Service fairly outstanding (didn't give us nightly specials or know how to pair wine), but ambiance is fantastic right on edge of Lake Superior in small town of Eagle Harbor, and the food... gourmet pairings of flavors, astounding menu choices focused on smoked meats. IT IS ALL FANTASTIC!!! read more

This was honestly one of the best surprisingly excellent meals I've had while traveling! We stumbled across Fitzgerald's while skiing at Mount Bohemia and stopped in without a reservation not expecting fine dining. The view is absolutely spectacular! The food is well prepared with quality ingredients and presented well- definitely fine dining on the shores of Suoerior! read more

See all

This was my first time dining here as a special birthday treat given to me by my friend. We had reservations so we were able to sit by a window overlooking the water. Beautiful views! The brisket was absolutely delicious and my pineapple margarita was amazing. For our appetizer we had the pulled pork sliders which were yummy. I'm not a fan of green beans so I'll pass on those next time. But most definitely will be going back. Beautiful place. read more

See all

I'll start by saying that the Fitz has been my favorite restaurant in the Keweenaw for over 15 years. I've referred many people to them. I take no pleasure in this. The first problem: I made a reservation for dinner and had to change it. Reservation states you can't change by phone you need to email or stop in. Stopping in is not convenient so I emailed. Five days later, no response. Thankfully, I was able to cancel it via the site and rebook. But if you aren't going to reply to customers, don't offer an email option. The day of the dinner arrived. We arrived early and were seated promptly. Our server (Melissa) was wonderful. Same fantastic view. The food was good. Like everywhere, it is more expensive and you get less than before (smaller portions, fewer sides, higher prices). But ok, that's how the world is now. We had drinks, appetizer, entree, and ordered dessert the moment the server asked. We even paid the bill while still eating dessert. The moment we finished eating we took turns going to the bathroom before heading home. My wife went first. While I was gone another staff member came to the table and said "We know it is your anniversary but someone has been waiting for your table for 20 minutes, can you move?" It was clear we were leaving. The pacing of the meal was not up to us. We ordered everything promptly when asked. There are a dozen ways the restaurant could have moved things along without making the customer feel like they are the bad guy. It is not our fault you booked the reservations more tightly than you can keep up with them. And if you do, maybe offer a discount to move to the bar for dessert? Or at least be nice? This is the service industry and you're riding on a history of good experiences. Ones like this don't take long to override decades of affinity. It was particularly stark because of a dinner at the Harbor Haus a couple of weeks back, which still offers top notch food and exemplary service start to finish. It might be just another day at work for the team there but making people feel crappy as they end their 25th anniversary dinner is not a great way to win fans. read more

We went to The Fitzgerald yesterday, and as expected, the culinary excellence has remained consistent throughout all these years. Every single element of my meal was clearly cooked with care and attention. You can truly taste the love and craftsmanship in each bite--this is not just a meal, it is genuine comfort on a plate. The brisket was beautifully smoked, incredibly tender, and full of rich, savory flavor. The green beans were cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of snap and seasoning to bring out their natural freshness. The baked beans were absolutely delicious--sweet, hearty, and deeply satisfying. They were, without question, the best I've had in a long time. Even the barbecue sauce served on the side was impressive. It had a thoughtful balance of tanginess and sweetness that enhanced the meat without overpowering it. The entire meal felt like something lovingly prepared in a home kitchen, but executed with the finesse of a seasoned chef. If you ever find yourself in Eagle River, I can't recommend this place highly enough. It's not just a good restaurant--it's the best in town. You'll walk away full, content, and already thinking about your next visit. read more

See all

I loved this place. It's obvious why you need reservations. We sat at the bar since we didn't have reservations. The bartender, Joe, was awesome! The beer was great. Omg, the food was delicious. I couldn't believe how good it was. It came out pretty quickly. The prices weren't that expensive. Next time I'll make a reservation so that I can sit and look out at the water. read more

See all

Never been here for Sunday brunch when they open earlier than normal and it did not disappoint! Sausage gravy poutine with bacon and an egg, blueberry pancakes, brisket burrito. None of us could finish the meals. And always a great view of Lake Superior! Great place read more

