Such a great bar. I came with my friend just for a drink and they have live music and the bartender and the server started singing and I felt like I was in a Disney movie ahaha So cuteeeee Loving it. read more

Don't Tell Mama - New American Near Me - New York, New York

This is a nice little cabaret spot in the heart of the theater district. In the front they have a nice bar and there's usually a performer there. It's always a treat to hear live music. We came to support our friends who were doing a show. They really pack people in and I'm good with paying to support the arts. For our friends' show, the cover was $35 each plus a two drink minimum with at least $20 required. We got drinks and two appetizers which were just okay but we weren't expecting gourmet fare. We got out of there for about $200 so a little pricey but it's nice to support artists. It's cash only so make sure you go before or else they send you to the sketchy ATM in the parking lot a couple of doors down and that charges a $4.75 fee. They are very good about notifying you that it's cash only, but bring more than you think you'll need. read more

Don't Tell Mama - Our friends have a show - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Totally started off on the wrong foot here. We booked Kitchen 46 so that we would be guaranteed seats here for the nighttime performance. Before dinner, I even popped by to remind them that we are a party of 8 and would kindly request a seat near the piano if possible. Once dinner was over, we were seated in the back room totally separate with zero view of the piano and the performers. Needless to say we were livid since we did everything they asked by making sure we had dinner at their restaurant for guaranteed seats. Of course after expressing our frustration and disappointment, they told us they would give us the next available table. Luckily it only took a couple mins and we were able to switch seats before our first round of drinks arrived. Lesson learned is always speak up when you think you're right. The staff was being super courteous about situation and understood why we were upset. Thank you staff! And now on to the real review! This place is hella FUN! Omg-I underestimated how much fun I would have with my girlfriends. The staff here are all so talented and their voices are unbelievable. Even the guests are invited to go up and sing as well. You can request songs for a tip. The venue requires a two drink minimum. Alcoholic or non alcoholic. The drinks are STRONG! Not sure if this is to hype up the crowd more but we were definitely hyped. Piano bars might be my new go to activity. read more

See all

We stopped here for a cocktail and to enjoy some live entertainment. Piano player and singer was great, and we also got a nice surprise when our bartender also belted out his rendition of "Don't Tell Mama", which is the inspirational name of the bar. I have been fortunate to catch a program on PBS regarding this venue. The owner was interviewed and discussed the origin and history through the years, which made this visit even more special. Worthwhile to revisit here during future NY visits. read more

See all

09/2024: Had to check out the local piano karaoke bar scene! First thing we see is the bartender belting out Natural Woman by Aretha Franklin from behind the bar. The talent from the employees here is mind blowing! Patrons can also get up and sing but the emphasis is more so on the staff, which was fine by me. Had some time to kill before our show so stopped by for happy hour. $7.50 well drinks. Guac and chips. $2 oysters. Guac tasted like it was made in house. Went to see our show and then came right back after. They switch pianists after 9 PM and that's when the real party starts. Drinks are $20 apiece but they were strong! French fries and NY Cheesecake were delicious. We had an amazing time at Don't Tell Mama and would definitely return! read more

See all

I had the pleasure of attending today's American Songbook Show at Don't Tell Mama, featuring the incredibly talented Marissa Mulder and Bill Zeffiro -- and it was an absolute smash! Their performance was everything cabaret should be: warm, engaging, and full of heart. What made the afternoon even more special was sharing the magic of live performance with two local public middle school choruses, many of whom were experiencing their very first show. Watching their excitement and curiosity was truly inspiring. A huge thank-you to the Cy Walter Foundation and Sophie Gerson Healthy Youth for championing this event and helping bring the arts to NYC middle school students. Don't Tell Mama continues to prove why it's such a beloved spot in the cabaret community. Highly recommend catching a show here. The environment is classic cabaret, and the service is excellent. read more

See all

Had a great time at this place. Love that the wait staff and bartenders join in on the fun and sing. Surprised that I didn't know more songs, but it was still a great time. Expect to be packed in line sardines, but it allows for some joint camaraderie. Great staff. Great times. read more

