10/10! The vibe is amazing - it feels like a little cafe you'd come across in Italy. The owner, Davide, comes around to say hi and is the sweetest man. There was also a singer who was awesome! Just a mic and his voice and we absolutely loved it! Food was delicious! I had the Fagottini Al Tartufo, which is a stuffed pouch pasta with cheese, mushrooms, truffles... it was so good! Everyone else's meals were tasty as well. We also had pizza, which the large size is very large. It was delish - not my usual style of Pizza but great anyway lol! Definitely a fun spot to go to when in Marco! read more

See all

What an amazing place! Ordered the pizza since the description was as close to the pizza that we had in Rome as possible. They did not disappoint. Servers were fabulous! Wine is great! Ambience fantastic and the singer play all our favorite tunes.. You could not go wrong. If in Marco, don't miss this place otherwise you'll be disappointed. read more

See all

Not only was the food fabulous and service exceptional, I want to thank them for going an extra mile helping make my sister's birthday party wonderful! Thank you Davide! and Staff! Also, I want to note I accidentally left my purse in all the excitement and when I came back the next day a wonderful staff member retrieved it for me and all was intact. Thank you so much! read more

We wanted to sit inside, and were told there were no tables immediately available, but that one would be opening up shortly. The host even pointed out the specific table and suggested we sit at the bar while we waited. My husband dislikes sitting at the bar, so we would not have agreed to that arrangement if we knew we would be there for the entire meal. There was also outdoor seating available right away, which we would have preferred over the bar had we been given accurate information. When the table became available, another couple was seated there instead. I overheard an interaction between employees implying they intentionally chose not to move us because we were already sitting at the bar. In other words, the table we were told was ours was knowingly given away. What made the situation worse was the lack of communication afterward. No one updated us or acknowledged what had happened until I finally asked about the table. At first, I was told the previous guests were taking longer than expected, which was not true. After I questioned that explanation, staff admitted the table had likely been reassigned by management. My biggest issues were the lack of communication, being misled about the situation and the complete lack of apology or acknowledgment from the manager, who was visibly checking on other tables while avoiding ours. Mistakes happen, but honesty and communication go a long way. Neither was handled well here. Otherwise, the food was delicious, but unfortunately it was hard to enjoy with our poor experience. read more

Ok finally a real fantastic Italian restaurant on Marco, fantastic food, the bolognese was teaming with veggies and meat, the rich red sauce was delightful. The chicken parm was very tasty, sweeter sauce and cooked to perfection, bread was hot and the olive spread was a perfect touch. Great place to eat service was very spot on and attended to our needs. The restaurant is in an interesting spot but the seating felt warm and comfortable. Excellent choice for Italian on Marco. read more

Davide Italian Cafe - Bolognese with Penne - Italian Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

I currently am on a trip to Marco island and we have tried many restaurants and by far this restaurant had the best food!!! The olive oil was soooo good!!! I was just about to start drinking it it was that's good. Also this place has such a nice vibe!!! And the service is awesome so kind and fun. I don't understand how this place is only 4 stars this place is so good read more

Love this place...been here 3 times in the last month and decided to report to my fellow Yelpers "Davide" is the real deal. We've traveled Italy extensively and feel like we are back at an Italian trattoria when here. When in Marco skip the high profile places and check out the local favorites. read more

Davide Italian Cafe - Davide Evening Specials. - Italian Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

I've Read a LOT of reviews on this place: it amazes me that people have such extreme difference of opinions. I am SO GLAD we decided to try this place ourselves. We tried to stop in last week - NOPE it was Packed - Recommend making a reservation! We ordered the Supreme Pizza minus Onions and Green Peppers. It was one of the BEST Pizzas I have ever had! We looked at the Portions on the plates that people ordered: much bigger than people made it sound in their post! Please try this place and judge for yourself! Highly Recommend it! read more

Davide Italian Cafe - Small Supreme Pizza - minus Onions and Green Peppers 6 LARGE Slices - Italian Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

If you're in Marco Island and looking for a true Italian dining experience, Davide Italian Cafe needs to be at the top of your list. From the moment you walk in, the hospitality sets the tone. You're not just seated -- you're welcomed. The service feels authentically Italian: warm, attentive, and genuinely happy you're there. The wait staff doesn't simply take your order; they guide you through the menu, confidently explaining what's exceptional that evening and helping you choose something you'll love. And then the food arrives. Every dish delivers bold, layered flavors that absolutely explode on the palate. Fresh ingredients, perfectly balanced sauces, and pasta cooked exactly as it should be. It's the kind of meal that makes you pause after the first bite. Comforting yet elevated -- somehow even better than Nonna's house. Exceptional service. Authentic atmosphere. Incredible food. If you're compiling your must-visit spots in Marco Island, this one isn't optional. read more

