We love firehouse pizza. We come to Bear Lake every year and we love eating here! This is the first year we ordered take out and we're super impressed. Our order was ready in 10 min and everyone was so helpful and pleasant. We got the large Cheese bread, Artichoke Chicken Pizza and Firehouse Combo Pizza. read more

See all

Took a large group here and was immediately seated and waited upon. Food was prepared quickly and our server was so nice. I really like the cool resin tables. Best pizzas in Bear Lake! read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - Large group pizza night - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

The description of your pizzas sounded good but they were the worse we've ever had. Hardly any pepperoni or olives on one pizza and the spinach, chicken artichoke pizza was so tasteless and dry. read more

This was an experience. We had a bunch of kids with us so we ordered a half cheese, half pepperoni pizza. Pretty normal order, right? It shows up as half pepperoni and half feta cheese. And I'm not talking a little feta, it was COVERED in feta. None of our kids would even touch it. So that was a waste. And then since they messed something up, they offered us free dessert, which was a nice gesture. But the dessert took forever and we were ready to leave. We would have rather had a new pizza made. Very disappointed with how much we paid for all of this. Staff was very friendly, but service was slow and we left feeling unsatisfied with the food. read more

Had the bbq chicken pizza wasnt the best. The crust good cheese chicken was eh...the onion on it saved it otherwise dry....If we just got tbe cheese it would of been ok! read more

Normally not the type to leave bad reviews I get people have bad days. Although I was very disappointed with our food and service. My boyfriend had gotten a Montana sandwich asked no tomato the server had brought us our food and there was tomato in the sandwich. The server had made it right with us but then when we closed out the server had gypped us. Our total was 33.36$ we had givin him 40.00$ cash he then came back with 4$ cash. Yes I get it, it was only 2.64$ but still really disappointing and dishonest. read more

I placed on online order saying my food would be done by 7:17. Got half the order complete after I arrived (7:20) and it's now 8:02pm and I'm waiting for three more things to be made. I get that it's Memorial Day weekend but either cancel online ordering or take ownership of being late. An HOUR of waiting for my food (which I had to correct three times with three employees who were handwriting my order again for the kitchen) is ridiculous. Even after waiting 39 minutes from placing my order. Multiple people talked about the poor service and timing for food after walking out of this place. read more

The service is amazing! The workers and service is 10/10. The food on the other hand is not very good. read more

See all

Being one of the only restaurants open in the area on a Monday morning, we came here on a random whim with very hungry bellies. We arrived right at opening time and were their first customers, so we were seated promptly. Two stray cats nearly followed us inside and they ended up being a funny part of our experience as we watched them through the window. For a group of 7, our service was accommodating and our food came out in a very timely manner. The wings were pretty average buffalo wings, a bit small in size but super saucy. There's the good stuff! Now for the okay things. Their pizza menu is extensive but the pizza itself was pretty bland in flavor and the crust was very thick. Our jalapeños weren't cooked and there were lots of seeds on them so we ended up picking them off, but our friend's pizza with ranch as sauce looked pretty good. Again, we were so hungry that it was a satisfying meal, but of all the pizzas I've had, this one sits pretty firm at 3 stars. read more

See all

We dined in but wished we didn't since the atmosphere felt depressing. Staff seemed unhappy and going through the motions. Then the pizza was just not good. My BBQ chicken pizza was slathered in a very sweet sauce (not at all spicy), and as the picture shows the crust was very floury and flavorless. The gluten-free crust was better but the hog heaven topping was surprisingly spicy - likely the sausage. Other pizza in town is better! read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - Texas Barbecue Chicken Pizza 8" - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

Dropped it near the end of a crazy dinner rush. Had about a 10min wait for a table to open up. By the time we ordered and our food came, many tables were emptying out. By the time we finished, the place was nearly empty. We ordered a large pizza and one pizookie (can't remember what they call them here). Both were great! Service was nice and friendly, though our table was overlooked for a little bit. We finally had the flag down someone to come take our drink and food order. The staff was super apologetic. Once our order was taken, the food did seem to come out pretty quickly. It was tasty! Great pizza place to stop at when in town. read more

See all

The pizza was alright, but the service was awesome! I didn't catch the name of the tall, dark-haired kid that served us, but he was very attentive and helpful with suggestions, since we had never eaten here before. We ordered the 8 cheese garlic bread, it was good. Perfect size for our party of 9. The Alfredo dipping sauce was really good, better than the marinara. We also ordered 4 medium pizzas, that our server advised would be good for the size of our group and it was perfect. We ordered hog heaven pizza, texas barbeque chicken, firehouse combo, and fresh spinach chicken. They were good, but nothing special. read more

See all

Best place I have ever eaten on earth Skyler made me so happy and had my belly bustin. I have never been happier service and vibe are amazing read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - Best pizza place on earth - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

Hog Heaven! That's all I'm gonna say! We walked in ordered and walked out within 15 minutes. Can I just say the pizza was delish!! With today being the kickoff for high season, they have their stuff together! read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - Hog Heaven Pizza 16" - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

The pizza (especially the crust) was delicious! Service was friendly and fast. We had a great dinner.

