We ordered in takeout - chicken parm, chicken caruso and chicken limone (GF). The food was really good, but more importantly Tracey (Manager...I'm pretty sure that's her name!) went above and beyond with her customer service. The entrees were supposed to come with garlic knots and salads, but I noticed when I returned home that they didn't. I called and went back to retrieve them, but then noticed one of the entrees didn't include the premium pasta I paid extra for. I called and Tracey not only offered to make the pasta for me, but then credited me back for the entire meal - a true act of kindness and seasoned hospitality. Please support these good people! read more

Last time I went here.....last year....i was sad....joeys seemed to have lost its touch.....this year.... We are SOOOOO BACK BABY SALAD! GARLIC KNOTS! PIZZA! LETS RIDE!!! shoutout Doreen! read more

See all

Joey - so glad you are back! Not sure where you have been but glad you are back! Outstanding meal all around. Thank you Donna and thank you Joey read more

Joey's Pizza - GF Chicago style - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Everything we ordered was awesome. We had 2 pizzas. One combo with pepperoni, sausage, onions and peppers. The other one was margarita pizza with a few additions of pineapple and ham. My mom had the chicken masala with lots of mushrooms a pasta side. That entree came with a house salad and garlic knot. Hubby and I ordered an antipasto which came with 2 garlic knots and we unknowingly order 6 garlic knots which were awesome and one of the things that disappeared quickly. If going here you can definitely share almost all the food because they are large portions. Oh my son has the manhattan clam chowder in a cup and that would have been a bowl in most places. Dessert was two regular cannolis. Oh my GOD, orgasmic ! I love cannolis!! read more

See all

Great choice for pizza & lots of Italian food options. Ordered 3 pizzas & salads to go & all were delicious. Very crowded so sure they have great options. It was worth waiting for freshly prepared pizzas. read more

See all

We went to Joey's Pizza to celebrate my sister's birthday, and they went above and beyond to make the night feel special. They brought out the dessert of her choice and even used the birthday candles we brought to make it a sweet surprise. It was such a thoughtful touch! One of my favorite parts of the meal was that every dish came with a buttery garlic knot. They seriously could be addictive. I ordered the Pasta alla Vodka, and it was creamy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The others in our group had the Burrata Salad, Caesar Salad, and Penne with Alfredo Sauce which were all delicious. The pastas also came with a side salad, and we tried both the Creamy Italian and Ranch dressings and both were great! The service was warm and welcoming, the food hit the spot, and the birthday celebration felt extra meaningful thanks to the staff. Definitely recommend Joey's if you're in Marco Island. Whether you're celebrating or just craving solid Italian comfort food it's a good spot. read more

Cute place very full as went early New Year's Eve. They accommodated us with our pup and we sat outside. They brought him water and we super sweet. We order knots, 2 thin crust pizzas and lasagna. All tasty the pizza I will ask for well done next time but that's just a personal preference. The lasagna has lots of meat but could have used more sauce with it. The drinks were tasty and we took a bunch of food home for guests and they all enjoyed. Def a spot to try again read more

See all

We had a great experience there. Our waiter was attentive and friendly. I was new to being on a gluten-free diet and had trepidation about eating there, but was put at ease by our waiter who let us know they had gluten-free pizza crust. He did say that it was a personal pizza and encouraged my husband to order his own mail because it was a personalized pizza. But I will say that personalized pizza could've fed three people. He described it as an 8 inch pizza and it was a large oval pizza that took up an entire plate and we came home with lots of leftovers.. that being said, the crust was amazing for a gluten-free free pizza. Such a pleasant surprise.. The atmosphere was fun and bustling Our captain from our boat excursion who was originally from New Jersey recommended it as the most authentic pizza place on Marco Island. So glad we listened to him. read more

Joey's Pizza - Gluten free pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Been to Joeys more than I can count and almost always have a great experience, we order takes out most of the time. This restaurant is a modern styles inside with open air format and a center full of service bar. The food was great, cooked perfectly, the Stromboli was cooked perfectly, crunch and clover with plenty of cheese. I recommend trying what I order for. My build your own Stromboli, having pineapple, green pepper, sausage, and tomatoes. Offer the combo of greens and meats and makes sure you got tomatoes wit read more