See all

We ate at the Fitz twice during a trip to the Keewenaw and really enjoyed it. The staff is outstanding, treating you like a treasured guest & they were just waiting for you to arrive (both times!). Very hardworking but all smiles. We were seated right by the window, such a gorgeous view, hovering over the beach & the magnificent Superior. We shared an appetizer, first time, the Risotto Fritters, delish, 2nd them the Walleye cake, which knocked us out, so good! Great combination of flavors, sitting on a corn tostada, a little corn & great smoky notes. We each got the whitefish once and ribs once. Both were excellent. We thought the ribs were better than what we'd had in Kansas City! Meaty, tender & smoky. Our second visit, we took after dinner cocktails to the deck, as it was a lovely day to enjoy the view. Oh--inventive delicious cocktails and a very nice wine list. You are wonderful hosts!! Thank you so much for all the kindness & relaxed, happy atmosphere, it was a treat! read more

See all

We showed up on a Monday with a larger group. They were unable to make accommodations, even to split our group. There were empty tables and a bar area. They offered to have us scan the menu and sit outside, which we would have done. But the attitude of the host was a very big turn off. read more

New Year's Eve Dinner was amazing. Great beer choices, I had a awesome old fashion. Dinning room was packed but service was fast and friendly. I had the mussels with pasta, Troy had 2 appetizers. The water with the big waves outside the windows made a beautiful experience. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Dinning view - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

The excellently prepared foods, the stellar wait staff and the setting which is lovely and a view that is beautiful will make you want to come repeatedly. Enjoy the food and your time with with friends and family! read more

Delicious. A small place with an awesome view and fantastic food. Unique dishes! Excellent and friendly service. I noticed all those around us having a great experience. There is nothing better than a restaurant offering an entertainment moment of happiness. Thank you! read more

See all

One of the best restaurants I've been to! Great food, drinks, service, views. It's much more than another burger bar. Keep it up! We hope to visit again soon. read more

I stayed here at the hotel and got a reservation for dinner. The food was amazing, i got the udon noodles with brisket and mushrooms. It was delicious except the brisket was a little too smoky/burnt for me. It's a small place, and maybe it's just the people, but it can get loud. I would recommend this for sure! read more

My husband had one objective aside from his work requirements when we went up to the Keweenaw peninsula: get BBQ at Fitzgerald's. So that's what we did! Due to the pandemic the menu is abbreviated and everything is done outdoors. Walk up, place your order, and in minutes you're eating delicious que overlooking Lake Superior! They have some outdoor picnic tables on a deck in the back but it was a windy evening so we dined in our car. A little challenging with BBQ but we made it work! We ordered the brisket, pulled pork, Mac and cheese, baked beans, and two pieces of pie (key lime and chocolate peanut butter). We also added buns to make our own sandwiches and I piled mine high with pulled pork, the side of pickles, and some of the paired BBQ sauce and it was *chef's kiss*. The Mac and cheese was also great. A little smokey, I think they add paprika? Either way, it was different than I was used to but still so good. The brisket and the beans were also very good but the pork and mac were the winners for me! The pie? OMG. So rich, not too sweet, and the pieces were huge. The chocolate peanut-butter one was my choice and I've been dreaming about it since. Can't wait to come back up here post pandemic and enjoy more from their menu, which I hope will be restored to its fully glory, then! Until that point, tho, don't sleep on them if you're in the area! read more

See all

Had heard so much about this place but realized that online reservation needs you to put a deposit. So we stopped by on our drive to the lighthouse and found that you still have to pay a deposit, although it goes towards your dinner. We were seated quick and had we been able to get an earlier reservation, would have been able to see the sunset from our table. For our drinks we had the Vieux Carre and Black Manhattan - both were well made drinks. My son ordered the orange dream soda but wasn't a fan of that style of soda. The umami fries seemed so interesting by its description but unfortunately the appetizer was kinda one dimensional. The gochujang was over powering and definitely some tartness would have helped the dish. For dinner we shared a brisket platter and half rack ribs. My son had the garlic udon with mushrooms and said it was great. Since there were no leftovers I presume it was truly great :). Our brisket was okay - was tender but not a great depth of flavor. The ribs too were just ok. We finished off with the white chocolate vanilla cheesecake and that was very tasty - wiped clean by us all . For us the restaurant didn't live up to the hype with respect to the food...but of course the location is one of a kind. read more

