Fort Hamilton Diner

Came here with my father for an early lunch because the place looked cool!…read more I ordered the breakfast burrito and when it came out there was only egg and cheese in there. When I brought it to the waitresses attention she said it comes with either bacon or sausage and I was like, okay you didn't ask so I wasn't aware. To which she responded that it was on the menu and proceeded to bring over the menu for me to read as if I couldn't understand her. I was really tired that morning so I guess that parts on me for just reading what I want and ordering it, but as someone who's work in the service industry you also clarify what the customer would like. I never said I wanted ONLY eggs. Just the way she handled it was really rude when I didn't even make a fuss I was just confused why there was nothing in my burrito weird energy here if you're not a white townie. Glad my father got to enjoy his corned beef hash though. Only positive in this experience.

Finally got a chance to patron one of the many restaurants in Bay Ridge that I have wanted to try…read moreand the Wicked Monk did not disappoint. Came in as a party of two on a rainy Sunday for their brunch menu and was quickly seated and served. Waiters/waitresses were very attentive and quick to give us menus, waters, take our orders, and clear our empty plates when we finished the app/food. Definitely has a pub/sports bar vibe with bar seating and multiple screens broadcasting pretty much all the sunday NFL games. But they also had ample seating for larger parties and families and it definitely seems like a place that locals visit often. The food was great, though we wouldve liked to try the chicken empanadas if we noticed it on the menu early. Oh wells, maybe next time!

0.1 mi•Fort Hamilton, Bay Ridge

The Monk.

Chicken pot pie

See all

Inside The Wicked Monk.

Bagel Supreme

3.6(84 reviews)

I really like to stop here for bagels and coffee. Always a friendly atmosphere and quick service…read more I can always count on fresh delicious bagels and coffee that brightens my day. I need to remember to take a picture. I get so excited I forget, lol.

Given my location, the overall taste, and the value, I'd say this is my favorite bagel place in…read moreFort Hamilton. Service is usually quick, though at the usual busy times there can be a bit of a wait. The BEC is always nicely filled, and when I ask for hot sauce (as I usually do), they put a good amount, unlike some other places nearby. Also, they toast their bagels just a little more than others so the outside has a nice crispness, while the inside was still soft. I feel like this place costs maybe 25 cents more than others in the area but it feels worth it. Ambiance is what it is: there are a few tables for people to sit at, but the vast majority are there to order and go. Great local spot.

0.1 mi•Fort Hamilton, Bay Ridge

Hard pass

See all

French toast bagels

Mr Bagels Cafe

3.5(31 reviews)

Great spot and opens at 6AM! We had scoped this out as a…read moremust-visit in the morning after packing up for the long drive back to Toronto on the last day of our trip. That was such a perfect idea. First thing we were there, and it was a warm and sultry morning at 6:30AM with the sun up to greet us along with a New York bridge adorning the scene to the south, with us eating outside on the sidewalk I could not imagine a better send off from this great world city. Bagels were a perfect breakfast and we sucked those back in a jiffy. Just as we were finishing, members of the US military, maybe national guardsmen, showed up in black SUVs right in front of us and parked. They got out, a gaggle of them and headed in for their bagels. Well that's something to remember and not an every day sight for us being from Canada, and added to the local flavour of this epic road trip.

Working in a new neighborhood is always a challenge. It's like you're the new kid in school, you…read moreneed to find out the lay of the land. Well, I went to my first bagel spot in Ft Hamilton. I pulled up and I see "Mr" Bagels cafe. For Brooklyn, it sounds like pure class. I'm sure the owner must have a pinky ring. Walking inside, the bagel counter are front and center. To the left, is a coffee bar with multiple coffee choices. Nice looking spot. I ask for a Sesame Bagel with Cream Cheese. Would you like that toasted sir? Wait a second Years ago, I asked for my bagel toasted at Murrays Bagels in Chelsea. The guy behind the counter? He lost his mind! The next day, they put up a hand written sign: No Toasted Bagels So I'm always lerry when asking for extras. Except the bagel guy asked me so I feel relaxed. I pour myself a cup of delicious French Roast Coffee and my bagel is ready. The bagel is perfect. It has a nice chew, just a little too big but thats my personal taste. The cream cheese, even though it's plain, is very silky. Mr Bagels, thank you. Until we meet again.

0.2 mi•Fort Hamilton, Bay Ridge

See all

You can see where we sat on stools at the little table along the window with the New York bridge in the background.

Subway

2.8(19 reviews)

I'm always in a mood for a Veggie Delite, thus, I stopped by the 4th Avenue location to pick one…read moreup. I love the smell of the bread when walking into a Subway.. it really wakes my nose up.. I ordered the Veggie with the usual suspects: spinach, black olives, red onion, provolone, pickles and green peppers with a little mayo and red wine and vinegar on whole wheat. The location is small but.. and this is big.. the sandwich maker was the sweetest person! I think this has to be one of the friendlier Subway restaurants. I added ice tea and Sun Chips to make it a combo. She really packed on the veggies and was very efficient. I took my sandwich to go and first bite...yummmmmm! This has become my new favorite Subway!

