I'm making a bold but very deserving claim that this is the best culinary experience in the area. It starts with the beautiful design of space and layout, but also carried through to carefully chosen high quality ingredients at a very reasonable price, and an excellent service experience. Can we get this in a Michelin guide for those traveling to Chautauqua or Lily Dale? What did we have? A perfectly juicy selection of lobster tail full of its own sweetness resting on top of a bed of pappardelle pasta bathing in saffron cream and sweet summer corn for pops of texture. A lumpy deep fried crab cake that crackled on the outside and then fell apart into juicy flakes upon breaking the fried shell. A sour dough bread with herbed butter that melted between the half sliced folds holding it together until fully pulling apart. Iced tea and lemonade Arnold Palmer with flavors that kept us guessing and curious about the added sweet spice profile. Definitely coming back, perhaps every single meal I can when I'm in the area. read more

See all

Great addition to the Institution/Mayville-area. Staff are professional, attentive and pleasant. Owner is really committed to fresh in season local ingredients and creative/elegant preparation. Nice seasonal cocktails, impressively considered wine list. The menu has something for everyone, except maybe for anyone who wants a traditional meat-and-potatoes meal. (But still... They'd probably like their food!) Not for everyone, just perfect for most. read more

Everything is delicious here!!! Wagyu steak, whipped ricotta, espresso martini...yum!!! read more

Truffle Honey - Wagyu - Pizza Near Me - Mayville, New York

See all

Best place in town! We tried steak, lobster rolls, salad, wings and all 3 dessert option , it was all great. The staff is friendly and the chef is consistent. We have also brought our dog at times to sit outside. read more

See all

Excellent dinner. Excellent service. We had the salmon and the spaghetti squash with mushrooms - both were tasty. Also a fabulous old fashioned and dessert. Decaf coffee after dinner was also well done. Best place to eat in the area. read more

We came on a Thursday night around 7pm in late September and we're happy to see 4+ tables filled, especially this late in the Chatauqua season. It felt warm and inviting when we walked inside. We were seated right away with menus. We weren't sure what the ordering process was so we noticed the QR code on the table so we placed our order online. We ordered a glass of the super Tuscan and I can't remember what my husband ordered. Both were nice, dry and good temp. Our Caesar salad came out first. It was crisp, fresh and we enjoyed the bacon bits. We could tell if there was anchovy in it but the menu had it listed. The filet was cooked to my medium rare request. I wish there were a small side potato or veg on the plate. It looked so bare and but I didn't really want to pay $8-10 more for a side on top of the $38. But I recognize how restaurants need to balance price, quality and quantity. My husband ordered the salmon so I stole some of his Brussels sprouts and kale. The salmon was cooked perfectly and had a lot of good flavors. The kale was very salty and our waiter said he shared that with the chef but didn't offer anything more. We finished our meal and our waiter asked if we had already closed out. He mentioned that we were probably one of the rare customers who figured out the online ordering process. We would like to give this place another try. The quality of food was very good and we liked the atmosphere. Pricing was on the higher end for the area so we'll save it for a special occasion! read more

See all

This is a great restaurant, and especially when judged against the decidedly sparse other options in this area! I have eaten here twice, and both times really enjoyed both the food, the drinks, and the atmosphere. I got a great salmon salad and a mocktail last time, and both were excellent, with the salmon not being overcooked (something that happens a lot, even at good restaurants). The pizzas are also well done in the fire oven. Definitely make a reservation, and try this restaurant! read more

Great truffle honey pizza. I keep coming back time and again. And the service is with a smile.

My favorite restaurant in the area. The Truffle honey pizza is the best. I sometimes ask for extra honey. The ambiance is great and the service is always friendly. read more

We went for date night and enjoyed our time there. Great service and delicious pizza!

Can't say enough about this gem of a restaurant! We are so lucky to have Truffle Honey in CHQ. The best dining on the lake. The staff is friendly, ambience is lively, and the food is delicious! Check out the beer garden on the hill behind the restaurant for pre or post dinner drinks and games. read more

The food here in amazing. Everything we had was delicious. John is an awesome waiter. The restaurant is very clean and super cute. Great for date nights or just to go with friends. read more

See all

I have always had a good meal at Truffle Honey. They have great service. Looking forward to trying the Fall Menu! Keep up the good work!!

Excellent service (Lexie), delicious food, varied menu. Totally enjoyed our dinner. Wish the noise level could come down with some soft and sound absorbing additions to the decor. read more

Great food for the area which we need. This location lacks in restaurants so it is nice to have one here.

Wow what a great place.. after the season! Super service ,atmosphere and food! Some of the best if not the best in the area. I had their wood fired hamburger with fries. OUTSTANDING. My wife had chose the Truffle Honey wood fired pizza. Very good and full of flavors. Add a Caesar side salad and their chocolate tuxedo bombe for desert and you have the perfect meal. Thanks Reilly for the great service and recommendations. We will be back!!! read more

Friendly service, nice environment and good food. Not inexpensive but not a meal you would get at a chain restaurant - it's different and very good read more

I couldn't be happier that we found this hidden gem just minutes from our cabin in Mayville. While we like to get out there to unplug, grill, and watch the fire burn we still love an upscale option nearby and this is the answer! We enjoyed an incredible brunch complete with cocktails and even a mocktail for our non drinking guest. The detail in the each dish and drink matches the ambience and design and of this locally family owned restaurant/bar and we were blown away from the moment we walked in until the moment we left. The crab cakes were for sure the star of the show but each menu item we ordered was unique and a winner in its own way. We cannot wait to go back for dinner and continue to be loyal customers. Keep it up!!! read more