Incredibly tasty food, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The bbq was especially good, and the beans were also a great side read more

An excellent little spot which is well worth the visit if you're in the area. My fiance and I came here after we got engaged in porcupine mts, this place was a very special spot to visit after. We were stunned with the quality and taste of the food here. It's not often you find top-notch food in the depth of the U.P. My fiance devoured her brussels sprouts salad and continues to laud it to this day. The location itself is excellent, right on picturesque Lake Superior. The restaurant is right on the water with exquisite views. If I am every near here we will make sure to pop-in. read more

See all

The food was absolutely AMAZING! Loved the decor. Very limited menu, but it is exceptionally delicious!! Service was excellent as well. It's rare a restaurant gets it right in all areas (especially in the Northwood) but Fitz's hits a home run! Mac & Cheese w/pork belly...I'm willing to bet the absolute best you have ever had. Hot Nashville Chicken sandwich is excellent! And there's a wonderful beach and river that you can walk up and down before or after or take your food to go and enjoy on beach or outdoor deck. read more

Excellent food, service and ambiance. No trip to the Keweenaw is complete without a visit to Fitzgerald's.

Went here for our 30th anniversary and my birthday. They ask you when you make the reservation if it is a special occasion. They take $20 for the reservation. When e arrived asked to wait for a table closer to the water. They sat us at a table in the back of the restaurant with the bar to my left (yes shaking drinks in my ear) and the door to my back. They had no less than 3 tables open near the lake the whole time we were there. The smoked meat was good, the special was akin to Shepards pie. Based on description expected it to have more vegetables but just had small chips of carrots. Hush puppies were cooked in same grease as fish or maybe we're supposed to taste like fish but were overcooked. Didn't get my $20 reservation deposit credited against my bill but was so unhappy with the whole experience I forgot to ask. I will never return. Very very loud. Difficult to hear your own thoughts let alone your loving spouses. read more

We batted in at 50% for a table of 4. I had Udon Noodles. Over the top salty, but tasty. I ate it all. Busy day and hiking. Fitgeralds was out of both Ribs and Chicken, my husbands first two choices. It was 6:00 pm. What? How can you be out of two of their top menu items at 6:00? He ordered the Brisket. Tasty but dry. One of our foursome ordered a porchetta sandwich which was inedible as it was seasoned over the top way too spicy hot. The 60% - or more - remainder uneaten sandwich was not taken home. Other friend ordered meatloaf. He liked it. But meatloaf ??? On a special night out , traveling, where you have to prepay for the reservation ---- Come on. Meatloaf? We ate here last year and the year before. I don't remember anything like this menu which I thought was limited. I had whitefish the night before at another restaurant, and did not want that two nights in a row. I gave Fitzgerald's three star because we sat by the window and had a great view. We will not be back. read more

Amazing views!!!! Watch eagles and if you're lucky wolves as you dine on food that rivals the views. And the staff are second to none!!!!! read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - The best brunch in the region!!! - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

See all

TL/DR: This is one of the best spots you'll find anywhere. Eat and drink here. Take in the view. Be happy. It's that damn simple. The longer review for a place that deserves it... It's a smaller place located about 10 feet off Lake Superior, with amazing food, a breathtaking view, and friendly service. Every time I am in the area for work, a stop at the Fitz is on my "must do" list... Get a cocktail and an appetizer. I recommend the brisket nachos. Take your time. Then for dinner get the udon noodles or Nashville Hot Chicken (yeah, its spicy). If it's on the menu, get the meatloaf. Now, I know what you're thinking... No chance you'd order meatloaf at a restaurant... You're wrong. Do it. You will have zero regrets. read more

Best lunch in the world! From the juicy smoked brisket sandwich to the tasty porchetta sandwich. The beans and Mac n cheese are delicious sides too. All, with a phenomenal view of Lake Superior. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Porchetta sandwich, smoked brisket sandwich, baked beans, mac-n-cheese. - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

We were absolutely blown away by the food at Fitzgerald's. We had a variety of appetizers and pulled pork and O-M-G. Every dish melts in your mouth. The chefs and staff preparing this food are EXTREMELY talented! Service staff was top notch! A MUST GO TO PLACE! AMAZING!! read more

