Went in for a cut,shampoo and blow-dry. Used Lynn. She saw my hair was very thin, but when I was…read moredone,I looked spectacular!

From the owner: At Middletown Auto Repair, we pride ourselves on providing top-notch automotive repair and…read moremaintenance services in Middletown, NY. Our experienced and certified technicians are dedicated to ensuring your vehicle runs smoothly and safely. From routine oil changes and brake repairs to complex engine diagnostics, electrical, and transmission services, we handle it all with precision and care. Our state-of-the-art facility is equipped with the tools and technology to diagnose and fix any issues your car may have. We believe in transparent, honest service and offer competitive pricing to ensure you get the best value for your money. Whether you drive a domestic or foreign vehicle, our team is here to help you keep it in optimal condition. Choose Middletown Auto Repair for all your automotive needs and experience the difference quality service makes. Visit us today or schedule an appointment!

New customer: The service date was easy to schedule just to take a look and see what's going on…read morewith the transmission. The schedule didn't have my name in the book bc one guy kept it separate from the rest. (in case of no show) but the person I spoke with offered coffee and was courteous.

brought my truck for transmission but Louie found frame rot and deemed not safe , most shops would…read morehave done transmission, got their money and said "Oh , by the way " . I appreciate Letty & Louies honesty and would highly recommend them. Needless to say truck coming home to be prepped for scrap yard and money earmarked for transmission can go for down payment on newer truck .

Great shop ,kind friendly,helpfull, cost affordable. My 2 cars were handled with a good mechanic.read more

THIS PLACE IS A SCAM. Changed the price of service retroactively. Worst car dealership I have been…read moreto in my life. Go anywhere but here.

Known Mel for well over 20 years. Before he passed in 2008, my father was friends with him, and the…read morebody shop he worked at even sponsored his racecar. At my recommendation, many of my law enforcement friends and family used him over the years. So naturally when my son recently had an issue with his truck, a 2004 Silverado, we took it to Mel.... And to our absolute shock we got screwed. Badly. The cost was outrageous and it took forever to what amounted to simply replacing a flywheel. Got it back and subsequently learned that many of my friends and family and their business and families also had recent bad experiences with Mel. Guess he really went down hill. However, a few days after we got the truck back we discovered a leak in the transmission that we didn't have before. We didn't have a leak. To avoid Mel, we decided to first look into it ourselves and with a simple visual observation it was clear that when the flywheel was installed the front seal must have been damaged. Reluctantly we took it back to Mel. Feeling like I disappointed my son by recommending Mel to begin with, I hoped that Mel would be responsible and reasonable as the leak was obviously a result of his work. A front seal is nothing and should have been done when he had it apart. Poor workmanship. Transmission work 101. We left the truck for him to inspect the leak. He had the truck for another three weeks. We waited and got the call and instead of just replacing the $15 seal and accepting that he should have caught that, or even just working with us a little , he said it would be over 4800 to rebuild. A rebuild? It doesn't need that, just a front seal, Mel. I explained that the leak was a result of their initial work and their reply wasn't to deny that fact, but rather to say that the truck was driven 1000 miles since their repair. Obscene. Absolutely obscene. I have since learned of many other ppl who were once friendly with Mel and relied on his work also got screwed. I have the names, Mel. Try me. Mel, you were once a good guy, reputable and honest. You are now nothing more than a crook. DO NOT USE ACADEMY TRANSMISSIONS. Almost 30 years of local law enforcement and I have only seen this type of disgusting behavior from the lowest of the low. Mel and Academy Transmission is absolutely the lowest of the low. You should be ashamed of yourselves.

These guys are the best! Totally trust their experience and knowledge regarding transmission issues.read more

Needed a jump after calling several places only to be given outrageous quotes and long wait times,…read moreI called Goshen Automotive. They cane right out and took care of my issue. Went to the shop for them to follow up. Very friendly and the cost of the follow up and jump were much less then the original quotes I got for just a jump. Like hundreds less

A year later and I most certainly needed some work done and this shop delivered a quality…read moreexperience. My SUV suspension just "felt off" and the techs at this shop discovered one of my sway bar links were completely broken. Don't ask me what that is but Good Lord they were able to fix me right up pronto. Thankfully I didn't need to leave my car her for 3 weeks like many mechanics ask you to do, well not exactly 3 weeks but they tend to take longer than a day at times. This team had me fixed up same day. The mechanic also told me my brakes were pretty worn out but that I could go a little longer before replacing them to save some money and get the most from my current brakes (rear). I value honesty and fair prices which in turn gets my respect & loyalty so the fact the mechanic told me my brakes were wearing out but he didn't want to take my money (yet) when I could get more life out of the brakes I currently have really is amazing. I was super thankful for the honest assessment of my brakes and opted to change them now rather than later. Besides I don't drive much so the brakes I had were probably last replaced about five years ago so from years of weather my rotors certainly looked bad, at least to an amateur like me because I'm certainly no mechanic. Overall I am super happy to have found this place and am committed to being a loyal customer for as long as I live in the Goshen area. If I eventually get a brand new car sadly the team here won't see me for a long time until that new car ages but I'd still recommend them in a heart beat. For now we will have a lasting business relationship for the next few years till my current SUV dies on me, hopefully not too soon under the care of these auto experts. Thank you Goshen Automotive team!

Went in for a NYS inspection and found out that I needed front struts and wipers. I left my car…read moreovernight and it was repaired the next day without any issues. Great service at a great price and the staff was very friendly and accommodating at the same time. Couldn't ask for anything more.

I'm writing this review as a former employee who wants to offer insight for potential customers…read more During my time working at this mechanic shop, I witnessed several troubling practices that customers deserve to be aware of. There were instances where parts were charged for but never actually installed. In some cases, unnecessary parts were sold to customers who didn't need them, and at times, the work billed was not fully completed. These practices were not isolated or accidental--they happened frequently enough to be considered routine. Additionally, the shop often lacked qualified technicians to perform repairs properly. Corners were cut, and customer vehicles did not always receive the level of care and attention they deserved. I'm sharing this to encourage others to ask questions, request to see the old parts that were "replaced," and to get second opinions if something doesn't feel right. Your safety and your wallet are worth protecting!