Their sauce is to die for. The Olin slice is perfect and the calzone filling. I keep saying I want to try the menu but I can't get passed how delicious these two items are. read more

Easy access location. Located in a plaza on 300 across the street from Walmart and Applebees. They say it's replicates a pie from the Bronx --- you can be the judge of that. I'm a Jersey pizza guy. But it definitely was a great pie. They definitely wasn't stingy with the sausage each slice had a decent amount. Service was super quick about 15min wait for a large pizza and some garlic knots. read more

See all

Was gonna go Panera for a work lunch but saw this place instead. Glad I did! Such a simple place offering a wide variety of pizzas. Got the eggplant Parmesan pizza and the crust is thin and crispy. It's so good! They also are quick and friendly! Highly recommend this place. read more

Pizzeria 300 - My hands for reference - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I like this pizzeria a lot. It was one of the first I came to when I moved to the area. The service has ALWAYS been great, everyone in there is always so welcoming and with a smile on their face. The pizza is also really good as are the garlic knots! Also reasonably priced given the cost of everything these days! On my most recent visit, I ordered a pepperoni slice and a chicken slice. Pepperoni slice was a little thin and oily, but it was still really tasty. Chicken slice was very good and also very filling. I always come to this pizzeria and will definitely continue! read more

Pizzeria 300 - Pepperoni and Chicken slice - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

They use fresh premium ingredients. I friendly staff and great food! A must try in Newburgh, it has become my favorite pizza place. I drove by so many times until thenday I finally stopped. Their marinara sause is simple done well. read more

See all

staff was pretty quick and though taking my order, and barely waited for my food to go. Meatball slider was very good, I appreciate they are cut in half meatballs then full ones since those are a lot messier to eat, plus the garlic knot it severed in very soft and not overkilled in minced garlic. Grandma slice was great, crust was perfect and not mussy, but wish there was more grated parm and basil on top. Italian combo was great, and the bread used for it was soft, pretty lightly dressed. overall good food here and i found there prices here pretty fair compared to other pizzerias in the area with the same items. read more

Pizzeria 300 - grandma slice and meatball slider - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

I love this sandwich. I wish I had bought two. I also love the eggplant pizza roll thing. And the sausage and pepper roll thing. I heated them up at home and were crispy, cheesy perfection. Next time I go, I want to try to freeze and reheat them because I don't pass by this place very often. I have yet to try the pizza. read more

Pizzeria 300 - What is left of a really good sandwich! - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Best penne alla vodka pizza I've ever had. So saucy without being too heavy that everything falls off when you lift it I also ordered tortellini and pasta fagioli and both were so over salted they were inedible so that's what makes this a 4 instead of 5 star review read more

Pizzeria 300 - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I had pizza 300 three times already then I would have to say the pizza is phenomenal. I never thought Newburgh Pizza was that good no offense also their service is beyond incredible. They're fast very friendly and they give you exactly which you ordered on time with the smile on their face honestly I would recommend Pizzeria 300 to all the pizza lovers out there. I'm born and raised in Hoboken New Jersey so you know I know what a good pie is what is supposed to taste like Pizzeria 300 nailed it five stars all the way. read more

Great pizza at a good price. And the two gents behind the counter were very friendly. Nice place!

The pizza was very good! I was passing through and decided to grab a couple of slices. Good variety, good flavor fresh ingredients. I will definitely be back when I'm in the area. read more

Really good pizza!! I eat pizza every single day, I kid you not! Slice with sausage I got was on point and while it was really good, crisp & tasty it's not the very best I've tasted so I'm rating 4-Stars cause I'm stingy with 5. I've blown past this place probably hundreds of times and I think because of the signage it blends in with the plaza area so it gets lost in the blur you see from the corner of your eye speeding past on route 300 . I'll definitely be grabbing a pie from this place in the future since it's close to home. At the time of this review they have a special $10 large pie after 8pm. They a decent amount of seating & service is on point. read more

Pizzeria 300 - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

$29.95 for 2 mediocre shrimp parm hero's wtf $14.97 ea Shrimp sucked too Never again Get ripped off read more

Ordered 3 buffalo chicken calzone's and 3 fountain drinks - everything was very good and the price was fair for the area, read more

Pizzeria 300 - Medium calzone - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Very nice place, pizza was alright. Price I thought was a little high but was good. Would buy again when in area. Guys where very nice. GO THERE, THERE GOOD read more