Amazing pizza. The crust is so soft and it was delicious. Also, very clean and organized. The server were very attentive. We will definitely be back. read more

Came here for the Fourth of July weekend for some pizza. It was past three on a Sunday afternoon and a lot of places were closed. Fortunately, this place is opened. Service on point. Didn't have to ask for a thing. She was already attentive. Got the wings. So good. Not fried. Delicious. Got the barbecue chicken pizza and that was really good baked in the stone oven. read more

They stayed open longer for us and were lovely 10/10 service Great human interaction read more

Some of the worst pizza we've had. No flavor. Barely any toppings and sauce. Doesn't even resemble or taste like pizza made in a "fire".. pizza oven. The olives by themselves didn't even taste like an olive and the pineapple was white! The large pizza was so sad and skippy looking. They also charged us for the green peppers we ordered on a pizza but left them off and didn't give us any green peppers! read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - No sauce under cheese, it's like they only put it towards the crust or something! - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

The food is heavenly, fresh and very filling plus the wait time was very short. A large pizza easily fed 5 growing kids. The service is wonderful and tended to our needs great! Place is so calm and feels homey and happy. Bring this to Salt Lake City utah! We'd be there often. Shout out our server! She was awesome! read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - Aftermath :) - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

The food was not good. The salad was brown, the bread wasn't good and the pasta had no flavor. Plus it only had a few pieces of meat. The service was ok, but we were so disappointed. read more

Great service. The pizza was excellent and we fell in love with the marinara sauce. Highly recommend!

Food was fast. Taste was okay. Kids got a pizza that was pretty standard. Chicken Sandwich was okay, a bit dry and could use more balsamic. (There was next to none on it, I'd almost forgotten it was meant to be there until I'd get a small bite with balsamic.) the wings were good, half order was 7 wings. Overall it was fine, one of the only places open where we were staying on a Sunday. read more

After a day at the beach, we were looking forward to some tasty pizza from the firehouse. We ordered for take out the combo, a cheese pizza with pepperoni and sausage and some cheesy bread were sorely disappointed in how the description totally missed the target from the pizza that we received. You can see that they put some meat and veggies in the center of the pizza and called it good. There wasn't even all that much cheese as they emphasize in their descriptions. It wasn't all that much meat and they definitely skimped on the veggies for the combo. I hope they didn't make this right with my brother and sister-in-law tomorrow who even left them a tip after picking up the pizzas. We will definitely be checking our pizza if we decide to order from the Firehouse in the future. read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - A large combo - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

See all

I absolutely love bear lake and this pizza place! But the fact they have it saying it's opened on sundays when it is not opened at all is very frustrating, I know it is maybe hard to change the hours I'm not sure. But you are still able to place an order for pickup/takeout when it is CLOSED, and still be CHARGED for the order! Should've done a little more research I guess that's on me but on their website, on here, and other places it says it's opened. Other than that their pizza and service is very good! read more

This pizza was super delicious and feed all of us. It was nice that you could customize the pizza into four sections so everyone had something they liked. read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - 36 inch Monster Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

This was the worst pizza ever. We order 3 large pizza. One was supposed to be chicken and artichokes, it has a green sauce on it, I guess that was supposed to be artichoke sauce? It was terrible! Well, then, none of our group enjoyed the pizza at all would not recommend we were so upset read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - What is this!!?!? - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

I'll give this some stars because the waiter was friendly and took good care of us despite being the only one serving people, and it was busy. The pizza was not good and tasted like "school pizza" if you know what I'm referring to. The environment was really frustrating. It was very loud and the soda machine kept making horrible loud noises. The bathroom was very gross and dirty. read more

