Just don't. Chaotic and not good. Fried chicken was inedible and vegetarian options non existent. This is our biggest regret on sag harbor and it was my choice to try it. I did order something vegetarian and it was an absolute tragedy. Husband will not let me live it down, that is how bad it was. He is teasing me as we speak and he will probably continue to do so for years to come -- the worst food we had in our 5+ year relationship. Yes, I deserve the teasing for suggesting this. Just don't. Don't listen to Reddit about the amazing sandwiches here. They don't live here. Infinitely better options nearby. read more

Friendly staff! Fresh quality groceries! Clean store. Would go back. Had everything we needed

Ordered a plain bagel with cream cheese and I'm pretty sure the cream cheese was applied with a whisper and a prayer. The bagel itself was fine, but the amount of cream cheese was so tiny it felt more symbolic than functional. I had to check twice to make sure I didn't accidentally order it dry. If you're going to charge for cream cheese, please let it actually exist read more

Cromer's Market - Grocery Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Great fresh meats. Groceries of the highest quality. Service with a smile but can be pricey.

Great fried chicken, ribs, egg potato salad, home fries, homemade brisket. Expensive, but convenient, and delicious.

I used to love this place. It's gone so far downhill. The staff is rude. They get so irritated if you ask for help and heaven forbid you call and ask if something is available. They actually try not to answer. The food has become worse as the prices have gotten higher. Sadly, we don't go there any more unless it's urgent. The butcher shop is the only saving grace. read more

Convenient Deli/Market. Everything is expensive but this is what you would expect for the area. If you order something from the deli counter there is a high probability they will make a mistake and get it wrong. You should make sure they get it right before you leave. read more

My review is more about a particular product versus the actual store. The store is a typical small supermarket which I am sure is fine if you are visiting or living in the area. I first heard of Cromer's Country Market on a cooking show about 10-15 years ago that featured its smoked Andouille and Kielbasa sausages. You'll find these at the meat counter. I have been stopping in to get these whenever I am out on the south fork ever since. Got some Andouille sausages yesterday. Yum! It's a little out of the way on Noyack Rd but worth it. Give it a try. :) read more

Easy and quick access, accessible location. Deli tends to take longer and workers are normally distracted. Overall reliable for a pit stop and quick last minute necessities. read more

For a local deli, the food is great, their attention to their customers is outstanding and it's got a really family style atmosphere. The meat department is one of the best on the east end. Sandwiches and breakfast are generous and tasty. Try the breakfast burrito. read more

Very much enjoyed a delicious sandwich on a seeded roll here. So much variety and helpful staff! The ingredients seemed quiet quality! Great local deli! read more

Great quality, very fair prices, attention to cleanliness, great inventory and appreciative staff. Job well done.

I come into this business often for their butcher's opinions and meat department. I buy their Noyac blend for hamburgers and other meat products. Fried chicken is good also. Excellent quality all around. Cannot say anything about other items, as I do my shopping elsewhere. But their meat department rules! read more

Cromer's is our go-to for breakfast pancakes and groceries in a pinch. The staff is always so kind! They have all of the grocery staples you can think of if you're out in the Noyac area and don't want to drive all the way to a grocery store. The pancakes are absolutely to die for! Only deducting a star because I've had some very average sandwiches there. They tend to use the yellow, pale part of the lettuce (I swear I've never gotten a green piece of lettuce from Cromer's) and the sandwiches on the menu always seem to be missing something, in my opinion. I usually avoid anything with grilled chicken because the cutlets are typically pretty dry. However, I still recommend this place because there are plenty of things to order besides sandwiches. My family has been ordering their fried chicken and mac & cheese for decades now! I'd say they have something for everyone. read more

Four stars considering it is a deli/market. They have everything you could need for a weekend out East (dairy products,meat, drinks, snacks etc), especially if you didn't run to king Kullen on the way out. Yes some of their items are pricer, but it's all about the convenience. We always come for the hot foods- fried chicken, mac and cheese, pulled pork, gravy & mashed potatoes and steak fries. They sell everything by the pound in a variety of different sized containers. It makes backyard dinners a breeze & their food is never disappointing; it's all true comfort food. My only complaint is that they don't fill the containers up fully- like if you're charging me my weight just keep going! Don't leave air spaces, but that's just me. We've even drove all the way out to bring some more back home to the city. It's a staple in the summer out East read more

