The pizza shop is off of a tiny parking lot by other business on the avenue. It was very welcoming. When you walk in there is a deli and slices available. Staff greeted us immediately and was very cordial. We settled on a few pre made slices and garlic knots. The chicken bacon was on red sauce and had ranch on the side. I'm not familiar with the sliced made that way but none the less it was a taste sensation. The white slice was a perfect blend of cheese which can be rare to find. The margarita pizza was a fun blend of goodness. All the dough was met somewhere in the middle of too under cooked and over done. The crust was perfect. The garlic knots were very oily but still satisfied the palate in the oily, garlicky greatness. I would definitely stop by again and try other slices as well as entrees. The shop was super clean, the seating area was quaint and the restroom very updated and clean. The cost of 4 slices and 6 knots was $20 so that was a fantastic delight on my wallet. It was an overall win for a pizza night. read more

Service was very fast, placed my order in no time and they said 15 wait and it was just that. Always appreciate up front service, even when slow like it was when I visited. Shrimp marinara was very good, large size plump shrimp cooked just right. Tangy, sweet and savory marinara sauce and plenty of it, angel hair just right, definitely a full meal. For the grandma slice, just right amount of cheese and tomato and not littered with fresh basil. I do enjoy that slice was cooked just right with a blistered crust and no burnt char. Overall great first impression. read more

F & J Pizzeria - Shrimp Marinara - Pizza Near Me - Washingtonville, New York

See all

Terrible Food...... They should close up immediately. The community deserves better!! The worst I've ever had.... Sauce taste very Bitter! read more

We ordered food to go, which we picked up ourselves. I ordered the chicken Scarpariello with a side of spaghetti with marinara sauce. My husband ordered the stuffed chicken Parmesan dinner. First of all, I should've looked at the menu because most places put potatoes in their scarpariello but they did not. The chicken pieces were so overcooked I could barely cut into them and just so very dry. I think they could improve on freshening up their sauce. My husband's dish was just OK. It was a piece of chicken with a piece of ham and a slice of cheese. There was no love in these dishes at all. I was really hoping to like this place because someone had mentioned it to us. I will never order dinner there, but we might try the pizza. read more

John and his staff are always upbeat and have the orders ready on time. Always welcome you upon arrival and must say their food is delicious Thank you all read more

I've had their hero's, pizza, and cannoli. Amazing pizzeria. I am confident in saying from a Bronx born perspective that F&J's are the best pizza in Orange County. The flavor, the no pizza flop, crust... Treat yourself to this amazing pizza. It's hard to find good pizza lately, and I will continue going there. Perfect for Lent! read more

Love their pizza especially the grandma's And we caterered from here also everything was great and fantastic service read more

F & J Pizzeria - a man and a woman posing for a picture - Pizza Near Me - Washingtonville, New York

Not the same anymore-- food is only mediocre-- staff doesn't care about customers ,they figure their reputation will carry the restaurant this will only last for a while read more

Outstanding place, parking is terrible at times but doesn't keep me away. I drive significantly out of my way to go there on the regular

Wow this place is incredible. I tried a few places locally but nothing tops the pizza here. Highly recommend. They are from Brooklyn!

I really like F and J. Super convenient location and they have great pie. Have not had anything else on the menu though it looks like they also have a small deli counter. Be careful ordering through GrubHub and UberEats as their system makes it so they sometimes have trouble "finding" your order. Small dining room is clean and well lit. Great spot for simple/quick lunch. read more

F & J Pizzeria - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Washingtonville, New York

Food is not what it used to be someone added cornstarch to make the sauce thick franchise sauce should be light and flavorful since the kids took over they lost Joe and his wife who were part of the backbone of f and j Pizza is still good they lost a 30-year customer I even took down my five stars on their website read more

Owner is really nice. Great pizza spot in Washigtonville. Love their vodka sauce pizza.

