My family was having a little staycation at a nearby hotel and purchased the $34.99 Family Special. We ordered via phone and I picked it up and took it back to our hotel. We substituted mozzarella cheese sticks in lieu of the garlic cheese bread option. Food was ready at time promised and customer service during phone and in-person interactions were top notch. Don't plan on eating onsite as the one downside here is very little seating. Parking is crazy in the little strip mall it's located at, too. All food was super fresh and tasted great. read more

Eatalia Pizza - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

We met friends who were staying in the area and needed dinner. They had been here a few nights before and their son really wanted to go there again Parking lot has limited parking and inside has a few tables and some counter seats. Ambiance was pizza place/mini mart but oh well at least there was seating as taking it back to our friends hotel was not a great option We got a large supreme, cheese and a two liter soda. Inside the place smelled delicious and they were fairly busy with many takeout orders We didn't have to wait long for our order - comes to our table in the takeout box but they provided plates. - spatula and cups and ice for the soda which was great Service was awesome - the gentleman working checked on us part way through our meal to see if we needed anything - very nice considering looks to be mostly takeout Table had salt and pepper and crushed red pepper - containers of Parmesan were in the drink cooler Crust was very flavorful and veggies on the supreme were all fresh - including the mushrooms. Lots of places opt for Canned so I appreciated the extra effort. Toppings were plentiful - sauce tasty as well. I didn't partake in the cheese version but everyone said it was good. The quality and pricing were fantastic . Considering we were close to the convention center and the area theme park I expected high prices or mediocre food and that was false on my part. 4 adults and a hungry preteen demolished both pizzas and were full. Bill was 45 bucks Would definitely return if I am in this area again The menu looked solid offering thin pizza, salads and some pastas read more

See all

I must say I am very impressed with the pizza that I ordered here while visiting Anaheim. It was very close to the hotel that I was staying at and it's located in a small strip mall, which is easy to find . I was cheerfully greeted when I came in and had a couple questions about their pizza, and the young gentleman answered it precisely so I went ahead and ordered a large pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and while I was waiting, I walked next-door and got a few donuts which I did leave a review of, and that was fantastic . The inside of this pizza place with somewhat neat and clean and organized they have many many different selections of sandwiches, pasta, and pizzas to select from and the price prices are in line with the location . Took the pizza back to the hotel flipped on the TV and enjoyed some hot fresh pizza which was fantastic , fresh ingredients, and the cheese flavoring was out of this world. Yes, I do highly recommend stopping here if you want a pizza for yourself or for your family I think you'll like it . read more

Eatalia Pizza - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

See all

TL;DR: If it's late, you don't want to drive far, and you just want pizza, literally nothing else--this place works. Just keep your expectations low. Family of five here, including one kid who would choose spaghetti over almost anything... except from this place. The bad first. Cheesy bread -- 0/5 The cheesy bread was literally just shredded white cheese on plain bread. No seasoning, no flavor--just cheese on bread. One bite was enough. Garlic Bread -- 0/5 The breadsticks were the same bread with a very light layer of garlic butter. Again, one bite and the rest went untouched. Spaghetti -- 0/5 The spaghetti was a huge disappointment. Overcooked and tasted like Chef Boyardee (however that's spelled). Our spaghetti-loving kid didn't even finish it, which has never happened before. Sadly, another dish wasted. The good. Pizza -- 3/5 We got a plain cheese pizza and a half pineapple and beef, half black olive pizza. The pizza was the only decent thing we had. Nothing amazing, nothing memorable, except for the ground beef which was chunks of what looked like beef sausage(?)--edible and acceptable when you just want pizza and don't want to go far. Salad -- 4/5 The salad was fine--exactly what you'd expect. It's hard to mess up a salad. We eat pizza every Friday and are no strangers to the typical Pizza Hut, papa John's, dominos, etc. and some more 'dine in spots' that are local to where we live. We also enjoy spots like Olive Garden which are more dine in but if I had the opportunity to do this over, I would have just gotten another pizza spot read more

Eatalia Pizza - Garlic Cheese Bread - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

See all

Pizza time again... and what did I tell you people? There's 5 kinds of pizza: (1) NYC; (2) Neapolitan; (3) Chicago; (4) Sicilian; and (5) Garbage. And to be clear, if it's not one of the first 4, it's garbage. Listen all you pizza joints out there - STOP advertising your pizza as NYC style when it's NOT! GAH! I guarantee 9 out of 10... or more... are garbage! Okay, on with the review. I judge all foods by their basic iteration. And for pizza, it's a slice of cheese pizza. Simple, clean, and where the crust and sauce should come through and shine. Geez, this place is so close, and yet, so far. That sauce was juuuuust under tangy... come on. And the crust? The flavor was good, but DAMN IT... cook that s#!t till it's freaking crispy... GAH! So to circle back - is it NYC style? Mmmm... yeah, and I do mean barely as it qualifies at the lowest minimum. Sure, it's better than garbage pizza, but again, it could/should be better. HOOOO man... it's upsetting when this happens. I wanted to like this pizza more than I did, but HEY... I got what I got... so you get the review I give. Go here? Meh... eh... do what you want... read more