I assume the only reason why this place is still open is because it's the only pizza in town + I wonder if the chef is a child cause there is nothing developed or creative about this joint. The food managed to taste worse than an Applebees without a microwave, even though there was a huge pizza oven on display. Key word *display* - the oven only churned out raw dough for every one of our pizzas. Quality of the ingredients was akin to that in a Lunchable. Pasta was tasteless. Artichoke dip was runny and perhaps a different vegetable. The cinnamon sticks was more raw dough with Nesquik chocolate sauce. Not only did everything taste like ANYone could have made it better but there was a reoccurring nails on chalkboard sound - likely cutlery scraping food into where it belongs. The bin. read more

Yummmm! Our server (from Logan) was FANTASTIC and the food was amazing too. We were a party of 10 that tried a little of everything - pizza, sandwiches, calzone and pasta and all of it was so good. Thank you for treating us during our trip to Bear Lake! read more

Ordered Focaccia but got dry unappetizing garlic bread instead, when I called to have the order corrected they connected me with someone who did not speak English, the person who answered did speak English but had me hold and connected me with the other person.Also not impressed by the artichoke chicken pizza, no real flavor at all. read more

We showed up a little late but our waiter was still very kind and helpful! Great guy who chatted with us for a while. The pizza was really good. I loved the margarita pizza and the others were really solid read more

See all

Worst pizza I've ever had. Not cooked and doughy sauce has no flavor. If I wasn't starving I would have not touched it. Def school pizza taste. I'm sad about this pizza. Maybe pass on this local eat. read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - Look at that underdone crust. - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

See all

The pizza here is delicious. We sat outside so I can't speak to the inside of the restaurant but we opted to sit outside because it was so nice. Everyone in our group loved the pizza. I would say it's one of the better pizza places in Bear Lake for sure. The only negative we have the service was kind of slow and the staff seemed overworked. This is seems to be the norm now, so I decided not to dock them for it. If you're wanting pizza... definitely get it from here! read more

Here's the quick and dirty on Firehouse Pizza: I've been visiting Bear Lake in the summers for a decade plus. Me and fam avoided Firehouse for years, because well, it just kinda lacked the lake town charm we look for on weekend holiday, and with the adjacent motel, it's always been a lackluster option (and slightly shady) from a marketing perspective. All that being said ... after a decade of greasy burger joint fare and raspberry shakes, me and my crew were craving pizza for the first time ever while in GC. Inside ... that lackluster vibe I referenced is alive and well. The place needs a serious facelift. It feels like the unloved corner of Pizza Hut where they have the 1-2 lone tables for the famished that can't wait to indulge on pizza until they get home. All that being said .. the pizza, salad, and ranch are excellent. Like, truly YUM. Next time we'll probably order to go and eat al fresco on the beach. Totally 100% recommend if you're craving pizza in Bear Lake! read more

We ordered a large Hog Heaven pizza and between my husband and I, we ate the whole thing! Yeah, it was that delicious! read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - Hog Heaven - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

See all

This place I ordered the monster pizza first the dude said 20 mins I asked my husband to take me home I need to do other cooking and he grabbed teen boys to help get it. First dude said 20 mins and then wouldn't make it and acted like we didn't just pay for it when my husband went back. It's off season so not busy so he know it was us to ordered and said we will be right back. So it took over 30 mins when dude should of been pulling it out as we went back. Second if you offer a pizza that big measure your door to fit through it. Show in picture pizza was messed up and not from the car ride. Pizza wasn't bad and again not busy so the lobby was clean I'll give them that. This is place I'd only go if Desperate read more

Firehouse Pizzeria - Large pizza was smashed just going through restaurant door - Pizza Near Me - Garden City, Utah

Food is great, service is excellent but its miserable to sit in a restaurant that is so hot during the summer. Wish they would turn down the A/C so it was more comfortable. read more

Firehouse Pizzeria in Garden City is a disappointment. We ordered four pizzas and cheese bread and the pizzas were doughy and under baked. Toppings and cheese were OK but kind of thrown on top haphazardly. Although it was a busy Saturday evening, they seated us right away which was appreciated. We had several hungry adults and kids in our large group. The seating was a little unusual though, plastic picnic tables on a scraggly, overgrown lawn, but it was pleasant to be outside and not inside the stuffy, hot restaurant. Our server, a young women, was terrific and took good care of us. If you're hankering for pizza while vacationing at Bear Lake, I'd encourage you to look elsewhere. The pizzas at Firehouse Pizzeria are disappointing. read more

Could not eat the pineapple pizza - was it the sauce, the pineapple, the canadian bacon? No one could finish their first, last and only slice. If you're like us and you can't stomach the pizza, the employees will politely listen to you - charge you in full $57 for pizza and wings - and wish you a good day. I would warn anyone and everyone from this nasty food and horrible service at checkout. read more