I had attended a luncheon last week that was held here following funeral services for a friend. It was a good buffet with the favorites of our friend. It was so good that I ended up going back on another day, about a week later. It was relatively quiet for a weekday lunch hour if you want to compare to other places that are open for lunch hour. That meant to me that the chef who is also the owner probably could spend more time to prepare the dishes ordered. I ordered the fried Oysters Po'Boy with fries and an iced tea. Didn't take too long for the meal to come out. I cut the Po'Boy in half and the Oysters were large. The bread was nice and soft, not hard and crunchy like bread can be for a Po'Boy. Fries were nicely done, not too crisp but not soggy and greasy. Had seasoning sprinkled on them, but not overwhelming. Just right. After I finished my sandwich, I was wondering about dessert and just as I was going to ask, my waiter, Chris came up to the table with the choices of dessert. I wanted something light, so I picked the chocolate pie. It was a good sized piece that came with some whipped cream on the side garnished with a strawberry. Nice and creamy and not overly sweet. Hit the spot! I will be back again because it's got a nice cozy homestyle atmosphere. May have to try the weekend brunch. read more

They seem to change the menu a lot; my friend had been there maybe a month ago and got things that were not on the current menu. I love that about this place! Because it's not a big menu with a ton of choices, but just enough different types of foods to give something for everyone - whether it's seafood or chicken, pasta, or meatloaf - it's just good food with interesting sauces. We had the grilled chicken sandwich and meatball sub, both tasting each other's and loving them. The only complaint is they seem to close after lunch for a few hours before dinner. If they stayed open continuously, they might get more business because I think the food is just too good for them to not constantly be crowded. The decor is clearly not what you're there for and the seats are just uncomfortable enough to discourage a leisurely meal (read: turn the tables over often); kind of a shame because if they stayed open continuously through dinner, had more comfortable seats, and less rundown looking interior they could actually attract a lot of business and stay very busy. Maybe they should try signing up with GrubHub, DoorDash or UberEats. Then you get to experience their terrific food at home. Looking forward to going back. read more

Everyone found the food delicious. I had the Shrimp Hoagie (po'boy) and paid the upcharge for pickles. The shrimp were large, plump, and fresh with an excellent crisp coating. The side of fries were also good and nicely seasoned. There are no fountain drinks so I got a bottled soft drink with my meal. For dessert I had the bread pudding with bourbon sauce, which was excellent (although a bit of real whipped cream would make it fantastic). Our server was attentive and friendly. The atmosphere is a bit utilitarian but the seating is comfortable and plentiful on our Saturday afternoon visit. read more

Lobster Roll was on point! Great lunch spot in Peachtree Corners! Can't wait to try more of the menu! Hope Gumbo appears one of these days! If you enjoy scratch-prepared food that is incredibly fresh, then try this one out! read more

Had lunch today at Eating Americana after church with my family of four. The food itself was good, but unfortunately the service left a lot to be desired. I have a shellfish allergy and was informed that the fried chicken is cooked in the same oil as the shrimp. Because of that, I ordered an omelet instead. This was my second visit--the first time I had the meatloaf. I mentioned to the server that it might be worth considering frying the chicken separately, since it's already seasoned and battered. That would provide a safe option for customers with shellfish allergies. I also shared that if my only choices are limited to items like meatloaf and omelets, it would make it difficult for me to return. His response was, "Well, we'll get other people to eat here," which was disappointing and frankly unexpected. Because of that interaction, they not only lost my business, but also that of the three others dining with me. With that kind of dismissive attitude, I imagine other customers may have similar experiences. read more

4 stars based mostly on service. My service was great! The food was pretty good. I got the seafood Alfredo which was mostly shrimp and crawfish with only one piece of crab. The ambience is a zero star experience. It's like visiting someone in prison or a school cafeteria. read more

See all

All of the meal was delicious! The waiter, Chris was friendly and efficient. The atmosphere was pleasant and peaceful. We had the Salisbury Steak and the Meatloaf meals. It was all served with finesse. And, the Peanut Butter Pie was just right to share. We're looking forward to trying the shrimp and brunch. Even the ice tea was perfectly done. It's clear that the chef/ owner cares about the details. read more

Eating Americana - Salisbury Steak with Mushroom Gravy. - New American Near Me - Norcross, Georgia