Trying to call them to order food and NO FREAKIN ANSWER!!!! This is every Sunday. At this point I'm so fed up, I had to leave a review. Nothing worse Than craving something from this place while pregnant and no one answering the damn phone! I feel like at this point, you should call me on Sundays and see if I'd like to order! So ridiculous! read more

I heard about this place from a friend. When I walked in I was greeted and asked if I had any questions. I ended up asking a bunch of questions. They have a large display filled with cheesy and meat awesomeness. I landed on a chicken, bacon, ranch slice and a sausage and peppers calzone type thing. They took my order and thru it in the pizza oven. In a few minutes I was handed this box of cheesy, what seemed fresh baked Italian goodness. I ordered it to go but when I took a look and could smell the peppers and bacon I just sat down in the Restauraunt. I asked for some Parmesan and they pulled a chilled shaker out of the fridge. The bacon ranch is ridiculous. There is so much bacon on this baby, one piece was perfect. The sausage pepper contraption was excellent as well. They include this sauce that I highly recommend dipping the crust in. I ended up asking for an additional serving and they just handed it to me. This was a great find and I will be back. I like places like this because you are not expected to tip but the food quality and service is excellent. I will update this review the next time I go. I am back for round two. I forgot to mention the crust. Crispy and light with a nice chew. This is really good true Italian pizza. read more

Pizzeria 300 - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Pretty good pizza, great location sub par customer service. Not much really to say about this place other than we did enjoy the pizza and it was relatively quick but not necessarily somewhere we would go again. read more

Pizzeria 300 - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

They changed the cheese from when they first open . The pizza are better as personal pan pizza,for one. Very good people that work there and own it. read more

Have wanted to try the pizza for awhile, but just haven't had the chance to stop in. Tonight was my chance, I had a slice of the Caprese and a cheese slice. The Caprese might be the best slice I've had in a long while. The cheese was average, but it's hard to follow up a Caprese slice with a plain cheese slice, right?! I had looked at reviews and was was unsure what to expect, but I am happy to report the staff was friendly, helpful and courteous. I went on a Friday night at 7pm and there were 2 other customers there. The alternate choices all looked delicious: empanadas, beef patties (which the customer ahead of me said were good) and even sliders made with garlic knots as buns!!! I plan to try that next! Looking forward to bringing my hubby for a try! read more

If you are familiar with Pizza in Naples Italy and you're feeling like you wish you could be there eating pizza, well no need to get on a plane and travel, Pizza 300 is your answer to that desire. The crust on the Grandma pie was crisp, perfect size in height and the mozzarella was fresh and delicious. Also ordered was a sausage and pepper roll that curled my toes. Great non pretentious atmosphere, clean, all the pies offered looked great and made us wish we had the kind of appetite to try them all. We will be back again and again so we can! We are residents of Sullivan County and will definitely make the trip for a great pie like this. read more

Not a bad pizza place. Really enjoyed the pizza. The wings weren't that great but the pizza was really good. Been here a few times now.

Walked in, was not greeted. A young kid behind the counter just stared at me until I nudged my daughter to place her order. I then asked him to let me know when the order was ready as we were eating-in (he never asked), he just nodded. The waitress brought out food, my daughter's meal wasn't even on a plate. Then the real fun came when I tried to get napkins from the dispenser. The napkins wouldn't budge. And rather than help, the my stood behind the counter and watched. It's one of those tall dispensers that gives you one at a time. Another customer even tried to help me. I ended up with pieces. Now to the food. I could almost forgive the service but the pizza is not good. The cheese was too thick and lacked any flavor. There are many other great pizza places in Newburgh, go to them instead of here. read more

Had to go to the bank next door. Went in to Pizza 300 to wait for my ride because it was pouring rain. I got a piece of Grandma's Pizza and a soda. This was the worst Grandma's Pizza I ever had - it was pizza dough and sauce on top ( not even flavorful sauce ) - there was absolutely no cheese at all. Every place I've ever had Grandma's pizza there was some cheese on it - it was so blah - I should have complained and gotten a Sicilian Slice - but the older, short fellow working was a bit of a grump - so I ate part of it. I've had there specialty slices before and they were very good but they need to change their Grandma's pizza. read more

