Wish I could give more than 5 stars!!…read more The cutest restaurant and the food is so good. Their gluten free crust is delicious. Very different than traditional GF crust. Thicker, but still chewy and crispy. The toppings are fresh and their homemade salad dressings are amazing. The staff is so nice and friendly and helpful. I cannot say enough good things! They also have gluten free desserts.

I followed my fellow yelpers advice and stopped here on the way out of town…read more A sweet atmosphere, nice staff and great pizza. I had the personal supreme minus mushrooms and it was awesome . They have 4 different sizes to choose from which is great if you are alone. It was done in a reasonable time and was served hot. They also have a lot of different salads and they come in two different sizes too. I was so tempted to get a dessert, they had several I would like to try but I was full and traveling so I had to pass it up this time. The dining room was super clean, even the bathroom was clean. I will stop here again when I am in town.

The food was Italian quality and the service was excellent. The wine was great also!…read more The restaurant was busy but the staff remained friendly and professional.

As always thus is one of our Top Spots for Italian!! Always amazing service, friendly staff. And…read morethey remember you!! We recently started bring church family there , and it has quickly become a favorite.Food you can't go wrong with anything ypu eat, qe switch it up from time to time between dinners and pizza. The atmosphere there always has that old school italian spot vibe. Definitely a MUST DO when in Gainesville!!

We had seen a review of Fratellos on Youtube , friends of mine who have a food review channel…read morealways share the locally owned spots, saw this nice Italian spot on there and added it to my want to try list. We got there after church and it was quiet, sat down right away, was greeted and helped by a young lady. Told her We saw them on Food with the Fellas.She was excited to see what we thought. We ordered the garlic rolls, and 2 pizzas(i knew i would have Lunch for 2 days from this) they pizza was very good , mind you the only other pizza in the area of trenton is a dominos so they are a welcomed sight for locals) If your passing through and want to try some italian food or pizza, give this locally owned restaurant a visit.

I ordered an eggplant parm sub from here and it was tasty! The bread was nice and soft and the…read moreeggplant was very good, I do wish there was a little more of the fillings in the sandwich though as it was pretty bread heavy. My supervisor picked the food up for me so I was unable to see the ambiance, but the food was ready very quickly after we ordered. I've heard they have a good pizza lunch deal as well so definitely check this place out!

Don't use the reservation system on their website, if you do you won't get seated…read more This is a great restaurant, but little things like this will keep us from returning.

Ribeyewas seasoned perfectly. Mushrooms were fresh and veggies were gr8…read more Was seated quick Jose was an attentive waiter did not have to ask for refills or anything Was a neat clean friendly place to eat. I will be back

God tier waffles and pizza? In Gainesville? Florida?How they do that?…read more Go for the motor city, well done bake.

This is a great place in so many ways. The location is fun and a lovely atmosphere. The food is…read morealways good, I've had both the pizza and waffles and they can both hit. I recommend the hot honey.

The food was very VERY good! The staff was nice and friendly. Something you don't see in…read morerestaurants today! I highly recommend NY Pizza Plus for anyone dining in the area. You will not be disappointed!

Had an amazing first experience at New York Pizza Plus this summer!…read more I am not from this area, so I visited here for lunch on the recommendation of some locals. We stopped on a Thursday in July for lunch on our way into Gainesville. The store is located on the corner of a strip of several businesses. There is a shared parking lot for the strip, but we did not have any trouble finding a spot. The restaurant was healthily busy, but we were seated right away. The inside is cozy, but can accommodate larger groups in the back room. I was in a group of 5, and we all opted to eat at the lunch buffet. Having previously eaten at chain pizza buffets, I did not expect the variety and quality that this buffet offered. In addition to a plethora of pizza and bread options, there were various cold salads (such as chicken, tuna, traditional salad, etc), and hot pasta and Italian dishes. It was an amazing spread! I had to make sure my eyes were not bigger than my stomach, since everything looked so good. I started off with a plate of salads and cold items. I love a traditional salad bar, but my favorite from this was the pesto pasta. Next, I tried some of the hot Italian dishes and pizzas - including the meatballs, hot pasta, and several pizza varieties. I did not have a bite of food that I did not like. It truly all was so wonderful. Not only was the food awesome, but so was the price. For the lunch buffet, it was under $100 for five to eat (cannot recall exact price, but I believe it was around $14 or $15 per person). I do not think you would find a better deal for a better meal in the area than this, for the price. The staff and service were great. My drink was refilled several times, and I noticed the buffet was refilled frequently. No complaints on either front. I could not recommend this place enough! I would encourage everyone to visit for the lunch buffet, it is truly a deal you cannot beat. I can't wait until we're back in the area so I can visit here again!

Papa Luigi's in Oldtown is super. The New York style Pizza…read moreis outstanding, and the owner has a heart of gold. He consistently does fundraisers and contributes proceeds to families in need. The service is always great and even though it's primarily a take out business, he and his helpers go above and beyond to set a good atmosphere!

My first visit at Papa Luigi's pizza . Small place with a couple table . We ordered a 16 inch…read moreMargarita Pie and it was very delicious. I love thin crust pizza and enjoyed every bite. Papa Luigi is very friendly and entertaining.

This was such a fresh and memorable dining experience. I ordered the lamb gyro plate and everything…read morewas perfect, the lamb was tender, the portion was generous, and the side salad was crisp and refreshing. The broccolini ended up being my favorite part of the plate; garlicky, tender, and so flavorful. My parents' meals looked incredible too, and I snagged a few bites. Everything was light, flavorful, and surprisingly delicious. After a hot day, we wanted something that felt both satisfying and not too heavy, and this meal was exactly what we needed. I would absolutely go back. Our server was attentive but not pushy or forgetful. He came and visited us throughout our meal to make sure everything was good. The manager also asked us personally how everything was as well.

Well the smiling faces you see to greet you when you first walk in the door make an immediate…read moreimpression and makes you definitely feel welcome and sets the pace for the evening. Our appetizer and drink orders taken, we set to decide whether to try the Greek offerings or the Italian! Both looked delicious and the reviews I read previously really set my mouth watering for pizza AND the souvlaki! Unfortunately, my husband got his good old standby, Chicken Parmesan. We both tried different medium pizzas and we ordered Calamari Fritta (but asked for the peppers to not be included) as our appetizer. Have you ever had super fresh REAL calamari? Sliced fresh and hand breaded and then served to you? I had one other time in Tarpon Springs, and this was just as incredibly dished up for us! Marinara sauce and a spicy sweet sauce like a Mae Ploy was also served with them and two nice lemon slices. Stupendous! Our drinks? Perfectly done-- considering our excellent waiter, AJ, didn't know what an Arnold Palmer even was! What a surprising, talented young man! My souvlaki! Absolutely to die for! Wowza! The side I got was the garlic broccolini and YUMMMMM! My husband's chicken parm was so good that he devoured it BEFORE I could even snap a picture! LOL Our pizzas were some of the best we've ever had. The crust is so delicious and they sure don't hold back on the toppings. I consumed half of mine without even realizing it. Wow. I got the Lil' Sicily that has pepperoni, sausage, ricotta, basil and oregano. The hubby chose the Scoula pie that has pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, mushrooms, onions and green peppers. Both were out of this WORLD! Needless to say, I think we just found our newest favorite spot for dinner. So many Greek dishes to keep me happy and plenty of Italian ones to keep the husband happy too! Don't know why we hadn't stopped in before now to try this place!! They are truly a wonderful restaurant and anyone would be hard pressed to find anything wrong with good food at good prices!