Benn coming here since they were in the old Moffat Library location, so around 45 years. Their pizza has not changed in all that time and their garlic knots are the best in the 'Ville! read more

Food is good and the staff is very serviceable. One can eat in or take out. Just don't like that they charge a service fee for using a credit card. read more

F&J has great Caesar salads but I must be honest it is the only food I have ever gotten there. Others that I have dined with though have nothing but good things to say about it. read more

This NYC native loves that we have a genuine Brooklyn style pizzeria right in the heart of the village. The restaurant is really nice AND they just added a private room in the back. I attended a meeting in their new room and was blown away by the customer service and, as usual, excellent food. read more

Great Sicilian pizza, all their food is good. Tough for parking but that's ok. Been going there for over 20 years.

I had an amazing meal, and Victoria was a lovely waitress. I loved the Eggplant Caprese Stack....where has it been all my life?! Tonight is my first time eating here, and I will be back for sure! read more

F & J Pizzeria - Eggplant Caprese Stack - Pizza Near Me - Washingtonville, New York

Horrible I called in for and order for fries and 2 slices I have them 40 mins to prepare my food and when I got there I still had to wait another 20 mins. Lastly I asked for pepperoni and it was cheese l. Of course I am already annoyed I had to wait a whole hour I wasn't going back to wait another 20 mins. The cashier was super rude. If I could give them zero stars if I could. read more

We were there yesterday for Mother's Day, but the dining room was so frigidly cold that it was uncomfortable to eat there. We asked the young woman behind the counter to possibly turn down the a/c, but she said she "didn't know how, and besides, the owner would not let them touch it". We left and went elsewhere to a much more comfortable and nicer setting. Perhaps the owner should consider the comfort levels of his customers and he would get more business. The place was dirty too, the counters were covered in pizza crumbs and droplets of soda/water which was in desperate need of cleaning. Sadly, this place has gone way downhill. read more

The girl on cashier is rude af, ordered food in advance and still had to wait. When you order in person the wait for food to be served easily takes about 50 mins. They don't like to serve if your not a local. Nasty tone for business. Especially their attitudes. read more

I really like their cheese pie. I'm from Brooklyn and riding out the lockdown here in town and finding F & J was a life savor. Solid pie with crispy and chewy crust; nice sauce and cheese; solid ratio of cheese to sauce and all around good pie. I'm a pizza snob and this is my weekly pie up here. read more

F&J Pizza is the best. We tell everyone that we moved from Manhattan for it!.. Great family run restaurant, great staff, really good food , service is great, no complaints at all! .. especially if you get there at 11:00 when they open for a fresh slice right out the oven. Mozzarella sticks are a must as they are not the typical frozen ones that you get at most places. Salads , pastas, platters , heros ,it's all good ! read more

Ordered a veal parmigiana and a shrimp Parm Bread was fresh and the Veal was tender and the Shrimp were big and fresh Definitely my new spot read more

Awesome pizza thin perfect sauce and cheese and toppings. Best pizza I had so far in the oc!

We went to F&Js at 8:30 on a Thurs evening b/c it is listed everywhere as open til 10:30. Other places were listed as closed and we were looking to share a meal with a friend. Although there were still people eating in, we were told their dining room was closed and we could only get take out. We wound up having pizza outside on a cold and drizzly evening. They did not offer to let us eat the pizza inside. Terrible service! False advertising. read more

Been coming here since 1996. Was always my go to for pizza or chicken parm. Over the last few months I've ordered chick parm dinners and each time the chicken has been tough and stringy. I heard it was taken over by a son. Hope they take this constructively and buy better chicken like Dad did. Pizza is still awesome, whatever kind you try. read more

Like most are saying, service is horrid. Living in the area I have gone here many times, and it's always a problem. Worst of all, they never take responsibility for the problem. No matter what they screw up, you get the attitude and somehow the blame. Pizza is good, but don't go in for a slice. Sometimes they don't even have any, or they've been sitting there since 10 am. And again they look at you like you did something wrong when you can't do something as simple as get a slice. read more

By far the best pizza in Washingtonville! Well done sesame seeds on the crust. Trust me!

