Waiter was extremely knowledgeable about Italian fine dining and greeted our friends who have never been to the restaurant with open arms. Explained to us how dinners in Italy work and answered any questions we had. The cheese wheel pasta is a show stopper and I love how everything is explained during the process. The cheese wheel is 2 years old and all wine is imported straight from Italy. My tagliatelle pasta was absolutely delicious. Although it looked like a small dish, it was very filling. The chocolate soufflé was cooked fresh (15 min to be exact!) Great dinner read more

See all

Base my reviews off what you pay: *Place was packed on a Saturday at 7:30PM Price - $150 (appetizer, entree, 2 drinks, dessert, tip) Food - 4/5 - great tasting food. Service - 4/5 - friendly and attentive. Ambiance - 3/5 - nice vibe with open fire, slightly tacky and dark. Overall - 4/5 - this is one of those places that is worth visiting once then probably not again. Everything was good but for the price you can get equally as good food at a budget. Food was really good, particularly the Wild Boar Gnocchi Ragu & Pistachio Cake, both easily worth a try. Service was great as well. Friendly, attentive, some conversation there, was good service. Ambiance was a mixed bag. While the indoors is really nice with a cool open flame, it can be dark inside and a little tacky (easy 4 if it wasn't as dark). Definitely worth a visit at one point but not as a regular spot. Best Dish - Wild Boar Ragu Gnocchi, Pistachio Cake Would Return - Probably not read more

Mixed feelings. So many friends have spoken so highly of this place that I felt we HAD to give it a try. They also cautioned about the price so, after selling off an inherited Monet, off we went! Umbra is in a nondescript strip mall with a Thai place next door. Dark, front-facing windows give it a chic look but... oh no... fake flowers. Normally, not a big deal but for a place known for being upscale, it seemed incongruous for the vibe. More on that later. Inside was cool and urban chic. Long bar gives view of their famous oven. Seating was comfortable enough though the artificial flowers and grapes (circa 1984 Patchogue's Fantasy Gardens) detracted. I get that they're trying to do an Italian countryside thing but it seemed forced. The food was a mixed bag. Wagyu tartar with quail egg was pretty awesome; rich, minerally, unctuous. So far so good. Cocktail was tasty and the wine was fine. But then... Wife got a pasta dish that she was happy with. She found it to be very good but not exemplary. I ordered the veal osso buco which was a tremendous disappointment. The bed of risotto was terrific but it seemed like they simply placed several (small) medallions of veal in the middle surrounding a tiny bone and then dropped sauce all over it. I'm a grown man and have faced all sorts of disappointments in my life (being an Islanders fan conditions you to this) but I kinda wanted to cry when that came to the table. I've had osso buco other places and this plate fell well short. (I actually was arguing with a friend who is a tremendous fan of Umbra and, when I showed him the pic, he fell silent. I included pics of two other osso bucos for comparison). Friends had mentioned that the steaks are really good here but I kinda go to steak joints for steaks, ya dig? They make their own pasta so maybe I should have chosen one of those dishes. Affogato for dessert which was less than what I was expecting but is (according to friend in the know) the classic and traditional preparation so no real complaints there. The service was very good, however. Both our waitress and the bartender/sommelier were attentive, friendly and well-informed. All-in-all, a nice place. A VERY nice place. But I think it's a tad overpriced and overhyped for what it is. We usually like to give a spot a second or third try but at the price point, probably not. Give it a shot if you've got money to burn but be aware of the cost and that some things may fall short of your expectations. read more

Osteria Umbra - Wagyu tartar - Italian Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Everything was absolutely perfect from beginning to end. The food, the service, the ambiance? A1 across the board. I will definitely be back read more

See all

Osteria Umbra is the ideal option for homemade Italian cuisine, from the main course to the dessert. Under Chef Marco Pellegrini's guidance, you will engage in a gourmet Italian adventure. read more