Eating Americana is one of our favorite local spots. James consistently makes high-quality, scratch-prepared food with fresh ingredients and none of the heavy saltiness you find elsewhere. We especially love the Shrimp Hoagies, Seafood Pasta, Chicken & Andouille Pasta (the sauce is incredible), and the Herbed Salmon with mashed potatoes and tomato-basil cream. The menu has a great mix of sandwiches and entrées, and while we haven't tried brunch yet, based on everything we've had -- including the excellent bread pudding -- we fully expect it to be just as good. They also host a wine tasting on the second Tuesday of each month. Located at the NW corner of Spalding Dr. and 5450 Peachtree Pkwy. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Very non assuming establishment, basic settings (not fancy & no frills) with straight up good food. We were the first customer before the dinner rush (arrived around 6PM on a Saturday evening). Food came out super fast. read more

See all

Ate there again tonight. Had the sauteed shrimp with fettucini (today's special). It was excellent, as expected. Wife had the fried shrimp with garlic mashed potatoes. She loved it. Chef James never disappoints. read more

Don't let the reviews about the "ambiance" fool you! This place is cute, quaint, comfortable and cozy. Our server, Chris, was TOP SHELF! He provided the best service I've had eating out in a LONG time! He was funny, paid attention, efficient, very professional and kind. His music selection, of Michael Jackson, kept us entertained as well. The food was DELICIOUS - ALL OF IT! There was 8 of us and I tasted ALL the plates!! Thank you Chef James!! Thank you Chris!!! - for an awesome experience! It's a drive for me, but I'll be back! read more

See all

Great food and service. I had shrimp Poorboy and fries with a wedge salad. Really good with great bread and good fries. Seems more reasonably priced than many places nowadays also. read more

A friend recommended Eating Americana for dinner. She said it's a hole in the wall, which sometimes is the best places and it is in this case. The restaurant is really cool looking with an amazing painted flag in the floor. The owner, who was also the cook and our waiter, was very welcoming and you can tell he takes pride in his restaurant. The food...fantastic! I was so happy to see lobster rolls on the menu. It was delicious!! It was a lot of food, but it was so good, I ate every bit of the lobster roll and fries. I look forward to going back and trying som new...or have another lobster roll. :) read more

Eating Americana - Delicious Lobster Roll and Fries - New American Near Me - Norcross, Georgia

We had Eating Americana bookmarked in Yelp as a 'want to try' and we found ourselves nearby after church. We were excited to give them a try based on the reviews and photos but found that they were serving their brunch menu not the full menu. That was ok, though, because some of the meals we wanted to try were available. As we entered we were greeted with smiles and informed that the wait would be longer than usual but that they could seat us if we were ok with it. There was a very large church group that had tied up the kitchen, but we must have timed it right because we only had to wait about 20 minutes or so. They kept us supplied with drinks and checked.on us often, continuing to apologize for the wait. We didn't mind - we were enjoying ourselves with conversation. If for no other reason we would recommend Eating Americana just for this level of service! So friendly and considerate! But there is another reason to go - the FOOD. Ooooo wwweeeeee - it was yummy. We both had the Boneless Fried Chicken with red pepper cream sauce and garlic mashed potatoes. I added a wedge salad and hubby grabbed the "adult" portion of mac-n-cheese. We highly recommend the Mac-n-cheese. It was so good! The pasta was al dented (not soggy and cheese laden as so many are); I think each portion is prepared before serving. The cheese sauce is rich and creamy and abundant. If you are wavering about trying it - don't! The Boneless Fried Chicken was delicious, too. We really wanted to try the fried chicken, but it is cooked to order and the menu warned it would take 20 mins to prepare so we opted for the boneless option instead. If what we order is an indication of how good the bone-in chicken will be; we'll be back for that! The red pepper cream sauce and the glaze drizzle that is served with the boneless chicken was so flavorful. There was just enough glaze drizzle to keep each bite varied by adding an acidic punch every now and then. Such a palate pleaser! Thank you Eating Americana for a relaxed delicious Sunday lunch - well I guess it was brunch...either way, thank you for a great experience. read more

See all

My family and I never heard of Eating Americana until we were searching for something different on Yelp. This restaurant has five stars so we said, why not give it a try. Wow we're we impressed. The restaurant doesn't open until 5:00PM so it was perfect for dinner time. We started off with the Chipotle Wings as an appetizer and boy they did justice to our taste buds and really hit the spot in our bellies. Our entrees included the Seafood Pasta, Loaded Mac & Cheese and Fried Shrimp Plate. Every plate arrived Hot and Freshly made. Each dish looked mouth watering and was delicious. The Seafood Pasta is loaded with Shrimp and the Shrimp Plate had about eight lightly crispy fried shrimp that rested on a bed of garlic mashed potatoes. Yummy!!! The Loaded Mac & Cheese was loaded with Chicken and Bacon and a lot of cheese. In addition our waiter Jose, provided excellent customer service from start to finish. He took the time to explain the menu options and the specials of the day. On top of that l, Jose was the only waiter on staff on Saturday and his customer service was still top notch. If I had a complaint, it would be that the restaurant could use more lighting. It was a little dark for me and I was happy we set close to a window. Overall, I would 100% recommend this restaurant for lunch or for dinner. It did NOT disappoint. Enjoy, we did!!! read more

