OMG! This place is amazing and is planning to improve. What??? It's close to perfect already. Such a cool environment. Leanna, our server, was professional, friendly, helpful and informative. She gave us some history and background of the building. She suggested beer flavors for us and let us sample before ordering. When I was debating on entree choice, she guided me in the right direction. We can't wait to come back and see what changes have been made. We highly recommend coming here. read more

See all

This has been a great local spot for Italian food, pizza, and salads. The bartenders are always friendly, attentive, and happy to offer suggestions for cocktails, which is something we have always appreciated. On our recent visit, we ordered the cheese pizza and were surprised to learn that the cheese blend includes provolone. Unfortunately, we are not fans of the sharper flavor, so it was not a good fit for us. That said, we absolutely loved the crust and the way the pizza was cooked. If not for the provolone, it would have been a home run. One area where I think there is room for improvement is pricing. While we understand that costs have gone up, some items felt a bit expensive. For example, I just cannot justify spending $17 on tiramisu. Overall, this is a charming neighborhood restaurant with good food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. I am interested to see what the new ownership brings and wish them success as they begin this next chapter. read more

Earl and Isabella's Taverna - Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Argyle, Texas

See all

Well, not what it used to be and this just makes me sad. My son needed to run to Argyle for an errand and we decided to have him pick up Earl's on the way home. We hadn't been since their renovation. Yayyy, Earl's! Not so fast. The prices have gone up quite a bit and the quality, way down. We ordered the Italian Cobb and it was good but a bit sparse - not packed full of all the yumminess it's made of anymore. Nonna's meatballs were the biggest disappointment. They have gone up almost $5 I believe and whoever's Nonna made them, overcooked or microwaved them to death. They used to be SO good! Now, they aren't. We ordered 3 pizzas - the Bianca, the Margherita and the BBQ Arezzo. The Bianca was good, the Margherita was good but a little sparse and the BBQ Arezzo was awful. Like, nobody would eat it awful and that's pretty bad. I don't know if ingredients were bad or what but there was little to no sauce and it was just...bad. So bad that I called and spoke to the manager that offered a free pizza - NO thanks - or a refund. I opted for the refund and because we still have not gotten a refund for the 1 pizza only, I decided to write a review. We have literally been going to Earl's for YEARS and it has always been amazing. I looked past the prices going up because the price of food had gone up but when nobody will eat the food because it tastes horrible or is overcooked and we have spent close to $100, I'm out. Not sure what's going on but they definitely need a new Nonna to whip them back into shape. read more

Highly recommend!! Words cannot describe how incredible this place is. The hospitality, service, atmosphere, and the quality of food. Are all top tier! Our server Donnie was out of this world. He informed us of the happy hour specials. It was my friend's birthday and he made her feel extra special with the food and drinks he brought out. Everything we had was hot, fresh, and delicious! read more

See all

Took 10 min. to point me to my group. I had water and a 1/2 meatball sub which had only 1 1/2 meatballs on it and very little sauce or cheese. Served with homemade over-peppered chips. Meatballs had good texture, but was extra spicy. I'll pay for that later. Wait person was efficient and nice. I can't go back there. Acoustics were horrible. The music wasn't the problem. We couldn't hear each other talk. We were also seated on hard wooden stools with no backs. Hard for old gals. read more

omg, where to start? We just moved from CA and stumbled onto this place. The food is insanely good, and huge. My son had the chicken parm and it was enough for four people. I had the "small" salad that my husband and I shared and still had leftovers. The hostesses are so sweet and welcoming. The servers, I've had Kenny and Johnny were fun and knowledgeable. My son had never been and now he's hooked. It is our go to for Italian food. I keep telling myself I'll save room for dessert but it's impossible! We cannot wait to bring all of our friends from CA here when they visit. Run don't walk to this hidden gem! read more

We moved here 6 weeks ago from WA state and have fallen in love with this spot. The 4 times we have been the service has been impeccable! The food is also out of this world! There is nothing like homemade pizza and pasta! Zach, Olive, and Luna are all great with their service. They all provide a very friendly experience filled with laughter. We love sitting outside because the ambiance is beautiful. I highly recommend this spot. read more