Osteria Umbra - ROSARIO S. CASSATA AND CAROLYN AT OSTERIA UMBRA IN SMITHTOWN NY. - Italian Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Lovely elevated Italian. The food was excellent, not your run of the mill Italian. Known for their one of a kind wood stove from Italy, our steak was cooked perfectly. The surprise of the night was our pasta dish. It was perfectly seasoned. It was the Orchiette with fava beans, guancale, cheese and grape tomatoes. It was so delicious. The pistachio cake was excellent too. I would recommend for a special occasion. read more

We just celebrated my brother's 30th birthday at Osteria Umbra, and it was truly an unforgettable experience from start to finish. It was a surprise party for 15 people (his absolute favorite restaurant), and the entire night exceeded every expectation we had. The level of service we received was nothing short of incredible. Our main server, John, was absolutely out of this world. Not only was he attentive and on top of everything all night long, but he also took the time to share background and knowledge about the restaurant and each dish we were enjoying. That combination of service, passion, and education made the entire experience feel so elevated and special. Anything we needed, he was there immediately--he truly made us feel taken care of the entire evening. His assistant, Charles, was just as amazing--so attentive, kind, and dedicated to making sure we had the best possible time. And the food... absolutely phenomenal. Huge credit to Chef Marco--there are honestly no words. We opted for a family-style setup with multiple appetizers, salads, entrées, and desserts. I was a little skeptical at first, but it ended up being the BEST decision. We got to try so many different dishes--way more than you normally would--and there was not a single thing I didn't love. Every bite was incredible. Between the outstanding service, the amazing food, and the overall experience, I cannot recommend this restaurant enough. If you go, definitely request John--you will not regret it! read more

See all

I'm sad to say this was my first time at Osteria Umbra. What the heck was I waiting for? As soon as we arrived we were greeted by 3 smiling faces, so adorable. We went to the bar to wait for the rest of our party and had some drinks served by Olivia. Once we were seated Jackie was our most gracious and accommodating server. We had the most delicious and fabulous meal. Orange and fennel salad, grilled calamari, pasta with truffle cream sauce and a 32oz bone in rib eye that was cooked to perfection. Medium rare with a crust, oh my goodness it was so good. It came with delicious mashed potatoes and we ordered the brussel sprouts, so yummy. We ended the meal with tiramisu and chocolate soufflé with vanilla gelato. The perfect ending to a great meal. The service was impeccable and the ambiance was comfortable. You must go here to have a beautiful experience. read more

See all

Going into Umbria, it's like a portal. From a side road shopping mall into an elegant eatery. We were greeted by a pre hostess who directed us to another hostess. We were in and out in an hour and I knew we were being rushed which I wasn't a fan of but it was done somewhat respectfully. The food was phenomenal. We opted for a special cheese wheel cacio e peppe. I should have known it was expensive when our waiter didn't mention its price, but other specials he did. All pasta dishes were in the high 20s or 30's but this was $45. My wife said it was the best pasta she's ever eaten and it was a pretty cool table side exhibit. But it was steep. My quince paste apple martini was sublime and I loved the glass it came in. Our dinners, I had to get venison as I never see it on menus and my wife got the sea bass. We really enjoyed our meals. Even looking at the menu, I think I could have gotten and enjoyed almost every meal which I normally can't say in an Italian restaurant. Maybe because Umbra doubles as a steakhouse, lol. Beware though, it is pricey and it's funny that the waiter asked if we are celebrating anything as I assume most do when coming here. They do a fun firecracker dessert for bdays. All in all, it was a really nice experience and would no doubt come here before going to nearby steakhouses, just gotta start saving again read more

Osteria Umbra - Quince paste apple martini - Italian Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Great food great service and just booked my valentines dinner. She will definitely be surprised