Don't Tell Mama - New American Near Me - New York, New York

I celebrated my 45th birthday with a girls' theatre trip to NYC. One of our brunch servers told us about Don't Tell Mama, and I am so grateful to her! We spent our last night there, and it was the perfect ending to a perfect trip! The music was fantastic, and we just loved the energy! I feel like I would spend a lot of time there if I lived in NYC. Being there made me feel joyful! Thank you to everyone there who have created such a welcoming and fun space! read more

Vocals and entertainment I have to say are AWESOME!!!!! That I would rate a 5! However, the food isn't that great. We ordered chicken tenders and some desserts. The desserts were a big miss especially the carrot cake. The drinks were okay, just on the pricey side. I would still come back and order drinks and listen to the amazing talent here. But I would eat elsewhere first. read more

See all

Always a must when I come to NY. The staff make it so much to listen to music and anyone who wants to sing with the piano. read more

Fun piano bar vibes and some wannabe Broadway singers even jump in to belt out a song. I was especially impressed by the bartender who had a great voice! read more

Don't Tell Mama - New American Near Me - New York, New York

*tourist trap* Don't go to that place. The service is abysmal, the drinks are both overpriced and poorly made, and the room is saturated with the bitterness of artists who never quite broke through. What's presented as edgy or intimate instead feels awkward, stale, and badly managed. Night after night, the same tired material is recycled without a hint of invention or risk. Whatever spark once made it worth visiting vanished long ago--certainly since Minh owned it--and it has never recovered. My colleagues that work in Broadway community feel the same. I will direct anyone reading this to Brandy's on the east side or Marie's Crisis in the village. Both with their own imperfections but more local and warm. read more

Our favorite place to go in NYC. Amazing singing by the most talented people, cozy little tucked away ambience and great drinks.

No idea why Don't Tell Mama would get anything less than five stars. Sure the drinks are nothing to write home about, and the food isn't setting the world on fire....but the music? Oh my the music is fun and the singing waitresses and bartenders are a joy. Saw some reviews mention $20 minimums and cash only but not sure what that's about as we were there late and didn't encounter either situation! Come here post-show or late night and you won't be disappointed! read more

0 Stars. This place should be shut down and the people who own it should be arrested. A complete and total scam. I only came here to see my friend perform but was forced to pay a 20 dollar minimum when there for drinks alone. On top of that i dont drink alcohol so i had to get soda meaning they charged 10 dollars for each soda. The sodas were flat and in small glasses . the place was stuffy and small. I downloaded yelp again after a while just because of how absolutely disgusting this place was. The waitresses were snarky and rude. Awful . I included here a picture of the 10 dollar flat soda. Update: They tipped themselves and there wasn't any say in it. Real scoundrels read more

Don't Tell Mama - 10 dollar flat diet coke - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Rude and not accommodating hostess when there was clearly open seats. It took a lot of convincing. Turned away a lot of customers

Had a night time cocktail prior to bedtime with my dinner date on a recent work trip to New York City. It was my first time to a piano bar located right on Restaurant Row or 46th Street in Hell's Kitchen between 8th & 9th Avenues. It's a really cute and quaint lounge for those wanting to listen to live show tunes performed by local broadway actors and actresses. Their voices are amazing and even the bartenders would sing live as they are making cocktails for customers. Their kitchen does serve food as well as desserts, but neither of us ordered anything from the kitchen as we came straight from dinner earlier. My friend she ordered a glass of wine as I was in the mood coffee drink with Bailey's, which The Latte Boy seems perfect for me! I think if you have a large group of people that you may have a challenging time fitting your whole entire party with you. Although the staff that greets you at the door will readjust tables and chairs to accommodate your group depending on how many other people are already in the bar. Will definitely go back again on another trip and maybe request some songs by the performers. It's a lot of fun and you'd probably bring more friends and stay out late too! read more

