I enjoy Enrico's for what it is - a Mom and Pop place that has friendly service and decent pizza. But that is just it. The pizza is just ok for me. The crust is really nice, with a good crisp, but the sauce is forgettable and I find the house made sausage to lack flavor. I like supporting places like this and I wouldn't say no to a slice, but it isn't a place I'm going to go out of my way for. If you want a similar vibe that fits better for my preferences, Luigi's in Hilliard is worth a try. read more

We have been getting pizza from here every Friday for over 10 years. Family owned and family operated. They get to know you and remember your order when they see you. Their pizza is delicious and consistently the same every time. We love sausage, pepperoni and green pepper. The kids like half cheese, which is fine with me. Their cheese blend is great! read more

The first time I went to Enrico's Pizza in Dublin was 30 years ago with then girlfriend and her parents after bowling at AMF Sawmill Lanes (now Bowlero Sawmill). It is a thick crust pizza with stretchy cheese and it was delicious, my girlfriend and her staff enjoyed the pizza and we got medium Pepperoni and Mushroom. She ordered Garlic Cheese Bread that was yummy too. The place is small, but quaint. No fountain drinks, but they have can sodas. I had Diet Coke, my girl got can Lemonade, and her staff has Coca-Cola. The service was excellent and told the server and staff that I will be going back to Enrico's Pizza in Dublin soon. read more

Enrico's Pizza & Restaurant - Pepperoni and Mushroom medium pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I was staying at a nearby hotel and read the reviews. The favor was good. But my pizzas and entree had a ton of salt so much so I couldn't eat it. read more

Everything was (as usual) very good. Was very crowded on the day after Christmas. Party of four adults and a one year old. read more

Enrico's is the hands down the best old school, family owned pizza restaurant in Columbus. The food is delicious, and the service is excellent. The inside of the restaurant smells delicious, and is very comfy. The food is fresh and delicious, and they have the best pizza ever, I recommend the capicola pizza. The food is consistent and is just as good every single time we visit. You feel like family when you are at Enrico's, everyone is so nice and friendly! I highly recommend Enrico's, I always look forward to visiting. read more

We ordered takeout pasta from Enrico's. The food was good but a little salty, and the portion size was small.

Great family run restaurant! Food always fresh and hot and delicious!! Always great service!!

Tried yesterday for the first time. There's a lot of hype about this place but the pizza didn't do it for me or my 2 companions. If you like the crisp crust style you may love. I prefer a softer doughier crust. I ordered a bambino (7"). Mushroom for me and my 2 companions shared a sausage & pep. They said the sausage as well as the pepperoni were tasteless. Again not my style but the one plus is the bambino size is pie cut which I prefer. Adequate amount of cheese. Another plus - sauce was not sweet. Server was nice and efficient just not very personable. Also on the menu were salads, subs and homemade pasta dishes. Everyone has their own opinion on what a good pizza is. Just because it was t. MY style doesn't mean that it was a bad pizza. Even though way on the other side of town I'm glad I tried it. You should give it a go too. read more

Enrico's Pizza & Restaurant - Bambino mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Wonderful family run business, pizza with a perfect crust and just the right amount of toppings.

There is no other Pizza like Enricos!! Crust, Sauce, cheese and toppings. It's a crispy white crust that I have yet to find anywhere, that has a similar crust! Even in Italy!! read more

Great little pizza location however there was only one waitress for the entire seating area. It was our first time there as we used to be customers of LaRosa's which recently went out of business. Pizza not quite as good as LaRosa's. Will continue looking for a new pizza spot. read more

Service was good. The food was awesome! Great salad! Fabulous pizza. Excellent pasta. First visit we'll be back.

We love Enricos! Their salad with house dressing is THE BEST! It's very simple but so delicious. I ordered the spaghetti dinner which included a meatball, roll and salad fir $11.25. Insider tip: order your pizza before or as you drive in. It'll be delivered pipping hot to your table. Order drinks and salads at your table. read more

Enrico's Pizza & Restaurant - Small pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Yuuummmm!!! Got a pizza, meatballs and salad to go. The pizza is thicker crust and it appears they put their cheese on top of the toppings. It looks like extra cheese but isn't. Missing a bit of spice, but red pepper does the trick. We had pep and bacon, and it wasn't overly greasy. Yum! We also got two meatballs which are huge, dense and taste wonderful, the sauce they come with is the best...absolute best I've had yet. The side salad is huge and their homemade house dressing is like an Italian only not as sweet. It's just perfection. We will be ordering this to go again soon. Did I say yum yet?! YUM!!! read more