Eaten here before and the quality has gone down severely while the prices have gone through the roof. Biggest disappointment was my tuna, extremely fishy and had to send it back. I'm 50 year old and I don't believe I have ever sent a dish back before. The tuna steak also had two large ribs (maybe 4" long by 1/4" wide) sticking out the side of it. Honestly looked like a tomahawk beef steak. I've done plenty of fishing and have eaten ton's of tuna and I've never seen a tuna with bones like that. Replacement dish was a lasagna, which they had to rush, and was cold in the middle. I felt bad and didn't send that back as well. Will just microwave it tomorrow. Have to say the desserts were excellent, lemon cake and a strawberry tiramisu. In any event, a $325 dinner for two (I had a bourbon cocktail and glass of wine, wife had a diet coke) and mostly I have a stomachache. Just so disappointed as I purposely didn't eat much, looking forward to this anniversary dinner, and as said I was unhappy. Keep your $325 in your pocket, make a steak or lasagna at home, buy a bottle of bourbon, maybe get a dessert to go I guess if they offer that. Osteria Umbra has collapsed under the weight of it's own pretentiousness. read more

I have heard so many things about the restaurant that I was very excited to finally dine there We can start with the ambiance. We were seated to the right of the bar area. Was just my wife and I but felt we were seated in the children's section. All the tables around us had young children seated around us. The other side of the restaurant appeared to look a bit brighter and no children. Not sure why we were seated in this area. Service was great. Morgan was our waitress and was very good and extremely attentive. Dinner was good but I would not say the most amazing. We had the caprese salad and the zucchini flowers. Both were good but I have had better at other places at much cheaper prices. We then had the Veal Ossobuco and the Branzino. My wife really enjoyed the veal. The Branzino was good but again I have had better. Nice restaurant, good food but for the price they charge I expected more read more

Ordered Rib Steak. It was prepared perfectly, best steak that I had in last 55 years. Wine selection is wonderful. Service is GREAT. It was our 58th Wedding Anniversary Dinner. I highly recomed this restaurant. $$$. read more

See all

5/5 every single time we go there. Can't get enough of this place love the history love the service. Will be coming back soon! Decor is fantastic and servers are very nice. From the appetizers to the bread the food is to die for every time. Love the open grill read more

See all

I came here on a weeknight with my co workers and had a fabulous meal. The restaurant is upscale and a perfect place to have a conversation as it was not loud inside. We were well taken care of by our waiter (he was excellent at upselling) and the staff and had excellent food. We started with the pasta appetizer that starts with lighting a huge Parmesan cheese wheel on fire. It is served table side so you get a show as well. While the cheese melts, the chef pours a pasta with truffle cream sauce into the cheese wheel and mixes everything together and serves it on your plate. The pasta was so creamy and cheesy and very rich. I ordered the Chilean sea bass for my main meal and it was one of the tastiest meals I've had in awhile. The fish was seared on the outside and very tender. It sat on top of a canneloni bean mixture, beet puree and broccolini. The Brussels sprouts were also very tasty. My co workers all enjoyed their meals as well (lamb chops, branzino, beef tartare, ribeye steak). The restaurant is located in a strip mall and there was plenty of parking in the lot. The restaurant is immaculate and bathrooms were very clean. I would definitely come back for the food! read more

See all

2nd time there,food was great service (Casandra)Amazing!only thing I would say is,when you walk in you can be a bit put off by the Greet. I will definitely go back! read more

What an amazing experience!!! This is a perfect place to celebrate a birthday or any kind of special event!!! we came here on a Friday night and it was very busy, the place was packed at every table, and the bar as well. It took around 10 minutes to get our table ready (we made a reservation and would recommend one) and we were on our way. For appetizers, we ordered the grilled calamari (highly recommend) the blueberry scallops, radicchio salad which was presented very nicely, and the black truffle pasta, which was SO good but it's one of those dishes that is very rich, and a little goes a long way! For entrees, we ordered the wagu ($99) and the porterhouse for 2. ($118) My husband and I shared the wagu and everything was so delicious, I unfortunately did not even take photos of the entrees because my group did not give me a chance to do so, lol. The desert, we had the blueberry cheesecake and the coffee panna cotta. Everything is made in house and you can tell it was extremely fresh. Service wise, our server was exceptional. I can't remember her name but she had brown hair and glasses! Ambiance wise, the inside and outside is so nicely decorated with flowers, and I loved the lighting fixtures on the ceiling. Overall this was a wonderful experience, my group was raving about everything and how wonderful it was even after we had all left! read more

See all

Best gnocchi I ever tasted. Ambiance is lovely. Live music makes it feel like a club.

