Ok pizza, the crust isn't the best but I'm happy to say that they have vegan cheese so I appreciate that! It was super pricey and very small. This place was dead and awkward upon coming in, the pizzas came out so fast that after we poured our drinks and sat down it was ready. They weren't lying about the pizza oven temp, it was hot and fresh. read more

Fire Crust - Aloha Pizza with vegan cheese - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

See all

Delivery took over an hour from the time it left the restaurant. No attempt was made to even keep it warm. It arrived room temperature and virtually inedible. Avoid. read more

We ordered pizza and wings to take back to our hotel to have while watching the World Cup. The food was incredible. Pizza was perfect for a thin crust with just enough toppings. The wings were meaty and the sauce was just right. The staff was super friendly when I picked it up. Definitely would go back there if we're in the area again. read more

True Fire Brick Pizza. It's soo good. The staff are very friendly. I would come back again as a regular now.

Hmm maybe it was a bad day here but this pizza was not good. The staff were very friendly and explained how ordering works. Unlimited toppings on a pizza for $14.45 and there was a huge selection of toppings! I was able to make two different pizza types for my halves. I tried the bbq chicken and Margherita no basil. The bbq chicken was much better than the Margherita topping wise and taste. The real turn off was the crust. It was horrible. It was very very very thin, cripsy, chewy (in a bad way) and taste like eating a dry stale cracker with no flavor. It ruined the pizza for me so I just pulled the toppings off. I also felt the margherita could have had a little better cheese to sauce ratio (I know margherita is classically as pictured but its a little too bare from how I've seen it at other places). I didnt watch him make the pizzas unfortunately. read more

See all

food great, but not worth it when the staff is rude and disrespectful. I was a regular customer but not worth my time or money if they treat customers like that. good luck! read more

Very cutsie, very demure. We're not from the area so this wasn't the kind of vibe we were anticipating (to go style) we were searching for more of a sports bar but this place is a gem! We ate the pizza either way and it was 10/10 with my little seltzer :) Also super sweet workers read more

The pizza came quickly and tasted great! We put a variety of different toppings and liked that you didn't have to pay too much extra.

What a nice little place. The pizza was fantastic and flavorful. It think the pizza over enhances the flavor of the pizza. The staff was nice. Bathrooms were clean. You could basically build your own pizza and choose whatever toppings you like. It was great. I would eat here again for sure. read more

I ordered pizza and wings for delivery. This is the first time I've tried Fire Crust. The delivery was fast, better than most places that deliver. I ordered the Im Meating Pizza. It was great, one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. The crust was tasty and not bland like every other pizza place around. The sauce and toppings all had great flavors. I also got the Fire Roasted Wings, garlic parm. These were the absolutely worst wings I've ever had. Rubbery, chewy, and the skin didn't even have a hint of crispness to it. It was as if they were cooked in a pot of boiling water. I'll go here for pizza, but will pass on the wings. read more

Fire Crust is my new go to for CYO pizzas. I hate to compare, but this establishment blows every other wood fired pizza joint out of the water. The toppings are endless! Over 6 different type of cheeses, over twenty different toppings, the possibilities are endless! I mean really - roasted broccoli? How cool! For a reasonable price of $10.75, customers can add as many toppings as they like. Did I mention - they serve Pittsford Dairy ice cream?! Pizza and ice cream? They have won my heart. read more

Fire Crust - a man preparing food in a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

See all

pizza is great, many different toppings, I got my pizza very fast and workers were very nice.

This place truly exceeded all expectations. I didn't know anything about Fire Crust when we walked in. I had the chicken Tikka Masala pizza and we tried the BBQ chicken pizza. Every aspect of the pizza was top notch. The spicy sauce on the Tikka Masala pizza was zesty. The chicken, by itself was quite spicy but very nicely balanced when eaten on the pizza. The crust had the perfect bready but thin texture. Besides the great food, the staff was fantastic. Friendly and they worked well together. I thought it must be a very new place because everything was sparkling and new looking but it's a 4 year old place. Truly a 5 star experience. read more

worst experience ordering pizza ever. never again. delivery driver left 120 dollars worth of pizza on my porch and didn't knock on the door. went to the restaurant and Alexis thought it was funny and that it wasn't their problem. Ask for food to be remade and it was up to me to contact door dash or uber eats . I ordered on the company website. not uber eats. Took over 3 hours of phone calls to get figured out and my guests left before it was figured out. Was a big joke to the kids running the store without supervision. Everyone pointed fingers at someone else. Never again. Don't order from this place and never choose delivery unless you are okay getting porch pizza read more