See all

Omg!!!! Excellent pizza and the crust is to die for ! Really awesome restaurant with super nice people and cool bar with awesome drinks! Highly recommend read more

Earl and Isabella's Taverna - Pepperoni jalapeño pizza - Pizza Near Me - Argyle, Texas

See all

Time to update my review :) AWESOMENESS! This is the best place to enjoy Great food, pizza and more, with extended family, little kids: the venue is perfect. Spacious, great outdoor play area, fantastic outside seating and big porch style seating, and indoors of course. The food, beverages, and desserts have always been tasty and fun. Party town, family style. Almost forgot: lovely friendly service. read more

See all

We've been coming to Earl's for several years and we're a bit skeptical when they changed their menu. Tonight reminded us that we still love Earl's 377, now know as Earl & Isabella's Taverna. The pizza is still amazing, even as simple as a cheese and pepperoni; but the star of the show was the pasta. Hand pulled and boy can you tell the difference. The spaghetti was absolutely one of the best we've had with thick noodles that scream homemade. We had a large party and Marco, the chef, checked in on us regularly. Tracy, our waitress was on point. Anticipating needs, super helpful, and overall a great server. While I know Earl is a bit of a fictional character...well done, Earl, well done read more

We started with the small Caesar salad. We subbed olives for the tomatoes, because we are not big raw tomato fans. The homemade Caesar dressing and focaccia croutons were INCREDIBLE! It was the BEST Caesar we've ever had. And we had enough to take home with us. We had the BBQ Pizza - the BBQ sauce was not overpowering. Not too spicy not too sweet. The roasted red peppers added just the right amount of smoky and spice and the grilled onion gave the sweet aspect with a little crunch! Well done! The Perfect dessert pizza was exactly that - Perfecto! Melty gooey marshmallows on a Nutella base! What else is there to say?!? We will be returning here EVEEY TIME we visit in the future!! read more

Earl and Isabella's Taverna - Pizza Near Me - Argyle, Texas

See all

Second visit and still liked it a lot. Pizza dough is delicious. Seems small but good enough for two or maybe three. Great music, the Caesar salad wasn't my thing , or maybe they brought me the wrong one, it had artichokes and tomatoes, (I hate to send food back so I didn't say anything) the dressing was good but won't order it again. Cheese bread looked great, I didn't taste it , service was outstanding. read more

Great fresh Pizza! Their Chicken Parm and new pasta menu is excellent! HURRY TO EARLS!!!! read more

This place was over the top delicious! We tried the pizza, pasta, salad and cheesy bread. It was all good! Wait staff was attentive and helpful with out being intrusive. We will be back! read more

SUMMARY: Hits all the marks for a solid dining experience: great food, fun atmosphere, and Outstanding service! VISIT We were first time visitors but not the first time we tried to dine here. Finally we made another attempt and glad we did. We were impressed by the country type atmosphere and by the cleanliness of the place. Big plus for this. FOOD We ordered a small margherita pizza as well as a small Caesar salad. We were really impressed by how well the crust came out. Nice and crispy without being burnt and still held its shape even with the ingredients soaking in. The sauce was outstanding too and the balance of the ingredients vs the ratio of pizza dough was perfect for us. Now the star of the show in my opinion was the Caesar salad. Boy, I gladly polished off what my wife couldn't! Perfectly sauced without drowning in the Caesar dressing and the right amount of ingredients. I especially liked the grape tomatoes. Nice n sweet and firm fresh skin, not old by any means. SERVICE: Can we say how much we loved our waitress Leanna? Hopefully I spelled her name correctly. She was absolutely the best and the restaurant should be happy that she represents the restaurant with her awesome service, demeanor, and service. She checked up on us enough at the right times and not too often so as to be intrusive. As a former waiter, I can tell she's experienced and good at what she does and she made our first experience at Earl's a memorable one. RETURN VISIT? We've decided Earl's is our go-to pizza place going forward! read more