Upon sitting down you are greeted with large chunks of parmesan cheese freshly taken out of a large cheese wheel, first press olive oil and the most unbelievable bread basket. Which in my opinion is a great way to start a Meal. The waiters love to share the story of Osteria Umbra and I was really impressed to hear it! I love the fact that they have an in house pastry chef who makes all of the desserts. I have ordered the cacio e pepe both times I have eaten here because it is incredible. I love that they give you the option for cheese wheel pasta where they will light the wheel of cheese on fire in front of you and sautee your pasta in the melted cheese table side. It turns your meal into an experience. For dessert I highly recommend the pistachio gelato! It is beyond delicious. They also have great drinks. read more

See all

Been back a number of times since my original review and always fabulous. Second time I tried their famed maialino (suckling pig). Amazingly good and so tender. My wife's Bolognese was killer as was my smoked negroni. Most recently, we went for my wife's birthday a few months ago (it's her fave restaurant). Appetizer of baccala and artichokes tempura with tomato, olive and caper sauce was terrific. For main I had bay leaf and juniper berry marinated racks of venison with Marsala sauce which was pretty freaking incredible. Dirty martini was exceptional. read more

See all

Everything at Osteria Umbra is a 10/10 -- from the impeccable service to the incredible food to the elegant ambiance. Every time I visit, I try something different, and it's always phenomenal. Their specials never disappoint, and I'm constantly excited to see what creative dishes they have to offer. It's my go-to spot for any special occasion. If you're looking for a fine dining experience that goes beyond the usual Italian fare, I can't recommend Osteria Umbra enough. read more

Food was 'okay' and extremely over priced. i have travelled to italy many times and they don't bring the true taste of Italy here, enjoy read more

Osteria Umbra is one of those places where you see everyone else going to and bookmark it for a special occasion. I mentioned to my wife, do you want to do anything for New Years Eve? Because I don't want to see anyone, pay for anyone and not start my New Year eating warmed up Costco tacos over someone's house. Can I plan a nice evening for us? I made reservations for Osteria Umbra. Pulling up to a small strip mall, we walked inside to a beautiful restaurant. There's a large decorated Christmas tree in the middle of the space. We're seated in a far corner next to a few other couples. It's New Years Eve so we ordered festive cocktails. My wife ordered a Pear Margarita and I ordered a smoky Old Fashioned. Kudos to the bartender, both drinks are excellent. The bread basket also impressed me. The assorted freshly made breads served with a fine olive oil was a nice touch. We are salmon fiends! Looking at the menu online, we zeroed in on the smoked Scottish Salmon plate to start. The waiter had a special table side smoker that he used in preparation for serving us. The Salmon was insane! Topped with crème fresh and caviar, the ultimate way to start 2023. Now I see the cheese wheel being passed around to various tables. I can't eat a mound of pasta! I told our waitress I'd like to order pasta entree and Branzino entree. My wife & I made our meal family style with both dishes in the middle of the table. The process is pretty amazing. First the cheese wheel cart comes to the table. The cheese wheel is hollowed out to get the pasta party started. The pasta, think of spaghetti and angel hair pastas. The freshly made pasta from Osteria Umbra noddle sits in the middle. The waiter set the wheel on fire! Once the cheese is nice and gooey, the pasta is tossed in rich, cheesy goodness. It was an incredible experience and not to be missed. Osteria Umbra truly provided a one of a kind dining experience. Highly recommended read more

See all

Visiting the area this week, and decided to try this restaurant. Very good! As you enter, the foyer was very lovely as was the hostess. A solo guitarist in the welcoming bar area. I would probably dine in the bar next time rather than the dining room, as it was more intimate. Dining room was very nice and the servers were friendly, efficient, and professional. Five stars for them! We ordered the snow pea salad and panzanella salad for apps. The snow pea salad was delicious and the portions were just right. The panzanella was not really authentic. It was more of a tossed salad with some croutons but it was good. My husband had NY strip steak with mashed potatoes and that also had some salad on the plate. Steak was done just right. Only negative was the sauce was ordered on the side but it was actually on the steak. I had the black ink pasta with baby clams and tomatoes. Loved it. Both food and experiences were enjoyed . I recommend this spot read more

