When I asked the owner's wife why they chop -- actually mince --pizza toppings, her response made sense. "We think it tastes better this way." Personally, I think they're best served by doing it the traditional way. So we ordered a pie, half extra cheese, half pepperoni. Look at my photo. Hard to distinguish which is which. Doing a taste test, the side with pepperoni was a bit spicier, had more oomph. But, with the pepperoni chopped so fine, if I didn't know, I'd equate the taste to a richer sauce. The extra cheese side didn't appear cheesier than a regular pie. (I think back to NY's Rays Pizza -- which popped up all over the place -- known for its cheesy goodness.) Everyone's gauge of good pizza is what they grew up with. I think Fat Apple's crust is fine. Has the "fold" I look for. I also do the grease test. When grease slides off the slice -- pointy side down -- that's a good thing! Yup, theirs passed the test. While I didn't order salad, I noticed the table next to mine. Their Greek salad looked delish. And when we started chatting, the couple confirmed that it was as good as it looks. All in all, 3.4 stars. And while I'm not a regular pizza-eater, I will come back! read more

Fat Apple - Half pepperoni, half extra cheese. (Similar in appearance.) - Pizza Near Me - North Fort Myers, Florida

Meh.... We were in town camping fir a few days and didn't want to cook the first night. So we try to find a local place to get carryout from. We tried this despite mixed reviews given its proximity. Wife got the eggplant parm sub and I got a pepperoni pizza. Wife said the sub was good and commented on how good the sauce was. My pizza was meh. I saw reviews saying the toppings were "chopped up," and the little girl that took our order asked if we knew about the toppings. I said yes. But honestly, I tasted ZERO pepperoni. She asked me if I got a cheese or pepperoni pizza, so maybe it was an honest mistake. When my order was taken the little girl asked the kitchen hiw long for the order. "25 minutes or so." So I get there 25 minutes later. Only one two-top in the place, but I have to wait another minutes or so. No big deal generally, but the gentleman in the kitchen moved as fast as my dead father. So I get back to my camper less than 10 minutes later and the pizza is literally ice cold. Oh well, win some and lose some. But don't spend your $30 for a pizza and sub here. PS, the Zeppelis were good. So there's that I guess. read more

1st time here; awaiting a surprise. Arrived 7p 16" pizza- meat ball and mushrooms + Philly chicken cheese steak with onions, peppers. We support local business and try to get out of routine ruts. We pass this accessible restaurant for 6 years- time to try it. The atmosphere most pleasant with plenty of parking adjacent to a Publix. Ten tables + seats (4) at the bar with light background music. Our bill was $31.34- walk out price. The wait for pizza was over 30 minutes. Disappointed. The meatball and mushroom pizza was different. I would have envisioned small meatballs or round slices surrounded by sliced mushrooms. Please look at my 2nd picture and identify either. The cashier visually confirmed my order. My wife's sandwich was mediocre. Smaller, chopped up, bread wasn't special When I arrived there was a couple at the bar. They also waited a long 30 minutes. During the interim another couple came in. Presumably waiting on carry out while another arrived as I left. The left over pizza was good and appreciated for lunch the next day. Zeppoles read more

Fat Apple - The dining room with kitchen in the rear. - Pizza Near Me - North Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Pleasant ownership with quality pizza and salads, along with other great food. great service for a small pizza store. non-combatant, consistent quality products read more

Pizza is great, almost thin crust and tastes great. Service is fast and you get two slices and a beverage for $5.99! Eat in if you choose with ample seating and nice and clean. I recommended this place many times. Price may be $6.99 now. read more

The pizza was outstanding, both quality and amount of ingredients. I would highly recommend The Fat Apple to my friends and neighbors as an excellent choice for their pizza choice. Having never used Grubhub before, I still don't understand the delay as to delivery of the pizza but the pizza itself made up for the delay. read more

There is nothing that can improve. It should've been a sign when I walked in at dinner time on a Saturday night and there was hardly anybody there. I went there once a couple years ago and it was less than spectacular. But I figured I'd give it another chance. I ordered a small pie with extra cheese. If what I received was extra cheese, then they put no cheese on their pizza and the pie was just mediocre. I will never waste my time again, even though it's the closest restaurant to my home. read more