Listen. I love this place, and that's saying a lot. It may not be true Neapolitan pizza, but it is good wood-fired pizza, for a more than reasonable price, and with all the toppings you could ask for, in an insane variety. They don't charge for extra toppings, and are happy to split a pizza with two completely different halves. Service is very friendly, and they have some great local sodas to try as well. The Paneer Tikka is my current go-to here, and it's great with a little spicy buffalo sauce, and spicy honey. Swap it out to fresh mozzarella, and add some ricotta, and it's absolutely to die for. I don't tend to order extra for leftovers, but here, I do. I'll get a whole other pizza for next day's lunch. Nothing beats day of, but it's still pretty damn good after. read more

Fast personal size pizza with creative options. We were pleasantly surprised to find four selections of beer on tap. Pizza was fired up exactly as we ordered and customer service was friendly and attentive, starting with the hello we received walking in the door. Will be back. read more

Love that I've found this place it deserves way more business than it gets. I haven't had pizza in so long because of a gluten issue and this was the first time I've gotten to enjoy pizza again without a flare up. Love their gluten free pizza and the options are endless. Always clean, really nice environment and the service is phenomenal . Employees are so fast, kind, yet did everything possible to make it accurate and the way we wanted. I also personally enjoy the ice cream part I think that's a unique combination that works together and their options are endless. A twist on some usual options with flavors I've also never seen before. (Lemon Oreo is so good). Easily has become a go to stop whenever visiting the city now. read more

Stopped in last week for pizza and left very satisfied. You can order online and pick-up via drive-thru window which is quick and easy. I got the create your own pizza with spicy red sauce, chicken tikka and plenty of veggies. The spices on the chicken and sauce went great with the crispy crust. Crust was average thickness, perfect amount of char on edges. Staff was very attentive and friendly. Pizza was ready quick (10 minutes from ordering to leaving). They have numerous Pittsford dairy hard ice cream, sundae options. They also have soft custard (currently not offered till March 2019 as winter season). Great addition to the area, stop in and give them a try. read more

Fire Crust - Create your own pizza with Chicken Tikka, plenty of veggies and yes pineapple! So Good! - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

A new pizza place near my work and home??? yes please! I had high hopes when this place opened and I was not disappointed! Fresh made to order pizza in a few short minutes! There are a few of set menu pizza choices listed on the chalk board to order from such as buffalo chicken, the white out, Pesto chicken but I prefer to do the create your own option. Unlimited toppings for one price, $9.75. The size is great, 6 slices... for lunch and leftovers. They offer a few different sauces to put on your pizza once its cooked. A few drink options include fountain soda, bottles of beer and some beer on tap. Pittsford dairy ice cream is available ( one of the best around) Plenty of inside seating at tables or a counter looking outside. When the weather is nice take advantage of the few outside tables. read more

See all

Such variety! There are certainly a few customizable wood fired pizza spots in the area now, but I have to say I think fire crust takes the cake with the variety of toppings. While the staff seemed pretty new when I dined in, the pizzas came out delicious. Would absolutely be back. read more

See all

If you like artisan pizza then this place is for you. Pizza wise, its very similar to some other hot spots around Rochester (think Pizza Favo, or Pi Crust). Same trend of walking down the line and picking your toppings and BOOM... pizza is ready in 3 minutes. My first go around I added some sun dried tomatoes to my pepperoni and mushroom pizza. WOW did those suckers burn. Guess they cant with stand the 3 minute oven. Anyway, lots of topping, and sauces to add before and after your pizza. My note to the management staff.... Please add garlic powder to your options. Fire Crust is also offering wings, but I have yet to have them. I did have their Pittsford Dairy ice cream though. They say there are more menu items to come.... Keep an eye on that menu! read more

See all

I'm going with a 3 star rating.  3.5 is probably more accurate. I was on a road trip this weekend and drove by Lehigh Station, so I decided to try this place out.  I was behind two people in line who had also never been here before, so they explain the process to you, so don't be afraid to try it out. I'm not adventurous with pizza, and I don't eat meat, so there's not much I get on it besides cheese and tomatoes.  I got white sauce, mozzarella and ricotta.  They had sundried tomatoes and cherry tomatoes, so I tried a little of both.  I would have preferred sliced roma tomatoes, but that wasn't an option.  They rang us all out, and it probably took 5 minutes for the pizzas to cook, which was fine.  I got a basil drizzle on at the end, and they also had ranch for dipping, which I was excited about. The crust was a little burned, and I had to rip pieces of it off.  I was not a fan of the sundried tomatoes, and they were pretty gummy, so I also took those off.  I ate the cherry tomatoes on a few slices, but I wasn't really a fan of them either, so I ended up taking those off.  When I was done, I had a plate full of burned crust, left over crust, and tomatoes, lol. What I did eat was pretty good.  I liked the ricotta a lot.  I prefer a thicker crust, but I knew it was thin crust pizza.  I was really excited about the ranch, but it wasn't good ranch.  You know when ranch tastes like a cross between ranch and blue cheese, and you're not really sure what it is?  That's how this ranch tasted, so I didn't eat much of it, either.  About $11 for a pizza with white sauce, ricotta and mozzarella is a lot, so I don't think I'll be going to this place again. They also had free Wifi, but it was password protected, and I couldn't find the password anywhere.  It wasn't on my receipt or on the wall or the table.  I meant to ask when I picked up my pizza, but I forgot, and I had sat down by the time I remembered.  I didn't feel like leaving my food alone to go get it.  I was able to guess it, but when a place offers free Wifi, I think it shouldn't be password protected, or the password should be easy to find. To compare it to Pi Craft, I've been there about 4 times.  Each pizza I had was good, and I preferred their crust.  I also preferred their tomatoes, and the basil drizzle they used.  I don't think they have ranch for dipping, but I didn't like the one at Fire Crust anyway, so they're even there.  If choosing between the two, I'd go to Pi Craft for sure.  That is based on personal preference though.  I would say service at both is pretty equal.  The seating area at Fire Crust is nicer, so they win there. read more

