There food from soup to salad to pizza hero's fantastic ! The grilled chicken with broccoli rabe OMG the best! The service is really good and friendly staff. read more

Good food, little high on price, but I would still travel to get there. My grand children Love their Pizza and garlic knots.

This is our go to pizza place to order in from. Everything is delicious! They have the best grandma pie around!

Very good pizza with great pepperoni. Had an awesome hero as well. Good people with good service.

I've ordered from this place using a certain food specific app several times and they have never let me down! The cheese pie is not all bread, it's between a thin slice and your normal slice. Definitely get your orders in much earlier on the weekends! They get real busy and you could be waiting an extra hour or more for your order. They're that good! read more

Always good menu. Good service and friendly. A mainstay in my choice of chow..........................!

My parents have ordered from here before and say their pizza is awesome. So we ordered it for dinner last night. We decided to get entrees instead. I had the penne ala vodka and the sauce was very very good. Rigatoni bolognese was great. Stuffed shells were stuffed and was a big portion. We also had a seafood dish that I forgot the name of but it had a spicy kick and was also very good. Salads were big and fresh. Delivery was fast for a Saturday night. Zeppoles were kind of doughy. Probably wouldn't get those again. But besides that everything was very good ! read more

Love this pizza place I've been coming here for years and the pizza is always good. Customer service is always friendly and food always comes out quickly. read more

Damn this is really some top tier pizza! Pepperoni slice was perfect. I definitely recommend

this pizza is terrible, garlic knots are stale, cheap cheese, no cheap sauce and specialty slices looks like they have been out for days. don't know how this place stays in business read more

Bellina's Pizza - a stale garlic knot - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

Great food at reasonable prices. The service is good and friendly. The ambiance is not fancy but the food, prices and quick service make up for it. read more

Very tasty pizza me and my family really enjoyed it.. it's honestly one of the best pie's that I have ordered they most definitely have my business and they have great deals on large pies on Tuesday's it will not disappoint and I'm very happy to leave this review. I highly recommend giving this place a try.. two thumbs up... read more

Love going to Bellina's with my family. The wait staff are so attentive and very sweet. Absolutely delicious salads, garlic twists, pasta and entrees ! Never have had a bad meal yet. Come here for pasta night for the best deal on the island. read more

Bellina's Pizza - a plate of salad and a bowl of dressing - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

Ordered food from here the other night. Placed an order for delivery. It was very easy and no wait to place my order. I was originally told 45 minutes. Within 20 minutes the food was delivered to my house. I had the chicken park with pasta and it was delicious. The chicken was thick and juicy and the red sauce had the perfect taste. We also ordered the the penne ala vodka which was also tasted great. I have ordered from here multiple times and never had a bad experience with any of the food. read more

Cozy little pizzeria in East Islip that is one of the very few places you can get "Brooklyn" style Sicilian with the cheese on the bottom and the sauce on top. If you like pepperoni, they use the small ones that get nice and crispy out the oven and taste great. Why I didn't rate it higher is because the regular slices are kind of small, they lay the cheese on too heavy and there's barely any sauce which is a shame because their sauce has great flavor. There was too much saltiness of the cheese and not much of the sweet, tomato, herb sauce to counter the saltiness. The crust, however, was nice and crispy. Also, no AC in the dining area on a hot day makes eating in uncomfortable. Counter service is fine and it's about the same price as every where else. They have good lunch specials during the week. Not my favorite pizza but not bad either. read more

Bellina's Pizza - two slices of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

I love pizza. I like all kinds of pizza. I have had pizza from every chain. I have had pizza in a dozen states and in at least 50 pizzerias on Long Island. With all of that said, this is some of the best pizza I have had anywhere. The sicilian was soft and fluffy as a cloud while the margarita was zippy with oregano. Would need to try some more menu options to go to 5 stars, but the pizza itself is top notch - give them a try! read more

asked for pepperoni roll and got eggplant.sauce was aiii, had a friend mention he cursed out the guy at counter for fucking up order, def would stick to dominos or amores. read more

Got a large pie. There was nothing about this pie that said "That was amazing" it lacked any sort of seasoning as the sauce was bland. The crust was just there and added nothing. The salad was a tossed sale however the dressing was so watered down it didn't stick to anything and just sat in the bottom of the dish. This place is a far cry from where Martino's was. With a lot of pizza places in the area they dropped the ball on this first impression. Garlic knots were good. Hence 2 stars. read more

Bellina's Pizza - a bowl of soup - Pizza Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

Food is delicious! Service was excellent. This place is very clean and updated! One thing I love is walking into a clean pizzeria!

