The atmosphere here is great! I always loved the Swillburg/South Wedge and miss living in the area. This place captures the essence of the area perfectly. And the food??? Amazing! We got a WGR and Big Dodge Ram for pizza, and an order of 8 mild wings (extra crispy with a side of the wicked sauce since I love spicy food). The pizza was perfect. Great, crispy crust, flavorful sauce and toppings. And the wings?? Spectacular. Fried perfectly and both sauces were great. Mild Buffalo had a really good flavor, unlike some of the mild that are bland and boring. And the wicked had a great spice but good flavor, too. Service was super friendly and helpful for these newbies. We'll be back for sure. We definitely had leftovers so plan accordingly. read more

Pizza Wizard - Mild wings, extra crispy, with a side of wicked sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Food was timely and hot, ambiance is a friendly backyard/garage door local business vibe. Counter service for to-go, in person dining you get a number with your order and they come find you. We did the create your own pizza. Definitely adding this to go to places around town! read more

Pizza Wizard - Pineapple, grilled chicken, red sauce, garlic oil, caramelized onion, blue cheese drizzled Pepperoni on half - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Very tasty, would totally recommend. Crispy edges and plenty of sauce. Would definitely go back.

I hate that this is my favorite kind of pizza but it is. I love the satisfying thick Western New York-Sicilian/Detroit (whatever!) style squares. Just one piece is enough for any reasonably hungry person. The veggie options are fantastic, byo, also. The numerous sauces elevate your customization-level. They even have vegan pepperoni, folks! Crispy crusty cheese on the outer edges is killer. Quick and courteous service is a bonus. I waited a while to try it, but will make it a regular stop. read more

Why does pizza wizard own my soul and stomach? Because they're too goddamn good at their jobs. Incredible pies. Just innovative flavors and pillowy dough. Got mother's gulch which was creamy and the zinger is a classic spicy mama Mia. Dipping sauces got me in a choke hold. That spicy ranch be spicy but gud. Service is grade A top notch always. Ambiance is exactly what you'd want if you wanted strange memorabilia and classic booths with those metal napkin containers to keep everybody safe. Lunch special is a steal of a deal. 10/10 pizza. 15/10 stickers. Will never not stop at pizza wizard when I'm in the mustard city. Please never close. read more

See all

I called in my order and it was ready in 15 minutes. Super joyful person answered the phone and I asked for a recommendation. The hype is real! Light, focaccia type crust with crispy bottom and edges. One pie is enough for a very hungry human or to share with somebody else. read more

Pizza Wizard - Pepperoni, banana peppers and hot honey pie. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Flip's Drip is the kind of pizza that makes you question every bland slice you've ever tolerated. Sweet heat, crispy pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, roasted garlic! read more

Pizza Wizard - Flip's Drip - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

I ordered a modified pizza (don't even remember what I put on it lol) and 8 buffalo wings, and everything was honestly so good! Me and my boyfriend are literally munching it up right now The pizza was flavorful and the wings had a nice kick without being too overpowering. Definitely hit the spot!! read more

Pizza Wizard - I FORGET, MODIFIED (not including kitty lol) - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Stop it! If you love deep dish pizza like I do ...ya gotta try this place. Delicious. Edges cooked to perfect crunch. Had to get one to go because I'm from Syracuse and we don't have one there !! read more

See all

I got the Dodge Ram and it is arguably the best pizza I've ever had and I usually don't prefer deep dish. Its only competition is a New York City 99¢ slice (I might have some nostalgia bias there). It seemed a bit pricy at first but I had to save half for leftover dinner the next day. But 2 $10 dinners is relatively cheap to me, and it reheats perfectly in an air fryer. My only request is to have a "lifted" option, I don't care what it means, I want to walk in and say "I want one lifted Dodge Ram please." read more

I'm no expert on Detroit style pizza, but In general this was a solid choice. Ordered delivery which from ordering to my door it took roughly 45 minutes. The pizza had a good crunch and plenty of pepperoni. I really enjoyed the thickness but didn't feel like the crust was taking over the pizza read more

Grabbed a pizza and 10 hot wings from Pizza Wizard--both were great. Wings had a solid kick and were cooked just right. The pizza (Big Dodge Ram) was hot, cheesy, and super satisfying. Fast service too. Will definitely be back! read more

Pizza Wizard - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

The food was amazing. Wings were spectacular! Pizza is similar to Detroit style. I had a pizza with vodka sauce, ricotta, Calabrian sausage, caramelized onion and jalapeño. Delicious and the leftovers were too! Parking is on the street so be sure to look for signs telling you where NOT to park. read more

Pizza Wizard - Ye Olde Dibblestick - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Pizza was really good if Chicago / Detroit style are for you. We really liked it and this is not normally our style. We did not enjoy the wings much at all read more