See all

Tried Enrico's for the first time due to recommendations from a FB group for pizzas with a sweet sauce. In my opinion, the sauce was not sweet at all. It actually left a bitter aftertaste to me which left me not wanting to eat more than a square or two. The staff were nice. Everything smelled and looked amazing but this isn't the spot for me. Glad to have tried it though! read more

See all

Outstanding food and service. Best pizza anywhere. The waitress is warm and friendly with fast and accurate service. 30 years and counting. Generations have eaten there. Mom and dad in their 80's and nineties there every day making the food. It doesn't get more real than that!! And we are New Yorkers. read more

While we have our typical places that we normally go to for pizza, after numerous friends have recommended this place we decided to switch things up and give it a try. As a place that's been given the title, "best pizza in Columbus" or even "best pizza ever" I will say that going in my expectations were a bit high. Having that, they did not disappoint. We ordered a large half cheese, half hot pepper and an order of garlic cheese bread. The pizza crust is not too thick, a little crunchy, without having too much sauce and a ton of cheese. I got a spaghetti dinner, and ordered the sauce on the side. The spaghetti as well as all of their dishes are made in house. They give you a ton of pasta, a meatball, as well as a side salad and bread which for a little over $10 is an absolute steal. The staff was friendly and the social distancing guidelines looked on point. We truly enjoyed our experience! Although I do wish they delivered. read more

See all

The food is consistently great. We live the sauce and pizza. The family is very friendly.

Same great pizza I remember from 20 years ago. Service and food were great, It has the same indoor dining charm as before. read more

My favorite Italian sub in the city! Enrico's is still a family owned and operated pizza shop and the vibes perfectly emulate that. Their pizza is fantastic and be sure to order their side salad as well and you will not be disappointed! read more

This place was recommended by our hotel, Embassy Suites so we decided to try it. It was authentic Italian and Italians at our table thought so too. The noodles were homemade , so yummy. One of my table mates got the lasagna and was not disappointed. I got the ravioli with option for 2 cheese and 2 meat , the noodle dough was phenomenal and the sauce very tasty. We got gnocchi to share at the table and it was delicious. We wanted to try the meatballs so we got a couple of those and they were very good. Our waitress was great she was so friendly and surprised us with a small pizza to try because she wanted us to taste how great their pizza was , and it was. The cheese was wonderful, the crust crispy. They grate their own cheese and said they get it from Wisconsin. Even the cheese shaker had grated Romano. And to top it off Mom and Pop were in the back helping out , really cute. read more

Enrico's is in my top 5 favorite pizza joints in the Columbus area. The quality is consistent and top notch. Orders are always correctly executed. This isn't your typical cracker-crust Columbus style pizza. Enrico's has a flavorful crust that is slightly thicker and chewier than a shop like Tommy's or Ange's. Cheese is flavorful, sausage and pepper are awesome. The double Italian sub is also a can't-miss. There is typically a 45 minute wait (or more) for pick-up, so plan around that. Due to covid, the dining room is closed and there's often a wait outside for carryout due to social distancing requirements inside. read more

Enrico's Pizza & Restaurant - Absolutely delicious. Extra cheese and 15" Large Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Hidden gem alert! Located in a small plaza off of Frantz Road in Dublin, Enrico's is the quintessential Mom and Pop restaurant. Family owned and operated for over 25 years. They hand make all of their pastas, meatballs, and sausages in house. If you've never been, I suggest the Ravioli, a meatball sub, and the sausage and cheese pizza. Their sausage is sliced, not crumbled and is delectable! The dining area is closed due to COVID, but their carry out is available with all of the social distancing regulations in place. We ordered carry out of a large sausage and cheese pizza and the Spaghetti Family Dinner. It included bread, salad, and spaghetti and meatballs for 4. They take cash and credit cards except for AMEX and Discover. read more

See all

Excellent pizza. Wonderful little place with authentic Italian food. Highly recommend.

This was our first time here. The OSU game was on and all the other restaurants we tried were packed. Besides us there were 3 other tables. It took 10 min for the waitress to see us and another 10 to get drinks. The pizza was good we ordered two small. Crispy crust and you could tell they use good quality cheese. We also ordered an Italian and meatball sub. The meatballs weren't balls they were broken down into a very thin layer of meat. When I order meatballs I want to bite into meat .The Italian sub had maybe 4 slices of very thin meat. They tasted ok but weren't worth the money in my opinion, all bread . I would return for the pizza and get it to go because in additionto slow service it is very smokey in there. read more

Enrico's Pizza & Restaurant - Sad "meatball" sub - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

I love this place they have the best pizza in town ! The pizza and subs are both really good!

The best!! Family owned The pizza, the salad, the subs!! Sooo good!!! And try the marinara pizza if you haven't it's amazing.