Don't Tell Mama - The Latte Boy Jameson, Bailey's Irish Cream, Ruby Red Slipper Cold Brew Coffee, Whipped Cream - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped by for a quick drink before a show. The space is cute with live music, with a tiny menu for food and drink. From the other reviews, I think we got an off-night because the service and drinks were pretty lackluster. However, we enjoyed the live music as we were chatting. read more

Don't Tell Mama - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Food is okay. People come, I imagine, for the entertainment. There's something about singers with simple piano accompaniment. Overall, a good pick for vibes and the bar. read more

Dueling piano bar at its funnest! Sunday night this place was jam packed and so much fun. Great relaxed laid back atmosphere, nice service,great bar And nice selection of food. The music was great and even some of the servers were singers. As the night went on it just got busier. We had a few rounds of drinks, the bubbly was plain good! And my friends had some fun colorful champagne cocktails. We got a charcuterie which hit the spot, and a great chocolate raspberry mousse, and we just had a great time. Lively , fun, great food and drinks. The music was excellent, and they honor requests. Was a great end to our day! read more

See all

I've been to several really good cabaret bars in the city, and I was really excited to see a friend-of-a-friend perform here. Honestly, the venue is a little complex and each room has separate "rules". Please note that it's cash only with a $20 cover and $20 food minimum that MUST include two drinks. Regular coke products count but they're just as much as the booze. They do have a happy hour from 5-8pm, but we found out that it didn't apply to our room after-the-fact... sooo make sure you read up on your room before! I will say that my chips and guac were really good. read more

See all

So incredible, everyone there was so sweet and was laughing with the guests. All workers are incredibly talented. The lava cake was to die for, and the drinks were very good. read more

My friend and I love piano bars so we made it a point to come here during a recent trip to NYC. We were able to grab some spots at the bar and found the service excellent. The drinks were good but average and we didn't order an food so I can't comment on that. The employees were great at entertaining and many from the audience that chose to perform were good as well. read more

Piano bar as interactive entertainment, with the pianist -- a great entertainer on his own -- roping in waitstaff and guests to sing sets and requests, usually with the house singing along on the choruses. Terrific fun. We didn't try any food, but were happy to fulfill the two drink minimum. Drink consistency between rounds was a bit off, but it was still all good. Lots of talent, lots of fun, a wonderful way to wrap the evening after a good dinner elsewhere. We'll definitely be back. read more

Don't Tell Mama - Decor - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place is fabulous! The bar food is fun and varied; the drinks are pricey, but the price is reasonable given the show put on by staff and sometimes guests! High end "karaoke" by some local off broadway talent with a live musician on the baby grand - makes for a great night. Only reason I held back a star - they need to provide more than one bartender on a Sat night, even before 9pm so that the wait time for drinks is reasonable. After 9 they seem to have plenty of staff! read more

See all

there is a cover charge of $20 for each person who attends a show at Mamas. Three guests were comped for the show by a performer.which means the comp was paid in advance. When the check arrived the cover of $20 was still on the tab and the guests paid as well as service charge for the whole amount. So, who got the extra money paid...I guess the servers. The operation is all in cash so there is no paper trail. BUYER BEWARE. read more

Such a cool spot! While strolling the city we saw the epic sign and decided to make a quick pit stop. Our bartender, Randy, welcomed us right in and starters the visit on a great note. Ambiance is super upbeat and you can feel the positivity in there. We were hoping to order some oysters, but were informed the kitchen had already closed. Totally understandable since it was a a little past midnight. Ordered a few of their cocktails and enjoyed the piano show accompanied with the great singing by the bartenders. read more

Don't Tell Mama - Don't Tell Mama... - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing time last summer. Can't wait to visit again next week! So fun and drinks were great. Staff was so fun and talented!! read more

Great drinks! Amazing staff! Broadway quality singing. Espresso Martini was my favorite!