See all

I loved Joey's, it is a fun atmosphere to go dine in, but also a great option to carry out! It is a great restaurant with great food and excellent customer service! Didn't disappoint! Laid back and relaxed atmosphere read more

Joey's Pizza - Joey's way calamari & linguini meatballs pasta - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

We ate here and it was wonderful. Had the antipasto sales that was enormous and delicious. Zucchini sticks and bruschetta bread which was fantastic. It was so good we decided to order a take out pizza another night. Unfortunately it was not delicious. We had gotten the Italian pizza here before and rated it overall #2 of the best pizzas we've ever had so naturally we came into this with high expectations. The half pepperoni pizza did not deliver. We'll be back and would still order pizza again Chef must of had an off night read more

It was a cool summer night and our large group of 13 was promptly seated out side under the bistro lights hanging on Joey's large terrace. The group was happy we were seated quickly and Mother Nature was gifting us with a slight breeze. Our waitress seemed pretty busy and thus the attention was lacking somewhat. Especially when other large groups were seated at on the terrace as well and they had their drinks, apps, entrees, and their bills way before us. It was a mini vacay for us and we're not the type to complain but our waitress service was slow. The food was good over all, I had the Gnocci with Chicken and it was delish. Many pizzas were ordered at our table, even the huge Sicilian, it was looks impressive, but it mostly just bread, not worth it unless you really want to eat a ton of bread. Their other pizzas looked amazing. Don't leave without getting a cannoli, you'll thank me later. Sorting out the check was also disappointing. We had ordered 2 of a certain app and only received one. No biggie as we had plenty of other apps. We asked the server that brought us our apps and they didn't do anything about it. They we asked our waitress if she had put 2 or 1 and she replied "one". Then when we finally got the bill, she had definitely put in 2 as we were charged for two. We had to find her in the restaurant to get her to fix the bill and she was not very cordial about it. Will we be back, yes. With another server please We dine at Joey's every time we're in Marco Island and enjoy it. Just wish this visit was as good as our previous visits. read more

See all

Ordering was a breeze and delivery was on time as stated. Ordered a pizza. I found it to be somewhat of a disappointment. It was very greasy which usually indicates low quality ingredients. Toppings were a bit scarce along with very little sauce. Tasted just ok. Next time I will probably try somewhere else to see how others compare. read more

We were excited to try Joey's as many rave about the pizza and say it is the best on Marco Island. Perhaps I have a high bar for pizza, and while it was good, I can't say it was great. We tried the "NY Style", and I will say the sauce and cheese were good, but unfortunately the crust was somewhat flavorless and too airy to be considered a NY style pizza. For me, all three elements need to come together for a truly great pizza. Apart from the pizza, our server was efficient and friendly and food came quickly. We sat outside on a nice patio as the inside was jammed. No reservations here and it is a popular spot. We also tried their ricotta and honey appetizer, which was nice. Perhaps could have been a tad bigger, for the price. Overall, an enjoyable dinner but I've had better pizza on Marco Island. We might try again to see how they do with their pasta and other dishes. read more

Joey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

First time at Joey's (December 2024) and we ordered a large combo and large white pizza with spinach for pick up. Total was about $60 which blew us away. The most we've ever paid for a pizza so we're expecting top tier pie. It smelled delicious. We get home (6 minute drive) and after trying the pizza, we realize instead of a combo we were given a sausage pizza with no sauce. (We did get the correct white pizza). Called to advise it was the wrong order and they offered to refund or come back to get the right pizza. (We opted for a refund) The pizza itself was so thin it was like they ran out of dough and were trying to make more pizzas than they could handle. The cheese was dry (on the sausage pizza). The crust was so hard/crispy, it was like you reheat old pizza 3 times and it's too hard to chew. (I LOVE a crispy pizza but not hard.) I typically prefer personal pan pizza or like a standard crust you'd get from papa John's. Nobody in my party liked thin crust so maybe that's why we didn't love it? read more

