The only thing I regret about coming here is that now every single time I go to Petaluma I'm going to go out of my way to come back. Seriously, you might think pie is pie, but no, there's pie, and then there's pie from Petaluma Pie Company. Friendly employee and clean area outside the shop is well. So that's good. My only complaint is the eco-friendly fork they provide is absolutely awful. Not sure if it's a Petaluma requirement but real plastic forks would be much appreciated. Regardless, this place is a must-try! read more

I Spy With My Little Pie This farm-to-table, locally-owned pie shop has been serving up both sweet and savory pie creations in Downtown Petaluma since 2010. They recently underwent an ownership change in 2024 from the OGs, but fortunately, instead of selling to a corporation, they sold it to an employee and his mother to help ensure the original ethos and quality remain intact. The Good: * Their pies are made with locally-sourced and organic ingredients bought from the local farmers market--as well as some fruit that they grow themselves! * Outdoor dog-friendly seating * As mentioned above, they have both sweet and savory pies. We only tried the sweet *oink oink* * Friendly service * Love that they have both full sized pies and smaller ones, so you don't have to commit to a big ol' pie. * We tried their Elvis (PB, banana, and chocolate) and their Black & Blue Crumble and they were both fabulous! I leaned a bit more to the B&B, as I absolutely adored that granola crumble on top, but the Elvis was no slouch either. The Meh: * Interior is small and very cramped. Definitely a grab-and-go type operation. The Ugly: * Parking in DT Petaluma can be a hassle, as it's street parking only, but at least it's free. Conclusion: Fantastic spot to scratch that 3.14 itch--and I'm always itchy! read more

See all

8/10 chicken pot pies(wish they were creamier and lacked a hair of salt). Didn't try but the blackberry pie looks amazing. Tried the apple pie and was disappointed on how hollow and very little filling it had. Tried their chile verde hand size empanada and that was my favorite and in my option had superior flavor. It was on the spicer side. Purchased their thin chocolate chip cookie which was too chewy for me. We arrived around 1pm hoping to get our hands on their key lime pie which there were out of and a hot chicken pot pie and ended leaving with 3 frozen chicken pot pies instead. Also had their Jamaican beef empanada although appreciate the meatiness it had an overwhelming amount of a particular string spice 6.5/10. read more

The pies were good. My girlfriend and I were craving pie and we decided to go here because we had heard about it but never been. There was jazz music playing outside and there was a good atmosphere. It was a little shop with fast service and a decent selection. We were surprised that there was no ice cream for sale but we went across the street to Angela's and got some vanilla ice cream for the perfect combo. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

Stopped by at the end of the day and there were only a couple flavors left. We tried the lemon meringue and it was very good. Tangy lemon curd, soft meringue, and a strong bake on a substantial crust. Will come back to try the other flavors! read more

SEP2025 Such a cute little shop. We happened upon it walking around downtown after a tasting and had to bring something back. Service helped with any questions that we had while we were in the store. The pies were quick to come out as well, and you have options to cook at home for some of the savory options. We got a few things to try out since it was the first time. Apple, strawberry rhubarb, a curried cauliflower, and a mushroom and gouda. Everything was well cooked, and the crusts nice and flaky. I'd say most successful for me was the strawberry rhubarb though. Really nice balance between the sweet and the tart. The mushroom I wanted a bit more from though. The gouda just didn't balance or stand out much. Definitely a worthwhile stop for us. We'll have to try some of the meat pies as well next time we're in the area. read more

See all

I got the Elvis pie which was pretty delicious, It was a chocolate moose pie with peanut butter and bananas. The crust on the bottom was light and it all was incorporated so well together to top it off with fresh whip cream. They have a lot of other pies to choose from but I would definitely recommend them if you are looking for a sweet treat with great flavor. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Elvis Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

My friends and I usually pass by this place when we go to the brunch place next door. I have never dared to go in and try some of their baked goods until one of our parents gifted us with Petaluma Pie Company! I chose a seasonal Blueberry and Peach crumble and it was so good! The pies were delivered to us and they were still warm! I have not eaten in the store yet but I know its a small spot and just a couple tables and chairs. I will definitely consider getting a pie here on holidays! read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Blueberry and Peach Crumble - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

