Divina is that rarest of restaurants: Professional service. Gracious welcome. A bread basket of crusty Italian bread perfect to sop up expertly made sauces. Sensible portions fit perfectly executed appetizers. Pasta courses and mains that have every detail executed well--fresh fish and meat, cooked to order. No microwave. Authenticity to every item on the menu. No trendy dishes. The Branzino is the best ever. The pappardelle with mushrooms was fresh pasta and a plethora of mushrooms in a rich and creamy sauce The cannoli she'll? Fresh and crisp, and the cream, not too sweet. A great meal. read more

OK, I know this place gets a lot of great reviews and it's very popular. But I have to be honest I don't think the food is that spectacular to justify their prices. $20 for a salad really? And it's just way too loud. The acoustics are horrible. I just don't like it. Maybe it's me, but I just don't like eating in a room filled with loud chatter. LOL B read more

OMG! What a find! This was the best Italian meal we've had since our vacation in Italy back in Oct. The service and attention of the staff was impeccable and the food...incredible, fresh and delicious! We will be back! read more

Anything you order is good. Specials? Fantastic. Weirdly everytime you go back it gets better. Price isn't crazy either. Big party food came out in a reasonable amount of time. read more

I have lived in Caldwell for around 13 years and just tried this restaurant recently after a friend recommended it. I wish I would've been going here regularly for the past 13 years because it is truly amazing!! The tortellini bolognese was to die for and the staff was very friendly. The prices are decent and it's BYOB. Absolutely they must try a restaurant! read more

This is a very good, neighborhood, Italian restaurant with really well made fresh food and great service. The first time we went was on the recommendation of a friend. When we returned two weeks later (!) the waiter remembered us, and what we ordered. It must've been from the fact that we got into a whole conversation about how delicious, fresh, and flavor balanced I thought the salad was at the meal :). Go. It'll make you feel good. Everything is fresh delicious, and familial. read more

Food is always excellent. Zuppa di Pesce and the pasta special had a ton of delicious and savory flavor. We also had the fried calamari which is lightly breaded and was paired with some sweet sauce. Service was fast and attentive and the prices were ok, in this day and age. Nice place with plenty of seating on a Thursday. read more

Divina Ristorante - Paccheti and pink sauce - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Food and service were great. The menu is very eclectic without being too crazy. Its BYOB/W. I came with my gal for birthday and i felt like celebrity from the service. Franco was really great and a pleasure to " parla Italiano" with. Def be back and recommend for a great meal to everyone! read more

I have no idea how I haven't been here considering I passed it so many times. This review is a conglomerate of times I have visited. It's in a shopping center plaza on a main road. Its a great date night spot with white table cloths and Italian paintings. It's very old school Italian and the owner is a gem. Mario is extremely personable and truly cares about providing his customers the highest quality ingredients. I spent a long time talking to him during one of my visits. The business has been around for over 25 years! Obviously he is doing something right! Everything I had here was delicious. It is also all made to order, which is incredibly rare in todays world. My personal favorite was the shrimp appetizer. I think I could have honestly licked the plate. The fresh mozzarella appetizer is also chefs kiss. It's also made daily in house. Also not pictured is seafood pasta with a slightly spicy marinara. The desserts are also excellent quality. The pumpkin cheesecake is made daily and Mario takes great pride in. A shot of espresso with hazelnut biscotti ends the dinner perfectly. The staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. It's exceptionally clean as well. If you are looking for a good date night spot and want actual Italian food with premium ingredients- you have to come to Divina. 10/10 read more

See all

Best italian Restaurant, i ate lasagna was amazing!!!! . Excellent service, delicious food and friendly people! Definitely we gonna come back again! read more

Mario and his staff are top notch! I've had the veal with mushrooms, linguini and white clam sauce, veal with eggplant, mozzarella and tomato all delish. My boss swears the osso bucco is the best he has ever had. My friend had the pasta primavera which she loved. I can go on and on. There is a reason Mario has been in business for a long time. Go you won't be disappointed! Oh and it's BYOB! Great desserts too! read more

Great dinner again last night!!!! Great food and service thank you to our server Franco!!

