We had an unforgettable experience at this restaurant while celebrating my grandpa's late birthday…read more From the moment we arrived, the staff were very friendly and kind. What I'm most appreciative of, is when my grandma, who wasn't feeling well that day, assisted our family with helping get a trash can so my grandma didn't get sick on herself. The staff who worked today was patient, attentive, and genuinely compassionate, helping her without ever making her feel like a burden. That level of humanity is rare and deeply appreciated. Our food was great and the service was the amazing and will be remembered by all of us! We'll always be grateful and will absolutely be back. The last time I ate here was 13-14 years ago and I'm glad I came back again with the family. My Nana loves those butter squares & bread. :) Kim S. was very friendly and kind. #1 server!!! Thanks for taking our photos!

Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere right off the square…read more Someone told me there were no good restaurants in Russellville. Wrong. This joint had excellent food. We started with the fried cheese ravioli appetizer. Two thumbs up. Way up. And they bring out bread with it that soaks up that extra sauce so well. It is the perfect complement to that appetizer. For the main meal, we went with the Baked Mac Poseidon, Chicken Parmigiano, Meatball Marinara, and Eggplant Parmigiano. The chicken and meatballs here are fantastic. The eggplant was maybe the best I've ever had. Anywhere. The Baked Mac was the only dish I didn't love, and that stems from the fact that I have never liked mixing cheese and seafood. If that's your thing, I say go for it. As a bonus, these guys can make a pretty good Bloody Mary. I'll be back. If you're driving anywhere near the county seat of Logan, it's worth a stop. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised.

We had 10 inch pizzas and the lemon cake. Everything was delicious and the deep dish crust was…read moregreat! I wish I had gotten two of these pieces of cake! Also loved the cherry vanilla old fashioned sofas

Best pizza I've had in a long time. Flavors and sauce take me back to my youth. Highly recommend…read morethe pizza, spaghetti, lasagna.

Absolutely outstanding - my family are staying at a nearby hotel for the night, and because my…read morehusband will be on a work trip on Father's Day, we decided to stop in because he loves Italian food. First of all, our waitress, Hannah, was SO nice - she checked on us often, was able to answer our questions, served us as quickly as she was able, AND she worked with me on my unique special request. Second, the atmosphere is so homey. There was Oldies on the radio, the lights weren't too bright, and the smell of the food just made me feel so comfortable. Third, their food was so good - we ordered fried mushrooms and garlic olive oil dipping sauce for our bread as appetizers, my husband ordered pasta, and I had a Sicilian pizza. The bread was soft and fresh, the mushrooms had the most delicious breading, the olive oil was flavorful, and my husband and I were in love with our entrees!! The entree portions are really large, too, so I'm actually really happy we're going to be able to enjoy their food again haha. Lastly, they were extremely courteous when it came to our still working on our food just past close - Hannah even made us feel at ease when she offered us dessert and I'd almost turned her down because it had just turned closing time (their tiramisu is SOOO good, by the way). We're not sure if were going to be in the area ever again, but if we ever come this way again, we're definitely stopping in for a meal. This place deserves all the praise!!

Food was great had muscles, lasagna, chicken fettuccine, stuffed shells and cannolis must get…read morebread. Our server was wonderful. Great atmosphere and friendly people. A must try!!! Hanna was the best!!!!!

What an absolute delight!…read more We walked in on a Saturday night without reservations & were immediately sat. They were so cool about it. Before I talk about the food let me tell you about the ambiance. Classy, clean, cool - am I in NYC or Murray, KY?! And the music selection surprised me at every turn. Nick Drake? Yes, please! For starters, it was happy hour & wine was $7 a glass. The cab was delicious. A perfect selection, poured fresh table-side. The starter kale salad with fresh fennel bulb was a testament to the goodness of God's creation. I crave that salad daily. House-made pasta - need I say more? The chicken in my mushroom pasta dish was house-roasted, you could taste it! And the mushrooms were so fresh and fragrant- the way mushrooms should be eaten. The red/sauce sausage pasta my daughter got was just the right amount of spicy. The next day I mixed our two pasta leftovers together & that was a real treat! For dessert we had the flourless chocolate torte which was the perfect ending to the perfect meal. I'm already planning my next meal when I visit Murray next weekend! Oh, also! They used Oneida Michelangelo silverware - the fancy stuff my parents used at home growing up. So that was special

Excellent food and great service. We loved the Caesar Salad! Alfredo with fresh Turkey Tail and…read moreOyster mushrooms atop Chicken...Amazingly tasty.

