Ordered a Margarita pizza and fettuccine Alfredo with mushrooms and broccoli. Both dishes were…read morevery good, well seasoned, cooked to order and nice portions. Ordered online and the order was finished for pickup 8 minutes early. Definitely coming back!

I struggled with the star rating for this place because it was my moms idea to eat here, as she…read morelives locally and I feel like this is more of a come for dinner when you don't want to cook yourself type of place. It's Saturday evening on a holiday weekend and the place was pretty busy. People continued to come in and pick up to-go orders and all the booths were full. Family owned and the owner even stopped by our table to let us know what he makes fresh, like the meatballs and lasagna. So maybe I gotta come back and try that. My meal for a slice of cheese pizza, small salad and a ginger ale was $8 which is a DEAL! I can tell the locals frequent and Zephyrhills is a less developed part of Florida in comparison to like a Wesley Chapel so I feel like you gotta give some perspective. It's a family vibe and the servings are plentiful and the service here is probably the first thing I noticed. Everyone is super friendly, for a small joint, they'll bring your food out piping hot if you're dining in and as I mentioned, the chef will have a chat and check in on you which is way more than I can say about a lot of places. The pizza was okay. I wasn't a fan of the crust and I'm someone who looks forward to the crust. I found it to be flavorless. I did like the crispy bottom and how it held up to a fold. The salad was fine, and the dressing was a standard Italian. Nothing to write home about but the eggplant parm was a lot of food. You could easily get three servings from it. I think the sauce was delicious, although just a tad on the salty side for me. I liked the spaghetti, it was al dente and for me was the only thing with texture on the plate. I thought everything else ate like soft food and I personally like different textures when I eat so while the flavor was good, it was just a lot of melted cheese and sauce and I wasn't really sure when or if I was getting a bite of eggplant. If I went back, I'd ask what's made in house and give it a try. If you're not too much of a food snob like me and can enjoy food that's giving home cooked vibes at a great value, then this place delivers.

I've still been going back to American Pizza every Friday. Jessica and her team of girls are just…read moregreat. They are always polite from the phone call to pickup. Last night we had friends in town from South Carolina and we changed it up a little bit. We ordered a Margarita pizza and it was awesome!! As a former pizza snob from NY, we have definitely found the best pizza in Dade City. Thanks Jess and team!!!

This pizza is incredible. Thin, crispy, delicious. Staff are welcoming and accommodating and my…read morekids and I came by in a day they were closed and they invited us in (they were there to setup a catering event) and we had a private lunch for just us! Great environment, great staff, even better pizza.

I've heard friends rave about this place and finally got the chance to check it out! It's on a Main…read moreStreet in downtown Dade City. Street parking was available and easy to find on a Saturday night at 6pm. They do not take reservations but we thankfully were able to be seated immediately and seemed to have beat the crowd that came after us. Our waiter was very attentive and friendly. He checked on us, refilled our water, and made sure our experience was great! I started off with a Passionfruit Martini. This was delicious and refreshing. We shared the Ipomodori Verdi Fritti, which are fried green tomatoes topped with burrata, goat cheese, tzatziki sauce, and a balsamic glaze. Very good and flavorful! The breading was not thick and it was perfect! For my entree I ordered the Shrimp Champagne, which is shrimp, tomatoes, champagne, roasted garlic cream, and spinach with a fettuccine pasta topped with a crostini. This was amazing! Absolutely fantastic! Perfect for at least 2-3 meals for me. We were also served complimentary bread and oil and herb dip. Very good! Would definitely come back and recommend! Quite a few items on the menu sounded delicious and made it hard to choose!

This is a hidden gem in Dade City. Not where I expected to find a very good Italian restaurant…read more Everything was excellent. The service, the ambiance and especially the food. We can't wait to go back!

I like the chicken, bacon ranch pizza it's so big and feeds 4 adults. Very helpful whenever we eat…read morethere or order.

The pizza is the best! While it is pretty expensive, I've never had a bad experience aside from…read moreoccasionally slow service. The patio is definitely the best spot when the weather is warm.

I didn't ordered through a third party provider. I ordered through your website. You chose to have…read morea third party deliver to me, instead of your regular driver. I was pretty clear about that in my review. I have never ordered from door dash in my life. The Manager never called me yesterday as promised either. Boo again!

We've ordered out from this location about 2 or 3 times now and each time the order is ready within…read morethe given time frame, the food is hot, prepared correctly, and delicious! I like their cheese pizza & when they had their special spicy pepperoni pizza. Can't go wrong! We've done both delivery and carry out. With delivery, the pizza was still so hot when it arrived!

I accidentally ordered the wrong pizza online when I picked it up. They made me new one at no…read moreextra cost within 5 minutes.

ONLY place with the gall to charge extra for bacon. Bacon. Pizza's aren't even that good but still…read morecharge 4.00 for a a basic topping. Stick to any other pizza joint like Domino's.

Appears clean and well-lit...would like to see more lighting and maybe security camera in the lot,…read moreparticularly at night.. but friendly service. Just seems like location may be getting towards seedy part of town.

Great people great service best pizza I have ever had I will only be eating here for the rest of my…read morelife the cheese bread are wonderful always perfectly cut the pepperoni pizza is just amazing and it's cheap I really like the blonde assistant manager she was really really nice to me!