they didnt put sauce at all on a buffalo chicken pizza. it was burnt too and the fries were barely…read morecooked. AWFUL

We were staying at the mines and meadows off road park and campground. Asked them to recommend some…read morefood. And the said candito's. Ordered a cheese steak hoagie and a pepperoni pizza. They delivered right to our camp site. BEST CHEESE STEAK I EVER HAD! Highly recommend it. Sorry no pics.

Everything about this place is great, including the owner…read more Best, pizza in Butler. I have never had a complaint about my order or been disappointed. MMMMMMmmmmm

I'm a new Butler resident, transplanted from Houston, where you really have to dig to find good…read morepizza. Luckily, I had a solid lead that the food was good here at Tani's. Last night we ordered a pepperoni pizza. We were quoted a 15 minute wait and by the time we completed the 8 minute drive to get there, it was ready for us! The inside is cute, though I'm not sure we'll ever sit down here. It's clean and charming and just the right amount of kitschy. Got the pizza home, tried it, and it's good! For me, the standout is the sauce. It tastes fresh and not over-processed. The crust, for me, could do with some work. It's a bit of a floppy slice and if their oven could get a little hotter I think they'd nail it. It has just the right amount of chew. The cheese is okay. I'd like it if it had a bit more flavor, you can tell there's room to improve the quality of the cheese. Same for the pepperoni. Definitely not a standout or anything, but I don't expect wonders in pepperonis anyway. We placed an order over the phone in less than a minute, the pizza was made quickly, and it was a solid slice. Not much at all to complain about. It isn't the BEST slice of my life, but it is definitely a great place to start here in Butler. I'll keep you posted!

Best pizza around! Order at least once per week! Super friendly, reasonably priced, simply the best!read more

Great people and amazing pizza! They came highly recommended by a coworker and are now my go-to…read moreplace for pizza.

if you like thin pizza with plenty of wonderful cheese and the perfect amount of wonderful sauce to…read morepull it all together , this is your place

It is all about the crust to sauce ratio for me (if that is even a thing!). The crust was able to…read morehandle the amount of sauce (and toppings) without getting soggy. It was perfectly cooked as it supplied a hint of "char"--the good kind--and remained crispy. The pizza had great flavor and the amount of cheese and toppings were perfect. The side salads were good. Plenty of veggies, instead of the typical salads you receive. This place only takes cash. There is an ATM machine a block away for those who aren't prepared.

I am never able to reach the Evans City Road location by phone. And when I call the other location,…read morethey tell me I can't order delivery from them because I'm not within their range, however, how can I order delivery from Evan's City Road if they're never going to answer their phone?? It's almost like they have it off the hook all the time as it just does the busy signal on repeat..

Delivery was fast and the food was made fresh. Loved the Buffalo chicken salad! Also really enjoyed…read morethe cheese fries.

I can't say enough about how grateful we were to the special employees at this pizza shop! The…read morenight before my sons birthday party, our original catering plan fell through. I called El Pizza plus and found that while they were not quite open at the start of his party, someone there was willing to show up early and prepare and even deliver all of the pizza for his birthday party. It was so clear to me that this woman loves her job and cared about making the pizza for the party. I had such a sense of gratitude and can see how this pizza shop goes above and beyond just the quality of their food. To that end, the quality of the pizza was outstanding! I can't wait to order it again!

What happened here? It used to be the best, but it is now ranking as one of the worst. Dough is…read morenever fully cooked, leaving a soggy mess and disgusting crust even after asking for them to cook it longer. I have given it one last chance for the last time. So sad because just a few months ago it was delicious!

Ali's is the best pizza in New Castle. It's crust is actually a raised style crust. Most of the…read morespots in New Castle have a flat crust, undercooked, floppy and lifeless. Or overcooked hard and cracker-like. Ali's crust has a great chewy lift to it. Under the sauce and toppings, the crust holds up. Biting into a slice has just the right feel, and taste as well. A flat thin crust doesn't have a flavor. It doesn't have the air in it that lets the flavor get out to you. The flavor of Ali's pizza crust is just about perfect. Like a great French or Italian crusty loaf. And no baking soda! This dough was yeast raised, like real pizza dough should be made. The sauce on this pie is also just about perfect. I hate a flat tasting sauce. Or a sauce that is too sweet or too tangy. Sauce on this pizza was just right, in taste and amount. Had a beautifully seasoned flavor which was not heavy on anything. It was center of target bullseye. Impossible to describe except to say, I liked it. A lot. Toppings... well, I had cheese and pepperoni. The cheese? It had a flavor! There was plenty of cheese too, when you get it home, hot, and pull a slice and there is enough hot gooey melty cheese to roll off the edge of the slice, and that's plenty of cheese. And it had mozzarella flavor. Not some generic cheese like a Bob's House'O'Cheese! This cheese tasted fantastic! The pepperoni was sliced thin, and covered the pie. Just the right amount for a perfect flavor and texture. First time order, after living here for nearly two years, figures. On the other hand, if I had come to Ali's for pizza first, I would have hated myself for not just getting Ali's every time. Getting Ali's after getting every.other.pie makes me feel like I had to work through all the mediocre pizza before I had finally earned the right to appreciate how good Ali's pizza is. The only extra instructions I gave when ordering was to brown the cheese that comes up over the roll of the crust. So, now that I've found pizza I like in New Castle, all I have left is changing around the toppings and whether I want the pepperoni brown on the edges, or the crust dark, or very dark. FINALLY I can stop driving to Youngstown to get Cornersburg, Belleria, Coca's or Uptown. Which if you like those, this is just as great!

I've had the pizza once and it wasn't terrible but I didn't really care for it. My wife was the one…read morewho picked it up so I didn't get a chance to go inside or see how the service is. One of these days I may give it another try seeing they have different items on their menu.

The food is wonderful and even when not in store, you can tell that the food is homemade. The guys…read morein the back are so kind and seem to truly care about what they're making and the service they are providing to their customers. The wait time is a little long but it doesn't really affect you when you know that the outcome is going to be 50x better than the wait. Great things take time. I love the feel of the shop when you go in to eat. Even with little space, it gets you closer to the action. Love Coffaro's! They are vegetarian friendly and welcoming to all eaters alike :)

Pepperoni Pizza was excellent. I didn't care much for the…read more"hot" wings. I was in the mood for wings & they were disappointing .. not hot or much flavor to them. I look forward to getting other items on the menu next time. The menu looks amazing. We will visit again.