Joey's Pizza - White Pizza with Spinach - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

See all

A poppin' place with some pretty good food. Members of my group really enjoyed wine and pizza and I enjoyed a pumpkin spice espresso martini and the baked ziti with gluten free noodles. Quick service and tasty. One thing to mention..they do not do substitutions for anything really except they will sub gluten free noodles...so beware if you are picky! read more

Joey's Pizza - Baked "ziti" (with GF noodles) - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Unbelievable taste quality and service! We sat on patio because we brought our dog. The manager got a glimpse of him and gave him some love. Found out it was our dogs birthday and gave him some extra special loving ! The food was amazing- so good, waitress was friendly and attentive- A great experience all around! We will definitely recommend to others and we will be back to visit!!! THANK YOU Johnny!!! read more

Joey's Pizza - Cooper's 6th birthday! - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

See all

Food was great and came out very timely. We had Maribel and her service was excellent..

Just had the best Philly cheesesteak without the squirt cheese like in Philadelphia, which I can't stand. The role was outstanding as well. French fries are over the top great place been here about 50 times can't say enough about it. read more

We ordered takeout last night and there were sadly some issues. The Philly cheese steaks tasted extremely gross. The meat tasted spoiled. The chicken sandwich we ordered didn't have any of the toppings on it that we ordered, it was just bread and grilled chicken. The tortellini was delicious, though. I called to inform them of the problems and they were very kind. However, I was told she would speak with the manager and call me back but I never heard back. The guy who dropped off the food was also kind. The meal was expensive, especially considering it was hardly edible. read more

Got to-go half cheese / pepperoni pizza. Quick service and pizza was very good. Would recommend for an easy dinner in. Order the thinner crust, cut into little squares to share better. read more

I've have seen such a bad place. I am here as a snowbird. My first I was sick all night. Yesterday, I ordered a chicken parm sub I received the meal. Said nothing. Then the next night we ordered again due to packing to go home. We order a make your own. We order an Italian and we received hamburger and peppers. We call she goes we don't have that, so we asked why didn't she just say that. Manager comes on and says this one time we will do it. I kid you not, we received a burnt Stromboli of steak and onions, still no Italian. They don't care, listen and the cook was unhappy and burned the bottom. Trust me, they are rotten. You'll see if you try. We just forgot about the 40.00. But my review will be everywhere. Build your own is what they want to give you. But burnt it is insulting and not called for! read more

Arrived at Joey's and god seated right away. Our waitress Selena was good, but the food not so much. My wife ordered the Caprese salad, and eggplant parm sub. The salad was not traditional. It was chopped Romaine two slices of tomato, mozzarella and red onion smothered in way too much dressing and the eggplant was literally burnt to a crisp and not edible. I had ziti and sausage. The pasta and sauce were fine, but the two sausages were also burnt and the presentation horrible. The casing was almost black. Thank God the Peroni I ordered was cold. I know this place is a local staple, but they should really take a good look at the food they are presenting to the customer. Maybe we should have just stuck with ordering a pizza as they looked okay. Sadly, it will be a while before I head back there. read more

Joey's Pizza - The burnt eggplant - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

A beautiful place to dine with family and friends. The service was nice and attentive and timely. We ordered a couple of salads, garlic bread, and Sicilian pizza. We liked all of them. read more

See all

We ordered the baked clams, seafood salad, pork chop Vessuvio, and a side salad with balsamic dressing. Every dish was swimming in excessive sauce or dressing. My wife's salad had so much dressing she couldn't eat it. Very disappointing read more

We have been going to Joeys Pizza for many years. We are in here almost daily when we visit the island. The food is outstanding and the service is amazing. The bartenders, Mike and Mike are the best in the business. They recommend and make the most amazing cocktails! Our favorite spot on Marco Island!! read more

Joey's Pizza - Bourbon Berry - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Came here with my family for dinner, the service was good and the food was great. The feel of the restaurant was laid back with good and the Stromboli was well made. read more

Joey's Pizza - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

See all

Restaurant is great, but their delivery pizza is the worst. High price and low quality.

