Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Custom Cookies By Natalie

    5.0 (9 reviews)

    Custom Cookies By Natalie Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Custom Cookies By Natalie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    So perfectly detailed!

    I saw of all her amazing cookies on social media! Absolutely amazing! Then i saw these holiday cookies kits she sells. I had to have one! They sold out within minutes! She does local drop offs. I got mine last night and wow is all i can say!! It's so cute and detailed and affordable. She was so nice and accommodating to work with. I will be ordering from her in the future and will be telling all my friends about her fabulous business! Right now it's especially important to shop local so for all your cookie needs please check out Natalie! I'd give her and this kit and personal service 100 stars if I could! I can't wait to decorate these Thanksgiving cookies! Great rainy day activity!

    Samantha V.

    This is my favorite custom cookie artist in Sonoma county hands down!! Natalie has the best Holiday themed cookies and can even do custom orders as well! I've never been disappointed when ordering with her the cookies always taste as good as they look and are packaged so nicely! My fav cookies are probably the Easter ones because when placing them in the kids Easter baskets they look so beautiful in their individual boxes . Can't wait to pick up my Valentines order! If you aren't following Natalie on Instagram and you have a Instagram go ahead and follow her @customcookiesbynatalie and turn ur post notifications on so you never miss a announcement about her beautifully made cookies

    See all

    Photo of Ally C.
    18
    42
    156

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Caitlin C.
    262
    48
    18

    2 years ago

    The absolute best looking & tasting cookies I have ever had!! Unreal how talented Natalie is!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Marri B.
    107
    47
    165

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ashley W.
    280
    10
    4

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Custom Cookies By Natalie

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 1,857 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Nimble & Finn’s

    Nimble & Finn’s

    4.6
    (220 reviews)
    6.7 km
    $$

    Y'all... we had ourselves a mighty fine day over in Railroad Square here in Santa Rosa!…read more Since moving all the way from Alabama to Northern California, we've been having the best time. Every time we turn around, we find another reason to love this place. The food has been incredible, the drinks have been top-notch, and the folks we've met have been as friendly as they come. Now let me tell y'all about the real star of the day... Nimble & Finn's Handmade Ice Cream! Now, I don't usually get all worked up over ice cream. It's good and all, but I'm usually more of a "maybe next time" kind of gal. But when I saw they had Lavender Honeycomb... well, suga, you didn't have to tell me twice! Lord have mercy... it was GOOD. I mean, "close your eyes and savor every bite" kind of good. I would've licked the cup clean if I'd thought nobody was watching. The sweet gal behind the counter said Lavender Honeycomb has quite the following, and after one bite, I believe every word of it. So if you're anywhere around Santa Rosa, do yourself a favor and scoot on over to Nimble & Finn's. Grab yourself a scoop--or two--and see what all the fuss is about. I have a feeling you'll be planning your next visit before you even leave the parking lot! Hubby got an Ice cream sandwich Northern California... y'all are sure making it easy to feel right at home.

    For my 40th birthday, we had made plans but unfortunately the inclement weather had other ideas, so…read morewe pivoted and decided to have dinner with my family. So we needed a dessert, I love banana cream pie so decided we would try to find one, since it was last minute we called around and shifted to an ice cream cake. When I called Nimble and Finns they were a little rude but said they were busy so I gave them the benefit of the doubt. But... they had a Banana Pudding ice cream pie!!! Boom! This Gatsby-esq ice cream shop is truly beautiful! The pie was awesome I throughly enjoyed it that night and days to come!!! It was worthy of a 40th celebration.

    Photos
    Lavender honeycomb. To die for!
    Lavender honeycomb. To die for!
    Lavender Honeycomb on a waffle cone
    Lavender Honeycomb on a waffle cone
    Passion fruit caramel on top and black sesame on bottom

    See all

    Passion fruit caramel on top and black sesame on bottom
    Blondie's Bakery Boutique

    Blondie's Bakery Boutique

    4.7
    (59 reviews)
    7.2 km

    Pros: The staff is extremely friendly and the interior of the shop is heavily decorated so much…read morepink! The decorations are adorable and make the place look livelier. I usually buy the raspberry cake slice, the macarons, and Whoopie Cookies. I've purchased the cruffles and the macarons as gifts for my friends, and they're always adorned in a cute box with a ribbon bow. There are also gluten-free cupcakes available. They've never disappointed me and I often walk out of the store with a smile and my sweet tooth satisfied. Cons: Street parking can be tricky during busier times. However, it's about a 5 minute walk away from the Santa Rosa Plaza Mall. The cake slices and cupcakes lay on the buttercream pretty thick, which can get overly sweet. Overall: I had been going to Sift Dessert Bar since 2015, and when it closed in 2024, I was surprised to find that the location for the original Santa Rosa store is now owned by a former manager of Sift Dessert Bar! If you missed Sift Dessert Bar, you'll definitely love Blondie's Bakery Boutique. The colorful interior and sweet treats make this shop a must-visit. While I have ordered a cake from Sift Dessert Bar, I have not done so for Blondie's Bakery Boutique.

