I rarely leave negative reviews, but I felt it was important to share my experience…read more I ordered a custom SpongeBob-inspired cake and provided a reference photo when placing the order. I specifically requested that the cake say "26 Years Later." The bakery assured me they could complete the cake by the date I needed it. Unfortunately, the cake I received looked significantly different from the inspiration photo I provided. The lettering was not what I requested, the colors were different, and the overall decorating quality did not meet my expectations for a custom cake. The frosting was uneven and had visible marks throughout the cake. To the bakery's credit, they did honor the original $60 price I was quoted after there was some confusion at pickup. However, I was disappointed with the final product and felt it did not reflect the design I ordered. I've included photos of both the inspiration cake and the cake I received so others can make their own comparison. Based on my experience, I would not order a custom decorated cake from this bakery again.

We have been here numerous times since they opened but have never given a review. I have to sat…read morethat they make the best cupcakes, by far, than anyone in the area. Great flavor options that are delicious. Staff is always pleasant and courteous. They are very helpful. If you are looking for great cupcakes in the area this is your must stop.

Thank you so much to Carefree Cakery for this amazing cake! It really bought my dream to life, I…read morewas able to order it and pay it online a week before I needed it. The staff was super accommodating and helpful, the cake came out to about $60 but I personally think it was worth it because the flavor was amazing. I do wish they carried Tres Leches cakes/flavored cakes. I feel like that's the only flavor missing from their list! I haven't found a bakery in the Amherst area that can do that flavor yet but I'm hoping they expand to include this! Would definitely order from them again.

Nice and moist. Our favorites in order are: * Raspberry -…read moreJason liked it even though chocolate cupcake! * Funfetti - (Jason thought this was as good as Raspberry Chocolate) * Oreo * Lemon and Strawberry - both good, but not as good as others Christine liked the mocha top aslo- I spit it out. IDK why I even tried it since I don't like coffee

Rachel at Oh Goodness Cakes has made about 3 of my special birthday cakes. They were really cool!…read moreThe best part is: THEY ARE ALSO DELICIOUS! She is so talented and also reasonably priced. If you need a custom Cake give her a call, she won't disappoint!

Rachel designed and made my wedding cake and it was perfect. She was very helpful and responsive to…read moreall questions and concerns we had. We had a very particular wedding cake in mind (carrot cake with cream cheese frosting) and it was devious. She was great the day of the wedding meeting with my husband and florist to make the cake look beautiful. I recommend her to any person who needs a cake for any occasion.

Loved the cake and service…read more Highly recommend Lorena! Fiftieth birthdays are rare and we celebrated this milestone with a great meal and tasty dessert. Delicious but also artfully crafted.

Sweet Fever will be where I am getting all my cakes/cupcakes made from here on out! The cake and…read moreadditional cupcakes Lorena made for us were so delicious, not too mention beautifully done. She made the cake I was envisioning a reality and was very responsive and so sweet throughout the entire process! Her attention to detail really blew us away, and everything on the cake was entirely edible, which everyone at the party loved. 10/10 Recommend!

Stephanie was wonderful to work with! We did two rounds of sample mini cakes, which really helped…read moreus make decisions. We had a 4-tier traditional wedding cake with 3 different flavors, American Buttercream frosting in a wavy pattern, hand-piped beading between layers, and decorated with real flowers. She executed our vision perfectly, and every guest said the cake was delicious!! Luckily we had leftovers and enjoyed it several more times after the wedding :)

From the owner: Serving beautiful, tasty, custom designed cakes within the Southern and Central Vermont area and…read moreparts of New York. Looking for the perfect cake to compliment your special occasion? Contact Steph today!

Decided to try this place out for my daughters first birthday. The cake was strawberry flavored…read morewith a whipped frosting. Everything my wife asked on this cake Jolene delivered and then some ! All the guests including the birthday girl loved the cake ! Reasonably priced for such great work , great taste and I was shocked that it wasn't overly sweet at all. Will definitely be back !!

Awesome job making cupcakes of a Buffalo Face from a picture. In addition to looking great, they…read moretasted great too! First time using this business and will definitely come back.

This is the place to go if you have an event! From being reasonably priced, to extremely responsive…read moreand efficient.. this baker exceeded our expectations for our wedding! They always say "not everything will go as planned on your wedding day" and they are right.. but when things took a turn for the worse, not only did Elizabeth Handle the situation amazingly.. but she did so without creating extra stress for me on my big day! Any one who has ever gotten married will tell you how important that is.. I will absolutely be using Elizabeth's custom bakes for any future events I have and I hope you will too!

From the owner: Custom cakes, luxury wedding cakes, hand made wafer paper florals, decorated cookies, and specialty…read moredesserts, all from scratch and designed by you! Cookie decorating classes

I've had the pleasure of ordering from Sienna and Danyahl! First, I randomly just looked up…read morebakeries near my house, sort of last minute, which I don't recommend, but Danyahl responded right away, and was so very kind and accommodating to help me select the strawberry celebration cake you see picture below. I wasn't sure which cake to pick because they all looked delicious. and her creative artistry seemed impeccable, but I know we didn't have time for that, but I'm keeping that in mind for other occasions in the future Note that this is a small business owner getting her feet firmly planted on the ground, has an interesting story and one that we should all be supporting. She is local in West Hartford, and while has an incorporated business still bakes out of her home, which is great, because this cake was full of love. Now back to the cake. This was amazing. it was layered with a confetti cake and layers of cheesecake. Yes, cheesecake! There's also a thin layer of fresh strawberry jam. I picked it up on Saturday didn't get to eat it until Sunday night and it was tremendous..highly recommend leaving it out for a while so that it gets room temperature and all the flavors meld together. It is now a few days later, and it is still quite moist and soft after storing it in some Tupperware All in all so very happy to have ordered from Sienna and I am hoping for nothing but success for this business, Danyahl and her family.

We came early and she still took our order she was very sweet and let us sit inside while we waited…read moreshe also made conversation. I loved it here its gorgeous inside as well

Thanks for making my psychedelic-artist-psychologist 80th birthday cake the centerpiece of my…read moreparty! Magnificent creation! Mark

Jackie is amazing! I wanted a fun creative cake for my unique and special dad's 80th birthday and…read moreI'm so grateful that I found Jackie at the Cake Studio who made exactly what I was looking for. Everyone loved it and thought it was perfect for him - AND everyone was blown away by the flavors! Even the fondant tasted good which I was shocked by. I drove a few hours to get this cake, and it was sooo worth it. Also Jackie was so prompt with communications - everything was seamless. Can't recommend her enough. I will be coming back for all special cake needs.

I have stopped by multiple times and sampled MANY of the tasty treats offered in the absolutely…read moreadorable little camper!! My mom agreed that the Mother's Day Cupcake bouquets were THE BEST tasting cupcakes we've had, and my other favorite items include pecan pie/bars, mini key lime pies and the always reliable chocolate chip cookies! If you're in the area on the weekend, don't pass by without stopping in! Note: I smushed the flower cupcakes a bit in transporting them, they were stunning when I picked them up!!

Amazing, beautiful cakes and pastries. I'm so impressed with the quality of everything from almond…read morecroissants (truly in the French bakery style as promised) to the cute frosted cookies that also taste delicious and the extravagant and beautiful custom cakes. I highly recommend a weekend drive to the very unique retro bakery stand in gorgeous Ashfield or ordering a custom cake or set of custom cookies to make a birthday, graduation, or holiday really special!