See all

Went here for the 1st time after church on Sunday and everything was fantastic! Our server was very attentive and courteous! I ordered the shrimp and grits and it was probably the best I have ever had! Very flavorful:) I will definitely be back! read more

Found this location in an old strip mall. The vibes are very interesting with jazz music playing and food in the American/italian/southern food genre. Service was very attentive. But it was very cold inside the restaurant (heater not working)? The food was great but it is a bit $$. read more

See all

Small family style restaurant in heart of PTCz Hamburgers never disappoint. Love Em! Hubby loves the fact he can get pasta to seafood keeping his palate happy. Our favorite is shrimp poboy. Grab lunch or dinner never disappoints. Staff friendly like family. read more

The food here is exceptional. If you want good food go here. The owner is very gracious and my dining experience was wonderful. Great place for great food. read more

See all

The food is always great. Today we ordered eggs Benedict, French toast, southern fried chicken and fried shrimp -- all were exceptional. Chris, our server, was excellent and James the chef came out and greeted us. The atmosphere is great, quiet but with low key jazz music. The restrooms were clean and so was the place. Check out our Sunday brunch tradition!! read more

Thankful to eat lunch with a friend at Eating Americana! The ambiance is cozy and the food was a recommendation by the service of a hospitable waitress! We loved the creaminess of the pasta and seafood was delicious! read more

Eating Americana - Seafood Pasta - New American Near Me - Norcross, Georgia

Had the fried chicken made from scratch with mashed potatoes that was awesome. Service was very attentive.

We enjoyed our meal here very much. The food was fresh and the staff super friendly. My only suggestion for improvement is to increase the portion size. Given the prices, I expected more food (though the pancakes were plentiful). That said, the food we received was quite tasty. read more

See all

Our seafood omelette was loaded the crawfish and shrimp and covered by tasty hollandaise. The pancakes are remarkably light and delicious also. Grandson loved the Brioche French toast. The service was excellent as we were seated right away. If you haven't tried this place you are missing out for sure. We will definitely eat here again when we come back through Norcross. read more

We have been reading about this spot on Nextdoor for quite some time, but we only recently got to try it out first hand. Friday night rolled around, and the spot we had planned to enjoy felt farther away than we wanted to travel. The spot we had intended to visit served Southern cuisine, so we decided to look for Southern closer to home. Enter Eating Americana. The folks on Nextdoor have been raving about their Family Fried Chicken Dinner, so we decided to give it a shot. A chicken, chopped and fried, green beans, macaroni and cheese, and rolls. Made to serve four. Sounded perfect. We called and placed the order with no problem at all, and it was ready for pick up exactly when promised. The meal was FANTASTIC. The chicken was crispy and fresh. Not at all dry (avoiding that other word here). Mac and cheese was creamy and rich. The green beans were crisp and made me feel virtuous for eating something green. We will definitely be back. We really want to try the seafood dishes, as well. However, the value of the family chicken dinner will be hard to beat! This is a great addition to the neighborhood. We will be doing our part to make sure it stays around for a good long time! read more

See all

Looks can be deceiving. Outside? Looks like any other place stuffed into a strip mall. First impression inside? Meh. Menu? Short. We ordered and began looking about. Friendly. Quiet. Clean. Got our food. Excellent. I had a chicken and andouille hoagie. Wife had friend chicken. Hoagie was well-balanced, high-quality, delicious. Fries were nicely seasoned. Excellent. Wife's fried chicken was also excellent. Breast was juicy and hot. Potatoes and green beans, nicely done. This was our first visit, won't be our last. read more

The food and service get 5 stars. Best bone in fried chicken I've ever eaten. Mashed potatoes and Mac n cheese were also to die for. Dining room is bare bones on decor but spacious and clean. Owner/chef was so friendly and quick to bring out our food. Only regret is we live in Smyrna and can't get here every week. read more

Eating Americana - New American Near Me - Norcross, Georgia

Loved it! Meatloaf was excellent. Service was perfect. We have found a new place to get great food. read more

Eating Americana - Meatloaf dinner - New American Near Me - Norcross, Georgia

If you can overlook the terrible ambiance, the food here is absolutely delicious! I highly recommend the fried chicken and fried shrimp.

