Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    DiMillo's On The Roll

    3.7 (3 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    DiMillo's On The Roll Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - DiMillo's On The Roll

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    26 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood 2,764 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Luke's Lobster Portland Pier

    Luke's Lobster Portland Pier

    4.3
    (1.4k reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    STEPH JUDGEMENT: Great place for New England classics…read more The hubby and I stopped in to get some food to go. Located at end of a pier, it was a pleasant bright, light space overlooking the ocean. We were pleasantly surprised to see some veggie options, and the hubby got the kelp burger, which he enjoyed. I got the 4 oz lobster roll (plenty big for me), which came with potato chips and a pickle. It was excellent, with just the right amount of butter on the roll and mayo in the lobster. Also great friendly service. We shared a cider at the bar while waiting for our order and had a nice time chatting with the bartender. Highly recommend.

    Monday night... pretty quiet. Expecting great hot food! Ordered a beer for hubby and wine for me!…read more Asked waitress, for best appetizers, fried calamari, (yeah, we live calamari) ok, not hot a layer or balsamic is over calamari... ok, however the breading has no taste. Then order large Caesar salad and fish and chips... to be split and shared. Both came out at same time... shame on me for not telling the waitress how to bring out. Both arrived at the same time. Caesar salad the lettuce was warm and wilted, croutons burned. Fried fish, the fries were tough and cold! The fish had the same breading as the calamari! The fish was warm, not much taste. Funny, at end of meal... where the waitress clearly sees we did not eat our food... she asks how the drinks were (remember we ordered beer and wine) The manager shows up, we told him we did not want comped food. Did tell him all of the above.... His bigger concern was "was the fish cooked correctly" The table behind us got the clams comped... no idea why! We will not recommend nor will we ever return!

    Photos
    Ain't she a beaut?
    Ain't she a beaut?
    Welcome!
    Welcome!
    Our classic lobster roll - not to be missed!

    See all

    Our classic lobster roll - not to be missed!
    The Highroller Lobster

    The Highroller Lobster

    4.3
    (2.3k reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$
    Locally owned & operated
    Outdoor seating

    DELICIOUS! The host…read morerecommended both the oysters and lobster rolls and we were not disappointed! We were seated quickly and our food came out quick as well, such a cool retro vibe here!! 10/10 Would recommend

    Not worth all the hype! Subpar customer service minus hostess. The hostess was great, helpful when…read moreshe saw us walking around and directed us to the washrooms. The younger guys running food and guys standing around chatting with each other weren't helpful. They saw my friends water cups were low but didnt offer any refills. I saw one of them putting food in the to go area when I walked up to the host stand, we made eye contact but no greeting at all. There were 2 tables who sat down way after us but immediately received their food. We ordered Lobby Pops, Lobster Rolls, Haddock Sandwich and their lobster flights. My cousin's food came out before ours, we only ordered 1 lobby pop and a haddock sandwich this visit. The wait wasn't too long but 45mins for just 1 lobster tail on a stick is ridiculous. My cousins larger order came out 15 minutes before ours. Maybe they were working on our sauce? My husband's Haddock sandwich was paper thin. The lettuce was thicker than the actual fish. Would not recommend it. Lobby pop was tasty. Blood Mary was okay, nothing special. Tasted fresh. I do love their charred pineapple sauce. Highlight of this place. It was creamy and refreshing. Honestly, don't think I'll recommend this to anyone. You can get better tentative service elsewhere and have yummy lobster. Saw others on here recently having customer service issues as well. I took all of my friends and family who visited from out of town here but its not the place anymore. Christmas decor was beautiful. But now maybe the staff changed, not a fan anymore. Disappointing...

    Photos
    SO GOOD. Lobster tasted so fresh and tender. Bread was hefty and a great compliment. (Lobster Roll)
    SO GOOD. Lobster tasted so fresh and tender. Bread was hefty and a great compliment. (Lobster Roll)
    The Highroller Lobster
    Lobster Cheese Crisp Taco, Lobster Roll

    See all

    Lobster Cheese Crisp Taco, Lobster Roll
    Street & Co.

    Street & Co.

    4.4
    (1.9k reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$$

    I recently had a most wonderful dinner at Street and Co with wonderful company!…read more Our servers were all excellent, and the food came in exactly the right amount of time. We started with burrata, a bluefish pate, and mussels for apps, and then moved right into: Bluefish tuna Lobster Fra Diavlo for two, and Roasted Branzino (which was FANTASTIC) After that, we still pursued dessert and ordered a pecan pie with in-house made ice cream and one of the most delicious rice puddings I have ever had. Overall, it was a GREAT night. 100% recommend.

