For my drive back to Cleveland from skiing at Holiday Valley I was looking for a place along the…read moreroute to grab some fish and chips for dinner. Steener's Pub popped up and the reviews were good. Located in Bemus Point just a couple of miles from I 86 made for a convenient stop. Steener's is located a bit outside of the Bemus Point main drag, but there are a couple of other businesses nearby. The building looks modern from the outside, inside it looks like the original bar area has been there quite a while, they then added a dining room and later a second dining room. The decor is casual tavern style, lots of wood and mellow colors without much extra. The menu is a nice mix of typical bar food with a good selection of fish and seafood which makes sense for a place so near to Chautauqua Lake. Service was good, the waitress was friendly. I ordered the fish and chips since it was highlighted in the menu. The order came out quickly, a huge batter fried fish fillet on top of a load of fries with side cups of tarter sauce and coleslaw. The fries and coleslaw were just what you expect, good but nothing special. The fish was outstanding, mild flaky white fish in a perfectly crunchy coating; delicious and very satisfying. My only complaint was that while it was nicely presented on a square plate, having the huge fish fillet on top of the fries made it difficult to eat since I had to move the fish around to get to the fries and cutting the fish with the fries underneath did not work well. I appreciate attractive food presentation is important, but this was too much food for the size of the plate. I really liked my dinner at Steener's, if they could raise the level of the side dishes to match the fried fish this would be truly exceptional. Keep making great fish, just upgrade the rest of food to match.

BEST Chicken Wings! They are the most consistent. Fresh, meaty, crispy, saucy. They just do it…read moreright here. I get the hot buffalo. My daughter gets brown sugar on medium buffalo. The ranch dressing is so good with the wings and salads. It's not runny and must be made in-house. On a cool night, I'll also order the French onion soup. Service is always friendly and quick. The remodel gives them more space and the patio is great when we bring our dog with us. The bathroom in the expanded space is newer and more spacious. We love supporting this local restaurant. We'll see you soon! Thank you for staying open all year!

This is a gas station and convenience store that is also famous for having delicious pizza and…read morewings to pick up on game day. It's convenient to the highway and has a lovely picnic area outside with a play area for the kids. We stopped for snacks only but the store was clean and service was efficient. Lots of little local trinkets and food if you want to buy a small gift or souvenir.

Girls weekend! Had to start out with pizza for dinner of course . I was slightly hesitant, because…read moreas is well known, this pizza place is also a gas station and a liquor store of sorts . However, the reviews looked good and it was convenient to our location. We ordered a traditional pepperoni pizza and the white spinach Florentine pizza. both pizzas were very good! Very impressed and definitely not gas station food!

Patio was lush. Mid August midweek visit was perfect. Giant inside could be a covered patio facing…read morewest to the lake. Cyprus salad (vegetarian was enough for 2. Very flavorful. Pulled pork sandwich was loaded and fries were crisp. Oh, Jenna was the best. Chill & always ready for more service Elicotville brewing had a nice selection of summer beers perfect for a shore dinner. Nice, relaxing outing.

Honestly our experience here was only okay. We were seated fast but didn't get served for a long…read moretime. Our server was pleasant, but just the urgency wasn't necessarily there. It's nice and dark inside, but it was very cold from being by the water. They had a live band playing. I wanted a flight of drinks, but they told me they don't serve flights after 8 which I thought was a little odd? The Mac and cheese was good, but very mustard forward with whatever sauce they put on top. I'm not a mustard girl but some people would probably love it! The piece of chicken was super good. The loaded tater tots 10/10!! There was a lot of meat and other toppings on them. My fiancé had a burger and fries which he really enjoyed. Honestly VERY expensive compared to most places. 2 beers, 1 appetizer, 2 meals over $100 before tip. One other thing I like is they give you a complimentary pickle upon request. I only enjoy this because I do not like pickles so It was nice knowing it wouldn't be there.

I'm making a bold but very deserving claim that this is the best culinary experience in the area…read more It starts with the beautiful design of space and layout, but also carried through to carefully chosen high quality ingredients at a very reasonable price, and an excellent service experience. Can we get this in a Michelin guide for those traveling to Chautauqua or Lily Dale? What did we have? A perfectly juicy selection of lobster tail full of its own sweetness resting on top of a bed of pappardelle pasta bathing in saffron cream and sweet summer corn for pops of texture. A lumpy deep fried crab cake that crackled on the outside and then fell apart into juicy flakes upon breaking the fried shell. A sour dough bread with herbed butter that melted between the half sliced folds holding it together until fully pulling apart. Iced tea and lemonade Arnold Palmer with flavors that kept us guessing and curious about the added sweet spice profile. Definitely coming back, perhaps every single meal I can when I'm in the area.