I've seen Eating Americana had updated it's menu on Facebook. I'm a big fan of lobster rolls from local food places including food trucks. Chef James created an open faced roll with tasty fries. It had delicious and tasty lobster meat in perfect proportion to the bread. I'll come back to try some of the other new items. This place never disappoints. 5 stars!! read more

See all

We saw great reviews but almost didn't go in because of how unassuming Eating Americana appeared from the parking lot. We're delighted that we stayed! It proved to be a very delicious and delightful experience. The food was terrific!!! My wife had the fried shrimp on a bed of garlic mashed potatoes in a Cajun cream sauce. Sublime. I had shrimp and grits. Simple ... but one of the best I've ever had. Perfectly cooked, perfectly seasoned, all very high quality ingredients. For desert we tried chocolate pie and bread pudding. Both were scrumptious. The service was quick, friendly, very professional. But here's the crazy part ... the chief was on his own! He seated us, took our order, cooked our food and served us. He was efficient, kind, fast ... but never seemed rushed. We never wanted for anything ... drinks were filled discreetly before they were empty, orders taken calmly. He wasn't flustered. I'm speechless. We will return! read more

A hidden gem. Located in the Goodwill parking lot behind a Wendy's and Arby's this place surprised me big time. We got our order to go and the process was easy. The service was quick and friendly. We opted for the fried chicken and it was some of the best fried chicken we've had in the Atlanta area. It comes with a side of mashed potatoes and green beans. They also have the option to get large sides to go to feed 2-3 people easily. Inside there is also a small bar to sit at or some tables to dine in. Anyone that enjoys southern fried chicken should definitely give Eating Americana a shot. read more

Eating Americana - delicious fried chicken - New American Near Me - Norcross, Georgia

See all

I ate lunch today at Eating Americana in Peachtree Corners. Our server was Chris and he was great! I had the lobster roll and it was every bit as delicious as any I have eaten in Maine or Boston. And a more generous serving for the price. I also highly recommend the fried chicken - I have eaten it there and got take-out. (My friend had a cheeseburger and said it was great.) This is a place you go to for the fabulous food, not the decor. ;-) read more

You've probably passed this place many times. You shouldn't. The food is so good! My family and I ordered 3 things and everything was good (Shrimp plate, burger, chicken sandwich)! We'll be back! read more

Excellent!! Here on business and saw the great reviews on Yelp. I'm adding a great review also. My wife got a 1/2 rack of BBQ Baby Back Ribs and it was huge!! Tasted great too! I got the Loaded Mac n Cheese with Chicken Bites and Bacon. Best Mac ever. Topped it off with a Rum Bread Pudding for my wife and Peanut Butter Pie for me. Excellent!! The place looks like a small take out place from the outside, but is dine in. Owner is very nice and does everything himself. Give him some love. He deserves your business. You will be glad you did. read more

Eating Americana - 1/2 rack of big Baby Back Ribs. Beans, Slaw and Loaded Mac n Cheese with Chicken Bites and Bacon. - New American Near Me - Norcross, Georgia

Made a reservation for Sunday brunch. All the tables were socially distant apart. This was the main reason we chose to eat here. The servers were all wearing masks. There was a board advertising the special of the day, some type of lump crab meat. I decided on eggs Benedict with ham and fried potatoes. Hubby got a ham and cheese omelette with fried potatoes. Everything tasted delicious and was cooked perfectly. The ingredients were nice and fresh. If we weren't driving we would have had a mimosa or two. read more

See all

As soon as we walked in we were greeted by our server. My husband and I wanted a quick lunch spot so we chose here. Once we ordered the food came out quickly and the food was fresh and the presentation was on point! It's definitely a hidden gem!! Its definitely a small cafe vibe which was a change of pace that was refreshing! We'll be back! read more

See all

Great food, chef prepared! We will visit every time we are in the area. Make sure you try the seafood omelette

Have been here many times, both dine-in and take out, and food is always perfection. Neither I nor anyone in my family has ever had anything but amazing meals. My personal favorites are the seafood pasta and the burger and fries. This is a hidden gem in Peachtree Corners and I hope it's here for a long, long time! read more

YUM....YUM....YUM I started with dessert....homemade bread pudding! It was delicious. I had the shrimp hoagie and my husband had the chicken andouille hoagie. The shrimp were HUGE and the combination of chicken and andouille was quite tasty. The owner is very nice and an excellent cook. He does it all. I can't wait to try brunch. read more