Our GO TO family place on the island! Get your reservation and enjoy a wonderful evening of music and excellent food. Their pizza is the best on the island ! You will not be disappointed!!! read more

It started with a simple take-out pizza order. The very welcoming Italian gentleman who was running the restaurant (who we unofficially call Mr. Davide???) made everyone feel welcome. Since we were a few minutes early, we had the opportunity to see several plates of pasta, veal, etc. go by and they all were presented perfectly. We will be back to Davide Italian Cafe. read more

We ordered carry out from here and would not order again. I'm not sure how this place even has 4stars. Nothing about our meal was "homemade" the pasta was from a box, asked for no mushrooms on our pizza and received mushrooms on it, the bread was hard as a rock. When I called the owner was extremely rude and did not want to give our money back to us. Calling me a liar and that I need to bring the pizza in myself to show him the mushrooms. Comical. Not sure why I would waste my time getting yelled at if there were in fact no mushrooms on it, however there were. Threw the whole pizza way. It wasn't homemade to begin with either. He said he was going to refund us, but my cc has never been credited back. Would NOT go here. Rude and terrible food. read more

We have dined at this restaurant for years whenever we visited/rented Marco Island. We made a reservation for our party but when we arrived they had no record - we did show our phone history showing the call was made with the time, date and length of call - to no avail we could not have our reservation honored - will suggest anyone call and confirm their reservation at least twice before arriving - seems there is only reservation record done by hand. This has clearly put a damper on any future support. read more

Always delicious true Italian dinners served and fun, lively place with wonderful service and music!

Been coming to Marco Island for years - we live here six months a year. Davide used to be a good place to eat. It has really slid downhill that last few years, ESPECIALLY for takeout food. Cold food, parts of which were tasteless, poorly put together and a miniscule salad. EXTREMELY OVERPRICED for the value received. When my wife called to complain, the response was that we don't need to come to their restaurant anymore. Good idea, we won't - and if you are reading this, you shouldn't either. With all the wonderful options for food on and off the island there is no need to throw you money away here. If you want Italian, take your money to Caio Bella, DiVinci's or any of the area's good Italian eateries. read more

Place was Cozy . We are In town for Golf and wanted a good place . We live in Florida and don't consider ourselves tourist! Read the reviews seemed to be good so we Picked this place. . Went in and it just felt like we weren't really welcomed. Food was good. Great rice ball bolognaise, but just didn't really feel Welcomed. Don't think we will go back! read more

Had dinner there last night. The food was just ok. What bothered me was the waiter who was extremely friendly tried to upcharge us at every opportunity. We ordered a pizza and a veal dish to share. He recommended that we get the large pizza and also have the fresh pasta with the veal. He recommended two salads but we changed it to one when we realized one came with the meal. They split the veal dish in two which we did not ask them to do. When we got the bill it included charges for the fresh pasta ( which did not taste fresh), a split plate fee and a salad that we should never have been charged for. We will never go back. read more

Very authentic Italian cuisine. The gentleman who runs this place is incredible! I must admit I don't even know his name, but I admired him. He make sure things get done, fast and efficiently. Great wine list. I loved lasagna! It even has peas in it! Who would've thought? Highly recommend but make a reservation! It was packed. read more

Amazing, amazing authentic Italian food. The owner and staff are amazing, very inviting and always making sure you are having a good time eating delicious food. Came in without a reservation with my family, they made room for us and never once rushed us. They have great indoor and outdoor seating. Very inviting and comfortable atmosphere. The pizza is amazing, authentic and to die for. The pasta and seafood are truly amazing, you can't go wrong with a dish. Definitely recommend, a neighborhood gem. read more

So many restaurants on Marco Island are only open for dinner, which makes getting into them, especially during high season, a bit of a competitive sport. Make sure you have reservations for Davide as they only serve between 4:30pm - 9pm. And their seating is limited to about 8 inside tables and 8 outside tables, making this a nice intimate Italian restaurant. Service is excellent, but know that this is a relaxed meal...you will not be rushed an the food will not be rushed, so plan on enjoying your night out and expect dinner to take 1.5 - 2 hours. The food is good...we started with the Stuffed Mushrooms which were fine, but the Short Rib Ravioli special of the day, as recommended by our server, was outstanding. Serving sizes are just right...not too big but not too small, either. The only downside is the live music, which is just too loud. The singer is located outside and has a sound system set up...and for those dining outside, you cannot even hear yourself think, let alone have a conversation at normal levels. Even inside, where we were seated, the music coming through the front door was just too loud. Bring it down 3-5 notches and it will be perfect. read more

This is by far the worst meal we've had in a looong time (yes, worse than ZaZa). I would never go back. We ordered the Gnocci Quatrofromaggi, Chicken Parm and the Lasagna Bolognese. They were all really bad. The chicken parm was soggy and flavorless and sopping wet. See picture. My plate was full of water. The marinara on the chicken and the lasagna was thin (watery) and flavorless and the lasagna had a very odd taste. The Gnocci was also mostly flavorless. The chicken had the texture of being heated in the microwave (might not have been, but that's what it tasted like). Oh, and the salad - hahaha. On the plus side, our waitress was very nice and very attentive. read more

Davide Italian Cafe - Plate full of water. Yuk! - Italian Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Best Italian restaurant on the island! Excellent lasagna and specials. Service is superb.