Well one day i walked in the door and my wife asks, "what do ya wanna do for dinner" i had no clue. She tells me she has a coupon for a free large pie with one topping from Pizza 300. Knowing she is the worlds biggest pizza fan(like queen of the fan club) and the fact that its free i said "sure" I called and ordered a large pie with anchovies(i dig those little fishy gems). Drove up to get it, was greeted, pizza was there ready, and coupon honored with zero issues, overall loved the hand to hand experience. Simple, friendly and quick. Now on to the pizza, perfect crust, great sauce, not overally cheesy, not soggy and sloppy at all. Really, really.good pie. Zero complaints and i will definitely be going back read more

This place great, first and foremost the pizza is gluten free. I think that everybody cares more about their health in this era so that's important. But what's really important to me is the customer service, A1 service! read more

Not going back! Thought the menu looked great so I ordered a sausage roll, slice of Sicilian pizza and pasta fagioli (soup) to go. The roll and slice were already cooked and at the counter. The menu and prices were prominently displayed. The guy told me the price and I paid it but thought it was high. Then I looked at the menu again and asked for my receipt. I was charged a dollar more than the menu said for both the roll and soup. When I pointed this out the guy said in his thick Italian accent, "That's awhat the computer asay." I'm Italian btw. When I said that the menu showed different prices he said, "You're nota the first one to say that". Great, whatever. Hope the food is great. The place was almost empty at 4 pm and I was waiting a long time for my order. A guy came in, ordered two slices, they were heated up in the oven, he paid and off he went. I asked about my order and was told it was being worked on. I waited many many more minutes and asked again. I was told something like they are making the soup. Was it a new batch? We're they making it from scratch? I really couldn't understand the guy. As I was waiting I noticed that the same guy who took the order, answered the phone and handled the money then went directly over to press pizza dough into a pan with his hands, WITHOUT WASHING THEM! I live in Arizona and when I go to Mexico I read to make sure that the same person who handles the money is not preparing the food. Sanitary conditions, you know? Now on to the food. The sausage roll was ok. The Sicilian slice was mediocre, bordering on terrible. The crust was burnt. I was really enjoying the pasta fagioli until I found a 3 inch long black hair in it. Yuk! Customer service was poor. Save yourselves the bad experience and go to J & F's on Broadway the next time you are looking for Italian food in Newburgh. UPDATE: An hour later after eating my stomach is not feeling so good. I should report them to the County health Dept. read more

Pizzeria 300 - Hair found in soup. - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I will happily drive out of my way to grab my pizza here. Not only is their food excellent, with high quality pizza ingredients and great salads but the entire staff is fantastic. They are friendly, pleasant & helpful! read more

Service is nothing to write home about. They are more expensive and not as good as Pizza Mia. Business appears to be slow despite being on a major road and next to Crystal Run. Maybe some better lunch specials could attract more business. read more

Pizzeria 300 - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Excellent. These guys can bake! The pizza is great, they bake their own sandwich bread, their garlic knots are awesome -- this is really good dough skillfully handled. If they have the meatball sliders when you're there, treat yourself and have 2 or 3 -- they make them on those awesome garlic knots and they're one of the best things I've ever eaten in a pizza joint. read more

Best Garlic knots I have ever had. Beautiful clean dining room. Very friendly customer service.

Good pizza, very happy with the slices they have here. Soap in the bathroom is very slimy and kind of icky but was ok. The girl at the counter was really nice when I was there... a little too nice ;) read more

The pizza is OK ,when ordering with onions if you do not sawtaed.never have a delivery driver

First time customer...Definitely going back soon !! Great people and Awesome Pizza !! Can't wait to try the Meatball Sliders next time !

Their Pasta e Fagioli is a very salty, watery tomato sauce with noodles and very few white beans that are undercooked; ended up throwing it away. It would do this place some good if they would just serve the progresso soup version straight from the can. The pizza that I got was also extremely salty and I had to throw it away too. Patronize this place at your own risk/peril. As for me, that was my first and last time. read more

We didn't have the greatest experience the first time around but as a new business we decided to give it a second shot and it was actually worst then the first. Food is very bland and delivered cold both times. read more

This is a great pizza place and more. I eat here a lot. The food is fantastic! Give Pizza 300 a try you'll be happy you did!!!

I walked in and the place is spotless, staff is very welcoming like if they knew me for years lol. I placed my order and food was ready within minutes, it was the BEST SICILIAN PIZZA i had ever had. Definitely will come back with friends read more

Unreliable delivery service. I can fully understand when someone calls out. But the driver keeps calling out! So they cant deliver. This has many times already. Don't get me wrong, it's great food.... But forget, delivery!!!! read more

We were very happy with our first time visiting Pizza 300! Friendly staff and everything was fresh! I encourage y'all to visit!