Cromer's Market - Take out night! from left to right: large gravy, (2) mac and cheeses, (2) large mashed potatoes - Grocery Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

4th of July Weekend... Place was jumping which made it very tight to move around. For the business they must do throughout the summer, they need to spruce the joint up a bit. Looks like it hasn't been redone since the 80's... Now for the important part... I was told they had a nice selection from the butcher and was not disappointed... After surveying the field, we came to a conclusion... THE TOMAHAWK RIB EYE! The butcher looked at me like I was crazy when I said, "cut it as thick as you can" He said, "sir that's probably 2.5lbs"... I said "Perfect!!" End result was a 3.25lb/ 52oz beautiful cut of meat... We were out celebrating my buddy's birthday and this seemed like the appropriate gift. Sea Salt, Cracked Black Pepper and a 3 am, 700 Degree Weber sear led to a top 5 steak I've ever had... Pittsburgh Style, Black and Blue, however you describe it, it was delicious. Enjoy the Pictures and We'll be back next time! read more

See all

The couple times Ive been there, I've only gotten the chicken and ribs because they're that good. Im really surprised because the food stays out all day and it doesn't get hard and dry like most hot foods in a steam table. I'm not too fond with their sides like their mashed potatoes or their salads (mac salad). I think it lacked a little something. But anyways, I could go without the sides....the chicken and ribs are that good :-) The place is very friendly, attentive, and takes credit cards! So many delis do not that credit cards so this is a huge plus for me. There's plenty of parking, but it's kind of hard to leave the deli because of on going traffic. The place is very clean and organize. It's pretty large so there are a few grocery items to accommodate the surrounding area because the next supermarket is in Bridgehampton and/or Southampton which is pretty far from that area. read more

Avoid the pulled pork at all costs! It's like going from being CEO of Goldman Sachs to managing a Pizzahut in Wisconsin. If you ever eat pulled pork again after Cromer's from anywhere else you will be so disappointed. Love the food and the price here. The butcher has everything too. Filet mignon to rabbit and duck. read more

I am lucky enough to live near Cromer's. The butcher dept is the BEST in the area. All the meats are restaurant grade and the prices are good for the quality of meat. The deli is fabulous as are their signature Fried Chicken ( very tasty!) I used to travel to Southampton years ago when they were located there. When Tony bought the place from the Cromer's he kept the Fried Chicken and made the store even better. The produce and bakery goods are excellent too! Tony even imports Babka from Riverhead for the Holidays so I don't have to travel for that too! If you don't want to cook for Thanksgiving or Christmas they will do it for you and are open tii 3 on the holidays in case you forgot something. Bravo GREAT STORE!!!! read more

Again, Nostalgia. I grew up here. This is the little bay side deli market that alllllll the hard working blue collar workers of the area go to to their lunch fix. I love the sandwiches, fried chx, and big wedge cut fries. Green box Hampton Dairy Iced Tea is a must. However the staff always seems cranky which is kind of a bummer. read more

Cromer's Market - a sandwich and a bag of chips - Grocery Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Cute little market. Fried chicken smells really good probably going to try that next time.

Forgetting the main part of the food that I ordered? Come on. I don't know how you do that. I paid for everything but didn't get everything

Busy place. I stopped in for bottled water and was surprised to see a full deli and cooked food counter inside. People came in to order ribs, steaks, fried chicken. Seems like a hidden jem. Outside is very unassuming, inside is small but people kept coming in for food. read more

Cromer's Market - a red truck parked in front of the store - Grocery Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Pit stop spot on the way in to the Hamptons that carries quickie staples, makes hot food,and is always busy because you always remember you need something just before you get to your driveway. Clean, food is good and they zip you right through. read more

Convenient little grocery store with amazing prepared foods, meats and cheese. I make a point to stop and pick up something whenever I go by. read more

Good selection. Marinated Steak sandwich was pretty good.