We went on a Sunday afternoon to listen to our friend sing her last show. Unfortunately there were at least two families with very rude, loud annoying children. And the parents did nothing. Should I quit while I'm ahead. Probably. The service and food were great!! read more

Never disappoints, amazing voices, and hospitality. You'd think it would be filled with tourists but late night becomes a refuge for talented locals read more

We had dinner next door, and it was absolutely delicious. Had the chicken and some oysters. Because we had dinner we were escorted to a fantastic table right in front of the piano. The whole experience was just tons of fun and ran very smoothly. Did I spy Marilyn Maye leaving the back room? We will be back!! read more

Came here on a Friday night from approximately when they opened at 5pm to around 8pm. Started out great. The bartender was amazing! Kudos to Alison. Problem started as the night went on and more people came into the bar. It was PACKED at about 6:45pm and still only had one bartender. Poor girl was handling making the drinks, prepping the garnishes, and being her own bar back literally the entire night. Talk about management fail. If there was a manager, they needed to roll up sleeves and help. Useless. Alison was very capable but obviously needed an extra hand. I've uploaded a video of just how busy and crowded it was. read more

Went there on Saturday with a group of 6. Amazing time!! I will be back. The atmosphere was awesome and the music and talented staff was simply amazing!!! read more

Our group of 5 was in Hells Kitchen for a site-seeing walk and dinner, then headed back to Times Square. We stopped at 'Don't tell Mama' by random. Oh my, what a great experience. We were there just for drinks, and found out we stumbled upon this Piano Bar. The atmosphere was amazing. The staff was amazing. In other words, if you are just North of Times Squares, near 343 W 46th Street, just drop in. We were there on a Thursday Night, and I can only image the great atmosphere we had on Thursday would even be greater on Friday and Saturday. Hey, Don't Tell Mama, thank you so much for the fantastic evening. read more

Lovely venue with friendly and hard working staff. We were lucky enough to see Lena Moy-Borgen's fabulous performance of It's a Man's World. She didn't oversell - she did make me laugh and cry! Would love to go again to enjoy the singing waitstaff too. read more

Don't Tell Mama - Outside sign - New American Near Me - New York, New York

It's a tradition for our family to stop by every time we visit NY. In the past, the only downside for me was how crowded and hot it was; however, since Covid, it wasn't as crowded and felt a lot more comfortable. We saw two piano host/ performers. They were both fantastic. The second host made up a song about a family friend and serenaded him on his birthday. It made his night. :) Great talent and conversation. If you are staying in mid town, near all the theatres it's a quick walk over to Mama's. read more

Don't Tell Mama - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Still a classic historic place to see local cabaret acts in NYC. Drinks are a little pricy and the place smells like a toilet, but free cover and oftentimes great entertainment. read more

Don't Tell Mama - Interior - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Yes!! Just yes! I don't have words... but yes! The piano. The singers... just go to this place! It is worth it!

I really enjoyed the ambience in this bar, after walking past so many flashy high end places this place had honesty and a ramshackle charm with lovely welcoming staff. The music was fantastic provided by Harris Roth on piano and vocals, with some members of staff also chiming in, I think also at some point in the evening the team take over the singing. The ones that we heard were brilliant. I would have loved to give this place a higher score but it (only slightly) let down by the food. While it was delicious for the most part it was a tad impractical. I ordered the double cheese burger which when it arrived was a tad on the small side (possibly dictates by the sizes of the pretzel bun), except for the giant garnish of red onions and tomatoes (I like both of these ingredients ina burger but the proportions could use work). The patty itself was delicious but again on the small side. Also the texture of the toasted pretzel bun (again delicious) meant that outer crust was a little tough so after a few bites I resorted to a knife and fork. The skin-on fries where great, not overseasoned and fluffy on the inside but not piping hot either (I suspect this might be on me though as I had gone to the bathroom while the food was coming out and the staffer couldn't locate me) my wife ordered the mussels and they were great in flavour, the broth was delicious and laced with saffron (I think) however some of the mussels themselves were a bit on the sandy side so a little bit gritty. My wife didn't mind so we ploughed on. Overall a great location with great vibes, but the food could use some tweaks. ;) read more