Ordered a pie to go and it was delicious. Not very big place inside, I think there were three tables? Pizza was done quickly and the guys working were pretty nice. read more

Ive been going to Vic's Pizza forever! Their calzones are delicious and they don't skimp on fillings like other places do, plus they deliver which is perfect! Enjoy! read more

came here to get lunch, since I been to the other pizza places in the area. I got a pepperoni slice and a chicken bacon ranch slice. The slices honestly tasted stale like it been left out and the crust itself would been better if slightly burnt to offset the taste. Should have tried something else here, but if man draw is meh, can't have faith in the others. read more

Vic's Pizza - pepperoni and chicken bacon ranch slices - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

Recently moved to the area and have been looking for real NYC pizza. Have been very disappointed in Walden do I decided to continue my search in the next town over. After trying Vic's my search is over! This place is amazing! The pizza reminds me of the city with nicely flavored sauce, not cheap on the cheese & just the perfect amount of crust! I ordered a pie for the kids and a shrimp parm hero for myself and I am not disappointed in the least. Pictures of both attached. You can tell there using fresh ingredients and the wait was very short. The lady working the front along with the owner (who made our pizza) were pleasant from the moment I walked in. Even discovered we live in the same neighborhood so I know they deliver to my part of Walden (yes)!! Overall if you haven't figured it out yet, I highly recommend this place for take out or even to sit down & dine in. They have a cute little restaurant section. read more

See all

Know that they charge 4 1/2 percent plus a dollar to use a card. $26 for a specialty pie is too much. read more

Vic's Pizza - Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

This place is a waste of money, first of all just a regular plain pizza doesn't even have flavor or taste the sauce on the pizza has no flavor and the cheese isn't even good. Service is fast and wasn't too busy but I'd never come again and I came all the way from Jersey let me say this Jersey got the better pizzas. read more

First and last time here. I bought two slices. They were stale. Crust was hard, sauce was bland and cheese was a little too salty.

Vic's Pizza is epic. Got a perfect chicken Marsala and linguine dinner with a house salad. Chicken Marsala was not overly salted with fresh mushrooms and lemon. Linguine was perfectly cooked. Sauce was light, flavorful and fresh. Salad had a homemade vinaigrette that was delicious. We also ordered wings and they were perfect. Good to know Vic's is a solid take-out place in Montgomery. read more

This is a very nice place. The dining room in back of restaurant is where I will be. Delicious food. Owner is a very nice hardworking lady along with the rest of her family. Pizza is best around too. Try a cannoli, there is some secret ingredients hat makes them superb. read more

Eggplant sandwich was terrible, sauce didn't go with the eggplant like it was just added because it was too dry or something. Meduim pizza was the worst , lw quality cheese, and very little sauce. I have experience as a baker and pizza guy and this place was not even worth reviewing but they charged my $25.75 for a tasteless small pie and a small eggplant sandwich, what a ripoff. never again. read more

The last time I went there, it was pouring, and the restaurant was empty, I asked the waiter if I could sit by the window with my family and when I told the waiter he said 'That's stupid.' He was very unpleasant and kept a serious face all throughout serving us, as if he was doing us a favor. Very poor attitude. Last night I decided to give it another try, I went in to buy pizza to go, and the young lady in the front was acting like she had a monkey on her back, with a poor attitude. She had a very unpleasant demeanor, which she also displayed this while taking an order from a separate customer, the father also had acted the same way and he tossed my pizza at me as he was handling it to me. The wife, on the other hand, was at least friendly and smiled to me but over all, these people need to take some courses on how to handle customers because they don't seem to have a clue, and come off as very rude. I would not be spending money there anytime soon. A bad attitude is like a tire; it doesn't take you anywhere. read more

Update: added 1 star. Last bunch of months pizza has gotten even better here. I don't go to other places now for pizza! I completely recommend the Hawaiian pizza. Great choice and great quality! Best pizza in the region. Great crust. Cheese is fresh. Cooking time perfect. ---- In my opinion the best pizza in the region. After a year of getting takeout here I was ready to review it. - pizza is consistently the best in area. - other dishes are pretty good to. - staff tends to be a little rude - prices are higher then other places Overall I recommend. Closest you will get to NYC pie read more

Just wanted to give a shout out to this great restaurant! I explained my food allergies and they were able to tailor a dish to my specific needs AND it was delicious, fresh and I didn't get sick! The portions are huge and the staff is terrific read more

Pizza wasn't freshly made, stale taste. The best thing about NYC is everything is kept freshly made and has more flavor. I will change my review once I see and taste improvement. Two stars for kindness, not the pizza. Disappointed because their pizza was good before. read more

Had the chicken parm dinners tonight and it was great! From the salad, pasta, chicken and bread we couldn't have been happier. Everything was delicious and the portions were huge. Usually we order pizza and have never been disappointed, so glad we now know how good the dinners are. Thanks to all working at Vics during these stressful times...you made our night read more

We are visiting from California and the food was great. Best Fettuccini Alfredo and Homemade lasagna. The cannoli and coffee was great also. The portions were very big and the price was very affordable. I wish they had a restaurant like this in my hometown. We're gonna try to visit again before we go home and try the pizza. read more

Vic's Pizza - Homemade Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

Great food and reasonable prices. Best place to eat in town! We had the lasagna and it was fabulous big enough to share for sure! Also love the homey feel, the lady and the tramp art is amazing! read more

