was cloyingly sweet with over an inch high of frosting. Sometimes less really is more. I won't be buying any more of these overpriced, unhealthy cookies. read more

I had the same experience as others did: Undercooked and WAY too sugary Nearly $5 a cookie The portions are insane & you're not given a smaller alternative. Go to insomnia and don't waste your time. read more

Sometimes busy and long wait times. Often out of cookies from the weekly menu. Ordering online doesn't give you quicker service.

The ease at which you order can be taken either on an in house computer or directly to an employee. In a short period of time my order of delicious was ready to be enjoyed I highly recommend this place read more