See all

Nothing bad to say about this place. Very modern chic and the atmosphere is like no other restaurant in Mayville. If you're in the Chautauqua area you need to try Truffle Honey! read more

See all

So much more than pizza and burgers. The arugula is sensational, and the broccolini is divine. This and Red Lobster are the only retreat for starved Chautauqua patrons read more

Another great meal. Hamburger made from short rib. Great salads and very nice and friendly people. Mango mocktail was well worth it. Very refreshing. read more

The focal point of the entry to this restaurant is a gorgeous tiled wood oven. My group ordered a Mediterranean pasta dish, halibut, and a burger with fries. Anything, especially a side of broccolini, touched by the oven was delicious. This restaurant is a great addition to the options near the Chautauqua Institution. read more

See all

This is my third time at Truffle Honey and it just keeps getting better! They are brand new so still training up the staff and working out some things but I can say 100% this is the best restaurant on the lake! The pizza is amazing because of their awesome ingredients and wood-fired oven, the burger and fries are insane and both the Salmon and Filet Mignon are top-notch!! No matter what you order, its going to be great! Its a casual atmosphere with gourmet food, the best combo! Also fun to just come in and eat and drink right at the bar. The owners are working hard here themselves every day and putring in their heart and soul. read more

See all

Great drinks, wood fire oven smells delectable with a modern but rustic atmosphere. Friendly wait staff and clean bathrooms. Food was made fresh to order; which does take extra time to make. Highly recommend reservations for parties greater than 2 people. Crab cakes- delicious and fresh Smoked Caesar salad- Devine dressing Truffle honey pizza- a delicate balance of savory and sweet Truffle honey margarita- lime and agave base with a smooth tequila and salted rim. read more

The food was delicious. Best mushroom pizza I ever had. Cocktails were delicious too. Lauren is an excellent server. read more

we have reservations for about 2 weeks, the waitress was wonderful. they put us in a back room with a party of 12 girls. Very cold atmosphere and you could not even talk. the gentlemen when we came in told us about this but failed to tell us no windows and very dark. This was our anniversary and I am sorry to say I would not go back. Very small restaurant and very limited menu Drinks excellent read more

Our experience here was amazing. The heirloom tomato salad was fresh and balanced, with beautiful tomatoes. My cucumber cocktail was so yummy, and the cucumber flavor really came through. My partner and I agreed the wagyu steak was one of the best steaks we'd ever had. We also loved the mashed potatoes. Finally, there were two desserts available so we got one of each, and they were both delicious! Everything was so tasty and very well balanced. We can't wait to come back here. read more

See all

Good food! Very creative menu. Wait status attentive and pleasant. During season be sure to make reservations!

Food was delicious atmosphere was nice. Service was excellent our waiter was very helpful and recommend some great dishes. Our table was kinda small in a corner but it was no big deal. Portions were pretty small but I guess that's what you get at these fancy restaurants. All in all great place to spoil yourself at once and a while read more

Our new go to place in the area. Previously we have gone for dinner which was great. Last Sunday we went for brunch. Had chicken and waffles that were yummy. Cozy place with a great bar selection. Check out the new beer garden. read more

Amazing find! Great food and cocktails! We have been several times now. Summer Sunday Brunch is one of a kind!

Came here with a friend and I thought this place was so cute!!! We had the wings which were both Buffalo and garlic Parmesan. We also had a vampire mimosa as festive for Halloween. It has pomegranate juice. We also had a pizza with mushrooms. I can't remember exactly what it was called but the portion size was really generous and my freeing and I split it! Overall I would receive md. If you are visiting the area. read more

We were looking forward to trying this newer restaurant in Chatauqua NY. We left disappointed. The Caesar Salad with grilled chicken is not something I would serve in my own home. The grilled chicken and croutons came to the table like they were prepared the day before. The chicken was dry and the croutons chewy. The service was spotty and the manager was uninterested in our feedback after the meal. Needless to say, we will not be back. read more

Oooh la la you better make a resie cuz this place in the sheet. Its always packed so better plan ahead. Anyways the tacos son muy delicioso y los papas fritas....mmm SI! A muerto para jajajaja. Anyways on a serious note... You gotta come down to Truffle Honey if you up in Watertown . Call me John Legend cuz the Crabcakes were... "The best I ever had". The ambiance was great. So quaint! You gotta go here :) read more

Delightful dining experience. Enjoyed the mushrooms paired with Asiago bread. The sauce was delicious. Smoked Caesar salad with salmon expertly prepared. Asparagus soup was tasty. read more

Ambiance was great along with the espresso martinis. Chicken wings were a little under cooked for my liking & salad didn't have enough dressing. Truffle fries were really good. Burger was overcooked, steak was perfectly cooked. Both lacked seasoning. Seemed like there was no salt & pepper on either. Chocolate bomb was really good! For $200 we were very underwhelmed. But, I would go back for pizza & fries. Food looked better than it tastes. Great service! read more

See all

This new spot has great food- and unique takes on many things. It can be expensive and portions are smaller

Everything about this place was perfect. The staff were kind and knowledgeable, the drinks were delicious, the wagyu literallyyyyy melted in my mouth. The menu is small yet diverse. Definitely options for everyone. And it's a very cute vibe, inside and outside! I would recommend this place to anyone. read more

We had a wonderful early dinner. Started with sharing the crab cakes. They were so good. Just lump crab and a crispy outside coating. Top notch. Then we shared a Greek salad and a pizza. They were both very good and high quality. This is great little restaurant- best food and cocktails that we have had in the area. Yay for this new addition. read more

Food was excellent, staff was friendly! Great vibe overall! Stopped for a quick bite before attending a performance at the Chautauqua Institute. Excellent start to a great evening out in Western New York. read more