Petaluma Pie Co. is a great example a quality, original small business. The staff were so kind and helpful and their pies are incredible. My family and I got a selection (both sweet and savory); they were all delicious. The key lime pie was especially notable, absolutely perfect! Their cafe drinks were also great. PPC will definitely become a regular stop when we drive through Petaluma. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Key lime pie and chai latte - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

stellar flavorful, ultra flaky pies! cant wait to come back and try more of the menu when we are in town again. the shop is cutesty and clean and has a mom and pop feel. service is kind. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - marionberry - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

We tried the banana cream butterscotch with Strauss creamery whipped cream. So very scrumptious. We loved this place so much we got a berry pie to take home. They have savory pies too. Fast counter service and located in the downtown area. read more

What a great find! Stumbled across this cute and small pie shop! The service was super friendly and quick to help us come to a decision. They had so many great choices it was really hard, but we picked the Butterscotch Banana Cream Pie with Salted Caramel. The crust was cripsy and flaky, the real bananas were amazing and the bourbon flavored butterscoth filling pulled it all together. There was a drizzle of salted caramel on the top that was not too overbearing. A great choice and we would definitely come back when in town. Side note, they also sell day old pies for 50% off. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Butterscotch Banana Cream Pie with Salted Caramel - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

Just OK. Had Lime Pie and Chocolate Pie. Fun stop, especially if you have kids, but wasn't wowed by the pies. read more

Absolutely delicious pie! Buttery flaky crust, perfectly filled with fruit and a great balance between sweet and sour. Love the little parklet outside - a couple small tables to sit. Quick service. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Strawberry rhubarb pie - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

I love Petaluma Pie Company! I remember when they first opened years ago. We stopped by last weekend and I got the 8" pear ginger cardamom pie. The filling wasn't too sweet and the crust was baked perfectly. My husband doesn't like sweet desserts so he goes for their savory pies. They're kept warm in a small oven behind the counter which is nice. I also like their savory pies but I gravitate towards sweet desserts. I've tried their other pies over the years including a black and blueberry crumble and the butterscotch banana cream pie. They were fantastic. Customer service is always friendly. They're located inside a small plaza on Petaluma Blvd N. read more

See all

So fun! Cute place! Quick in and out service as pies are premade daily I assume? Would have loved to try the sweet pies but only passing through and needed a savory snack.I had the cheeseburger pie. Not too much pastry and lots of grass fed beef! Super satisfying and delicious!! read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Cheeseburger pie! - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

I have walked by Petaluma Pie Company so many times but I cannot believe I have missed out so many opportunities for delicious pie! I went in to purchase a drink and was really intrigued by the Cardamom, Ginger, and Pear Pie. I got myself a mini size to go for ten dollars which felt like a reasonable price to me. It was hands down the best pie I have ever had. I'm normally not a pie person but this flavor combination was absolutely delicious. The fruit was not overly soggy or tangy, and the crust was flaky with coarse sugar on top. I cannot wait to try their other flavor combinations. I am glad that they will be expanding, and I cannot wait for other people to check this place out. read more

We came late in the day and there weren't many flavors left. They are very popular! We tried the banana cream pie and the triple berry. Both were delicious. Starbucks is nearby so we went to get an iced coffee to enjoy with our pie. *Chefs kiss*. They do serve coffee, but have only milk and no heavy cream. They had a blackberry, nectarine pie that I would have loved to have tried! Next time! read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Banana cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

Petaluma Pie Co bakes quality savory pies and sweet pies. Whether youre in the mood for a vegetarian mushroom and gouda pie a beef or chicken pie or bananan cream pie, you are in for a great experience. Theres enough variety to please every palette. The price is right. Ingredients appear to be fresh and local. Its a take out place, but they do have small tables in the adjacent courtyard. The servers are most always friendly and fast and deserving of a tip. Enjoy! read more

I stopped by here during the antique fair and will definitely be going back! I've picked up pies here before and enjoy their seasonal flavors, but it's the people that work here that make it extra special. The staff are always so nice and helpful, patient while you pick a flavor too! It's a perfect spot to take a pie home or sit right outside and enjoy the peace in the middle of the hustle & bustle of downtown. read more

