Throwback to my teens! Same quality and delicious pizza exactly as I recall. Service was excellent…read more Ambiance is how I remember Noble Romans. Do yourself a favor and dine- in!

We went on a drive and ended up in Columbus and stopped here for lunch. As a disabled person i…read morediscovered that the strip mall owner does not much worry about people with disabilities. The workers did care and were helpful. I would say that this restaurant was a fast food place for pizzas. They limited their offerings to keep the customer limited to choices. The pizza was not greasy and was eatable. if you are looking for something quick and eatable here it is.

Service was great. The room was empty. Lots of doordashers came by. The food was good. We got…read morespaggetti and meatballs and pulled pork mac.

Ok I would usually try to say that I understand that even the best place has a off day. That some…read moredays are more stressful than we would all like. BUT IF YOU CAN'T MASTER FREAKING "NOODLES " AND THE TASTELESS CRAP THAT YOU ADD WATER TOO. I didn't want to seem like I was yelling there but I was. Listen it's great to see a company that is hiring felons everyone deserves a 2nd,3rd 4th chance. My wife had something like pesto yes it was green and had the feel of wet coffee grounds on your tongue. What had didn't have any taste other the tears of the whole country of Italy mixed in a plastic bowl with some felony sweat. Oh and what I think was supposed to be chicken. But oh the one bright side of this disgusting mistake is that. Now I am going to be nice here when I saw FOOD. Left me and my wife very quickly and helped removed everything else from me and her's system. Yep at 2 gas stations and 3 times last night twice this morning. So thank you noodles and company for the wonderful weight loss program and the worst night of sleep in have had for years.

Stopped by for the buffet they have at lunch! The staff is really friendly and are accommodating,…read morethey even offer military discount! The food was really good value and their desert pizza is one of the best things I've ever had! I'll definitely be back next time I'm at drill!

The pizza is always hot and fresh and the environment here is amazing. The manager is one of nicest…read morepeople I've met!!!

Fantastic. Great and fast service even when busy. It's nice to have sandwich choices in town and…read morethis is a good one.

So glad they opened in Colombus. The service and food were great. Friendly and quick service. What…read moreI expected and more.

My boyfriend and I have been going to five guys for 9 years, spending like $40-80 a month; you can…read moredo the math. We decided we won't be going back after tonight due to poor food quality and lack of customer service. I was just at columbus five guys around 5pm 01-10-2024 and ordered 1 little cheese burger, 1 regular cheese burger and 1 little fry . First I'll explain the fry issue then the burger issue. To set the scene: we come in to an EMPTY dining room. 2 couples came in from the time we sat to the time we left. Meaning they were NOT BUSY, in fact they were dead for 5pm! Little fry was $4.35+tax. When we got the bag we were extremely surprised by the LACK of fries. There were like 14 fries in all haha! It was literally JUST the small tiny white container of fries , no extra. We have been going for 9 years and always get more dumped in, like extra fries at the bottom of the bag... so we're like "maybe with inflation they can't do the usual amount?" Which we would have been understanding of - we were totally cool with it at first and mentioned eventually it might happen. We decided to ask for confirmation. I got up from eating and walked to the food grab table where the young teen boy who was manning the fry station stood, and asked "have you changed the amount of fries you give customers for little fries?" He responds: "no" . (No other inquiry back, no "how can I help you".) I say "we are used to getting like a healthy helping in the bag, bottom of bag full of fries". Teen boy responds by just *smirking* and *shrugging his shoulders* at me. No words spoken at all, so I just go back and sit down. The response blowing us off is what really pissed my boyfriend off and I! We are like 15yrs older than this boy and always very careful with not coming off as Karen's. My boyfriend and I believe that as soon as a customer is even remotely sharing unhappiness, go get the shift lead. Don't smirk and shrug at customers! We didn't recognize this boy, but the other workers are usually so friendly and chitchat with us about so much; they even know our order by heart because we literally were going once a week for like a year in 2022 haha.. then we tried to ween to once a month. But the way he just blew me off and wouldn't offer more than ONE word to us was weird & surprising to us and the other 2 employees (whom we didn't recognize either) acted like nothing was amiss and ignored my standing there and my comment about the fries. We continued to eat but it wasn't good because our bread was stale (possibly not enough butter during toasting because it was like hard & dry but still white and flaking off, not golden buttery toasted and not keeping integrity . ), the cheese was not melted - it was cold cheese; not drooping over the sides of the burger, just sticking straight out like a square and cold. This cheese occurrence has happened to us a handful of times in the past year and we were already getting weary that food quality was going downhill...and lastly, the hamburgers were dry, not yummy, not dripping with oil like we love ha!. Reminder: they were dead slow, we ordered food in an EMPTY dining room and then only 2 couples came in staggered in the duration we ate. They were not swamped. They had plenty of time to get the food right, especially for dine-in. If a DM or GM reads this, check your receipts for timestamp proof. We wanted to go up and give them the burgers back and explain about the quality issues, but after that response we just knew there was no reason. My boyfriend commented "place is going downhill". The fry teen kept looking at us while we ate like he knew we were unhappy, so I kept thinking he was going to ask the shift lead to come to our table, to save the customer satisfaction, but nope! he never did anything or let anyone know that we were possibly unhappy, he just kept staring at us. . It was really awkward and frustrating . We are the type of people to ask 1 time, give 1 chance and then we drop it. We don't go harp over and over again, we just gracefully tap out - so we are tapping out of this. No more five guys for us.