Eatalia Pizza - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

I went in. I ordered a pizza I asked for extra sauce and I wanted a fresh meat pizza. They told me 15 minutes to make it. I paid for it. Two minutes later he handed me an old dried up pizza out of their hot bin that keeps the food hot. It was obviously from somebody who didn't bother to pick up their pizza He lied and said it had extra sauce. You can't make a pizza in less than a minute and a half to two minutes. The pizza is garbage. The picture will be attached. I got ripped off by these people. They obviously have no interest in serving any type of quality anything. And if yelp removes this, I will definitely start complaining as well to yelp. This will be posted on Google as well. Do not do business with this pizza place. If you're staying in local hotels do not go in there and eat. If you feel that you have to have a pizza go anywhere else . You would be better off buying a frozen one and just eating it frozen; it's that bad! And if I had used the credit card, I would've stopped the payment. Unfortunately we didn't. They get a minus rating from us. Look at the pictures.. read more

Eatalia Pizza - This is the back of the pizza completely burnt from sitting in the storage unit - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

See all

Horrible. Ordered the food on DoorDash and the food was atrocious. I regret ordering from this place. A total waste of $85 and most of the food was not even edible. The cheese calzone was okay, but the crust was bland and not good. The dough was dry. The shrimp Alfredo was super saucy like a bowl of soup. And the Alfredo sauce was super underwhelming. It tasted like it was straight from a jar of Alfredo sauce. Actually no, store bought Alfredo sauce tastes better than what they made. The fettuccine was disgusting. The fried calamari was appallingly gross. The pieces of calamari were not coated all the way with breading, and the calamari were overcooked. It was chewy and inedible. The clam chowder was an absolute embarrassment. Tasted like some crap from a can. I couldn't even eat it. The cannoli was the only thing that was edible out of the entire order. The mozzarella sticks were gross. What even were those? They don't taste like mozzarella sticks at all. Also inedible along with everything else. So disappointed. And still hungry. I had to place another order for food somewhere else afterwards. The food here is complete garbage!! Calzone 1x Cheese Ricotta * Small $14.98 1x Fettuccine Alfredo Single * Shrimp $14.99 1x Fried Calamari $13.99 1x Mozzarella Sticks $10.99 1x Clam Chowder $7.99 1x Cannoli $6.99 1x Ranch $1.50 Total $71.43 read more

See all

I got the front window special one topping with pepperoni and garlic large. When I complained about paying almost 2 bucks for adding crushed garlic he threw it on for free. It was a little small for a medium but solid pizza given how late you can get a decent slice anywhere else that late and with what seemed like hand pressed crust. The crust and or sauce are lacking something that I cannot put my finger on but that would make it a five star taste. It's a small sit and eat with the family kind of place but typical old strip mall style shop with not so comfortable seating. Also got a salad for my daughter that she didn't eat and I ate it two days later. It was still crispy very large portion and delicious. Could be enough for two or three to share even though it came in what looked like a smaller container than expected for a large. It was packed full and tight with Romain, fresh grilled chicken, that had the grill marks on it, and had really good caesar dressing on the side. Even though it was very basic it hit the spot in more ways than one and I'll be back for more of it. Can't say anything really positive or negative about the staff. When pressed for answers to questions about the food, like does the salad have croutons it didn't seem like I was understood but it was late and maybe they were as tired and burned out as I was yet still making some decent food. Giving it four stars for being the best pizza place around open late. Comparing it to other fast food type pizza places it's three. read more

See all

Our go to pizza so far... right across from our hotel. 2nd time visiting and ordered again from here. Thin crust pizza that taste soo good!! 5 out 5. Wings taste good, my preference will be a little more sauce please! 4 out 5. Price 5 out 5. Location, convenience, friendly 5 out 5. read more

Eatalia Pizza - Xlarge pepperoni, - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

3.1 stars place was quite and lonesome so had to give it my business since I hard their calzones were great. One guy in the counter not sure what he was doing but he was there. Place was kinda dead but wasn't messy. Got the calzone I paid $4 for a large and boy was that a mistake. This thing was massive! Filling was good crust was fine. Enjoyed it more Olives than anything which is fine by me. Was kinda wet which was what I think due to not fresh toppings (canned olives) 100% but ok. Biggest turnoff. Cannoli. Bro wtf was this. Like th just fried it and piped with either not your tipped mascarpone. It was melted out and paid $4 a piece! Never again cannoli read more

