Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Custom Cookies By Natalie

    5.0 (9 reviews)

    Custom Cookies By Natalie Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Custom Cookies By Natalie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    So perfectly detailed!

    I saw of all her amazing cookies on social media! Absolutely amazing! Then i saw these holiday cookies kits she sells. I had to have one! They sold out within minutes! She does local drop offs. I got mine last night and wow is all i can say!! It's so cute and detailed and affordable. She was so nice and accommodating to work with. I will be ordering from her in the future and will be telling all my friends about her fabulous business! Right now it's especially important to shop local so for all your cookie needs please check out Natalie! I'd give her and this kit and personal service 100 stars if I could! I can't wait to decorate these Thanksgiving cookies! Great rainy day activity!

    Samantha V.

    This is my favorite custom cookie artist in Sonoma county hands down!! Natalie has the best Holiday themed cookies and can even do custom orders as well! I've never been disappointed when ordering with her the cookies always taste as good as they look and are packaged so nicely! My fav cookies are probably the Easter ones because when placing them in the kids Easter baskets they look so beautiful in their individual boxes . Can't wait to pick up my Valentines order! If you aren't following Natalie on Instagram and you have a Instagram go ahead and follow her @customcookiesbynatalie and turn ur post notifications on so you never miss a announcement about her beautifully made cookies

    See all

    Photo of Ally C.
    18
    42
    156

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Caitlin C.
    262
    48
    18

    2 years ago

    The absolute best looking & tasting cookies I have ever had!! Unreal how talented Natalie is!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Marri B.
    107
    48
    172

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ashley W.
    280
    10
    4

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Custom Cookies By Natalie

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 1,557 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Nimble & Finn’s - Whiskey butterscotch - My fave!

    Nimble & Finn’s

    4.6(226 reviews)
    6.7 km
    $$

    Nimble & Finn's, what have you done? Your ice cream was so good I'm craving it from San Francisco!…read more We were visiting Santa Rosa and we wanted to treat ourselves to some ice cream after lunch. I searched Yelp for a good ice cream spot and found Nimble & Finn's. Upon entering, we were surprised by the really cute decor and ambiance of the place. They had unique and creative ice cream flavors and I really liked that they combined two of my favorites - Lavender and Honeycomb. They also had Creme Brûlée, which I also liked, so I convinced my husband to get it. I'm glad he got that coz I got to try both and was very satisfied. Even my husband who is not really into sweets actually enjoyed his ice cream and finished it! Oh how I wish they had a location here in SF so I can just have it any time and try their other flavors. But if you're ever in Santa Rosa, you got to give Nimble & Finn's a try. It's totally worth it. Also bring a cooler with you so you can bring home this ice cream goodness!

    A really cute ice cream shop (with other unique items and even happy hour!). Service was amazing!!…read moreThey were patient with us while we sampled their array of unique ice cream flavors and were so kind. I ended up getting the Lavender Honeycomb and it was super yummy! It's only a personal preference, but I felt like the honeycomb candy made it too sweet. However, I understand that's a little hard to control since it is honeycomb candy. The lavender flavor paired very nicely with the honeycomb candy regardless! If I'm ever in Santa Rosa, I will definitely be back!!

    Photos
    Nimble & Finn’s - Lavender honeycomb. To die for!

    Lavender honeycomb. To die for!

    Nimble & Finn’s - Lavender Honeycomb on a waffle cone

    Lavender Honeycomb on a waffle cone

    Nimble & Finn’s - Passion fruit caramel on top and black sesame on bottom

    See all

    Passion fruit caramel on top and black sesame on bottom

    Petaluma Pie Company - The Elvis ($10/5")

    Petaluma Pie Company

    4.3(653 reviews)
    26.7 km
    $$

    I had such a perfect pie experience here today! Walked in with high hopes to get a strawberry…read morerhubarb pie. They didn't have one ready, but they rearranged their orders, and soon I had just the pie I wanted. I so appreciate their willingness to make me happy! The pie was absolutely delicious, wonderful fruit filling, absolutely flakey crust with cute cut outs. It was an absolute hit at our dinner gathering . I totally recommend this bakery for your dessert happiness. I also picked up a chicken hand pie for my lunch, and it was also delicious! Win win...

    If you're ever in the mood for pie and don't feel like making it yourself, this is the place to go…read more I got one apple pie for my husband and I got the berry pie. I could not wait to get home to try them and it was worth the wait. The young lady at the counter did make some suggestions in case I wanted to try something different other than a sweet pie. They had meat pies there too. I said I would probably try that next time. When we got home, we had dinner and we couldn't wait for dessert and it did not disappoint. We warmed them up in the oven and put a little bit of ice cream on top and it was simply wonderful. The apples and the apple pie were nice and tart and the berries were sweet. Definitely a place to return to, but if you don't know where it is, it might be a little difficult to find, but it's in a little. I guess you would call it an adjuster way nestled in between Starbucks and the deli. It's not too fancy inside, but they have all their pies and stuff on display.

    Photos
    Petaluma Pie Company - Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

    Petaluma Pie Company - Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

    Petaluma Pie Company - Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

    See all

    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

    Dave's Gourmet Ice Cream - Double scoops: triple berry and butter scotch

    Dave's Gourmet Ice Cream

    4.3(122 reviews)
    6.2 km
    $$
    Locally owned & operated
    Kid friendly

    On the way back from Mendocino to the Bay Area, I thought a break for ice cream would fit the bill…read more I like ice cream shops that make their own premium ice cream with great care. Dave's Ice Cream stood out on that score so we stopped by. I opted for the Macchiato Salted Caramel and my wife had a smaller Coffee Toffee. Oh my. This was totally great ice cream - rich, creamy and delicious! We savored every mouthful. On the wall they posted awards from the Sonoma County Fair, winning Best Of The Show ice cream three separate years. And my ice cream choice, Macchiato Salted Caramel, had won Best Of Show in 2025. Seven other flavors had also won awards. Dave's Ice Cream will be up there with the top ice cream shops I have visited. I've never tasted better ice cream!

    I was in Santa Rosa for a meeting with my husband and afterwards he suggested that we go get ice…read morecream and found Dave's Gourmet Ice Cream using of course Yelp which is our go to. There isn't a huge range of flavors to choose from but I wanted to try the lemon lime swirl and their mango. Both were delicious and I was having a hard time deciding which flavor I wanted my scoop, the server said do 1/2 scope of each. Delicious! The mango had chunks of fresh mango and the lemon lime swirl you could taste the distinct flavors. My husband had a couple scoops of jamoca almond fudge and agrees on the taste. They make the ice cream by scratch. They also have a coffee bar inside too. Again not a lot of choices but I had the London Fog tea and it was good. I wish they had sleeves for the cups.

    Photos
    Dave's Gourmet Ice Cream
    Dave's Gourmet Ice Cream - Peppermint Candy on Carmel Latte

    Peppermint Candy on Carmel Latte

    Dave's Gourmet Ice Cream

    See all

    Custom Cookies By Natalie - desserts - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...