Fire Crust - My pizza with white sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, sundried tomatoes and cherry tomatoes. - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

See all

I have been here a handful of times and have never left unsatisfied! The staff is always very friendly and eager to assist. I usually do the CYO pizza and get my favorite toppings! So good! Today I tried the Chicken Tikka Pizza and it was delicious! It had all my favorite Tikka flavors with the joy and convenience of being on a pizza slice and topped with mozzarella cheese! My mom tried the Buffalo Chicken pizza which was also delicious! We were very pleased with our lunch today. We also love the ambiance of the place. Very rustic pizzeria and great tunes! read more

See all

First time at Fire Crust with family! Wow! Great pizza. Ordered four pizzas and chicken wings. All were delicious!! Very nice and helpful staff with a clean and attractive dining area. Thank you! We will be back. read more

I had to go and check to see if that cauliflower crust was regular gluten pizza. I couldn't tell the difference! It was so good! I got a veggie pizza with pesto sauce and no cheese. They made me feel "normal"! read more

I was the only one there at 5:30 which made me a little skeptical. They were cleaning at the time so the place was clean. The young lady who took my order was very polite. I ordered a I'm meating pie and six wings. The pizza was a 7/10 but the wings were maybe a 4/10. They had decent flavor but the texture was really odd, spongey maybe. I'd go back for the pizza but not the wings read more

We have been here a couple times. The staff is friendly and attentive. I love that there are so many options for vegan and gluten free diets. read more

First time to Fire Crust and certainly not our last. We had the Classic Margherita with extra fresh mozzarella and extra basil for under $10! It was absolutely delicious. The place was busy and the staff was quick and very friendly. For quick pizza, I can't say I've had any better. Love the look of the place too. They have specialty pizzas, build your own pizza, wings, beer, wine, fountain drinks and Pittsford Dairy Ice Cream! read more

See all

Their website is organized well for online orders and they are always fast and nice! Their stone oven pizza is always perfect and their wings and ice cream also are amazing read more

We stopped by for the first time after trying to find a place to eat as we don't live in the area. We got the Buffalo chicken and chicken tikka pizza. They were so good. And the service was fantastic, everyone was friendly. We will definitely be back read more

Fire Crust - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

See all

Drove by this place a bunch of times while it was being built. Finally decided to check them out. Felt warm and inviting inside. Staff was very friendly and attentive. Just got the basic cheese and pepperoni and my mom got some wings. The pizza was really good. Dough was really fresh with a chewy airy texture to it, which I prefer. Sauce was good. Just the right amount. Some might like it to be a little lighter. My mom said wings were ok. I'm not a big fan of baked wings. Ordered the orange float. The girl didn't know what that was and it basically ended up being a vanilla shake with a hint of orange. Thats ok though..overall if I had to choose a place in Henrietta this would be my new go to. read more

Fire Crust - Baked wings - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

Well worth the 5 min drive off the highway. Fresh and delicious! The staff was very friendly as well. A++++++

Friendly staff, delicious pizza, comparable prices to other local fast pizza shops. I got a basic margarita pizza which was delicious! It was a little disorganized at times but they just opened. There is a seperate line for pizza and ice cream. It would be nice if they put a sign saying pizza line starts here and ice cream line starts here. The cashier is in the middle and is used for both sides. Besides that the atmosphere and decor is awesome and there is plenty of seating - even some outside! Will definitely be back! read more