Called to order 2 family sized Stromboli's, the girl insisted I was asking for a calzone which I wasn't. After insisting I wanted a Stromboli, she said I was all set. 20 minutes later, I pick up and it's a tiny box. When I asked her this is the 2 family sized Stromboli? I was told it comes one size, this is the pizza roll.... Which is not a Stromboli. Apparently the staff doesn't know simple menu items. $26 later for food I didn't even order to now order the right food from somewhere else. Complete waste of time and money. read more

We ordered tonight and got super fast hot delivery of 3 pies ..great family run establishment that cares and goes the extra mile ...literally ! We live a bit outside delivery zone in CH . This is what pizza tasted like when I was a kid growing up on LI...Our family uses F&J for our xmas eve pre-game calzones and spinach pies ever year ..these guys are the best around , period! read more

So last night we ordered from F&J's. Three pies, they got the order wrong - they gave us a plain instead of the meatball we paid for- so we called them to let them know. They said they could deliver it in 45 minutes. That was too long we had a house full of people. So they said 20 minutes and we said that was fine. Well, 50 minutes later, they showed up and wanted the plain pie back. My niece told them it was gone. The driver said "ok" and left. They called us later on and said that because of an incident their driver had with us not returning the pie, they will no longer deliver to us and we should please not order from them anymore. First of all, we've been going there for over 20 years. Second of all, it was THEIR mistake, third, they said 20 minutes and didn't show up until almost one hour later! They should have been apologizing to us! I will not only no longer give them any business but I will spread the word about their bad business practices. Also, what were they doing with a pie that had been at someone's house for an hour? Are you warming it and serving it to other people? read more

This is one of my favorite pizza spots in the Washingtonville, NY area. I like the sauce they use for their pizza and Italian food. My favorite dish is the Eggplant Parmesan. The seating area is small. read more

F & J Pizzeria - Restaurant entrance - Pizza Near Me - Washingtonville, New York

Front desk person can't take orders right. Got home with the food and it was all wrong. Won't come back. PS: Just finished half way thru the plate. Not impressed. Will definitely not be back. read more

Excellent food & service! The delivery guy's are extremely nice !!! I feel everybody goes out of there way to help!!!

i love this pizza. It's one of my favorites in the area. the garlic knots are delicious too. A friend got the broccoli and pasta in oil and said it was tasty. The service is always good- never great nor terrible. read more

Life is too short to eat bad pizza. So go here. Yelpers helped me choose this spot, and I'm glad I did. Had a simple Margherita slice. Good crust, tasty sauce and the right amount of good cheese. Everything else looked great. Pleasant service. I'm picky about pizza but this place is right on par with the best spots in the city. read more

This place is a staple in Washingtonville. Pizza is certainly the best in Washingtonville and maybe even Orange County. Food is great and staff is very friendly as well. read more

I wasn't going to write anything but after seeing I'm not the only one that had such a shitty customer service experience I figure I might as well. New to the area and had our friends and family helping us move in today. Ordered two pizzas wings and a salad. Went over the order with the gentlemen on the phone. When I went to pick up the items the girl with a puss on her face brought me one pizza and two bags (the salad and wings) I told her I had ordered two pies she tells me I did not. I said I did in fact I went over the order with the gentlemen over the phone. She insisted I did not order two pies. I said okay how long to make another plain pie she tells me she doesn't know and walks away to the back and doesn't return until other customers come in and she comes up takes their order and hasn't acknowledged my question still. I then ask her how much for another six slices after she is done helping the two customers. SHE WALKS AWAY AGAIN!!!!!!!!!! I really wanted to ask for my receipt back to cross out the tip I had left but instead I said have a nice day and walked out. Sucks because the pizza we did actually get was good. But there isn't a chance we'll be going back there. read more