This is a very nice little spot at the end of the public shopping center. Staff was nice. We ordered salads and they were OK, on the way home. I ordered a pizza to take home. Once I got home and began to eat it lacked the Italian feeling to me. Again it was a pick up and so it was not hot and fresh. I'm sure that it was a very good pie when it came out of the oven and I will definitely try them again. To the owner talk with a customer you can tell the passion that they have for their sauces and their doze so I am sure it was just my tastebuds at that time read more

A year ago I would have left a 3 star review probably due to the doe being thick and after the pizza started to cool it became tough to eat. But recently it seems their crust is much thinner and to die for good. The inside is always empty which is kind of strange since they have a nice sized dining room. The staff is always very polite and friendly. This pizza in my opinion is as close as you're going to get to authentic newyork pizza in fort myers, if you love pizza this is a must try. read more

Fat Apple - Pizza Near Me - North Fort Myers, Florida

See all

I stopped by this very clean restaurant on Friday and had one of the American House Heroes sandwiches. As always, this was more than enough for lunch. These folk really know how to make great food, from pizza, chicken wings, sandwiches and everything else. The price is well below other establishments plus the owners are very nice & so friendly. This is my favorite place. read more

I phoned in my order, and the friendly person on the other end took my order, read it back to me to make sure she wrote it accurately. She said it would be ready in about 30 minutes. It was ready and waiting for me when I got there. The counter person was very nice and answered a few questions I had about other items. The restaurant was cozy and clean. The pizza was cold when I got home (45 minutes later due to an accident on 75), but it reheated beautifully! It was also delicious cold! Zeppoles were really good- not greasy and not too sweet! Great experience, and we plan to return! read more

See all

Still very good pizza. Just wish the did not chop/mince up the toppings. Will continue take our but stay with plain cheese pies. read more

We have tried just about everything on the menu, never disappointed. The pizza is NY style, which we enjoy coming from Chicago. Also the subs, wings and cheese steaks are the best. This restaurant saves my butt with my picky wife's palette every time. Also the staff is AWESOME! Great ambiance as well, highly recommend! read more

My wife was not happy with her burger, but I was satisfied with my bbq beef sandwich. Portions were good. Fries were perfect.

Great pizza and desserts! We always stop in when we are in town! Always fresh, nicely prepared food.

Just moved here from the East Coast of Florida. Tried Fat Apple & the pizza was really good. Will definitely visit again!

We decided to try this place out for the first time and we live very close by. Let's just say I'm not sure why we didn't try them sooner! It was so good! I ordered the garlic Parmesan wings and fries. Fries were amazingly hot which I love me a fresh order of fries. It's really hard to find a place that has and knows how to make a good chicken wing. They were so crispy and the garlic parmmesan sauce was amazing!! They were perfectly fried to a golden color. Perfect size wings. Not to skinny and not to fat. Way better than hotters. And that's a lot coming from me. lol you have to try them. read more

Fat Apple - Garlic Parmesan wings with fries - Pizza Near Me - North Fort Myers, Florida

We just ordered their fat five and a plain cheese and they are inedible. Cardboard crust! I couldn't even make it through a single slice of either. Their sub isn't much better. I actually just ate the meat from it the bread was so terrible. And it cost almost $70! $70 for pizza That is so bad I am throwing it away. Even bad pizza is usually still good and this isn't even better then a hot n' ready. Really upset how much money we just wasted. read more

I had lunch today and had the American House Hero sandwich. As always this is the best sandwich in Florida. Plenty of sweet tea and the owner kept it full until I departed. I also had two small house salads for a take home and they are a meal in itself. Both owners, husband and wife, make you feel as if you are part of family and that I like. Their prices are not pricy and the food quality is the best there is. Folks, you and your family won't wrong having a meal at this restaurant. read more

Awesome Pizza call them at 239-567-4743 Try their garlic knots they are delicious! They are supe nice folks and you will wonder why did I not have this pie sooner! Enjoy read more

Amazing pizza. One of the best NY style that I can find in Florida. Will drive out of the way just to pick up a couple of pies.