See all

Okay this is the definition of do not judge a book by its cover. When driving into the parking lot, it will not look like much. It is a very mediocre looking exterior in a gas station parking lot. However then you park and head inside. WOW! The inside is truly remarkable. Insanely clean and filled with a lot of tables to enjoy the pizza at the restaurant. Immediately when I walked in I was greeted with the friendliest hello I have ever received. It also amazed me with how quickly they managed to get the pizza baked and in my hands. Remarkable service! Now the big piece of this pie, how was the pizza? We all come to a pizza place for the food. Well this place serves traditional New York pizza. They offer by the slice, but when I went it was only cheese by the slice. Overall this is a great pizza. It is filled with some great flavors and toppings. Truly everyone needs to try this place! Parking is super easy here and I highly recommend visiting this gem! read more

Eatalia Pizza - a table and chairs in a store - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

See all

Great service. Steven at the front was awesome, took my order perfectly and was meticulous with preparing and ensuring I got everything exactly. And was so kind. Great food selection. read more

Pizza was less pricey than the other pizza joints around the area but wouldn't say it was one of the best pizzas I've had. Based on the reviews I was expecting a little more from the pizza but it was very basic looking. Had good taste but again, wasn't the best. It was just alright. They did have my pizza ready quick and staff was friendly. read more

Late night pizza hangout after Disneyland! We stumbled upon this joint after checking out the liquor store next door. What more could you ask for? A freshly baked medium pepperoni pizza deal!!!! Definitely going here again!!! read more

See all

The last slice of my pizza had hair. No one in my household has that long and grey colored hair. Calamari was normally priced but was only about 40% full of those small to-go containers. It was also over cooked, like rubber. Pizza was good, unfortunately, I didn't get to eat my last slice because of the hair. I picked this up to go, so service and ambiance means nothing to me. read more

Eatalia Pizza - Last slice + hair - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

Always our go-to when at Disneyland. Our kids loved the pizza & Loved the wings! Great deals, friendly service, and was in and out for pick up. read more

We ordered this while visiting the Disney parks. Important to know that this place is open late, S of the writing of this review. I used their website to place our order. I got a large pepperoni, Medium Hawaiian and double order of spaghetti with meatballs. The large pizza was huge, while the medium is more the regular pizza parlor large size. We had leftovers of both but they were great on flavor. The spaghetti also had flavor but is a tomato based sauce without meat. The meatballs were also good. When we ordered this, it was about. Midnight. The food arrived, delivered to the hotel, just before 1am. The delivery driver was very friendly and greeted me properly. I would recommend this place. read more

Amazing customer service, and really tasty food. Will definitely come back if I am in the area

Stopped in last night. Asked for 3 slices to go not heated up. As I have trouble eating piping hot food. Waited a good 15 minutes just to find they heated up my slices. When the slices cooled down 15 minutes later they weren't bad but the crust is borderline inedible. No offense to the staff but I Wouldn't go here again. The interior was old like they were trying to be a small market, pizza shop and Disney magnet store all in one. read more

Eatalia was so good -- we ate the pizza so fast I couldn't even get a picture! The service was quick and super polite. Shoutout to the two young men who helped us; I didn't catch their names but they were awesome. The place was clean, pretty quiet, and overall such a good vibe. Love it here -- if I could give more stars, I would! read more

Whoever made the lasagna that I ordered dumped a ton of salt in the food. It was unbearable! I had to throw it away. EASE UP ON THE SALT! read more

Will definitely order again! After a day of Disney, this hit the spot and was FAST AND EASY! The pizza is a totally fair price, toppings are on point and flavor was FANTASTIC! I appreciate when I can order and have delivery from the business directly- this was exactly that type of place. The driver brought plates, napkins, cheese and peppers- I didn't even ask. Sorry I didn't take pictures! I should've. Great job Eatalia Pizza! read more

It's a hole in the wall type shop but the food is delicious. We got the BBQ chicken pizza and made our own. Would definitely go back

Best pizza and wings I've had in California! I took my sons to get their two slices and a drink combo that was such a good deal for the size of the pizza slices. Their pizza was so good that I went back later for a meat lovers pizza and buffalo wings, both of which were fantastic! read more

Pizza was good, undercarriage was cooked good, sausage had little flavor, good sauce and pepperoni. Ordered fried calamari - was ok, some had a weird flavor. Ordered chicken alfredo, please utilize a different container the plastic with lid made this very soupy and almost unedible. Garlic bread is very basic low flavor but toasty. Chicken wings are basic and good with included vegetables. Got a surprise cheesesteak which was AMAZING (i thought i ordered a cheese cake). Overall not a bad choice but can improve and be very good. read more

This is good NY style pizza. I grew up in Chicago and NE. Traveled and lived in many states in between. Is it 100% New York? No, but you are in CA. Have gone back several times and haven't been disappointed. Great service and great pizza. read more