    Blondie is a badass. She and her team made gorgeous custom…read moresucculent design cupcakes. She came in early to make sure we got them in time for our party. The cupcakes were gorgeous and the gluten-free almond cake was delicious for all.

    Photos
    Blondie's Bakery Boutique
    Blondie's Bakery Boutique
    6' Chocolate Cake

    See all

    6' Chocolate Cake
    Petaluma Pie Company

    Petaluma Pie Company

    4.3
    (648 reviews)
    26.7 km
    $$

    The only thing I regret about coming here is that now every single time I go to Petaluma I'm going…read moreto go out of my way to come back. Seriously, you might think pie is pie, but no, there's pie, and then there's pie from Petaluma Pie Company. Friendly employee and clean area outside the shop is well. So that's good. My only complaint is the eco-friendly fork they provide is absolutely awful. Not sure if it's a Petaluma requirement but real plastic forks would be much appreciated. Regardless, this place is a must-try!

    I Spy With My Little Pie…read more This farm-to-table, locally-owned pie shop has been serving up both sweet and savory pie creations in Downtown Petaluma since 2010. They recently underwent an ownership change in 2024 from the OGs, but fortunately, instead of selling to a corporation, they sold it to an employee and his mother to help ensure the original ethos and quality remain intact. The Good: * Their pies are made with locally-sourced and organic ingredients bought from the local farmers market--as well as some fruit that they grow themselves! * Outdoor dog-friendly seating * As mentioned above, they have both sweet and savory pies. We only tried the sweet *oink oink* * Friendly service * Love that they have both full sized pies and smaller ones, so you don't have to commit to a big ol' pie. * We tried their Elvis (PB, banana, and chocolate) and their Black & Blue Crumble and they were both fabulous! I leaned a bit more to the B&B, as I absolutely adored that granola crumble on top, but the Elvis was no slouch either. The Meh: * Interior is small and very cramped. Definitely a grab-and-go type operation. The Ugly: * Parking in DT Petaluma can be a hassle, as it's street parking only, but at least it's free. Conclusion: Fantastic spot to scratch that 3.14 itch--and I'm always itchy!

    Photos
    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")
    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")
    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")
    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")
    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

    See all

    Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")
    Noble Folk Ice Cream And Pie Bar

    Noble Folk Ice Cream And Pie Bar

    4.4
    (690 reviews)
    19.9 km
    $$

    I've had an ice cream tooth lately so have been indulging in a lot of sweet treats, and boy did…read moreNoble Folk hit the spot. They have a rotating menu of items along with their mainstays, so depending on when you come, you can try something new. They have standard flavors like vanilla and chocolate, along with some more creative and off the wall like black sesame, I think there was a lavender, and more. I got the flight of 6 mini scoops. I can't remember my exact flavors, but the ice cream is so creamy, not crystallized- it's almost like gelato. I couldn't finish my ice cream because even as a mini it was so much (I should have shared) but it was absolutely delicious. I've been here a few times and there's always a line, but it moves really fast. The folks behind the counter hustle! It's such a cute place and such a mainstay of Healdsburg that I'll be back.

    Some friends took us here to try it out, and it did not disappoint! There were so many desserts to…read morechoose from, so I opted for their Ice Cream Flight to try out all their unique flavors. The worker was so friendly, answered any questions I had, and even offered some recommendations. I tried: - Dutch Cookie - Strawberry Miso Butterscotch - Salted Caramel - Cornflake Maple - Housemade "Oreo" - Vanilla Bean They were all good & not super sweet! They are very generous with their servings for such a good price. The rest of my party all had pies with ice cream. The pies are warmed up, so they make the perfect combination with the ice cream. There's not much seating inside, but we were able to sit in the few seats they did have to enjoy our food. We all had a great dessert on a sunny Sunday post-lunch.

    Photos
    Meyer lemon pie with blueberry compote
    Meyer lemon pie with blueberry compote
    Rose petals
    Rose petals
    Six scoop sampler. Clockwise from top left: salted caramel, black sesame, vanilla bean, passion fruit, strawberry sorbet, Swiss chocolate.

    See all

    Six scoop sampler. Clockwise from top left: salted caramel, black sesame, vanilla bean, passion fruit, strawberry sorbet, Swiss chocolate.

    Custom Cookies By Natalie - desserts - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...