Food wasn't great. Couldn't get bread un til we got up and requested it. End of our meal because batches made were too burnt to serve the manager said. Our waitress also part time bartender and helped at cooking wheel while our dirty dishes sat in front of us. Manager said. NOt their fault their service so bad. They are short handed ..beautiful building but very expensive and ruined our dinner. With awful service. We even had to find the manager to get us a check to leave No re.morse on their part. Curt and condescending attitude. Such a disappointment for such a beautiful restaurant. read more

What an incredible dining experience! Front start to finish it really is different dining. We made a reservation for the 4 of us back in August. It was a Thursday night and live music was playing. Food is as delicious from appetizers to dessert. Service was great the Entire time until the end. He forgot my takeout order and we sat for a long time waiting for it. This place will definitely be bookmarked for special occasions only because the prices??!! Phewwww. The special dining experience definitely comes with the price tag. read more

Osteria Umbra - Italian Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

I wanted to like this place so bad ! Had reservations at a high top table.. only thing available and this was like a last resort spot.. waiter and I guess the GM were nice enough.. waiter overwhelmed but sweet, it was packed ..we all went there starving since we knew we were gonna eat like slobs so ..... Ordered the burrata app and beef carpaccio ... burrata didn't taste fresh. Usually it's warm to room temp inside and super fresh n milky.. not the case.. Beef carpaccio tasted like roast beef from the deli, I've had better. We ordered 3 pastas. Black truffle ravioli which was in a runny, watered down truffle sauce with basic ravioli... spaghetti carbonara.. this was prob the most decent? It was just a bit eggy (I liked, my gf's didn't).. and then this pasta that they toss table side in a cheese wheel. Obv, this catches everyone's attention for the novelty factor and IG photo opp but it was a miss for us. It was so congealed and unenjoyable. We didn't finish. I actually don't care for pasta really much.... this reminded me again why. A waste of calories. Then for the finale, we ordered a profiterole which was a stale cream puff but had a really awesome side of white chocolate gelato. I was so disappointed in this place... I might come back to give it another shot bc they were cranking but I would not order any of the things mentioned above. Prob like a bottle of wine and a pizzette or something lol... they are ballsy with their prices too... I don't care about the money I spend on food but when it's completely lackluster, I get annoyed. Oh and we had to ask for bread for our table since we all went there like beasts and weren't offered the complimentary parm from the cheese wheel until the GM was like, "oh didn't the waiter offer u....." uh no guy, obv u see we're all sitting here starving with nothing in front of us, lol... On the other hand, it's in the shopping center with Raan Thai which is an awesome spot so if you hate it, you can dip out to next door... mediocre at best but v pretty interior. Update: I came back here the other night and honestly, the food is tasteless. Our oysters and steak were ok. All of it just lackluster. And I was up sick allllll night !!!!! Not coming back here read more

See all

Incredible! What more can I say, probably not somewhere where you would stop if you drove by but you would be missing so much. I've been here numerous times never had bad meal. Only complaint I could have is they stop making the rotisserie pig but everything else you could eat is incredible services on point and I can truly recommend read more

I had lunch at Osteria Umbra last Friday. It's in a small shopping center and I wasn't expecting much. Surprise! The best Italian food I have had. Started with the truffle pasta that is made inside a giant cheese wheel table side. I intended it to be an appetizer and it was a very generous portion. You simply must order that. It was amazing! My group ordered paperdelle, lamb skewers and a mortadella and burrata sandwich. Everything was amazing. I cannot recommend this restaurant enough. The next time I am on Long Island it will be my first stop! read more

Osteria Umbra - Truffle homemade pasta tableside - Italian Near Me - Smithtown, New York

The service, food, and ambiance were terrific. We had a fantastic time. My husband had a wonderful birthday, he still talks about the truffle pasta and smoked old fashion. We will certainly return. read more