Food was good atmosphere not so great. Loud music and to many tables pushed together . You can't even get up without hitting the table next to you . Maybe carry out would be the only option . read more

Good food, drinks, and the live singer is a nice touch. Recommend sitting outside, if it's not too hot, so you can appreciate the singer. The owner/host and wait staff make you feel like you're in Italy. read more

Lasagna was yummy. Free salad comes with an expensive main course: average 22-45$ The bread is ok--kind of spicy. The homemade pasta is Great but expect to pay $30-$45 for that. Fun singers entertain happily. The chocolate cake is a bunt cake topped with chocolate (not a lava cake), lemon cake is more yummy. One time the meatballs were large and not spicy and the next time they were small and too spicy. Why do they have 1960s fringes hanging between bathroom and restaurant? Good service.Thank you. read more

See all

Food was terrific service was great and an all around fun time. They've done a great job improving the ambience with planters and musicians. Will be back! read more

Fun, entertaining atmosphere. Food delicious. Staff very attentive and friendly. Great experience.

Excellent food. We love this wonderful, family owned business! Service was very attentive. Courses were very well timed. I have a severe shrimp allergy and they took great care of me! We went on a Saturday night and they had a terrific singer for the evening. She was very sweet and had an amazing voice! We sat outside to hear the music. Remember to make a reservation. read more

Davide Italian Cafe - Lasagna was reallllly good. I had a seafood (clams and mussels) with freshly made tagliatelle pasta. It was great! - Italian Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Small piece of chicken parm for $30. They advertise homemade pasta, but that's an extra $10.95 charge. Sauce is not very good and the salad was laughable. Waitress chewing gum taking our order....would not return. read more

Wonderful food, great experience. Highly recommend the sangria and pasta Al forno. Loved it read more

My family has been coming to Davide ever since we bought our house on Marco Island years ago and the food is always excellent. The owner and servers are incredibly kind and attentive. We are big fans of the unlimited warm bread and olive tapenade. Most meals come with a small salad and the portion sizes are perfect. The only downside to this restaurant is the live music which is so loud you can't even talk to the person next to you. It wouldn't be bad if the singers took a break, but since there is two of them, they take turns singing the entire night. I would not recommend this restaurant if you want to talk to anyone you are eating with. I hope this place makes a change in their entertainment - my family was looking forward to coming a few times on vacation but hesitated due to the loud singing. read more

My wife and I have been coming here for over 10 years! We are from Boston and whenever we come to Marco Island we always make sure to come here to eat and to visit Davide and the staff! The food is delicious! My wife is gluten-free and she loves the pizza and pasta options they have here!!! Davide always makes us feel so at home when we visit. Thank you as always Davide! We love you guys! read more

Davide Italian Cafe - Italian Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

I have visited Italian restaurants in Naples and Marco Islands over the past several years I have lived here and Davide is by far my favorite! Authentic Italian cuisine, excellent service and being Italian I appreciate the music played! Highly recommend! read more

Always enjoyed the food and ambience. On April 2 I dined with my wife and 2 friends. The food was very good, however make sure you ask for a price on the specials.. the "entertainment" was boring and amateurish. The singer Johnny fusco behaved like a pompous ass. Actually called me an A__hole because I actually sang better than he did .. I'll never eat at another restaurant where he's performing. read more

One of our favorite places on the island. Just love the food and staff. A hidden gem for sure! Very Mediterranean Italian and yummy

The food was very good here, however charging $54 for a pasta dish is a little ridiculous. I had the special which was tagliatelle with shrimp and scallops in a pesto crème sauce which had 4 small shrimp and two scallops. That's not even $10 in seafood! The entertainer was a prick. My husband was singing along and was called an asshole by this person under his breath, or so he thought because I heard him. How unprofessional Johnny Fusco. A singer/entertainer you're not. Go back to your day job. read more

Food was great, service was excellent, and amazing and cozy ambiance! Would highly recommend to anyone who is looking for some phenomenal Italian food at a reasonable price. read more

Just a fantastic experience at a true Italian Restaurant - love this place on Marco Island read more

I love Davide! It's my favorite place in Marco! The food is delicious and great service! The ambiance is great too! Can't wait for January until I'm back in Marco and Davide is first place I'm going to have dinner! read more

Excellent Italian food very authentic. Food is always fresh. Service is excellent. Ambiance is perfect.