My sister and I stopped by here recently. We were greeted by Lisa who was super helpful and kind!! After staring at the menu for a few minutes we decided on sharing a chicken pot pie. The pie was full of chicken and veggies. The filling doesn't seem to be cream based, but it was still super tasty. The pie crust was PERFECT. I could eat it on its own. They do offer day old pies at a discount! I hope to come back soon! read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

If you're craving a slice of pie in Sonoma County, you should be coming to Petaluma Pie Company. The cutest shop with a wonderful selection of fresh and seasonal sweet and savory pies. Chicken pot pie and ginger cardamom are must trys! Lovely staff and locally owned as well. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Hot chocolate, made with love - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

Really sweet staff, great menu, good coffee. I love how practically everything they use is locally sourced. The banana cream pie had chunks of banana in there that were a great choice. The salsa verde with chicken was DELICIOUS! The outside seating is very comfortable. Big fan and ready to come again. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Banana cream pie, salsa verde with chicken, blackberry Izzr - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

It's been a while - the interior has changed quite a bit, but wow, impressed with all the new (to me) savory hand pies. I was coming for a blueberry hand pie to drive home with a cold brew. The guy who helped me was so patient & Helpful in trying to decide-describing nearly everything to me in detail. Had to get a couple small pies-the triple berry and the current flavor- peach pie. Hard to choose which hand pie to bring my husband- he was leaning Cornish Pasty or Cheeseburger. Got him the first one- can't tell you how many times he kept saying- "wow! That is So amazing!" As he ate it! He felt like it reminded him of traditional pub food vibe. I almost got the chicken pot pie for dinner but didn't- I will for sure next time. So many pies, too little time! Still my favorite place in Petaluma-I love pastry pies! if you do too def- stop in and get something to go and something to have now. read more

See all

The Petaluma Pie Company is my go to pie shop. I will use any excuse to go here and grab a little chocolate cream pie and a strawberry Rhubarb. I have tried savory pies, handpies and about half a dozen sweet pies - everything is good here. The crust is perfect! check it out, but leave some for me! Service is variable. read more

Love that they have a menu for sweet, savory and vegetarian pies! The apple caramel pecan one was warm and had the perfect crust, and I appreciate that they have tables to sit outside in the nearby park. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

This pie shop has a cute setting, with a bit of outdoor seating at Putnam Plaza Park. The staff here was patient and friendly when we stopped by this past weekend to pick up some yummy pies and empanadas. We got the cheeseburger pie, spinach egg and cheese, and mushroom and goat gouda (all of these came heated). We also got the strawberry rhubarb and elvis pie (a peanut butter pie made with bananas and chocolate cream). Wow, all of the items we purchased were so tasty. The fruit and dessert pies were creamy and not too sweet, it was addicting, especially that elvis!! The empanadas were bursting from all the delicious savory fillings. The cheeseburger pie really tasted like a cheeseburger, stuffed with nicely seasoned ground beef in a warm flaky shell. And the spinach egg and cheese pie had a nice mix of ingredients which made for the perfect snack at brunch time. What I appreciate most is that they had a lot of options from their menu in stock during our recent visit on a Sunday. read more

See all

I've been coming here for several years now cause I'm crazy for hand pies, savory hand pies, namely, the cheeseburger hand pie.. Something I discovered in Scotland, the home of a savory hand pie or maybe it's a England? Now while the hand pies in the Trossach's cannot be beat, these guys make it really delicious version. Using grass-fed beef and quality ingredients, they offer a variety of savories. I have also had one of the meatless version which was also delicious. It was mushroom and Gruyère cheese I believe. The other sweet thing they do I mean, besides all the sweet pies, which are very good both fruit and cream pies, you name it, In small and large sizes including pot pies as well. They have a frequent Pieyer club, yes like the frequent flyer, but they give you a card where you can get your purchase punches and earn a free hand pie. read more

See all

The apple and berry crumble pie fillings were not sweet. The 2/$10 on day old pie was a great deal. Their meat pies were not to bad either.