Delicious Italian. BYOB. Excellent host. Service is great. Would recommend. Check out the specials.

Been going here for years!! Zero complaints!! Mario the owner and chef is awesome as is their staff. Highly recommend calling ahead asking for the appetizer gnocchi and for entree if you like heat go with the chicken arrabiata (can ask for it chopped/not on bone if you prefer) but really love it all! Affogato for dessert, my favorite! read more

Divina Ristorante - Affogato - Italian Near Me - Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Best Italian in New Jersey for 30 plus years. Mario the chef has never let me down. Best cheesecake in the world.

The Octopus Fra Diablo is AMAZING! Also loved the sole francese. Perfect! Service is great. Great place. I Recommend a later seating, so there is no rush. read more

Ordered a few trays for Mother's Day. The lasagna bolognese and chicken piccata were delicious. Customer service in placing and receiving the order was excellent. Thank you Jasmine. read more

My favorite Jersey Italian restaurant since I was a kid. It's still as good as it's always been. The flourless chocolate cake and cheesecake are musts for any dessert hounds. read more

Simply put, Divina Ristorante is THE BEST Italian restaurant in North Jersey. Mario (Chef/Owner) and his staff do an incredible job making sure that anyone who walks through the door is treated to not only an incredible meal, but to friendly and attentive service. All of the dishes are delectable, but the pasta is especially delicious and everything is made from the highest quality ingredients with impeccable attention to detail. While you can't go wrong with anything on the menu (especially the specials, which are rotated often), a few of the biggest home runs that you can hit are: -Pear-stuffed fiocchi in a gorgonzola cream-sauce -Branzino w/ potatoes and vegetables -hot peppers & potatoes appetizer -Veal Saltimbocca -Buffalo Riccota Pappardelle -After dinner you can't go wrong with the affogato. Whether you're looking for a place to go out for a Saturday night, going out for a mid-week dish, or just trying to get Sunday Sauce, you can't beat Divina Ristorante. read more

Better than Grandma's cooking! Perfect for special occasions, or a quiet dinner. Great service! Warm and cozy atmosphere! No place better in NJ. read more

A superlative hidden gem among the many quality Italian restaurants in the area. Two trips to Divina confirmed that this is a first quality establishment. The ingredients are obviously first rate and fresh, preparation superb. Pro waiters, with an obvious passion for what they do. Overall, a terrific "white tablecloth" exceptional Italian restaurant you'll enjoy time and again. read more

One of the best Italian restaurants around. Food is outstanding, portion size is huge, & the food is freshly made when you order. You can tell the chef loves his job, it is definitely in the flavor in the meals he prepares. Must stop in if your in the neighborhood! read more

I have been a customer since they opened. Amazing food and service. The specials and the desserts are unbelievable.

I come here often for dinner as well as for business lunches. It is one of the best Italian restaurants in the area and a personal favorite. The quality of the food and variety of dishes is excellent as is the service. Highly recommended! read more

Another great meal tonight, Father's Day. Staff is a joy, small and humble place. Everything made to order (always a plus ). I posted pictures with little or zero screen maneuvering because all the food looks great as is, completely fresh and made just for you. The only item I didn't get a picture of (my father and I started eating to fast) was the Chicken Arrabbiata (in a vinegar with hot pepper reduction) on the bone... Every dish was 100% fork tender (no knife necessary). The homemade Mozzarella appetizer was absurd (Mozzarella was crazy fresh and creamy). Oh apparently I inhaled my Raviolis stuffed with crab meat and some herbs as well (can't find photo). Rav's were outstanding (I got a huge plate of raviolis as an appetizer so I had to share) definitely fresh pasta, unsure if house made. The fresh Pistachio cake (tasted like a flourless cake) topped with powdered sugar was light and crispy on outside and warm and fluffy inside. This is a BYO and a OMG I'm so full and happy. Cheers. read more

See all

Wonderful service and phenomenal food. I had the pasta dish with shrimp and crabmeat. Outstanding and would definitely have it again!

