Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Five Star Pizza

    3.5 (4 reviews)

    Five Star Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Five Star Pizza

    Recommended Reviews - Five Star Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Hedy D.
    19
    14
    1

    13 years ago

    Delicious! Great taste for low cost. Very, very good. No heartburn later which is even better. Good job! Happy to have in za Newberry!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J C.
    25
    177
    62

    13 years ago

    Consistent pizza at a great price. Delivery service always prompt and friendly. Recommend for those nights you don't want to go out or cook.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Five Star Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,212 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Stone House Neighborhood Grill

    Stone House Neighborhood Grill

    4.0(76 reviews)
    0.6 mi

    Mostly ordering take out, but the few times I sat in the dining room, I had a pleasant experience…read morewith friendly staff and a calm atmosphere. The food is amazing and something I wish I was back in Newberry in so I could enjoy it more.

    Unfortunately, we won't be back…read more That being said, I do want to recognize our server, Ashlyn, who was amazing. She did everything she could to apologize and make the situation right, despite the issues with the kitchen and the misleading wording on the menu. My $30 steak was cooked incorrectly twice. There were also other steaks at our table that were not prepared as ordered, although those guests were willing to settle for what they received. When you're paying that much for a steak, it should be cooked exactly as requested. When my steak was finally corrected, my sides were ice cold, and they were not replaced. By that point, our party of six had finished eating and was ready to leave. Unfortunately, there were several other issues throughout the meal as well, including drinks and other food items that were not up to par. What was most disappointing was that the manager never came by our table to check on our experience, even though things were clearly going wrong. It left me wondering whether the manager was on the cook line dealing with the steaks and simply didn't have time for table visits. I appreciate Ashlyn's effort and professionalism, but unfortunately, the overall experience was not one we would want to repeat. We won't be back.

    Photos
    Stone House Neighborhood Grill
    Stone House Neighborhood Grill
    Stone House Neighborhood Grill - Respectable pickle chips

    See all

    Respectable pickle chips

    SquareHouse Pizza - EDIT: Green color is NOT mold but oxidized garlic.

    SquareHouse Pizza

    4.5(187 reviews)
    16.7 mi
    $$

    I often went to SquareHouse Pizza thinking it would be like when they first opened, but it makes…read moresense after they separated from Satchels it would never be the same. I have come time and time again disappointed with the pizza size and the time it took to make it. Size: Pizza used to come in the size of their box! As you can see in my picture, that is no longer the case. It is no longer an actual square like its namesake but a rectangle. It reminds me of "all squares are rectangles, but not all rectangles are squares." And while it makes me chuckle to think how SquareHouse should know that. I am still disappointed in paying for that much of a pizza when I could get a larger one to share with friends at the same price point elsewhere. Service: Now I understand they can get busy but one time I waited 25 minutes with only one person ahead of me for my food -- a before anyone says anything. I ordered their waffles. Another time, they never called my name. They have a speaker but don't use it. It is a food park with tables everywhere. If you don't use the speaker system and know folks sit further than you can scream, then I think they should give a beeper. Ambience: It's at the food park which is great as long as it's not raining bc spaces to sit under covered areas are limited. And bc it was previously partnered with Satchels it has the same vibe. Overall, go once if you haven't but just be ready for disappointment Update since writing to address the comments of the business owner: 1) When I say first opened, I meant when it was called SatchSquared. 2) Size of the pizza: You're right I looked at pictures and updated. They aren't squares but from one years ago. They definitely filled the box more. 3) I sincerely don't appreciate being told about waiting or orders ahead and phone calls. I have come here more than 20 times and my experiences are always the same. I've come at opening, during high traffic times, and etc. And I am not someone to review after one instance of a place, I like to give them chances. I have lived in Gainesville for 17 years, and I'm very well aware of being polite to residents. I have definitely sat in the tables in the covered area close to the pick up window and have had to ask if my food was ready bc my name was not called and just to find out it was ready. I gave a suggestion about using beepers like the other places. I'm sorry my review caused some upset feeling but I stand by it. Service is not great. If you wanted to discuss via email then you could've politely said that. I won't be returning. Thanks!

    Love this place! The pizza is always fresh, delicious and piping hot. The inventive flavor…read morecombinations keep me coming back. While my favorite is the Mariah Curry with chicken -- a fun name for a tasty curry pizza with just the right amount of spice -- I also recommend checking out the specials sign by the register, as there are usually some hidden gems. Also love that this is part of 4th Ave Food Park, a great place to go with friends, pups and/or kids.

    Photos
    SquareHouse Pizza - Where you pick up joy

    Where you pick up joy

    SquareHouse Pizza - Square Cheese Pizza pepperoni

    Square Cheese Pizza pepperoni

    SquareHouse Pizza - Depot park sitting area

    See all

    Depot park sitting area

    Scuola Pizza - House Salad

    Scuola Pizza

    4.4(130 reviews)
    15.0 mi
    $$

    updated review here…read more. So glad to see this restaurant doing so well, their menu has grown from when we last ate here. We met some friends here for dinner and they love it.from the friendly attentive staff, the atmosphere of the restaurant is very unique , and i always find something new on the walls to stare at or at least ask about or take a photo of. We opted to try the pizza we got a prosciutto pizzs and the athena pizza Both were very rich in taste and ingredients. We all ended up bringing some leftovers home. Definietely worth the visit!! And its in my neighborhood, making it that much more convenient.

    Reserved seating for 6 for a Saturday lunch and had great table service from Seth. The owners…read morevisited us as well to ask how our food was and everything was top-notch. We ordered several pizzas (1 garlic 16", 1 two-topping 12" with prosciutto + roasted garlic, 1 Hawaiian 12", 1 pita pizza with ham) plus ravioli fritti appetizer and steak pesto. Pizzas were excellent , steak was soft / medium well as I requested, and ravioli was deliciously crunchy - a crowd pleaser. The others had never tried Scuola before and now they'll all be back for the great food , friendly service, as well as chill ambiance of the place. Highly recommend visiting during lunch time since it's not too crowded and still quiet enough to hear one another at a table. The owner stopped by our table before we left and graciously offered to take a photo for us so thank you for that. Always a pleasure to meet the management. Pricing was fair considering the large portions and quality of the food. We had separate checks so our share of the food (including a to go order of Chicken Souvlaki and Kokkinisto!) was about $125 with generous tip. Free parking lot outside the restaurant is shared but there were still many spots to choose from. We'll certainly be back again ^_^ !!

    Photos
    Scuola Pizza - Entry Lobby

    Entry Lobby

    Scuola Pizza - Greeks salad

    Greeks salad

    Scuola Pizza - House Salad

    See all

    House Salad

    Five Star Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...