Pizza Wizard - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Wasn't my first time here but by far my favorite experience and pizza! I had the big dodge ram. The pizza sauce was so flavorful. The cheese snd meat covered the whole pizza, not a spot missed! We also got a side of house made ranch, let me say I do not like ranch nearly ever. But this ranch almost made me contemplate changing my stance Staff was enthusiastic about pizza and other menu creations and was willing to give recommendations. While I didn't eat in the restaurant this time, on the other occasions when I have I have enjoyed the overall vibe of the restaurant. read more

Pizza Wizard - BIG DODGE RAM - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

This place knows how to make pizza that everyone likes. Very warm people who are patient and understanding. Love their deals and lunch menu options. Everything about them is absolutely brilliant. The seating area is pretty great too although many people prefer takeout. Their drinks most often pair well with the pizza you order. I look forward to seeing what new things they can do with pizza and add to their menu! read more

See all

The. vegan. pizza. is. AMAZING. Like what? Never have I ever had good non dairy cheese. And to top it off they have tasty vegan pepperoni and sausage. Wow. Unheard of these days. Ive done a build your own and the vodka sauce pizza (the sauce isnt vegan per the website) via doordash and the pizza holds up really well for delivery and pipping hot. It also warms well the next day or so. Great options for toppings too. I do wish they put a little more of the vegan sausage on the pizza. Ah, Im a picture taker but I cant believe I didnt snap any photos to share lol. Guess it was too good to wait! read more

Pretty fire. I feel like this is what Pizza Hut tries really hard to be and fails. The pizzas come as 4 slices and they are thick and fluffy. I was full from 2 slices. The crust is super crisp, the sauce on top is new to my New York-mind. I got the original Roni and my mom had the rooty toot. The original Roni was the perfect ratio of cheese to sauce to pep. The sauce was tangy but balanced. The pepperonis had a nice little char to them that gave it even more texture. Part of me wishes this was drizzled with honey like a beesting pizza--I just know those flavors would mesh together incredibly. The pizza was super crispy throughout; I feel like this can be challenging with a thick crust which can sometimes be doughy inside. But pizza wizard does a great job. As for the rooty toot, I felt like the sauce was a little bit too tangy for my taste. The sausage was good though. The restaurant itself wasn't packed on a Friday night but they had a ton of takeout orders. It did take about 20 minutes to get our pizza which is what we were told. Will be coming back to try their other pies! read more

See all

Amazing food! The pizza was super fresh and delicious, had a great crust and fluffy dough with an amazing cheese pull. The wings were surprisingly crispy and not heavily breaded. The seasoning was a little bit lacking for something that is supposed to be spicy but the texture makes up for it. The only thing to note about this place is that parking can be a little weird, there are only 2 spots for people dining in and a couple for pick up. read more

Pizza Wizard - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Unique flavors and warm pizza. What else can you ask for? We stopped here after visiting the museum of play. It's not very farm from it. Parking was not great, but we found a spot. I really liked my general tso pizza. I feel like it was more Detroit style. We went here with an 17 month old who would not touch the cheese pizza. He loves pizza, so that was a little strange. Was it an off day? Or was it that the pizza is too fancy for him? Either way, I would recommend stopping by to try the unique pizza flavors. read more

See all

Idk if I'll be a friend or foe when I say the crust reminded me a lil of pizza hut. The toppings sure don't they were delicious, and unique. The service was quick, the place was clean and the vibe was chill. I loved the snippets of humor in their homemade signs. I thought the price point was spot on. read more

See all

The pizza was absolutely amazing. I especially liked the Sum Buck with kale. Not bitter at all! The wings were ok. I think I should have gotten a different flavor. That's on me though. I can't wait to order again. read more

See all

Great Detroit style pizza! If you want slices make sure to get there early enough. Parking is tough but it's worth it. Tiny little pizza gem in Rochester with neat decor. read more

I love Pizza Wizard! They have the best vegan chicken wings I've ever had in my life!!! Their pizza is also incredible, and their salads are perfect! I love their merch too, very unique and cool designs! I can't wait to cop a shirt or hoodie. Very unique and cool vibes in here, one of my favorite spots to sit and linger while I eat! I also love interacting with the cool staff members! Can't wait for my next meal at Pizza Wizard! read more

The hype is real, folks. I don't know what these people do to make their pizza so deliciously crispy, but it's the best. Two slices and a drink for $8.50 is a perfect weekday lunch (this includes a Genny if you desire). The crust is light and airy yet substantial, the cheese and toppings are fresh. As with any pizza place, they do a significant takeout business but you can eat in as well. Parking is weird and there are 1-2 spots available in front of the restaurant. I usually try to street park as the little lots with signs make me nervous about being towed. read more

Pizza Wizard - Mushroom/onion and cheese slices - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

I've been wanting to try this place for a while. Me and 2 of my friends decided to dine in. Parking is limited. I liked the place and it's decor. It was very clean. The people were friendly and service was quick. I ordered the Roughneck pizza which came with sausage, bacon, pepperoni, red sauce. I added banana peppers and onion. Beware the sausage is spicy. I liked it but my friend can't handle spice and she was struggling. They should warn people that it's spicy or have a mild sausage option. The crust was thick and very crispy . I like thick pizza over thin. I feel that I would of preferred the sauce on the dough instead of the toppings going on first and then the sauce last. Cool concept though. The wing were good. I could of used more sauce but overall everything was good. read more