See all

We have been in the DFW area for some appointments, and love to eat at new restaurant places when can. This time, we stopped at Earl's 377 Pizza. It was great! When you enter, you see a strong atmosphere of support for those who serve. They have set up in an old fire station, so the building has a very unique style of decor that works well for a pizza place. On their website, you find the story of how their restaurant started, and it is a lovely story of two WW2 young people who fell in love in Italy and came back to the states and started the restaurant. (At the top of the page it says, "Now, if this isn't true, it oughta be!"). We had the BBQ Arezzo pizza and our daughter had the kid's pepperoni. Both were outstanding. At the end of the meal, we had the Nutella dessert pizza. I have come to realize that the crust makes the pizza- and the Nutella Pizza was outstanding because of this! Our 10 year old daughter said - give them 5 stars- we will be returning! I couldn't agree more! read more

See all

Slightly overpriced, however, Earl and Isabella's Taverna is the kind of place that reminds you why local, family-run restaurants matter. You can taste the heart in every dish and feel the story behind it--Earl and Isabella built something truly special together. Chef Wade absolutely stole the show with the brisket ravioli. It's smoky, savory perfection, and easily one of the best dishes I've had anywhere. Between the warm atmosphere, genuine hospitality, and incredible food, this place earns a full 10/10. Do yourself a favor--skip the chains and come here instead. You'll leave full, happy, and already planning your next visit. read more

Very nice staff but the food is different in taste. It's true authentic food, but not my cup of tea. I miss when it was just pizza, appetizers and salads. Won't be going back. Took a large group and no one liked their food. read more

Good pizzas, salads and drinks! Our server was busy, but we never would have guessed as he was perfectly attentive, refilling our drinks often and even offering us to-go cups when we left. I wish the pizzas came in different sizes - they are all basically medium size, good for sharing with 2 hungry people or 3 slightly peckish people. read more

I forgot to take more pics! Ha! The spinach artichoke dip was really good, they should serve it with a little more bread. The Small salads are huge and easily shared for 2-4 people, it was a good salad. The pizza we enjoyed was the padre island and it was VERY tasty!! Their ranch is also very good!! The service we had was amazing, her name was Megan and she did a great job. I love the heated patio seating which I'm sure is also nice in the warmer months...I would recommend a stop in, it was a nice relaxing meal! read more

Earl and Isabella's Taverna - *Small Caesar* - Pizza Near Me - Argyle, Texas

See all

Stopped by for a late lunch today in between meetings. We ordered they spaghetti and meatballs (it had a much better name but I can't remember it ) and we split that to start. They brought our plates out and we told the waitress that we wanted to split one, not have one each. Turns out that was the split portion and that's when I knew we were in trouble . Pasta and sauce were good the meatballs were great. Next up was a Carne pizza where the waitress was nice enough to suggest swapping the salami for brisket. Dough and crust tasted great, toppings were awesome and the cheese was good. Next we had the Nutella desert. We thought it was going to be the size of a large brownie (didn't even look at the description.). What was delivered is in the pic attached. Great meal and hopefully solid leftovers! read more

Earl and Isabella's Taverna - Nutella Dessert Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Argyle, Texas

My wife and I headed out to a new place for us in Argyle called Earl's 377. Seemed like a great little place for date night when we walked in and a huge patio awaits the good weather months. All the folks there were very nice and welcoming. It seemed pretty slow even for a Tuesday night as there were only 3 tables including us at 7:15 or so. The menus are neat antique clipboard style and very simple to understand. My wife got a beer for like $6.5 and I got a margarita for $10 and a $3 Grand Marnier topper. Everything seemed to start out right. We put in our order of lasagna, Caesar salad, and a meatball sub. With so few tables in the place I was surprised at the length of time it took to get food out. The salad was first to arrive and I will say a small salad of $8 will be more than enough for four people to start out the meal with. They add artichokes to it which I think are ok, but just a warning in case you don't like them. I asked for a side of anchovies and they came out. Certainly they're the canned variety. I'd say the salad could have used a little more dressing. Their forks are also quite unique, neither good nor bad for me, but curved like a spoon and tines like a fork. Certainly a spork if I've ever seen one. About ten minutes after Nonna's meatball sandwich came out to us. Perhaps I'm used to a lot more sauce when it comes to this type of sandwich but I will say it came out with no sauce, caked in mozzarella, and very bland. Pepper chips came with it as an included side which I thought were ok. The meatballs were moist but just nothing head and shoulders above other places. For $15 I'd be inclined to say it's not much value either between price, quantity, and flavor. Though the sandwich came out in decent time, there was enough time for us to play shuffleboard as it was nearby our table. It's free and shows the wear and tear of customers use, but was nonetheless a nice way to pass the time. We were thankful it was there because it took another 20 minutes for the Vita Mia lasagna to come out. Again perhaps it's homemade and takes time to make, but 25-30 mins from order to table seems like a bit much. The edges seemed burned and the bottom was even worse. Bolognese style is the description but not sure they'd give their thumbs up for this one, especially for $17. Meals aren't really big enough for two except for the salad, unless you have smaller appetites. Thanks to the staff for being so cordial, but it's the food that keeps people coming back and I'd be hard-pressed to make another trip here other than to sit out on the patio and have a few drinks. In addition there were enough fruit flies buzzing around our table to be a significant turn-off for the place. read more

