I must love it since I keep coming back. Normally I get a cannoli and sit by the window. There's…read morealways other pleasant customers inside as well happy to see children. It's quiet, on the smaller side.

I love that West Allis has so many cute spots for a classy meal or quick bite, and very much…read morefamily-owned businesses. Aggie's is a fun, hip bakery and cake shop that been around for a really long time. I was excited to finally try a "cake shop" although I didn't get cake on this trip, I would try another time! There's a great seating area, a nice display of all the baked good made fresh that morning, and an opportunity to grab a cup of coffee too. I had asked the person working behind the display what their most popular baked goods were and I was met with silence and then a "everything is good." I was slightly peeved by my interaction here and didn't let it fully deter my review of the baked goods themselves. I had the apple dumpling after seeing decent reviews about it on Yelp. The pastry wasn't at all flaky or buttery but rather hard and biscuit-like. Maybe I went in with the wrong expectation of what an apple dumpling was but it wasn't what I had wanted exactly. It leaned more sweet and glaze heavy than it did cinnamon spice. Overall, would recommend checking out Aggie's for their longstanding history in the Milwaukee area. It just wasn't for me!

We got a cutting cake for our wedding from Classy Girl and it looked and tasted AMAZING! I provided…read morea photo for inspo and it was exactly what I wanted! I've also had their cupcakes before and they are delicious. Erica was so nice and very responsive via email.

I had a team of 10 people from out of town working in Milwaukee. I wanted to show them some…read moreappreciation and found "Classy Girl Cupcakes" were nearby. I walked over to their shop, told them what I was thinking, and she said "No problem. I know just what you need." She packed up 18 assorted cup cakes, I paid for them at about $2/cupcake, and she sent me on my way. It was a hit with the team. The frosting was great. The cupcakes were moist. And, I was able to provide instant appreciation. If I lived here, I'd go to them for parties and other office events. The quality is great and the customer service was awesome. Friendly people too!

Delicately Delicious is by far my favorite cake spot in Milwaukee area. Their cakes are so tasty…read moreand always beautiful. I frequently stop in during strolls through Cedarburg to enjoy their cupcakes (salted caramel & raspberry are my favorites). Jen and the Delicately Delicious team are incredibly generous as well. They helped create the most beautiful cake for Make-A-Wish Wisconsin's 40th Birthday celebration, Wild Wishes. This zoo themed cake was the highlight of the event!

Birthday Cake look very nice but that is where it ended. Cake was dry and had to be thrown out. I…read morecould have take a box cake mix and had a more appetizing cake. Delicately Delicious support would not do anything to rectify the issue.

yummy Valentine's Day treats from Lucy Bakes! I couldn't decide so I go a few things. Cupcakes, a…read morecookie, brownie and small chocolate cake. Cutie little shop inside!

Lucy is the best. So is her talent! If you're looking for delicious and beautiful baked desserts,…read moreshe has you covered with everything from cookies and cakes, to cupcakes, pies, cinnamon rolls, and cookie sandwiches. The retail shop is great if you want to pop in a pick up ready-to-buy items, which I did most recently. I was in need for a little smash cake for my one year old's birthday, so I stopped in for one of those. She kindly added "one" on the top per my request. My son did indeed smash part of it, but fear-not, we got to eat some of it too! So delicious. On the other hand, if you are looking for really custom creations, she does not disappoint there either! Lucy has made incredible cookies for both my kids birthdays, and for work functions. She has true talent, so if you have an upcoming baby shower, wedding, party, you name it... request cookie's from Lucy Bakes!

I LOVE C Adam's bakery. They've been in the MPM as long as I've been alive. Their cookie dough cake…read morejar is to die for. Their brownies are always delicious, too. They are reasonably priced, especially in this era of expensive pastries. Service is always very friendly!!

I love this bakery located in the Public Market. I've been here many of times and have tried…read morevarious desserts from cupcakes, cakes, macarons, cake pops, and cheesecake! I have never been disappointed by a dessert but their cheesecake, cakes pops, and macarons are my favorite! The staff is always super friendly, quick, and welcoming. The display is big and lit so customers are able to see the different goodies and they have flavors that rotate so it isn't the same desserts every time. Very cute place!

The last time The Cake Lady made us a cake was for our a gender reveal in 2021, and here we are…read morefour years later, she has now made a birthday cake for our son! Cecelia is so easy to get in touch with and communicate the vision. It's as simple as filling out the contact form on her website. She was quick to respond and request a few additional details about the cake we were looking to have made, including size, filling, and flavors. We went with a small round cake for 8-10 people, and I sent over a few photos of what I had in mind for the 'Cars theme.' I paid the digital invoice that came through via email, and picked up on our requested date. Easy as that. Oh and of course my son and all of his friends loved the cake!

I have visited the cake lady for birthday cakes and specialty cookies. They always turn out…read moreabsolutely incredible! The cakes have been exactly to my vision (or even better than what I wanted) and very delicious. I highly recommend for all of your baked goods needs!

Consistently high-quality, tasty breads and pastries, friendly and accommodating staff, and a…read morerelaxed, low-key vibe, whether dining indoors or outside... What better way to complement a trip to Cedarburg!

The bakery gets a solid five stars--one of the best old school bakeries I've ever patronized. My…read morefav is the rare Gibassier, with its subtle anise and orange flavoring. Their bread is the best you'll find. The staff is always pleasant. The only suggestions I have: Bake more items so that you are not always out, and adjust hours to be open longer.