Food was mediocre, at best. We were so excited due to how much they pushed how amazing the fries…read morewere only to receive fries that tasted like they were cooked in old oil and had been sitting. Not good at all. It was so expensive too! Very disappointed and will not be back.

Sunday evening birthday dinner. Food was great and the service was excellent. A good value and…read morefamily friendly!

I think I was the first to arrive for lunch at 11:15 am. The multiple dining rooms looked in tip…read moretop shape with their usual dark wood furniture. Their dining rooms are always welcoming and a comfortable place to eat your meal. They afford more privacy than most places too. Service was very fast all around. I was greeted immediately upon walking through the door. My server, Jennifer, was super attentive. All of the food arrived quickly. I ordered the Admiral's Feast which is Walt's Favorite Shrimp, Wild-Caught Flounder, Clam Strips and Bay Scallops, all fried to a golden-brown. For the two sides, I went with the Steamed Broccoli and the Coleslaw. I am a big time fan of shrimp and have been for years but today the clam strips were the number one item on this huge seafood platter. They were cooked perfectly and tasted awesome! I could have easily ate a second portion of them before devouring everything else. Every fried item was good. They had a light and crunchy breading that tasted pretty good. The steamed broccoli was superb with its generous buttery coating. The coleslaw portion was huge; way more than I could eat but a nice compliment to the large meal I ordered. I did not taste the complimentary bread on the table. For dessert I ordered the Vanilla Bean Cheesecake. The whipped cream topping had shavings of the vanilla beans. I don't recall seeing that before and I think it made the vanilla flavor stand out even more. Vanilla is my favorite flavor and this dessert hit the spot. The restrooms were clean with auto motion flushing. Parking was plentiful in their private lot. The lobsters were living in clean water in the lobby aquarium ;-)

3 weeks under new ownership and we think they are on the right track -we drive over from…read moreShelbyville a few times a yr and stopped in today for dinner. Lisa was still there from previous ownership, she does a great job and is attentive and friendly. The new owner came out and spent about 5 min with us discussing other Gatti locations and his vision for improvements here in Martinsville. On our way out the owners wife spoke out from the kitchen. thanking us for coming in. Food was good as always and per request of my wife they put in a fresh BBQ Chicken Pizza. Salad bar was fresh and well stocked. We will for sure make the effort to visit again before the summer is over ! Good luck to the new owner and effort to make Gattis an even better better place to eat!

Well Mr. Gatti's is again under new management. Not Good! They are more concerned about cutting…read moretheir cost of making the Pizza than the quality (Cutting back the ingredients 'it takes to producing a quality Pizza, told your staff to use less sauce on the pizza. ) The BBQ Pizza is undoubtably the worst I have ever tasted) along with other Basic Pizzas offered on your buffet. Don't worry about your Cheese Sause and the cost of placing your lit up signs around the city use your money and improve your Pizzas!. in asking other customers of yours their opinion, they agree you suck! You can be "The Best" again instead of cheapening your products!!

Love this place !!! no surprises just consistent great quality food ever time…read more Been eating here since the 1980's if I remember correctly Best Italian restaurant in Columbus with reasonable prices a good selection on their menu don't pass up this place

Pizza was just what I was looking for, NY style and delicious. Owner and staff were friendly and…read moreattentive.