Service excellent, food out of this world. Can't wait to go back !! Waiting time for food was minimal and the staff was kind and very helpful. read more

Right out of the box, I have to say that EVERYTHING we ordered was excellent. Arugula, Radicchio, and Fennel Salad was perfectly dressed with some shaved pieces of Parmesan. Mozzarella , Tomato, and Pepper appetizer, very good with house made mozzarella. Pasta e Fagioli came out hot and it was delicious. Tortellini Alla Bolognese was perfect , it was great. On the low calorie side is the Chicken with mixed veggies. The chicken was not over cooked and the mushrooms, broccoli, and several small wedges of potato were very good. Nicely seasoned and not stinking of garlic! Veal Principessa , my friend told me was very enjoyable The chef/owner knows what he is doing and the crowded dining room shows it. I would have given, a rare for me, 5 star rating if I was reviewing only the food. I had to take off a star because from the moment we sat down, we were rushed. The first thing our waiter said to us is that we are very busy tonight. Menus on table immediately, in a very, very short time, we are asked if we are ready to order. We were not. WE order, appetizers out quickly, not a bad thing, but before I finished my salad, our entrees came out. Before we had a chance to take a breath after finishing our entrees, the table was cleaned and we are given desert menus. One of our party finally went to the hostess and said this has got to stop. It did, and for the final 30 minutes we ordered desert, coffees, etc. and breathed normally. WE did not over stay, in at 6 and out at 8. Spending $370 for a party of 6. The cost is not a complaint, the great food is worth it. Back to the positives! The flourless chocolate cake is a chocoholics dream, the cannoli was one of the best anywhere. With that said, the service good but as I told you it was rushed. The dining room is small but it is very well cared for and inviting. I would come back, but not on a Saturday evening. read more

Went here for a birthday party for my sister in law and she has raved about this place for some time. She is 100% correct - this was such a nice treat. From the appetizers to the salads to the main course to dessert - spot on. Going back for Mothers Day and I cannot wait. Homemade pasta like no other and while it may seem silly - the cheesecake here has me dreaming of going back. If you love Italian food - and think there are only a few "really good restaurants that are bring your own and have top notch food" - here is one to add to your list. You will not be disappointed. read more

I phoned an order in for pickup. When picking up while I was paying I was told that they didn't have enough bread for the 3rd sandwich and gave me a smaller loaf of bread and put the chicken parm into a container. I only discovered this when picking the order up with guests at my home. I was not called and appraised of this or given the opportunity to possibly order something else before, and absolutely no concessions were made or offered. Very disappointing. read more

Have been here a few times. It's a great little BYOB neighborhood restaurant it does get packed so make a reservation or go early. The food is always fresh. I love a restaurant that serves homemade macaroni and they do the sauce is good. You cannot go wrong with the veal Parmesan. It's thin and crispy the way I like it, I appreciate that it's a BYOB and you can bring your red or white and enjoy a delicious meal. It's small inside. They don't have a lot of tables but they get packed so I can make a reservation. i've been here a few times. It's a great little BYOB neighborhood restaurant it does get packed so make a reservation or go early. The food is always fresh. I love a restaurant that serves homemade macaroni and they do the sauce is good. You cannot go wrong with the veal Parmesan. It's thin and crispy the way I like it, I appreciate that it's a BYOB and you can bring your red or white and enjoy a delicious meal. It's small inside. They don't have a lot of tables but they get packed so I can make a reservation.Definitely give it a try read more

Great place. Great food. Great service. Great selection. BYOB. I'd go back a few more times.

Always delicious. Arugula fennel salad was very good. Chicken Mascotta very tasty and hot when served.

Always excellent!! Food is great, waiters are always very friendly. Paccheri special is always great, crab meat and shrimp.