If you are looking for authentic, house-made Italian comfort food, you will love this restaurant…read more The ambiance was comfortable and quiet, making it an ideal choice for a relaxed dinner where you can actually hear the person across the table. I had the House Sampler, which is a great chance to try several different menu items: Lasagna, Chicken Parmesan, and Fettuccine Alfredo. The Lasagna and Chicken Parmesan were excellent--perfectly seasoned and clearly prepared with fresh, house-made ingredients. The Fettuccine Alfredo was good and served as a nice, creamy addition to the plate. My wife had the manicotti and thought it was great; it's definitely a winner if you're a fan of stuffed pasta. What really made the night was our server, Marin. She was great--professional, friendly, and incredibly attentive. We never had an empty glass, our items were served hot and accurate, and she checked on us regularly to see if we needed anything. It's rare to find service this seamless. Between the quality of the house-made dishes and the top-tier service from Marin, we had a wonderful experience.

I gave this place 2 tries and won't be going back. The first time my food was fine however my…read moregirlfriends lobster ravioli (not near an ocean so we let it slide) just tasted like freezer & wasn't even the same temp as the sauce it was served with. The second time, we were seated fairly quickly; service was pretty slow after that. Food was given out at vastly different times. I had my full salad and my meal came with a second round of bread before my girlfriends plate. The person serving our food also had chipped nail polish and smelled of urine. Our waitress also kept disappearing towards the end of our meal. They clearly focus on larger parties (not more than 5) because we were only checked on once the entire time. I had to wait an extra 15mins just to get my check.

Inedible, absolutely awful, overpriced, garbage called "food". Was told to wait 40 minutes for pick…read moreup order and showed up on time for cold food. Do not recommend in the slightest

Fantastic food!....pizza is tasty and made by scratch and Oven cooked....NO pre-made pre-formed or…read morefrozen crust here....2 thumbs up!

The food is good but not great, and they tack on a MANDATORY 20% gratuity, and a 3.99% add on for…read morethe use of any kind of card. If it weren't for my friends who really like the crab cakes, I'd have absolutely no reason to eat there. Maybe I won't be able to make it next time...

Service was very iffy on a holiday weekend…read more Good food. (I have to add more characters to post this review, so I feel like our party of 12 got ignored. No refills. Naive hosts and waiters. And then a forced tip. Felt like the forced tip was a reason to be ignored. We were polite, we asked and waited, but the establishment was not ready. We had a reservation..... They failed. This might have been a one time issue, but it most definitely made us all feel unwelcome.

We were in Bowling Green to visit Beech Bend and we wanted some Italian food. We saw Cafe Italia…read morewas highly rated on both Google and Yelp, so we decided to come here. I started with a soup, while my brother started with a salad. They were served with these garlic rolls, which were absolutely delicious to eat both alone and with the soup. Then came time for the entrees. I got the Sausage and Pepper Parmigiana, while my brother got the Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken. My Sausage and Pepper Parmigiana had a delicious mix of flavor and spice which I enjoyed every bite of, while my brother enjoyed his Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken. Additionally, we had thought from looking online that this would be one of our pricier meals out, but Cafe Italia actually ended up being a great value, as our meals included a soup or salad and rolls, and the portions were so generous, I needed to pack some of my entree away to eat in the morning. In short, we wholeheartly recommend Cafe Italia, both because the food is excellent but also because the portions are so large they are an excellent value. We are glad we chose to go here and would definitely come back here if in the area again.

Cafe Italia has quickly become one of my favorite restaurants in Bowling Green. From the moment you…read morewalk in, the atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and perfect for a date night or dinner with family and friends. The food is absolutely outstanding--everything tastes fresh, homemade, and full of flavor. The portions are generous, and you can tell they take pride in every dish they serve. The homemade bread and pasta are worth the visit alone! The service was just as impressive. Everyone was friendly, attentive, and made us feel genuinely appreciated as customers.