OH MY!!!! Somebody please tell me why this place isn't five star ratedListen I am from Chicago and everyone knows we had some of the best pizza ever so if you guys don't appreciate Enrico's In Chicago they would get all the love. What a hidden gem and I have to some I am extremely impressed and my stomach is happy it was so good I almost couldn't stop. Then minute we walked through the door you could smell the aroma of amazing fresh oven baked pizza and I knew right away this could be something special. As I expected that pie came out piping hot super cheesy just cooked to pure perfection. I rushed right in for my first slice and oooooohhhh weeeeeee my stomach was singing like the angels in the heavenly choir. Everything we ordered was delicious freshly made and served with love. Our waiter was great very attentive and did an amazing job. You guys can have all theses other pizza joints cause at this very moment Enrico's brings it all the way home for me. Don't just take me at my word my Yelp family please go and give them a try you will not be disappointed! read more

See all

Boyfriend and I ordered carryout. We ordered a small pepperoni, onion, mushroom, banana pepper & extra sauce pizza, meatball sub with onion added, and garlic bread. I personally think the crust on the pizza was bland, the sauce very basic and seemed watered down and was just ok. The meatball sub was on chewy bread and was cut up in pieces and smooshed together. (see pictures) Not much flavor. The highlight for me was the garlic bread. It was very flavorful and could have ate the whole order instead of the pizza or sub but I had to share. I would stop by here for the garlic bread to accompany a pasta dish we make at home. read more

See all

Great family style place. Very friendly staff and waitress. Felt like I was at someone home. Which is a good thing. Pizza is bomb

Whether it's pick up or dine in their pizza is always great! Family owned, family ran, and you're treated like family when you're there! Don't be surprised if you get an order for pick up and you have to wait in a line. It is worth the wait! read more

The service was okay, took a bit of standing at the counter to get noticed. A sign indicating to seat yourself would be helpful as it wasn't really clear if you were supposed to order at the counter. The pizza crust and sauce were pretty good, but the toppings fell well short of what is expected in a quality pie. The sausage was bland and the excessive (personal preference) amount of cheese was overcooked such that water was pooled on the surface of the cheese when the pie was served to me, indicating that they overcooked it. Because of that, the cheese was too chewy, almost to the point of a bubble gum consistency. Also, the unsweetened iced tea is pretty flavorless and appeared to be heavily watered down (based on color). Finally, and this is just a preference, but they use a party cut for their pizza, rather than a pie cut. read more

A relic of the past in so many ways. The only downside is how busy they are. What a great family run establishment. Been going here for 15 years. A pizza you could take to any city or pizza challenge. Order a pizza, get a beer at dub pub. Done deal. read more

Pizza is fantastic, Lasagna horrible. Wait staff is absolutely the sweetest. Nice family owned restaurant. I took one bite of my lasagna and it was burnt and chopped up like it had been cut for a child. The woman said I will only take 1/2. I took one bite and it was nasty. I sent it back read more

They are horrible people! Called ordered a large plain pie and pepperoni. Accidentally called the wrong place they would not credit. Like they can't get rid of a plain pie at dinner time. They should be ashamed of themselves! read more

The place is run by an Italian family that works the back, in a shopping mall in an generic restaurant space. But Enrico's is the real deal. In a city that's already pretty stacked with great pizza options, you may ask yourself "do we need another one?" Well, we do. Because it's insane how good it is. Plenty of gooey cheese and toppings. The sauce is sweet, but you can clearly taste the tomatoes in there, not some chemically paste. There's plenty of other Italian red sauce favorites on the menu, I haven't gotten around to trying it though because like I said, the pizza is insanely good. read more

Went in on a Thursday, had no problem getting a table as there are about 12 to 16 available, anywhere from a two top to six to eight top, place was three quarters full with carryout do8ng a brisk business. One waitress was working tables but had no problem at all handling everything, got to me within thirty seconds to get my drink order and I already knew what I wanted, she took order, got me my soda and salad very quickly, when I finished my salad my order was ready, lasagna was excellent along with everything else, the waitress even brought me another salad I liked the dressing so much. Very good place, very good people! Good find for a small place tucked back in a shopping area, will be back for sure! read more

The best Italian sub in the Columbus area ! Garlic bread with cheese - FANTASTIC !! The lasagna is also first rate. The pizza is very, very good (love the everything) 5 stars all the way!! Service,too, is first class, even on busy days (or nights) Very comfortable setting. read more

I looked the Coronovirus straight in the eyes and said, "YOU WILL NEVER" stop me going out for my favorite pizza at Enricos. The virus said, "I understand." read more