Uber-popular and often sold-out pie shop in downtown Petaluma; the highlight for me was the meat pies, which can make a great light lunch. They're about twice the size (and twice the price) of an empanada, and they're delicious. The pie I got was solid, but I can find that anywhere... meat pies, though.... Yum read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Maple pumpkin - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

To appreciate Petaluma Pie Company a person has to like desserts that don't have a ton of added sugar. Think more like Asian desserts as compared to pie from Marie Calendars. I wouldn't recommend these pies for a person who likes really rich desserts. But if you are a person who appreciates good pie crusts along with more mild flavors, this is the place. I ordered: Banana Cream: a mellow pie with very lightly sweetened cream and custard. The good thing about that is the entire personal sized pie can be eaten in one sitting. Peach pie: the crust really shines with this pie. Also very mellow sweetness with more focus on the peaches and crust. Cheeseburger pie: this is like a stuffed Empanada or hot pocket filled with ground beef and cheese. Very generous portion and a great choice for those who are more into savory foods. I liked the pies more than my wife did, because I prefer less sweet. Overall a solid savory pie and dessert spot. read more

See all

The pie crust was really good, and you can tell they only use seasonal fruits and items in their pies. The downside to this though, is that if the fruit isn't in season, there is not a pie for it. So even though you can find apples in June, they do not have apple pie until August/September read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Blackberry nectarine pie - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

WOW. How bout a cheeseburger in a pie. Yes you heard me right, not only a hand pie with the savory taste of a cheeseburger all in one, make it grass fed beef too, yup you get the benefit of Omega 3's & other health benefits while downing that cheeseburger pie. Taylor, one of the new owners stopped me in my tracks when he told me about the best seller. It sounded unusual but I went ahead & tried it. It was like a cheeseburger but not like a cheeseburger cause it's a pie too. They pack the hand pie with lots of ground up local grass fed beef. It was delicious and filled me up. Go ahead and order that pie and any other scrumptious pie on the menu. They have fruit pies, big pies and hand pies. And wish Taylor & his mom his business partner the best. Gosh it's great to see a young, local Petaluma entrepreneur have a dream and act on it. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Cheeseburger Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

What a sweetheart the owner is! When our early Thanksgiving lemon meringue pie order got screwed up he gifted with four small ones wouldn't let me pay for even though I tried deep gratitude for his generosity read more

Great spot to pick up pies. We come here every time we're in town. We just discovered that they have hot pies. The fruit pies are amazing, very buttery, the fruits are fresh and sweet. They're really really good. The hot pies are great, the fillings are savory and the crust is crunchy. I highly recommend. read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Beef pot pie - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

Great quality pies! Love coming here especially because they have a punch card. The staff is very friendly and the place is clean inside + out. My favorite is the cream pies, the cheeseburger and pork bun pies. Definitely come early if you want to try certain ones because they update the menu based on availability. The coffee cake is also $5 and it's a HUGE slice. I paid $9.75 for the pork bun pie. It's very flavorful! The pies are not very big, so keep that in mind. People complain about the price but forget about the quality of the pies. If you want to treat yourself or try a good pie, you should come here. I will definitely continue to come back. read more

See all

I came here because I saw it on Yelp before visiting and I wanted to eat here. I was not disappointed. The pie was one of the best pies I've ever eaten before. We got the 5" banana cream pie and it was enough to share for two people. The crust was so yummy and flaky. I wish there was more filling, but it was still so good. Every bite I wanted more. The staff was so nice and there is outdoor seating around the area too. read more

See all

The food was amazing like always with both pies having amazing crust and tastes. The service was friendly and you can really tell they love what they do. The vibes are always giving cozy fall feelings and I cannot wait to really see how much the business will expand read more

Petaluma Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

I'm not sure what happened, but the last year (year and a half?) the most delicious pies have been not so yummy. Our favs : cheeseburger no longer seems to have cheese in it (flavor seems to have changed a bit). Sagaloo was extremely tasty and now rather bland. Cornish pasty is just ok. But not nearly as good as it used to be. Picadillo, new to us, was a nice surprise! Husband really liked that one. read more

Love their Elvis pie! It's the best. Very friendly and great service read more