This place is very solid. Polite and fast dinner service and exceptional Italian food all around. Do not be dissuaded by the very few bad reviews... you can't please everyone. read more

Joey's Pizza - Outside at night - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Not one thing we ordered was less than amazing! From the salads to pizza to pasta to cocktails!!! I wish I would have taken pictures before we demolished everything! The service was fantastic our dogs were welcomed and adored!!! The live music was gentle and soothing not loud and overwhelming. 10/10 would recommend!!!! read more

My order was incorrect. I brought it back to the take out counter. Asked to place a different order instead, pulled out my wallet to pay for the new order was berated by a hostess with a pony tail and head band. I told her to never mind, I was going else where. She continued to yell at my out the window, then spoke badly about me to the next customer. Unbeknownst to her, that next customer is my neighbor. I was also in 2 nights before that, she was rude to me then as well. read more

This is our 1st time visiting Marco Island. A lot of local vacation restaurants are not that good. Joeys has great good & large portions! Try it you won't be disappointed! read more

Terrible waiter, could hardly understand him. He brought things that weren't ours. Brought an extra salad dressing we did not ask for and charged us $2.00. We had a group of 3 families in our party of 12 could not split the check in three. Don't plan on returning!!! read more

Food amazing, drinks amazing, services with Kelsey 10/10. If you're in Marco island and looking for Italian, this is your spot.

Nothing about this food was good. I ordered the house Italian dressing....awful. The cheese ravioli was cold and the marinara sauce was bitter! The price was way too high for pasta! $24 plus tip...for one order of cheese ravioli, which came with a house salad, and NO bread!! ‍ read more

The pizzas and drinks were amazing! Our server, Ibrahim was very friendly and attentive. Will definitely be back. read more

Joey's Pizza - Spicy mango margarita, Gulf of America! Both super yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

See all

Very disappointed. We had a white pizza and salad on Sunday afternoon and it was delicious. It so so good that we decided to go back Wednesday night for dinner and it was very disappointing. We ordered calamari which had no flavor and extremely tough and dry The marinara sauce had no flavor. We ordered the bread salad. It had a strong vinegar flavor with very little olive oil and seasonings. The pasta with sausage was bland had no flavor. I usually never salt my food but all there items I had to use salt. I'm in Marco often and will go back for just pizza and garlic knots. For an Italian restaurant it truly missed the mark on flavors. read more

Everything was wonderful. We had no wait for our larger party. The appetizers were really good. I especially liked the fried zucchini. Everyone enjoyed their pizzas and I thought the meatball salad was fabulous. Drink options were great as well. Our service was fast and very pleasant. Great experience! read more

We got carry out from Joey's while we were in Marco Island. We got a classic pepperoni and a chicken Parmesan pizza. Both were amazing! The cheese to sauce ratio was perfect! The chicken parm pizza was loaded with breaded chicken pieces that were seasoned perfectly and very tasty. It was a hand tossed crust, but not too thick. Our pizza was hot and the service was friendly, although we just picked it up and left. If you're in Marco Island and are having a pizza night try Joey's you won't be disappointed. read more

Joey's Pizza was a great place to eat after a long day at the beach. It has the style of a small family owned pizza restaurant so it has a nice and cozy atmosphere. We were seated immediately on arrival, so that's always a good thing! We ordered the garlic bread with cheese and the Sicilian (2" of dough!!) with five meat topping. The food came out very quickly and was absolutely delicious. Even though it was a small size, the pizza was extremely filling. Even between my wife and I, we couldn't get to half the pizza. The garlic bread was super crispy and cheesy as well. We finished off with the chocolate cannoli and the pistachio affogato. Both desserts were delicious as well with a great portion size. All in all, I would definitely recommend eating here on your next trip to Marco Island! read more

Joey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

See all