The service was kind and prompt, street parking was easy, and while there are just a couple of…read moretables to dine in, this pizza travels really well--so you can enjoy it anywhere! Must try the Clark Kent Pizza. Loaded with meatballs, banana peppers, cup n' char pepperoni, and a dreamy hot honey drizzle, it's the perfect mix of sweet, spicy, and savory. The Buffalo-style dough holds up like a champ to all those bold, delicious toppings. And getting to enjoy it with the creator himself? Such a cool bonus. Great company, incredible pizza... honestly, what more could you ask for?

We had take out and was not too impressed for a Buffalo Pizza. It was $36 before tax with two…read moretoppings. Not work the price. Could only eat two small slices. It was very heavy but not good. We oy tried this place since the other places closed earlier.

Every time we order the pie is excellent. Fresh dough for the crust, sauce is perfectly done…read more And no matter how busy they are the pizza is done at the given time. How is THAT for service? Yes, please. They will even cut the pizza into squares, so that is a plus. They are a stand pizza joint, so nothing fancy about the place, but it is clean and well kept.

Excellent pizza and service!! Placed a phone order for large pepperoni via timed delivery at the…read moreMarina. It's a thick pie that was delivered hot, fresh, and exactly at the time requested by a nice young man named Brady. Crust was cooked to perfection with just the right crisp on the cup-n-char pepperoni, and the sauce had great flavor that made me want more slices. Will definitely order again when I am in the area!

Walked in and was greeted by the rudest man. He took our order AND cashed us out with 1 glove on…read more.. and the glove was filthy, covered in grease, and had holes in it. I prayed he wasn't going to make our food. We ordered to-go. We sat in the dining room while we waited, which was so dirty I was losing my appetite. When he brought our food out....yup.....still only wearing the 1 dirty glove!!!! And the to-go bag... had some drops of blood on it. I will never go back.

Love Fontana's! Great Pizza, wings and fries! Would recommend to all!! Not sure about the subs or…read moreother dishes but based on what I have had it's most likely good!

Great subs. Best in town. I always ask them "toast it" a little in the oven. Kicks it up a notch…read more Pizza is good too, if you are looking for traditional Buffalo pizza with pepperoni and thick crust.

I ordered sheet pizza & 50 wings & a lg fries today. Paid $86.00…read more My order was for the wings to be extra crispy 1/2 hot 1/2 honey mustard with extra sauce. When we arrived 1 hour later, the wings weren't even started due to them running out, bad enough I had to wait longer I was expecting exactly what I ordered! I was craving honey mustard crispy wings for a while & to say i got the complete opposite & was super upsetting, the wings were not crisp, wings were soggy not a piece of crispness, no extra sauce. Very disappointed to say the least. My sons said pizza was good so that's a plus for them. I definitely need to find a new pizza shop!!

Traveling through North Collins and stopped at Pizza Italia and ordered a pizza. Best pizza I've…read morehad in year! Highly recommend

Food is okay and service is really nice, the ambiance is just a normal pizza place with a tv and me…read moreand my friends hang out there a lot.

Ric Otter owns this, I think he's the descendant of an actual Otter because he has that sort of…read moreOtter-face look about him, which is like a Butter-face, only for a descendant of an Otter. Like Dan said, it's not going to blow you away but it's solid pizza. It's also dirt, dirt cheap. For that reason, I'd probably have given it a 4, except that the slice I was given was cold, congealed and dry. No option was suggested to warm it up. I would have gone back in to ask for it heated but I had to get the slice to someone and had already started driving it. I tried it for a second time more recently and it was lukewarm and a little congealed again. So while I think the slices would be excellent fresh, they don't seem to sell enough to warrant keeping a fresh pie handy, and are happy to sell the old, tired, barely edible slices. Which still taste okay. I recommend going here for a fresh whole pizza and skipping the slices, especially in the evenings. I'm not sure how good the wings are yet, but I'll try them next. I'm not sure exactly when, I'll have to wing it.

The pizza and wings here is pretty damn good. They keep that south Buffalo style that I loved as a…read morekid. Wings are spot on aswell. I like mine bbq pit with extra sauce. Banger. Subs are hit n miss. Mostly hit. Really depends on who's making the subs. Owner is amazing. They are also a small convenience store which you can have also delivered.

Not like I needed a reminder, but One Pie Pizza Co. serves up an excellent, truly authentic…read moreBuffalo-style pizza. This time I ordered their take on a WNY specialty pizza: the chicken finger pizza. In short, it was fantastic! Since I'm a member of their rewards program, I received a "$5 off your next order" code and figured it'd been a couple months since my last visit. The coupon couldn't have come at a better time. I placed my order online on a Saturday around 4:15pm for a 5:05pm pick-up. I know, you lose a bit of the personability when you don't call the restaurant to place an order, but online ordering is so easy and quick, and I love being able to pick my pick-up time and know my order will be ready, and paid for, when I arrive. As of 07/2026, the inside of One Pie Pizza Co. underwent a remodel. It's not as spacious, but I think it opens up their kitchen more, which I'm 100% on-board with since that means more pizza and other goodies. The staff are just as friendly and courteous as ever, I'm glad that hasn't changed. So, for dinner, I ordered a QTR Sheet (six slice) from their "SUPER Specialty Pizza" menu - The BFLO Chicken Finger (blue cheese base) cooked "LIGHT WELL DONE", which is a choice between their homemade red sauce or blue cheese base that is topped with diced chicken fingers, mozzarella cheese, and Frank's (medium) sauce. The "LIGHT WELL DONE" option is for cooking the dough underneath a bit more, firming it up, making it crispier. I like a little extra cook on my pizza as, sometimes, the Buffalo-style dough is a bit too limp, almost soggy/wet, which makes holding a slice... challenging. haha Now, I've had a few chicken finger pizzas throughout the years and while I love them, they don't always love me back. They're typically very dense pizzas thanks to all the cheese (blue cheese base AND cheese blends on top) but I was impressed with how well One Pie Pizza Co.'s sat. Don't get me wrong, this pizza is absolutely loaded. When I opened the box, I was worried how I was going to pick it up as it looked messy, but as they say, appearances can be deceiving! I was impressed and didn't finish my meal wearing it all over my hands and face. Every slice was generously topped, the flavor was spot-on. Now, I love a cheesy pizza, but I really appreciate the constraint One Pie Pizza Co. showed with not going overboard with a "blend" of cheeses on top of a blue cheese base - The layer of mozzarella was plenty, a great flavor on its own. As with all of their pizza, this left me happy and full. With that $5 off coupon, this brought the price to under $20, an incredible price, especially in 2026! One Pie Pizza Co. remains one of my favorite pizzas in Buffalo. I'm glad I finally tried their chicken finger pizza, this was excellent. With how well it agreed with me, I'm pretty confident in saying One Pie Pizza Co. will be where I order chicken finger pizzas from exclusively going forward!

Excellent crispy crust. Go for bolder toppings. I had pepp with hit honey. I also had mush onion…read moreand that didn't hold up as well. Anthony Bourdain tip...I had to use restroom which is really only for staff. However it was super clean and nice and AB says if they keep it that nice you can imagine the kitchen. Well done One Pie!

Great pizza. Daily specials. Sweet sauce. Just how I like it. They updated the restaurant. Very…read moreappealing with lots of tvs to watch sports while eating pizza and drinking beer

Big menu and busy bar. It's very loud and takeout area recently expanded. 13 dollar lunch…read morespecials. Roast beef on a weck roll was great. Large parking lot and a S Bflo favorite.