The service was great by Rachel, but the restaurant in atmosphere could be upgraded a little bit…read moremore with modern furniture tables. Just a whole new look all the way around updated. We are in 2026. The restaurant looks like it could be 1996. If it was nice and hot and it came out pretty quickly, I would say try the pizza. The grilled shrimp was OK. It could've been cooked a little bit longer,

Omg it so good pizza come here fast cheap definitely order again very good order now 2nd best pizza…read moreplace in Horseheads and Elmira and Corning and Saracuse

Very good pizza,as close to Brooklyn pizza you can get up here. Their sandwiches are very good as…read morewell. Highly recommend. Excellent service as well.

Great NY style slices! Not much to choose from at the Mall, but there is still pizza!read more

Pizza was awesome. Very friendly people Service was awesome and the sizes are crazy a lot bigger…read morethan what you think. I will definitely order from there again when we come back next season. I highly recommend them.

One of the servers at a winery told us to go here and we genuinely never would've had she not…read moresuggested it. Our server was very attentive despite a packed restaurant. Food came out super fast. We got garlic knots (sooo buttery omg!!) and the I got a creamy pasta and my friend got chicken parm. My pasta was really delicious and flavorful but my friend wasn't in love with her chicken parm. If you get anything here I would highly suggest the garlic knots.. yes you already get bread for the table but these are damn good.

The pizza here is delicious and the slices are huge! Truly one of my favorite pizza places. My…read morehusband and I also got subs the last time we were here and they were also gigantic and really good! You order at the counter and then your food is brought to you. Everyone we interacted with was friendly enough. The ambiance is similar to your typical fast food place. Definitely recommend if you are looking for a good slice of pizza!

Always quick kind service. Pizza is always made fresh. Enjoy coming here anytime chance I get. A…read moremust is their fresh made bread.

I took my son to dinner here while I was in town. He had been before with friends and recommended…read moreeverything. We had an amazing waitress and a series of back-up help who were so attentive to every detail. The food was delicious. We both left feeling like it was time to go to bed....satiated and relaxed. Would recommend.

Cozy (if a touch loud), excellent Italianesque pizza/pasta/salad joint. Good cocktails, beer and…read morewine cards. Experienced and personable servers. Bougie uni crowd, but good value for money nevertheless -- not always the case in Ithaca. Pasta Alla Vodka was particularly fine.

There is no better option than Horseheads Picnic Pizza. I am a chicken wing pizza fan, and these…read moreguys knock it out of the park every time I go there! The service is amazing. You are always greeted with a smile. Great atmosphere. 10 out of 10 would recommend to anyone looking for great food!

Paid over 40$ for a large pizza with pepperoni, half sausage and a large soda. Expensive for no…read morereason.

Absolutely the best Pizza in the entire area !! I know his is a bold statement, as everyones tastes…read moreare different. Try a mushroom and fresh tomato pizza first then it will be difficult to argue with me. Note: for pickup go earlier than they tell you. It will most likely be ready.

4.5 stars We stopped…read morehere on our way down from Niagara Falls. We were hungry and in the mood for pizza. Rico, the owner, recommended the Big Game special - which was a large cheese pizza, 10 wings and garlic knots. Garlic knots (at least 8, maybe 10) were fresh and coated in a delicious buttery garlic sauce. The pizza was decent, fresh and cheesy. I prefer my NY style pizza to be super crispy on the bottom, and this one came out normal. The wings were the highlight: steaming, freshly made and large. I hate paying for dinky small wings and these did not disappoint. The service was even better - Rico was very friendly and promptly brought out food, plates, waters for us, etc. When we first pulled up, there were some friendly state troopers having lunch here, so you know it's well enjoyed by the locals! Definitely worth a visit! Tip: the marinara that came with the garlic knots was yummy and great for dipping pizza crust too, and Rico was nice enough to give us some extra garlic dip that the garlic knots came in. Great dipping sauce for pizza crust!

First thing I noticed when I walked in here was the Calabria poster. That gets you an extra star in…read moremy book. As usual I tried a plain cheese . I also got white slice. Plain cheese was very good. A little flop but not too bad. Nice sauce and good cheese. The white slice was ok. A little too much ricotta but overall was decent. They had a great menu of Italian food. I noticed all the customers there ordered a bunch of things besides pizza. Everything looked good. I would go again.

For this area, pretty average (horrible food in this area). Compared against food spots in general,…read morenot good. Positive was fries were crispy even after sitting in container for 15 during my ride home. Pizza has some sort of really strong cheese flavor that is non typical and over powering.