We've been going to Vic's for years, because the pizza is good and overshadows the disgruntled attitude of the staff. That said, we were there during the peak of the pandemic for pick up and well after 'masks on' was an executive order. Not one of the three people working had a mask on, including the chef. It bothered me so much I hoped it was just an off moment for them and that they were taking the public's safety seriously. I drove by several other times hoping to see them masked, but nope. Dine at your own risk. If they won't take your safety seriously during a deadly global pandemic and are willing to risk being fined, imagine what we don't see. read more

Vic's is the latest leaseholder in a building who has held more pizza joints than I can remember. Although they've been open for some time now, I finally stopped in to grab a slice. I ordered a chicken parm slice, and at $3.25 I found it a bit pricey, but sat down to see what's what. The chicken was especially crispy, which I really liked. The crust was pretty standard, it had definitely been sitting out for a little while but hey, most pizza places do that. The main point is that I would go back. Their sausage slice looked pretty awesome. read more

Best pizza place in Montgomery! Not only is the staff extremely kind and welcoming but the food is delicious for a very good price. Always kept very clean inside and has a nice dining area as well!! read more

Great place to eat and relax... Awesome owners and great environment New owners Are very friendly they talk to people and make sure everything is ok Extremely clean and they are always willing to go above and beyond to customize meals to meet customer needs read more

Vic's has the best cheese slice in Orange County, no contest. We've been coming here for true New York City style pizza for years and they never disappoint. As a true Brooklyn native, I can assure you that you're not going to find better pizza locally. Inside, you'll find the restaurant split up into two halves. The main part, the entrance, is a small pizzeria with three tables, a two top and two four tops. If you walk left when you go through the front door, you'll find your way to the main dining area. It's got lots of room for big parties, so being a bunch of your friends and family. It's usually pretty busy on weekend nights, so plan accordingly. Parking can sometimes be a chore, but almost directly across the street (on Clinton) is a municipal lot that usually has open spots. Vic's delivers, too, so if you're not in the mood to go out to eat, stay in with a pie and some cheesy garlic bread. They're quick and it won't put a dent in your wallet. read more

The owners -- an Italian man and his italian/Albanian wife -- are friendly, engaging people who made us feel welcome. The young lady working there also was a pleasure to deal with. The pizza was quite good, reasonably priced for this area, and the bathrooms were nice and clean. Definitely worth a stop on your road trip. read more

Great pizza, I ALWAYS get the pizza, I had it tonight. Delicious and fresh as always, my only problem is with one older waiter, no attitude, just a blank face. The rest of the staff is kind and outgoing, my old mother loves striking up conversations with them, nothing usually makes her laugh anymore, but they're one of them! Awesome food. read more

I HEARD the lady tell the cook "no sauce or cheese on the chicken cutlets" like I asked. I should have checked BEFORE I left...LOADED WITH SAUCE AND CHEESE. Smelled good but I had peanut butter and jelly for my dinner bc I couldn't eat this! I can't do cheese or sauce. Gave it to my neighbor who tossed it bc she said it tasted like cardboard with sauce and cheese. It's OK, with COVID, it's a $14.00 donation to my local business that I'll never go to again. 2nd time I have been disappointed by them, there will not be a 3rd. The 1st time, they were very rude bc I said their chicken cutlets were a little dry. My fault for trying again. To be honest, I have never tried their pizza and I see people like it but I'll never know bc I'm done (and I can't do sauce and cheese). They have been in business for a long time so maybe the pizza IS good, just don't get the chicken cutlets. read more

I've lived around this area basically my entire life and have seen a few pizza places come and go in this town. I hope Vic's stays. They make great pizza and great wings. Their specialty pizzas are amazing. Since they've opened, my family has probably eaten it's way through the entire menu and we have never once gotten anything less than fabulous from them. While I still wish I could just walk to Giuseppe's, Vic's definitely hits the spot. They are also very kid friendly. read more

The best pizzeria in town, by far... We are regular patrons [2-3x/week] of this restaurant. Every entree' my family has tasted there has been great. Warm, family-friendly environment... They've catered several events of mine--each time, providing the same quality dishes of their everyday menu. Vic and his team are hospitable, giving off that small-town, friendly vibe. read more

The restaurant is under new ownership. The food is still great. And the people treat you with kindness and respect. Love them!

My family and I, along with some friends found this spot in Montgomery after visiting Wallkill, NY. The pizza was excellent (sauce was amazing), Sicilian and regular crust (we ate both). Spaghetti and meatballs, chicken alfredo, calamari, we ate all the usual suspects and we were very happy. We had so much food left over we had enough for breakfast/lunch the next day. Truth be told, I am leaving this review so I can find this place again next time I am up that way... I will go back read more

i love vics! working down the street i come here often and their mozzarella sticks are awesome. the staff is super friendly to me and always makes me want to come back! prices are fair as well and pizza is tasty. read more

really? 4/5 stars - if frozen meatballs, canned sauce and overcooked chicken rate high at an Italian joint this place should have 11 out of 10 stars - Pizza is do-able though.. read more

What a great restaurant. The food is great. The service is friendly. By far the best pizza in the area. Their sauce is homemade as is there dough. Makes for a great pizza. My "go to" Italian in restaurant for either take out or eat in. read more

My family has been going to Vic's since I was a baby. Although Vic has moved his restaurant from New Windsor to Middletown back to New Windsor and now Montgomery the food has remained the same, absolutely awesome. Family owned, reasonably priced, and delicious. What else could you possibly look for in a small town restaurant? read more

Have ordered food several times and they won't deliver to all parts of Montgomery. They have mixed up take out orders or left items out - leaving me to have to return to get it fixed. Food is generally ok but not great. Some of these reviews over bost of such great food.....makes me wonder why. read more