Great Pizza don't miss this spot if you're in the area. Beer and wine plus salad. We had a Hawaiian, Met pie and a Greek salad. So good. read more

Can't tell it's open from the outside except for a small sign in the bottom corner of the window. Lit like a bar inside but with no alcohol. Music sucks and u can't get away from it. Some new wave shit. Can't imagine they will be open long. I wanted wings but 8 isn't enough for two and the next size up is 16 which is way too many. Oh and don't think the price is correct on the menu cause it's not. It's more. read more

Whenever I get back home, I always make sure to stop in for THE BEST New York pizza outside of Manhattan. Guy is an absolute master of pizza making and as he will tell you, it starts with ingredients. Guy only sources the highest quality meats and veggies and then cuts and cooks them daily to insure the best slice ever. Aside from the pizza, the sandwiches and salads are always great but the garlic knots are almost worth the trip alone. Just wow.... a dozen will disappear in no time so consider doubling up. Finally, make sure to save room for Zeppoles! The Fat Apple is hands down the best pizza in South Flordia and as a frequesnt traveller of this country, I will put it up against any NY style slice in the country...even some in NY. The service is friendly and attentive and while they do get busy on occasion, just keep one thought in your mind as your mouth waters...It can either be quick or amazing. If you are like me and have a love for food and enjoy every bite then the answer is forever delicious. Take the extra 5 minutes and enjoy one of the top 3 slices in the country! read more

Fat Apple - Perfectly toasted mozzarella....is there anything better? - Pizza Near Me - North Fort Myers, Florida

White pizza. YES. 3.5 stars is my rating; rounding up to 4. I love white pizza, and while visiting family in my hometown of FM, discovered this local place for white pizza, which is hard to come by where I now live. (NO, white pizza is NOT made with alfredo sauce. Gag.) I like it a slightly thicker crust; this one is pretty thin. We ordered a pepperoni pizza one night (that one was for someone else, not me) and the pepperoni was actually chopped into tiny pieces that were so small they were actually barely perceptible! We were expecting normal, full size, intact pieces of pepperoni. We had to look really hard for the pepperoni and because they were so small, you could barely taste them either. Especially for what they charge, we were disappointed. I usually go the carry-out route, and appreciate the drive-up door on the side of the building ("curbside"). But I went in once for dine-in, and when our pizza was ready, they just called out to use from the counter, handed the pizza to us, and the pan was SO scalding oven-hot that my sister practically burned her palms on it. (Maybe they should rethink that process...) The pizza is decent and the menu is extensive, though I always order the same thing. I love that it's convenient to where I stay when I am here and the staff I deal with is always pleasant. It did bring back Birdie's memories, as someone else mentioned. Ahhh...Birdie's. Recommended. read more

Okay so they are from Long Island and their pizza is legit. The customer service was meh. Nice young girl but no personality and no convo. I might be back bc the pizza was a nice hand tossed, perfect crunch, and minimal grease! Suggestion, just be a little more welcoming ‍. Y'all sell pizza but relationships will keep your business going. read more

Cannot say enough about Birdie's re-emerging here! What a great surprise. We finally got over there to take home a large white pie and it did NOT disappoint! This pizza checked every box! Will be getting our fix on the regular!! Thanks Fat Apple - glad we learned who is really running the show! I was so sad when Birdies closed. read more

If your looking for a good pizza, look elsewhere. I ordered a large veggie, I've had some bad pizza's in the past. But this was in the top 2 of worst I've ever had. I love a good crust. This was more like eating a dog bone. I gave it to my dog, and he was going at it for 2 minutes. I gave him the 2nd crust and he started choking. My dog can devour anything (except this pizza crust) I wish I was joking, but this was really really bad. I ordered 2 subs, meatball and chicken Parmesan. They were better than the pizza, but very bland. Chicken parm tasted like it was frozen, not homemade. Meatball was bland and mushy. If you want a better pizza than this, look in Google for a pizza place near you, I'm sure it will be better than this pizza. Again, this pizza place was one of the worst I've ever had. read more

If you want a real NY pizza this is the place try the double doe pizza you will be amazed if u like a thicker crust! read more

