Great food with very attentive, courteous staff. There is a wide variety of dishes on the…read moremenu--chicken, pork, beef, and fish based. We had some of each, minus chicken, and all were excellent. We finished off with flan and it was superb. Highly recommend!

My husband and I (Marathon locals) recently ate dinner on June 9, 2026 at El Siboney Overseas. This…read morewas our 2nd time eating at this restaurant. The first time was during their grand opening week late last year (4Q2025), in which the service and food were amazingly fantastic! Unfortunately, last night was disappointing. The food quality was lacking (salty, not hot, and seemingly not fresh) and the service was not exceptional particularly since there were only two additional tables besides ours being served indoors. Attention to detail, like filling water glasses and clearing plates without the guest having to ask would be a great start. Also a friendly, welcoming service team would make all the difference in the world when the food is below average. Going out to dinner these days truly is a luxury. The prices are high and the servings are much smaller than they used to be. A consideration for El Siboney Overseas is to compensate the higher prices with phenomenal, undeniable food and service...especially, when it's obviously slow due to it currently being the "off season" in the Florida Keyes. Sadly, after last night's experience, we're not planning on returning to El Siboney Overseas.

Wow! The food was so good. Service was fast and friendly. Picnic tables on the front porch for…read moredining "in". I've wanted to stop here in the past and finally had the opportunity. This is a FL Keys experience you don't want to miss.

the FOOD was chef's kiss. 10/10 highly recommended. they have tables to sit at. it was relaxing and…read moref

Food was alright - not that much of a selection... Give it about 2-3 hours then it hits you like a…read moretsunam. Man I don't know what they put in the food but it had me on the toilet for a while. My whole family and this is not good since we are all sharing a one bathroom hotel. Good food but bad aftermath...

The restaurant has been remodeled and it's absolutely beautiful. It had a fresh and modern feel…read more The drinks were absolutely wonderful and the tapas were exquisite. The service is amazing. Our server was Eddy and he was extraordinary. We will definitely come back. Thank you,, Eddy!!! P.S. - and the prices are reasonable. Totally recommend.

Great fish sandwich (it was yellowtail at that day) and Cuban coffee! Lady serving food is very…read moresweet. It felt like home-meal and it was perfect for tired stomach from tourism-business restaurants:) I am afraid this place does not have a customer bathroom. That is only reason for one less star:)

Good food. Decent pricing. Small shack mainly for to go orders. Service is ok. Best in the arearead more

I can never find a good Mexican place in florida. But I was so happy to have stumbled upon this…read moreone! It's a small Mexican shop. Ac inside with some seating on the windows and side wall then outdoor seating. Was happy to see a lot of locals who were working come by for lunch. Which is a good sign! Had the burrito with my fav-onion cilantro rice. But it comes with lettuce tomato if you want. It was a decent size. I had the carnitas. It was slow roasted pork-not deep fried. But it was really good. My partner had the fish tacos. We were going off the pictures from Yelp but they didn't come deep fried. Not sure if we had to ask for that. It was good regardless. Both the fish and carnitas had the same seasoning. Had the chips and salsa. The salsa taste like fresh tomato and garlic. Very garlicky. It was good but you've been warned if you don't like garlic. Chips are obviously fried in store. The salsa verde was mild and taste also fresh. The salsa rojo was different than what came with chips. It was mild as well. We also had their Jamaica and it was so fresh and perfectly made!!!!!! We would have eaten here twice if we had time. It's a great place to stop by if you need something quick. It's different from Whats offered in the keys. But it's very good! Would definitely go back!

If you love authentic Italian and are looking for the BEST Alfredo you've ever tasted, you gotta go…read moreto Frank's. Modest looking from the outside in the strip mall. Trust me-delish! Atmosphere: Laid back. 12 tables. Good service. We had a great waitress with a good sense of humor. After taking our order, she disappeared for less than 2 minutes and returned with our salads. She apologized for the long wait (hahaha). Menu: Extensive! Great selection of wine, pastas, meats, and seafood platters. All exceptionally fresh! The homemade blue cheese dressing was exceptional too! The linguine was the default, but they are happy to change out the pasta type upon request. Food for thought: If you have a party of 8+ call in advance by a couple of days. They really only accommodate a party this large one table at a time. The restaurant is small. After an amazing first meal, we tried to return. I called the same day (Friday afternoon), the lady was rather rude and told me "We only got one table, Hun, shoulda thought ahead." I asked about coming in and waiting and she provided another disrespectful response. We tried again on Saturday and the gentleman tried to accommodate us better (ie/ 2 tables). Unfortunately, the timing still didn't work out, so they lost our sale. Tried to get sympathy for working past 9pm (staying open just for the current customers). Note they are closed on Sundays and for most of August for a vacation. Worth the visit overall though! We will try again next time we're in town.

Loved our waitress!! She was funny and attentive. Thoroughly explained the specials and any…read morequestions my party had. The food was so fresh and flavorful. We got lucky with being seated right away - it was very popular for weekday dinner. Would definitely come back.

Good Cracked Conch and service was good. It was not busy when we were there and food arrived…read morequickly.

Cracked Conch Cafe (Marathon) -- This Is What We're Accepting Now?…read more If your conch chowder shows up without conch, and the solution is to add it afterward, that's not a mistake -- that's how the kitchen is operating. First bowl: Sent back. No conch. None. Look at the photos -- it's vegetable soup. Second bowl: now there's conch, but it's clearly dropped in after the fact. Pale, rubbery, sitting on top like a garnish that showed up late. That's not chowder. That's a cover-up. And it doesn't get better. Cut open the "conch balls". Mushy filler with tiny bits of conch, greasy, fried hard to hold together. That's not a conch fritter. Is that what a "ball" is supposed to be? Cracked conch? Uniform, tight, clearly from frozen. Ceviche? Overworked, rubbery, heavy oregano -- more masking than seasoning. The place is doing steady business, so clearly there's a loyal crowd here. Which brings us to the uncomfortable question: At what point do we stop giving a pass to places coasting on reputation and start expecting the food to match the name on the sign? Because this isn't a small miss -- this is the entire identity of the restaurant not being executed at a basic level. So I'll ask it directly: If this is acceptable conch to you... what does good conch even look like?

EASILY some of the BEST food I've ever had in my life -- no exaggeration…read more We went all in: shrimp tacos, chicken tacos, carne tacos, the shrimp po' boy, and the fried pork... and EVERY. SINGLE. THING. was unreal. Like, not one weak item on the table. But let me be clear -- that shrimp po' boy??? ABSOLUTELY STOLE THE SHOW. I'd go back for that alone. The whole place has that perfect outdoor Keys vibe -- laid back, great energy, just straight-up good times. And the service?? Top tier. Olivia and Mikey were on point the entire time -- super friendly, nailed the order, and made the experience even better. Huge respect to the kitchen too -- Marcus and Chapel are putting out some seriously special food. You can TASTE the effort and care in every bite. This place isn't just good... it's the kind of spot you think about after you leave. A spot you talk about until you go back. We'll 1000% be back. Probably way too soon

Food was good and fresh. Ate the tune poke bowl and the ceviche…read more Wasn't a fan of the ceviche, was a bit spicy and made in some sort of Jamaicans rule recipe. The tuna poke made up for it though. Tune was very fresh.