See all

Stopped by for a quick lunch and was not disappointed. Their lunch special was a great deal with 2 slices of your choosing and a drink for $8.50! I ordered two of the original roni slices and they hit the spot. Cheesy, saucy and absolutely delicious. Will definitely be back! read more

What a great place! The pizza is amazing and the salad and dressing was a my favorite. Can't wait to go back. Two parking spaces in front and a few more in the side. Great service and they even had Otherhalf beer! Can't wait to go back read more

See all

Their food is simply AMAZING and the staff is the Best! My family and I are coming back for sure.

Yum yum yum!! I finally got to try this place and I was not disappointed. My fiancé and I got the #1 salad (veggie mix with vinaigrette) and the My Brother Randy pizza. The salad came out on a pizza platter and was probably enough for 3 people but we devoured it. The pizza was of course the highlight of the meal and absolutely delicious. At that point we could only eat one slice each since they are so thick but I wish I could have eaten more. The crust was thick but wasn't too bready and it had a nice crunch to it. I'm already thinking about when I can go back next. If you are a pizza lover, you have to check this place out. read more

See all

Phenomenal garlic bread! So lusciously cheesy and garlicky. Tried their pepperoni pizza, the original 'roni. It was pretty good but was beaten out by the garlic bread. The pizza had good flavor but is also quite heavy. It's delicious but it's a lot, definitely has the potential to give you a stomach ache if you don't know when to stop :P read more

See all

There is a sign on the building but it's set back from the street. Parking is hard in this area. It's next to Stuarts Spices. There is room for two cars in front but it's extremely hard to get out so watch yourself. I placed an online order for 1pm pickup and it was ready when we got there. We ordered a scilian sq, a thin crust meat lovers type and some wings. There were only 3 of us at home and this order was in the $50 range. Definitely pricey and not doable when our entire family is home when we can get 2-3 pizzas elsewhere for that price. The wings were $12 for an order of 8. But they were cooked well. But def pricey! read more

See all

Stopped in very early on a Saturday morning. We were the only ones in the shop. They had a nice selection of slices to choose from but we wanted to get our own pie. Our food was made and ready in about 15 minutes. The staff brought the food out to us. We absolutely loved our meal! The wings are crispy and have such a tasty hot sauce. Easily some of my favorite wings in Rochester. The pizza was perfect. I can see why this was voted best pizza in the CITY magazine. Nothing but good things to say about our visit. The bathroom was very clean. The retro arcade games on site were a nice touch. read more

Pizza Wizard - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Quick, delicious. Crust is heavenly. My first time getting Detroit style pizza and I wasn't disappointed. Next time I'd forego the sausage, but overall delicious. read more

I'm no expert on Detroit-style but if this is faithful example then count me in. They serve single pan pizzas which are billed as "enough for one person" - my college student son and I each finished half of ours, so I'd say two people could split one if they were hungry. The pizzas came out piping hot, and there was a wonderful gristly cheesy coating on the outside of the crust - my kid got a plain cheese but I got pepperoni with banana peppers and it was money. Not much to say in terms of ambiance and service, but the patio outside was nice on a September evening. read more

Pizza Wizard - Good shit - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Outstanding pizza spot. Delicious pie, friendly service. I look forward to coming back

Can I give more than 5 stars? This place causes me to dream of their pizza, wings, and salads. Easily our family's favorite pizza spot. You can't beat the Wizard. read more

Came here on a Wednesday night - there's a large indoor space with ample seating. Has an industrial vibe. Not crowded (seems to have a lot of takeout orders). I made my own pizza (tomato sauce, ricotta, arugula, onion, and hot honey drizzle). It took about 10-15 minutes for it to come out. It was AMAZING. The crust is very thick but LIGHT (not heavy) on the inside, and it has a very crunchy, delicious burnt cheese exterior. The tomato sauce was so flavorful and fresh. I was actually stunned and speechless... couldn't function as a human being until I finished the third slice. GO HERE. It'll change your life. read more

Pizza Wizard - Made my own pie - tomato sauce, ricotta, onions, arugula, and hot honey drizzle. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

First timer: Cozy atmosphere, friendly staff and customers (recommendations from tables on either side of us). We ordered New Number One Salad (HUGE - it feed 4), Zigger Pizza and WGC. Yum, Yum Staff was attentive, food was hot and delivered with a smile. We plan a return visit. AMP/DAP read more

have been hearing about how good this place was and I was not disappointed at all! I got a gluten free pepperoni pizza and it was the fluffiest pizza I've ever had. The food came out fast and the staff were very nice and approachable. Will definitely be coming here again and recommending it to my friends. read more

Pizza Wizard - gluten free pepperoni pizza and #1 BEST SALAD BUT NOW A LITTLE DIFFERENT - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York