See all

I think my recommendation would be based on what you order, rather than an across the board 'thumbs up'. I have to take issue with their presentation of 'Bolognese', which traditionally does not include any peppers-no chili flakes, no red or green peppers, basically no 'heat'. When whatever added ingredient is so overwhelming, that it destroys the taste of the sauce, especially at these prices, then I am disappointed. The particular time I ordered their pasta with 'bolognese sauce', was so laced with heat-whether chili flakes or something else, that I almost could not eat it. So, I recommend you stick with the pizzas as a main course, and steer away from the pasta dishes. Adding chili flakes or peppers goes against the flavor profile of the recipe, ruins the subtlety, and is exactly why one does not add garlic to a traditional bolognese sauce. Perhaps a bit more nutmeg? If that WAS an ingredient, then it was completely missed. However, if you do not care and prefer to have 'heat' in everything you eat, then have at it and don't pay any mind to my criticism. Let's just not call it 'bolognese' and then perhaps make up a new name for that newly created sauce...one less suggestive of what it really should taste like. Service and ambiance are great! Wait staff is very friendly and helpful. read more

We visited Earl's a while back for an impromptu lunch. It has a country vibe and thankfully not very crowded at the time. The server was attentive and helpful. They serve beer and wine and other drinks if you're the type to unwind with a libation. The Caesar salad was large enough to share and the pizza crisp and tasty, but not out of this world. If you're looking for an off the beaten path pizza place, you should check out Earls. read more

First times back since they rebranded, and the service has gone way up. Cassie was an amazing waitress, food came out fresh and quickly and was even more delicious than before. New table settings very welcome! When they accidentally left cilantro on our pizza the cooked us another full new one without it. Would give them10 stars if I could! read more

See all

The pizza is the best around. Wood fired and just the right amount of crispiness The meatballs and tiramisu are VERY good! read more

We tried Earls about a year ago and loved it -- great vibe inside with cool decor, plenty of seating, and amazing food. Fast forward to now, and it's a totally different story. They rebranded and changed the recipes, and the food is just bad. We spent over $100 on takeout and ended up throwing it away. Such a shame because it used to be one of our favorites. You're better off going some place else. read more

This was our first time here since the renovation and (some) change in menu items. We went on a Wednesday night and there were only a few tables that were occupied. Quite a few people seemed to be working at that time, however, we waited close to 5 minutes at our table before anyone came over to get our drink order. A guy finally came to our table to let us know that our wait person (who was standing at a table close to us) would be with us shortly (she had been talking to the people at that table since we had been seated) and asked if he could take our drinks. I asked if there were any wine specials and he said, "I don't know, I've been off for a week, so not sure, but I can find out." He walks away to check and to get my son's drink order. A few minutes later, our wait person comes over to get our drink order. I asked her if there were any wine specials and she didn't know either. Spoiler alert.....there weren't. We then ordered an Italian Cobb salad (previously one of our favorite menu items) and an Uncle Carmen's pizza. When the salad arrived, it did not disappoint and was just as I had remembered (delicious). However, when our pizza arrived, it was a major disappointment. One of the ingredients is supposed to be Italian sausage, but there were only a few crumbles here and there. No cheese visible; it basically looked like a red sauce pizza and very wet and runny sauce at that. If we tried to lift a piece off the pan (we were not given any utensil to help with this), we had to put a fork underneath the piece because everything was running off onto the pan. The taste was not bad and the outer edge crust was good, but I really wanted more than "sauce pizza". I think I'm safe in saying we will not be returning here any time soon unless we hear from others that they have made improvements. I would love to support a local restaurant because they are desperately needed in Argyle, but I just can't get behind this place. read more