Leaving a 5 star review to counter the angry 1-star reviewers complaining about delivery services (not controlled by establishment) and deals. There is still a $9 carry out deal, but it's for a Medium Cheese or Pepperoni, not a large. It's simple to call and ask about it rather than crying about a poster in the window. Anyway, good pizza, very NY-style. Tried the garlic bread too, seems they use fresh garlic and make it using their house bread - delicious with the marinara sauce. I recommend getting a slice at the actual restaurant. It's a reasonable price, good size, and you shouldn't have any issues with it "getting cold" on the way to your hotel. Best part is they're open late. read more

Excellent pizza! I highly recommend and they are very attentive to ensure your order is accurate. Every time I've ordered from here, I get it to go since I live really close by....it seats around 30 people and they have a TV on one of the walls. I live that they're open until midnight and their prices are very reasonable. I come here for their pizzas only as I have other spots in the area for my pasta fix....personally, I'm not a fan of domino's or pizza hut type of places so If you're craving delicious pizza that is made to order with fresh and quality ingredients, then this is your place in Anaheim! read more

Probably the only pizza place open late after a long day at Disney. We showed up at 1:15 am and the guy at the counter was friendly as could be for the time and the pizza was pretty good. Kind of a dumpy plaza but oh well pizza did its job. read more

Easy DoorDash pick up after a long drive from the Bay Area. We stayed nearby and carb overload sounded good. I personally wanted Carls Junior but the SO got a veggie pizza and Margherita pizza for him to try and share with his friends. Order was done on time and the store gave us plenty of plates, cheese and peppers. SO and friends loved the crust and the toppings ratio was on point. Will come back when near the happiest place on earth. read more

Great pizza would recommend if you're in the area. Double check with the store on when they close because Apple Maps lied. They're open till 12am as stated on the website and store. read more

The shrimp Alfredo is so good. Its my favorite place for alfredo, its better than all the sit down italian chain restaurants and the portion size is huge. read more

Unfortunately our pizza arrived undercooked & super moist; making it unappetizing & unedible. When you picked up a slice all of the toppings just slid right off, the wings had no flavor, and the bottom of our box had a rip in it due to excessive moisture. The salad came already tossed in the dressing (that was our fault assuming all to-go salads had dressing put on the side) & the mozzarella sticks are huge! We had it delivered & asked the driver to knock on the door when they arrived, but instead the food was left on the ground outside of our door. First time giving this place a shot & we will most likely not be back. read more

See all

The best Hawaiian pizza ever! Also love the by the slice pizza as well. Great prices and great customer service also very clean inside. Honestly the best pizza and my go to spot. read more

Just ordered from them about an hour ago. We are staying at a hotel and I called them to make sure they were able to deliver here. The gentleman who answered the phone confirmed they received my online order and they would be able to deliver here. I asked for plates and utensils, And he said of course. He was super duper nice! We had the family special which included pizza, pasta , cheesy bread and salad. The pizza was awesome!! Thin, cheesey and hot! The spaghetti was good. Nothing too authentic, but still yummmmy. I would definitely order again based on the pizza and customer service. Prices are great, and they are open late. Also, the deliver guy was prompt and nice. Thanks guys!!! read more

Eatalia Pizza - Yummy hot pizza - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

See all

Great place to grab a quick slice of pizza. $3.25 for a slice of cheese. I thought it was delicious. The pizza had a nice amount of sauce and cheese. The dough was thin, just how I like it. Also, the crust was nice and crunchy. I look forward to also trying a salad and a sandwich in the future. The service was also very friendly and helpful. This place opened in the middle of a pandemic! Give them a try. read more

Eatalia Pizza - Cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

On our last day of our Southern California trip, decided to order some pizza to take back up to the hotel room. Ordered two small pizzas, a salad, and fettuccine Alfredo. Small strip mall area with other businesses..the area is a little sketchy bc of the transients..had one come into the store and try to rummage through the garbage but the cashier was able to shoo him out of the store. The pizzas were perfect size (as my 6 yr old was able to finish almost the entire small pizza ). Fettuccine was tasty. Prices were affordable and would order from there again. read more

Not too bad when it comes to the pies with a couple exceptions. Usually when you get ricotta one a pie it is put on in small dollops before it hits the oven, here they have some massive dollops that when on cold after the pie cooked, not a good method in my opinion. With that said the pie itself is good, great crisp on the crust, tangy sauce, and chewy cheese. The real downside was the wings, over sauced and no crisp at all, kind of disappointing. read more

Eatalia Pizza - Pepperoni with ricotta - Italian Near Me - Anaheim, California

We got an XL supreme pizza to go and a Caesar salad. Both were really good! Good bang for your buck here. Will definitely be our new go to takeout pizza place. read more

Do not order Food from this place it is from Postmates they cancel your order at last minute