In short, yes, go, highly recommend. Well run, delicious, and nice inside. You won't be disappointed. ----------- If tl;dr doesn't apply to you.... Osteria Umbra is a nice calibration for me on what a five star experience ought to be. Don't let outside appearances fool you, step inside and get taken away to what resembles a villa, with upscale touches, neatly upholstered seating areas, eye catching fixtures, and matching masonry and flooring throughout. The most remarkable feature is the open wood fire pit, with a spit of 'maiale' - which immediately sells you on needing to try it. The hostess weaved us through the lounge to the dining room to our table for four. The lounge was loud with a band playing. Nice touch, but the acoustics made for impossible dinner conversation. I couldn't hear a thing while they were playing. The menu was similar to what was online, with a few specials thrown in. We started with perfectly battered zucchini flowers, a unique pairing of blueberry chutney and guanciale crisps over scallops, and the "signature" Caprese salad. Ok... what is signature about a Caprese salad??? Frankly, nothing fancy, just the most delicious heirloom tomatoes you could possibly pick, with a baseball sized mozzarella di bufala (rumor has it they sing to the buffalo). They do add a scoop of basil gelato which is a nice touch as they make their gelato in house. Service, Annalise, was pleasant, well informed, and passionate about the menu. We did the Parma wheel of fire pasta, which was delicious home made, melt in your mouth vino-infused pasta, topped with fresh shaved black Summer truffle. The dish was unreal. We split two for the four of us. For entrees, we split the tomahawk ribeye, maialino (suckling pig) and a slab of salmon. Everything was amazing. As a Lugers guy, I wasn't sure what to expect on the steak - but it was perfect. And the wood imparts a flavor that is unique. We tried the apple chutney for the pig, and the braised pearl onions with the steak. Very nice. The pig came with a perfect crisp of skin on top! Yum. Deserts were delish, we split three, tiramisu, cheesecake and gelato. Coffee was "ok". Nice to have a special occasion place going East versus into Manhattan. read more

See all

After a long day at work for my girlfriend and I, we decided to try a new restaurant as we often do, and we chose Osteria Umbria, which has plenty of great reviews, and it was all wonderful. The food is spectacular, the service was friendly, the drinks were well made, the atmosphere was very romantic, and overall this is definitely a special occasion restaurant. However the Happy Hour, 4-7pm has some great items for solid prices on their menu, they also said they get their regulars that come in often, so if you're into that this is a good spot to try. Everything is also imported, nothing domestic, hand made pasta, top of the line ingredients, which is A) Why everything is so delicious B) Why all of the items are expensive But if you are coming here for dinner be prepared for that, and you will not be dissapointed Truffle Parm Wheel Pasta special is a MUST. The Blueberry Scallops my gf went crazy for as well. We had the outside patio to ourselves, private dining, exactly what we wanted with glasses of wine and conversation. Loved this spot. 5 stars. read more

All of our food was excellent!! Olivia was wonderful and... she made an AMAZING Zabiaone Thank You read more

See all

High end cuisine with premium prices. Best wine selection and amazing dishes. Some of the appetizers are over $100 each so asking for a price prior to ordering may be in some people's best interests. read more

The place is utterly gorgeous. It is completely upscale and pretentious in the best way, which allows me to give 2 stars. The service from the wait staff is impeccable as well. The food is a whole other story. Many of the options that we ordered were way too heavily doused with Black pepper, and everything is as overpriced as could be. My wife's wine was sour, and the sommelier made a face when getting her another bottle. Don't allow the customer to taste if you don't want the opinion. After sinking 500 bucks into a dinner that wasn't worth it, we decided not to return. Perhaps your experience will be different, though I'm well versed in high-end cuisine, and Osteria Umbra is all about the flash and not about the flavor. read more