Great Pizza! Italian food. I've never left a review before. I ordered the wrong pizza, my error. They called the next day to check. They gave a gift card totally unnecessary. And a totally cool Place. Thank you Mohit ****** read more

Wonderful Service by all including Dunashay. We had gluten-free pizza for my granddaughter, Lilly. She gave it two thumbs up. It was cheese and bacon. Salads were Fresh, Filling & Crispy! We had a Giardino and an Uncle Carmen, which was crispy. Tasty perfect. !! read more

See all

It was amazing. It was the best service and also the best food. It's a very cool vibe that has space for children to play, a quiet enjoyable space read more

Earl and Isabella's Taverna - *Perfecto Pie* - Pizza Near Me - Argyle, Texas

We absolutely love this place and truly have never tried anything on the menu we didn't love. It may be pricier than Pizza Hut, but you can't beat the clearly fresher, higher quality food. It's been a consistent experience for us and we are so grateful to have somewhere so unique like this to eat up here in Argyle. read more

I'm not sure why but after the remodel it's not as good. Our Padre Island pizza was missing the sauce, the spaghetti and meatballs came out COLD, and the salad wasn't as good as before. The cheese bread was decent however. The service was also not the same. Looking around the restaurant there was no sign of a manager type person. Seemed like it was just chaos and kids standing around. read more

Y'all just went to this place after a long hiatus from pizza. They have changed the name/look and menu buuuttt yall the food was better than the last time I went! The Cobb salad was AWESOME!! The meatball and cheesy bread were delish! The pizzas were so yummy and flavorful!! Server never brought my lemon for water but she was sweet lol. Ambiance is more Italianish than it used to be but we had a great time! Definitely will be back! read more

With the new changes of Earl's and Isabella's... they have not gone unnoticed. The bar drinks are good! The food is delicious, appetizers are bursting with flavors! The service was superior. They really are working hard to create a fabulous experience and they did! read more

We had a party of four. We ordered the meat balls appetizer, two small pizzas, a small salad, and one lasagne and had a lot to take home. After we ate we also ordered the Nutella pizza, a definite 5 stars with strawberries as recommended by our waitress. The service was outstanding, we were seated in minutes, our drink and food orders taken within 5 minutes and things began to arrive. Our waitress did an excellent job. The food was very good and the portions were sized for sharing. It was a fun outing with good food and good service. We will definitely return!! read more

Earl and Isabella's Taverna - a half eaten pizza and a salad - Pizza Near Me - Argyle, Texas

See all

Had the Margarita pizza. Best version of this I have ever had. The dough was magnificent. We also had the Italian Cobb and it's one of those comfort salads with red wine vinaigrette over shredded greens, tomatoes, olives, cheese. Perfect. The salad was $6 before the remodel now $12 but it was under priced back then. read more

This place should have 5 $ signs on menu . $17 for a slice of Tiramisu wow $18 for a small bowl of spaghetti.that is separate from the $17 Chicken Parmesan that would normally come under this chicken Parmesan . The atmosphere doesn't match the $ signs on the menu . Don't waste your money !!!! We have given this place at least five visits food is inconsistent especially the Tiramisu sometimes very dry like a cake ! I hate to leave a review like this but the menu is just ODD as well as food ! read more

First time visit. Great food and extraordinary service. We came by this restaurant at the last minute and we will be back! The restaurant is spacious and has a rustic decor. The portions are large and the value is excellent. I didn't expect the food and service to be so amazing. This is my new favorite restaurant. We ordered a small Caesar salad and one pizza that was half my liking and half my husband's liking. It was perfect. The salad was humungous and plenty to share for 2 people. The pizza was fresh and delicious!! Best in the area. I'm now a huge fan and it's my new favorite restaurant. read more

Rustic setting for delicious pizza. Good for families, outdoor seating and good service. Pizza crust could be better but great pies (pizza pies!). Best in area. read more

Earl and Isabella's Taverna - Bar - Pizza Near Me - Argyle, Texas