I really really really want to give this place a bomb review but I think I'd prefer to pick Blaze Pizza or other pizza spots over this. Or maybe I'd need to switch up on some of my topping choices onto the pizza. But yall, this place looks really dope with the word artworks that you can read & take photos for Instagram. I'm actually impressed​ with the look of it and the style of choice​ to create your pizza is a cool concept even though almost every pizza spot​ in Rochester does the same​ thing. When I look at all of the ingredients they provide, it's​ extremely common as the other places have but their places have more favorable​ gourmet ingredients​ that​​ I personally​ appreciate​. BUT they have ice cream! I soooo wish I could grab some of that before I left, next time I will try it. I decided to go a simple route with spicy red sauce, topped with fresh mozzarella​ cheese, red onions, sun-dried​ tomato, minced garlic, and baby arugula​. It was okay, it didn't really wow me compared to other pizzas I've tried. The crust was as crusty as it should be, the spicy red sauce​ wasn't​ spicy as I thought it would be, and the toppings were the only thing that I love love love. And when I went online to learn about their​ restaurant, I came across to their menu and they have VEGAN cheese, I wish they were more vocal on that because​ I did not see anything about them providing vegan ingredients​. Good place but next time, I will try with different toppings including​ the vegan cheese and their​ ice cream as well!! read more

Fire Crust - Red Spicy Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Red Onions, Minced Garlic, Sun-Dried Tomato, & Babg Arugula - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

It's good, but in my opinion, Fire Crust is not as shockingly good and well priced as other reviewers have ranted and raved about on here. I mean kudos to the unlimited toppings on what is actually a small sized pizza. That's a plus, but for someone who doesn't like a lot of toppings, this isn't a huge deal. The pizza (sauce, crust) isn't great either. It's just an average pizza with the option for personalization; that you have to pay for regardless of the type of pizza you choose (toppings or no toppings). I was quite disappointed with their soft drink selection. This girl likes name-brand sodas. Though there off-brand sodas were good, I don't intend on going out of my way to try the:3 sodas again (or purchase them) - and if I'm paying over $2 for a beverage, I'd prefer to get at least an option for a classic Coca-cola. Ice-cream was okay. I'm a sucker for soft-served, but I couldn't finish my cup of soft-served here. It was much too soupy and foamy, but had a good flavor overall. The restaurant layout was a tad nerve-racking. There was no real division between the order area, waiting area, and dining area. It made eating uncomfortable when people waiting in line to order were literally a foot behind your chair. I believe a physical room divider added into the floor plan and the moving of tables could potentially solve this problem - and offer eat-in customers some additional privacy and comfort. Overall, I had quite a par teetering sub-par experience. I had high expectations, but wasn't impressed at all honestly. I don't think I'd return to this restaurant unless: (1) I received a gift card or (2) someone else in my party wanted to try it. read more

Comfortable seating to dine in (with only the early 2000s pop hits playing). The staff was very friendly and helpful as we costumized our pizzas. They have a wide selection of alcoholic beverages for reasonable prices. If you're not feeling alcohol they have plenty of soda choices. The pizzas came out great. We ordered ours well done for a nice, crispy bottom. If you're feeling some dessert after they offer Pittsford dairy ice cream! Kids and parents alike love it here. read more

See all

Failed. The pizza dough tasted like frozen bought pizza. The pizza dough needs more love and better ingredients. Not airy and soft, sauce is bland. Needs more time to proof the dough. Nice decor. read more

We went for ice cream, and what's not to love about Pittsford Farms Dairy ice cream? Nothing, if you get it at Pittsford Farms! As we waited to be served we noticed some of the flavors were melting at the top but didn't think too much of it. My husband ordered the mint chocolate chip and I got the pistachio. Mine was fine, but my husband's was so grainy in texture that he didn't even get halfway through it before giving up. We went to the patio area to eat our desserts and the music that was coming through the speakers was nowhere near professional with all of the curse words and lewd content in the first song alone. We're not usually affected by things like that, but it was over the top too much. Lastly, the cleanliness was lacking. Sadly, we won't be back. read more

-Drive thru pizza ? Yay! Pittsford Dairy Farms Ice cream ? Yippee! Good crust , quick service. They don't char the bottom. Little bit of Indian flair for those who like those flavors and a great Create Your Own Pizza. It's almost a perfect family place , except I found the BBQ sauce a little ketchupy. read more

WOW ... I completely stumbled upon this place! My local Pizza joint did not take orders after 8 pm, so I took to Yelp to help me out ... and low and behold found Fire Crust on West Henrietta Road (was looking for delivery). Not knowing a thing about this place, I ordered the Chicken Tikka Pizza and the Sweet Chili Fire roasted wings ... AMAZING! The flavor profile in the pizza was dead on of what a great chicken tikka should taste like, beautiful spice with a touch of heat ... and the wings were smokey and tasty! Delivery was on time; food was still nice and hot and again ... worth mentioning ... so flavorful. I am seriously looking forward to working my way through this menu ... and perhaps pop in one day! This is definitely a must try if you want an elevated Pizza and Wing experience that won't break the bank and deliver a flavorful punch! read more