We were unaware that this pizzeria is now open under new owners/new management when we stopped for dinner and were pleasantly surprised when we went in. We were immediately greeted and although the restaurant has not been redecorated, it is MUCH cleaner than it was with the prior owner. I noticed it right away as the tables, floor, wood on the walls, etc. were sparkling clean in comparison to the way they were last time we were there. Our waitress was very attentive and our food was ready quickly and served nice and hot. They even gave us a couple of Italian deserts that consisted of a fried dough rolled in powdered sugar just so we could give them a try. Much improvement here, we will be back! read more

I catered food for my daughters communion from Bellina's. I got so many compliments on the food. We ordered the package for 30 people. It was plenty of food and it was all delicious! The kids even thought the meatballs were Nanny's famous meatballs!! Thank you Bellina's! read more

Stopped in for lunch, not really expecting to find anything, but damn! Their regular slice was seriously good, in a goddamn that's a really tasty slice kinda good. Perfectly cooked, not too thick, right type of crispy! When I'm in the area, I'll definitely be back!! read more

Consistently delicious, and genuinely good people running the place. My son never leaves a hair cut without stopping next door for a slice (or 2). read more

I love this spot! I go at least once or twice a week. The food is great and the staff is so welcoming. I have never had an issue here. The workers are kind and always helpful. I live in Bohemia but drive here frequently for their Crispino slice. Highly recommend! read more

Decided to stop in and grab a slice with my boyfriend. When we walked in, they greeted us with a smile and asked what we wanted ! The place itself was very clean and nice. After we ordered, we sat down to wait and they brought over our pizza. I got the buffalo slice and my boyfriend got the bbq slice. It was delicious. One of the best buffalo slices I have ever had. My boyfriend said his bbq slice was amazing as well. I would definitely recommend to a friend. AND as we were walking out we saw a sign that said if you have no money they will feed you. Talk about AMAZING. This pizzeria is #1 in East Islip! read more

They have great food here. The cheesy knots are so delicious. Get them every time and eat more than I should. The pizza is solid and the owners are great people. Give them a try! read more

The food is great and their specialty slices are the best! Very friendly and caring staff- always attentive. Their hours are good too- I work long hours and they're open on my way home from work! read more

Delicious! We tried a little of everything because the selection to choose from was vast and all looked great. The rice balls are awesome! Just like my grandma used to make! Cheese crepe thingys(forgot name) are also great. Eggplant parm was delicious. I find it hard to get good eggplant parm! Buffalo chicken outta adlai a hit. Highly recommend. read more

Loved it. Welcome to the neighborhood!! I tried the pizza the other night and I thought it was delicious. I had a reg and a grandma slice. The staff was friendly and attentive. I honestly couldn't of had a better experience. I'll definitely be a customer. read more

So my neighbor recommended Bellina's. He is an old school Italian aficionado and I trusted him on his call for this is really good pizza in the Islip area. I wasn't disappointed. Ordered a large well done sausage pie, and got a high quality well done sausage pie in the time promised. Counter guys were friendly and helpful. Pie was $18 not too bad for deliciousness. Will definitely return and try other varieties. read more

If I could give them zero stars I would. I watched the pizza maker cough into his hand and then immediately started stretching pizza dough. When I brought it to the attention of the other employees behind the counter they started giving me dirty looks an an attitude telling me I was lying. I wasn't trying to get my money back I was just trying to stop them from getting other complaints in the future. read more

I called in a order for two pie special including drinks and garlic nots. They said 30-35 mins. A hour later no food. Food came they gave me the wrong pies that were under cooked never gave me my drinks or nots. The driver was very nice about it. Called and said they will make and send the right pies it will take 15 mins. Well 45 mins past and no pizza. The girls on the phones sound completely confused and don't know what there doing read more

My first time at this pizzeria . Pizza was delicious and very clean reaturant. The staff and owner very polite and kind they also have a sign at the door that says "if you are hungry and have no money we will feed you" I have never seen a sign like that before in any pizza place I have been to. They amazing people.. the owner is a very kind man to do that . Visit this establishment if you can and if you and your children are hungry and cant afford to eat? They will give you something to eat.. read more

Great pizza! Can always count on a good variety of perfectly cooked pizza! Never disappointed

Just ordered a "create your own pizza" and didn't even get the pizza / toppings that I had ordered. The food smelled good until I opened my pizza and realized it was not what I had ordered. Being a vegetarian it is relatively important that my order is correct and doesn't contain meat (which it did - it had pepperonis on it). EXTREMELY disappointing. read more

Great food very fresh all of the staff are Pleasant to deal with I recommend them. There's A lot of Pizza Places in East Islip they are one my favorite read more

I stopped in yesterday for a late afternoon slice and didnt realize there were new owners. My slice was great... good flavor.. not greasy with a crispy crust. The gentleman gave me a couple of complimentary garlic knots that where also delicious. The things i noticed out of the ordinary was a sign in the front window that read. " if youre hungry and have no money we will feed you " which i thought was something seen far to rarely today... i just want to comend them on this effort to help othes less fortunate. The other thing was the lunch prices. I work on the road every day and am getting a little tired of a " gourmet deli " sandwich costing me 11$ they had great pasta choices for i believe 4.95 and most of the heros were 6.95. .. ill be back for sure. read more