We had dinner there Sunday Oct. 2nd 4:45pm I have a complaint about some of our food. Less of a complaint and more of an FYI. Some things were delicious, some not as good. The Walleye cakes oh my gosh how amazing they were!!! Couple bones were still in the dish. The whitefish dinner was too salty, scraped the seasoning off of the fish and ate as much as we could. The potatoes were not edible at all cause of the salt. Veggies were perfect. I had the udon noodles. At first it tasted ok. Once I mixed it up with the sauce on the bottom it was overwhelming with salt. Even the brisket in it was salty. Smokey and tender but salty. The pie didn't appear to be homemade unfortunately and had a pit in the cherry pie, the apple pie flavor was off. The ribs were perfectly delicious and expertly done, as was the Mac and cheese. Thank you for a good meal despite the fyi. The drinks were delicious and beautiful! The view and ambiance you can't beat. Our service was first class as usual. read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

This was fantastic! Make sure you have reservations. Food and drinks were fabulous. Service was excellent. I will go again though it is so far away! read more

Fitzgerald's Restaurant - Great view! - American Near Me - Eagle River, Michigan

The food lived up to the hype. However the service is like a minus 4. We arrived on time. Our first interaction was a waitress telling us we only have 90 minutes to sit and that were already 15 minutes late. I explained we were on time and showed the email that confirms that. Then we order drinks. Wait 15 minutes to get them. Wait even longer to order. Then we order 2nd round of drinks. Wait 20 minutes. We get them and then 10 minutes later, we're told we have to leave bc the next group is here. That's not how you run a place. Won't go back. Food was good. Wasn't worth the hassle. read more

Food was pub fare with a good wordsmith behind the menu and design of the entrees and appetizers. Ordered a bunch of the bbq, poutine (worst I have ever had) and the udon noodle dish (peculiar flavors that flat out don't work) Go for a drink and a view of beautiful Lake Superior. Pass on the food and run towards the nearest "bigger" city. My wife called this place a mirage. That's about as accurate as it gets. read more

Absolutely wonderful! Here is a restaurant that employs an honest to god chef. We ate here several times during our trip to the Keewenaw peninsula and had a great meal every time. Delicious vegetarian options. Lovely ambience and beautiful view of the water. Highly recommend. read more

Seating available without reservation. Pleasant atmosphere. Waitstaff efficient. Delicious cocktail menu

Easily the best dinner we had in the UP and even in the parts of Michigan that we explored on a. two week trip. We started with the risotto fritters, and then moved on. I had the grilled whitefish. I'd had it a few other times but Fitz did the best job - it was very fresh and cooked perfectly. The drinks were great too - they have a nice selection of beer, spirits, etc. The staff were all friendly, cheerful and helpful. It's a bit of a drive from Houghton or other parts of the UP but well worth it. Highly recommended! read more

based off what we ordered i have zero complaints! we walked in and we were sat down immediately (4) ordered the poutine as an appetizer which was amazing and as an entree i ordered the gouda mac n cheese with pork belly and omg so good!! definitely worth the money, the service was great and the view was so pretty (ocean/lake view) read more

Excellent food. Great experience. Pork belly, Mac n cheese was excellent. Highly recommend.

The last stop on my up north trip was the the best. Can't wait to come back. I recommend the poutine.

We had the most amazing experience at Fitzgerald's! The food was amazing. It was one of the best brisket and smoked chicken dinners we have ever had. The sunset view was incredible and the staff went over and above! read more

My family and I visited the Keweenaw Peninsula for a camping weekend and made a reservation for dinner at Fitzgerald's. Appetizers, dinner and beer selection were all amazing. I would definitely return if I was in the area and would recommend this place for great smoky food, excellent craft beer and excellent bourbon selection. read more

Out-of-the-way on the lake nice and quiet waves hitting the rocks ships going by what a nice area they have a steak dinner at Fitzgerald

Food was great. Had Sunday brunch. The porkastrami hash was top notch and my girlfriend had biscuits and berries and loved it. Service was great, super nice people, great view of the lake and a calm, nice atmosphere. Would go back 10/10 read more