Great addition to the Institution/Mayville-area. Staff are…read moreprofessional, attentive and pleasant. Owner is really committed to fresh in season local ingredients and creative/elegant preparation. Nice seasonal cocktails, impressively considered wine list. The menu has something for everyone, except maybe for anyone who wants a traditional meat-and-potatoes meal. (But still... They'd probably like their food!) Not for everyone, just perfect for most.

Have stayed here lately. Have had dinner and breakfast at the restaurant. Both were very good…read more Service is outstanding. Hotel is top-notch. The view is the best on the lake I think. Amenities are great.

Twice Disappointed…read more We have now dined at this restaurant on two separate occasions, and unfortunately, both experiences left us very unimpressed--especially for a restaurant located in such a nice hotel and charging these prices. Our first experience was lunch in the spring of 2026 while we were staying at the hotel. We were extremely impressed with the hotel itself--the room, staff, and location were wonderful--so naturally we expected the restaurant to be of comparable quality. Sadly, it was not. Our food came out fairly quickly, but it was cold, and several items we ordered were missing. We then had to wait quite a while for someone to return so we could ask for the missing items and condiments, which were definitely needed to help the already subpar flavor. We left disappointed but decided perhaps it was simply an off day. We gave the restaurant another chance in August 2026 while celebrating my father-in-law's 89th birthday. Since this was dinner service, we hoped for a much better experience. His prime rib was actually very good, with no complaints other than the mashed potatoes being served cold. I ordered the Charbroiled Frenched Pork Chop, and unfortunately, it was awful. It had very little flavor and was dry and badly overcooked. The three onion rings served with it were rock hard, overcooked, and cold. They tasted as though they had been deep-fried much earlier and left sitting rather than being prepared fresh. I did send the onion rings back, but I chose not to send the pork chop back because I didn't want my 89-year-old father-in-law, who tires easily, to have to sit and wait while my meal was remade on his birthday. The coffee was another disappointment. At $15, even with a carafe provided, I certainly expected it to at least be hot. It wasn't. Our waiter was adequate and did nothing particularly wrong, but the level of service simply didn't match what I would expect at this price point. The interaction lacked the warmth, attentiveness, and polish you would normally associate with a higher-end dining experience. After two visits with many of the same issues--cold food, poorly prepared food, missing items, and service that doesn't match the prices--I don't think we can chalk this up to one bad night. The hotel itself is lovely, which makes the restaurant even more disappointing. With its location and atmosphere, this restaurant has the potential to be very good, but the kitchen and service need considerable attention. At these prices, guests should be able to expect freshly prepared, properly cooked, hot food accompanied by attentive service. Sadly, twice disappointed.

So happy I stopped in here! Such a cute little spot…read more Was in a rush and was on the road so decided to call here and order ahead. I told them I had a gluten allergy and needed gluten free toast and they said no problem at all! I ordered the Cajun Inspired omelet (forget the name) gluten free toast and extra crispy bacon. It was all SO GOOD! The toast barely tasted gluten free, which I love and the Omelet and bacon were perfect and both full of flavor! Great spot, would come back if I was in the area!

Five stars! Great meals always and good friends @ Bemus…read more Corned beef hash is my usual breakfast. Mom got the bemus burger. Never fails! Good coffee. Beer too, thanks!

Guppy's Restaurant and Tavern arches point near the Finger Lakes in New York is a great place to go…read moreto eat. The staff is wonderful and the menu is extensive . Everything is delicious!!!!

We had the aesthetically pleasing Bloody Mary-that was garnished like no other Bloody Mary I have…read morehad in my entire life! Delicious!!!---and the service was impeccable. The atmosphere was amazing and I felt Disney World vibes! Love this place!! The only drawback is the restroom situated in the main dining room with no privacy once entered for female guests. The outside bar-- was heated and so were the gondola's--but no restrooms available unless you travel outside to main dining room. If it's not pouring rain, or snowing---it's not an issue. Just something to consider with varying physical needs. Again-we were treated like royalty and I love this place!!!

I was here several times for ice cream, never food. Today I got bacon cheeseburger and fry. It…read morewas excellent. Clean restaurant and good service. Many menu favorites. I'll be back Good job!

Love their Banana Splits! Everything went well there! Fast service and very friendly!read more

Great golf course. Lawn kept "like a golf course" hence the pun!!!! They serve the most best…read morefood at this gulf course. If you're a beginning or a pro come here. !

Food and service top notch. Wide selection of adult beverages. The view of the golf course is so…read morenice to look at while you eat. We go often.