Bon G. and I chose Osteria Umbra to celebrate our Anniversary due to the great Yelp Reviews. Glad we did.. from the reception by a sweet young lady who ushered us to the quiet side of the restaurant for us to enjoy our celebratory dinner. We were immediately greeted by our server Melinda, who recited the history of the restaurants and its owners...she was terrific! Started with cocktails and worked into appys and mains. For appy we chose the Scallops...were delish and melt in your mouth. Melinda suggested we choose the pasta special made in the Parm Wheel as an intermediate course before the main. Was spectacular prep and creamy delishishness!! During dinner we were visited by the Manager, Carlos several times asking how our dinner was and if there were any questions he could answer for us. For mains, Bon had the Veal Chop as it looked great in the pictures on Yelp. Was not as large as depicted, but was perfectly prepared MR and was delish!. I had the Branzino, also cooked in their fiery wood fueled oven...came out looking great and with the seasoning on the skin, tasting better! For dessert, we shared the Strawberry Sorbet...the perfect finish to our meal. All in all, we were so happy dining at this upscale venue and were appreciative of the attentivness and quality of the offerings. We will return for another occasion !! read more

See all

Four of us went there for dinner. We felt like they were trying to push us to purchase too much food. We were all disappointed in our meals- had better elsewhere and for less $. Haven't been back as we think it's over rated read more

It's tough to please my mom's taste buds after she's eaten in Italy for months. While we enjoyed this restaurant, there was no signature dish where everything blended seamlessly. Something seemed off one way or another to give it 3.5 stars. Nonetheless, the strengths was that everything was cooked just right. It's hard to screw up bread, butternut squash soup, and burrata (unless it's not fresh). Even though grilled octopus can be rubbery, I'm glad it was tender enough to chew without a fight. Whether you had the Mediterranean cod, wood fired veal chop, or tagliatelle, nothing was overcooked. To end on a sweet note, the gelato was creamy and freshly made. However, I'm not a fan of tomato-based sauces on fish or their special with watered down white truffle pasta ($95) even if it's cooked tableside in a cheese bowl. The tiramisu was so light that it seemed to be missing some texture from ladyfingers. Parking is ample and the staff is attentive and helpful in terms of service. The complimentary cheese tastings are a treat. However, just check the reviews and go with your gut on what you enjoy without being tempted otherwise =P read more

See all

You know immediately when you're in some special restaurant. You see the action. You smell the aromas. Osteria Umbra is that type of place. You walk in to the bar area and the scent of the wood fire where much of the magic that is this restaurant occurs. We visited for our anniversary. Not first timers, we were intent on having the grilled calamari app. Now, don't get me wrong. I love a good fried crispy calamari just as much as the next guy, but this is just different, in a very great way. Bread crumbs. Tender. The flavor is almost other worldly. We then had the gnocchi with the ragu. WOWOWOWOW!!! The only thing keeping these light, fluffy and airy pillows of deliciousness on the plate was the amazing ragu it was sauced with! Then, well, the penultimate part of the meal came out, the 32 OZ steak Fiorentina. Cook to perfection, just, and I mean EXACTLY as we asked it to be cooked. The crust and smoky goodness from the wood fire is unmatched on Long Island! Attention to detail is a hallmark of this establishment. The steak wasn't perfect enough, we were offered to finish it off with sea salt and rosemary extra virgin olive oil! YES PLEASE! We finished the evening's meal off with a slice of the best Italian cheesecake and blueberry compote I've ever experienced! All in all, this was an amazing experience and we've come to expect to be amazed whenever we dine under the very creative and capable hands of Chef Marco Pellegrini and his wife Chef Sabrina Vallorini. Five stars just doesn't seem to be enough, but this place is five stars all day long! Go. Eat. Thank me later. read more

Came for tasting menu. Food was good, the oyster course was not it. They should lose the whole smoke thing. Tasted like burnt oyster. Everything else was great. Waitress was lovely. Service all around was great. One suggestion. The lights inside the dining room to the left when you walk in almost flickers. It was beyond annoying and almost nauseating. We hated it. It didn't seem to be like that in the rest of the restaurant but for a migraine sufferer this really will keep me from coming back. My husband was annoyed by it too. Super distracting and made for an unpleasant night. Couldn't wait to get out of that room. read more