    I'd like to give Street and Co a 4.5 as I'm not sure it deserves a full 5 but it was very very…read moregood. One of the best meals we had in Portland. We liked it more than Scales which I think might be a less popular opinion. The ambiance was very rustic and cozy. It did feel a little cramped and the first table they sat us at was in the middle of a bunch of other tables and I really don't think it would be a nice table for anyone. Thankfully they moved us to a corner/booth which was very nice of them. Even in the corner it was still a little cramped which is my reason for not giving it 5 stars. The pasta dish with lobster in a red sauce was divine. Full of other seafood in addition to the lobster like mussels and clams too. It was definitely messy but the flavor was fantastic. Tons of garlic which we love. The octopus appetizer was also delicious. Very charred which normally I wouldn't like but it worked very well with this dish. We also got hummus which was a special appetizer. It was ok- not very memorable. The desserts didn't appeal to us (maybe we were just too full). Would love to return if we find ourselves back in Portland!

    Photos
    Inside
    Inside
    Clam linguine
    Clam linguine
    Grilled Lobster with Butter and Garlic

    See all

    Grilled Lobster with Butter and Garlic
    Scales

    Scales

    4.3
    (1.2k reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$$

    Great place ! Cant wait to go back for dinner . Make reservations early hard to get…read more Decor was on point ! Service great Food was delicious and presented beautifully !

    Scales was on our bucket list and we are so happy we made it come true. Gorgeous location, this…read morerestaurant runs like a well oiled machine. From the moment you arrive, you know you are walking into a quality restaurant. We sat at the bar, what a show! We got immediate attention, got our drink order right away, got to see everyone behind the bar work in harmony. We then ordered some oysters, watch out, they come to you, up front and close. They shuck them right in front of you, explain what they are and where they came from and leave you the condiments to enjoy. THE BEST OYSTERS I've had in my life and I've had them all over the world. Fresh, soft delicate goodness. After you are done, they send the ice and shells down a hole built in the bar! Genius! The tuna crudo was sooo good! It is made in front of you, carefully and artfully arranged on a plate. A masterpiece! The specials where then covered and today I wanted to have one of each is an understatement. We both had to order the brown butter halibut, good God that was so delicious. Insanely delicious! We were told that there is one chef that dedicates their time cooking this dish as well as the scallops. Can't beat that! My hubby ordered some rolls to "sop up" some of that brown butter goodness and he was not disappointed. Everyone was so happy, talkative, truly enjoying the evening. This waterfront place is a true masterpiece and classic beauty. Don't walk, run, and then book it twice at least while you are in Portland.

    Photos
    Beautiful !
    Beautiful !
    Buckwheat brownie
    Buckwheat brownie
    Peach & Blueberry Cobbler

    See all

    Peach & Blueberry Cobbler
    The Shop

    The Shop

    4.5
    (260 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    This place came recommended by multiple people, and now that I've been, I can really see why this…read moreis a must-visit in Portland. Once you are seated, you're handed a paper menu on which you mark your selections, then bring that marked-up menu to the counter, where you order and get a number. Food is brought up to you, and you can order subsequent rounds of food by crossing out previous orders and marking up the menu anew. I would highly recommend multiple rounds of oysters -- the first to try one of each and figure out which varieties you prefer, the second to get more of the ones you like, and the last to go all in on your favorite. They've got a varied selection that will suit various tastes, whether you favor a large creamy oyster, a small briny guy, or somewhere in between. All from Maine, which made me feel better about having oysters in a non-ber month. The oysters here are top notch, and the shuckers are, too. Not a single speck of shell in there! I love oysters, and this was my paradise. The non oyster items are also worth trying, so if you have a friend who isn't into oysters, there's something here for them, too. The smoked fish dip and french onion dip are awesome, and the chips they get from another local producer are fantastic. Whether you're a beer lover, a wine person, or a cocktailer, they've got something for you here. Any of those could be the perfect company for your favorite oyster, or you could go for their cucumber mint lemonade slushy, which is insanely refreshing and a great palate cleanser between oysters. Service is efficient, welcoming, and friendly. I think anyone from an oyster novice to an aficionado would feel right at home here. If I didn't live on the opposite side of the country, I'd be here all the time. Unfortunately for me, I'm relegated to pining for these oysters from a distance. If you live nearby, take advantage of your proximity and eat some oysters for me.

    5/29/26 A special note- a new dish added to the menu- the…read moreseafood cocktail- is a winner. This is the go-to dish for the partner who doesn't care for oysters- it it superlative, and I hope it remains on the offerings. The service today- especially fine. I have become, as the French would say, "an habitué"

    Photos
    Bloody mary (already ate the oyster, oops)
    Bloody mary (already ate the oyster, oops)
    From the street- plenty of parking
    From the street- plenty of parking
    Oysters

    See all

    Oysters

    DiMillo's On The Roll - seafood - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...