Fat Apple - Pizza Near Me - North Fort Myers, Florida

Tried for the 1st time tonight. It was so queit inside the tiny restaurant it should have been my 1st clue! The service was terrible! You order at a counter and then they call your name to get your food. Everything was served on paper plates but they had real sliverware! We ordered garlic knots with sauce. Knots are small and VERY salty! Sauce was bland. Got a 16" pie with sausage. The sausage was too finely chopped. Barely any cheese and again VERY salty!! Salt should not be the 1st thing you taste in italian food. Very disappointed! read more

Fat Apple - 16" sausage pie - Pizza Near Me - North Fort Myers, Florida

When I asked the owner why the staff that interacts with the public is not wearing masks, the answer was "We don't have to." When I tried to engage about the meaning of 'asymptomatic', she said they advise people that feel sick to get a test and then walked away from me. They don't care if they infect their vulnerable customers. Not a place i want to give my business. I won't be going back. I did pay for the take-out pizza, it was just 'okay'. read more

Wanted to share our experience at Fat Apple last night. They gave us the wrong items as a carry out after waiting 20 minutes after they said it would be done . Went back to return the food and the owner (husband) was really rude and trying to say we ordered the wrong item. Argued that a calzone doesn't have meat in it. Simply untrue and we asked for meat which was not inside either of the two calzones. He was super reluctant to refund the money and said feel free to go somewhere else next time. We live in the community right next to the establishment and it is the general consensus with the whole community that the food is sub par on top of being treated poorly as a paying customer. Their hired help took the phone order and was clearly the reason for the mishap. We have been there a few times and enjoyed the owners (wife) conversation. Long story short, his choice of response has resulted in us never going back there in the future. read more

Great pizza spot! Friendly and family owned! And they have zeppoles! Can't get any better than that. read more

Fat Apple - Zeppoles best ever! So glad to find a good pizza spot and that they make zeppoles! A must try! - Pizza Near Me - North Fort Myers, Florida

We drive here because the article I read said it was birdies recipes. While the pizza was ok, it was not what we recall as being Birdies. The service was pleasant and friendly and the place was very clean. read more

Just saw they finally opened. Placed 2 pizza orders. One 1/2 Sicilian with pepperoni. The other was just a regular. When I got there to pick up I expected to smell some yummy garlic. You know, it's a pizzaria. Well, it was very faint. The place looks fantastic. Small but nice. I collected up our pizzas and I shelled out $38+. I forgot that I also ordered some Zeppoli. They're pizza dough knots fried up with powdered sugar. Still. It was expensive. As we dug into our pizzas at home I noticed how tough the dough was. Even my regular pie was very dry. Definitely lacking olive oil and garlic. Husbands Sicilian was super dry and he couldn't find the pepperoni. Paid for extra cheese on both. Never saw it. I'm going to give their sandwiches a try before I condemn them. I like my pies softer, bigger and with lots of garlic and oil. Jersey Shore style...... watch your shirt! read more

Delicious. Just had this pizza for the first time as The company for which I work just moved near by. It has taking me a very long time to find pizza that is as good as back in NJ. The closest I have found is DHOP, which in my opinion, is excellent pizza; but Fat Apple has thinner crust that I desire! Def worth the price and the trip from Alva. Perfect crust, sauce, cheese ratio. read more

Cute place with a cafe feel in a strip mall. So fresh and the crust is tender and chewy. We had the NY White Pie and added garlic, basil and tomatoes. Next time we'll leave the tomatoes off, they were good but just ordinary chopped tomatoes. I guess I was expecting sun-dried. I can't wait to finish my leftovers so we can reorder! read more

See all

So good! After so many peoples recommendations we finally tried it and we will be back ! read more

The large cheese or pepperoni pizza is loved by our famiky of six. Have ordered mutiple times and always consistently good. Same as Birdies pizza that used to be off US41 by Edison Mall years ago. My son lives the boneless chicken wings there too. read more

Pizza Was excellent. Wings and fries were very good. Didn't appreciate the fact that every single thing you order when you dine in they want you to pay for immediately. And they upcharge 50 cents every time they run your card for every single transaction. Hence we order a pizza they charge us 50 cents on top of the pizza then we decided we wanted wings and fries they charged 50 cents again then I ordered a beer a charge 50 cents again ordered a second beer charge an extra 50 cents again every single time period they won't run at all on one check. Unfortunately for the girl who is doing it it came out of her tip. Next time we'll get take out. read more