Quick and friendly service, good quality prepared foods, year round, but still a little too pricey to be a regular stop. I'm always satisfied, even with limited choices. Best chicken around. Glad for the renovations in recent years. read more

I was appalled to see the increase in prices due to pandemic. A few prices have come down. Maybe a few shoppers complained.....very rude to take advantage of a community. The gals at checkout are rude as well. They should be courteous to customers. read more

Good food. Nice deli people and butcher people. Some of the cashiers could be rude at times. But it's the only market in Noyac.

It's a nice market, lots of prepared foods and a few British/Irish products if you like that stuff. I went for the fried chicken which unfortunately I was disappointed with. It looks really good from the glass but it was eh. The potato wedges were also very eh. Can't recommend either of those things. read more

What would we do without Cromers? Thank you Tony for keeping this business at its best. From the freshest meat ~ tasty deli ~ fried chicken .... mouthwatering. Everything you need at this ideally located market. Worth the wait for a egg sandwich in the morning to the rotiserre chicken in the evening. 5 star plus! read more

Cromer's has always been a great place for the 30 years we've been coming out here. The only downside was the inconsistent counter cashiers and the somewhat banged-up arrangement of the registers. Both of those liabilities have been fixed - major renovation is complete (much more light, easier flow, no more plexiglass!) and the folks at register are always nice (it's a two way street, folks, so be nice to them) - so there is nothing negative to say about Cromer's. And just one more plug - the butcher is the reason Cromer's is what it is. Those guys know their stuff and do not mess around. They'll answer any question and give you great tips on how to cook what you've bought. Best spot on Noyac road by a mile! read more

Got corned beef hash and two over easy eggs and grabbed an Italian hero for lunch. Hero was premade.. The hash was out of a hormel can and my eggs weren't over easy, they came out well done. Make your own assessment. Though I've gone before and atleast the fried chicken is good, only reason I'll give it two. read more

The only place I stop on my way to the beach. Great egg sandwiches (served all day long) and a wide array of deli sandwiches to choose from or just make your own. They also have an A+ butcher for when you want to throw together a last minute bbq with friends. Knocked off a star because it's gets really crowded at peak times and even though they re-paved the parking lot, it's still a pain to park sometimes. read more

Cromer's doesn't aspire to be great. Despite a bristling summer trade, there's no pretense of welcome. The cafeteria lady mundanity is consistent year-round. If you need milk, eggs and a sandwich, might as well stop here if it's close. The atmosphere is decidedly small grocer purgatory. And they're completely content with that. read more

What can I say about Cromer's, have stopped in here quite a few times, for coffee, sandwiches, and soups, they have been really good, coffee is fresh every time, sandwiches have been tasty the breads have been nice and crusty, there California chicken sandwich good amount of chicken, nice toppings fresh, this soups are always hot and fresh beef barley is really good, chicken noodle and or chicken rice equally satisfying, staff is friendly. Price is not bad. read more

Stopped in again this Thursday for brunch, quality is still high and the place has changed a bit. They recessed the middle grocery island for a coffee section and bread but didn't miss much. They basically cut back on their box / can grocery items, which in a place like this - you don't really need. They have lots of FRESH other grocery items that deserve your attention. read more

also known as "the nickle & dime deli" with unfriendly (disinterested) staff at best. out of three orders: messedup two. However they do have delicious fried chicken & since the food is to go you can shrug off the snotty chasheers. read more

I don't know how much other food I'd eat here, and it's a little on the greasy side, but the egg sandwich is my New York must, and they make one delicious egg sandwich here! read more

The butchers at Cromer's are great. Excellent steaks cut perfectly to order. Thumbs up for produce department, and the hot food to go. Service at deli department always seems slow as molasses. I have never felt welcome there... Just tolerated because I have cash in my pocket... but that's typical for a lot of South Fork places. For friendlier service, head to the North Fork. read more