I have to say, I was very disappointed as we had a party of seven to celebrate a birthday. It started off poorly with a hard dry bread and the calamari was soft texture wise. Mediocre at best. Dinner came, and all the entrées were being placed in front of the wrong people. Also, two pasta dishes were very lean portion wise. Cheesecake was average at best and one dessert was forgotten. We had to remind the staff. AWFUL amount of $$$ dropped for a very average dinner. Hard to convince me to go back! read more

Recommended to us by a local police officer, so we didn't do our usual online research before we arrived. This place is on the small side, so we were definitely lucky to get a table without a reservation...even on a Wednesday evening. Fabulous mix of tasty-looking plates arrived at tables all around us, so we knew we were in for a treat. And when the table was graced with a lusciously toasty loaf of firm-crusted bread AND a self-serve cauldron of cheese...well, our hopes rose even higher. We opted for tried-and-true mainstays of Italian (lasagna and minestrone for me, tortellini alla Bolognese and another soup for him). Flavors and textures were wonderful all the way around: the only problem with this great restaurant is they aren't located nearer our home. Since we were on the road, we did not use the BYOB option to augment our meal with wine. We also had to skip dessert and espresso due to timing, but saw other diners with sweet treats I long to try on our next visit. (On a personal note, I loved how this restaurant was table after table of conversation -- not the blue glare of smart screens while people ignore each other. Crowd was a bit older, but the diners were definitely fully engaged in a great meal with great company.) read more

See all

Excellent Italian. The owner/chef comes out to your table and says hello. The salads and entrees are amazing. The chicken special like a chicken park w prosciutto was one of best dishes I've had in a long time. BYOB is a plus and there seems to be length of parking behind restaurant. read more

Second Time I've dined here last one being several years ago but the results were about the same very good enjoyable but missing out on greatness. Arrived to a packed house 7:30 PM reservation and with many BYOB's in NJ ambiance is not the center piece of dining, the food is. Brought some good wine which was promptly opened and 2 sets of wine glasses provided for 2 different bottles nice touch. Bread was "NICOLA's of Montclair hot crusty and fresh so you can't go wrong, though the pads of foil butter and no offer of dipping oil etc detract from what could have been an outstanding start. APPETIZERS: Shrimp $14.95 with white wine, hot pepper & garlic plentiful amount of tasty shrimp clean cooked properly. Not much spice and could have used a bit more sauce but a really good start. Two on special Octopus fra Diablo appetizers $14.95 were a bit on the small side fresh and tasty, spicy marinara was just not hot enough for my taste and a bit thin. Arugula, Radicchio & Fennel Salad with shaved parmigiano cheese............. $11.95 was fine if not slightly expensive for size of dish vs price points. Penne Alla Zingara (Hot) $18.95 with pancetta, onions & hot peppers really good though again I couldn't taste the spice needed to make this a over the top dish while the pasta was slightly over cooked. Chicken Marengo $22.95 with red wine vinegar and garlic on the bone couple of small pieces of chicken with a nice sauce, though for amount of chicken provided and type of chicken legs and thigh pieces this was a disappointment. Zuppa Di Pesce Marechiara $30.95 red sauce, with scallops, shrimp, calamari best dish on the table if not pricey. Linguini with scallops & broccoli............$26.95 found the scallops overcooked and broccoli undercooked.. SMH on this one. Flourless Chocolate Cake for desert and hot coffee and espresso were excellent. Service was good. Just missing that extra kick to separate it from the pack of BYOB's in NJ but certainly an enjoyable meal. read more

Service is just ok. It is a good 3star restaurant. Service lacks. They don't pour wine or check up on you enough. Dishes are hit or miss. Seafood salad was great but calamari was average. Gravy was average but not salty as some other places. Nice, cozy, small place. If you ask for a soda or a sparkling water , they will give you an unopened can. Cappuccino is served in a mug. read more

See all

Why wait?! I'm sitting at the table right now in Divina. I just finished zuppa di pesce over spinach absolutely unbelievable 10/10. The fish is so fresh and flavors are delicious. Bravo! Best meal I have had in a while. read more