Great sandwich, the service is great, he's a friendly guy, works fast. I like the location, close…read moreto all conveniences

0.2 mi•Fort Hamilton, Bay Ridge

See all

Charlie’s Sandwich Shop

4.4(121 reviews)

"Charlie's Sandwich Shop is a popular neighborhood eatery in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, celebrated for…read moreits hearty Italian-style heroes and daily hot specials made with freshly stretched mozzarella" Question: what makes a sandwich great? The bread? The meat? The condiments? The sauce.. gravy, francese, red sauce? The originality? What happens if you find all of the above in one shop? And where would you find it? Answer: Charlie's Sandwich Shop I am a long time resident of Bay Ridge and this is THE FIRST time I have tried a sandwich here. Mind you, my friends have raved about it. The shop is a gem and the options are plentiful. Every sandwich offered sounds delicious and there are weekly specials like Shrimp Parmigiana and Chicken Francese. I decided to go with the "How You Doing" sammy which consists of fried chicken cutlets, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella on a toasted hero bread.The preparation took around ten minutes but the wait was worth it. The craftsman who prepared it handed it to me and said " Now here's a sandwich and it is going to take a bit to finish".* I replied " Yeah, a whole week"! Lol! I love the charm of the place; there are little gems, statues, pictures, menus adorning walls, counter and behind the scenes. Charlie's Sandwich Shop in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn is owned by Charlie Bellomo along with his father, Salvatore Bellomo. This duo are serving "grand slams" sandwich style. I see many sandwiches in my future not just for me. How you doin? Just fine after tasting this delicious work of art! * take a look at my sandwich pic, tell me it is not the size of a boat? I had a 1/3 of it and saved the rest for future meal.

- cash only - fast service (~20 min per order)…read more- tasty chicken sandwich - tasty pastrami

0.3 mi•Fort Hamilton, Bay Ridge

Cash wrap

6. The How You Doin: boat size

See all

Funny signs

Paneantico Bakery

3.5(505 reviews)

- really nice service - ice lemonade is sweet…read more- really good desserts - my mom liked the sausage and rice pause - coffee was alright - i like the fact that there's seating

Came in yesterday and asked for table service outside, was told to have a seat and that the…read morewaitress would come and take care of me. 15 minutes of sitting outside, no one came to me. I let the girl at the front know and left. Please keep in mind it was a 90 degree day, I did see a waitress take care of the already occupied area but she never walked over to me. It was peak lunchtime so I found it very odd to not notice someone sitting in your area. Signed, A Pregnant woman who was looking forward to lunch.

Giant cinnamon rolls

See all

Pasticiotti (or maybe a Pasta Croce.) Unique chocolate filling with some citrus. Favorite of the bunch

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Janine P.

Elite 26

168

170

349

4 months ago

Fort Hamilton Diner is one of the greatest unsolved mysteries of Brooklyn. Every time we walk in, the place is practically empty, as if the entire neighborhood collectively decided to ignore the best food within a five‑mile radius. I don't know if people think it's too affordable, or if they're intimidated by the concept of flavor, but the fact that this diner isn't packed feels like a social experiment no one told us we were part of. The Food I ordered the focaccia with herb chicken and mozzarella, minus the bacon, plus a mountain of fries and a bowl of chicken soup that could fix childhood trauma. The focaccia was warm and pillowy, but the chicken... the chicken was so juicy and flavorful that I'm convinced they either brine it, braise it, or whisper ancient culinary incantations over it. Whatever the method, it works. And the mozzarella? They didn't sprinkle it. They didn't "add a touch." They deployed it. Easily a third to half a pound of molten dairy glory blanketing the entire sandwich like it was being tucked in for a long winter's nap. The chicken soup was unmistakably homemade -- that collagen-rich broth that clings to your lips like it's trying to sign a lease. Boxed broth could never. Bouillon cubes could never. This was soup with depth, soul, and possibly a moral compass. Meanwhile, the man ordered the gyro platter with curly fries and immediately ascended into a state of bliss normally reserved for people who discover unexpected tax refunds. He inhaled everything except a few curly fries, and considering the portions could feed a family of three, that's both impressive and mildly concerning. The Service One man -- one -- ran the entire front of the house. He greeted people, poured drinks, handled takeout orders, delivered plates, closed checks, and probably mediated international conflicts in the back when no one was looking. The man deserves a raise, a trophy, and possibly a parade. The Value Our total was about $46 for two overflowing plates, a bowl of soup, a soda, and a hot tea. In 2026, that's basically a public service. I've paid more for sandwiches that tasted like printer paper. Final Thoughts Fort Hamilton Diner is a hidden gem, a neighborhood treasure, and frankly, a place that deserves far more foot traffic than it gets. Consistent, delicious, affordable, and run by people who actually care -- it's the kind of diner you want to gatekeep but also want to scream about from the rooftops. read more

Gus S.

8 years ago

I love grabbing a burger from here. Always fresh and always made just the way I like it. I came and had the avocado burger today and it was bomb. They are open all the time and perfect for those nights when you've had too much fun at the local bar and want a good diner bite to eat to sober back up in a good way. The food is so good here I highly recommend if you're in the area to stop by. read more

Katie K.

13 years ago

I have been coming here for 3 month,I really love this place. Still one of my favorites!!! The food was delicious: very authentic, perfectly cooked. The service in here is great,the staff is always friendly without being intrusive, and you feel so nice here within a great atmosphere. read more

Barbara B.

17 years ago

I love the Ft. Hamilton Diner. If you know what you want, you ask for it. The world is your oyster if you know what you want. The prices are a little high - but it's Bay Ridge! 5 stars. read more

Devin S.

7 years ago

If I could give half a star I would terrible food took them five hours to get our food and non of which any one ordered terrible terrible terrible would never eat thyr again . read more

Hussein K.

7 years ago

Great place to go and get a midnight bite there open 24 hours and the food is amazing

marina y.

13 years ago

meh..not bad but barely worth reviewing

John E.

14 years ago

what happened to the prices here????

Fort Hamilton Diner - diners - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Fort Hamilton Diner also viewed

Gus' American Grill

4.2

(97 reviews)

I've never felt more disrespected or disappointed in a diner. While working in the neighborhood, I…read morevisited this diner because a coworker recommended it. Initially, the prices seemed fair, and the owner appeared friendly and accommodating. However, I soon noticed something off. When my breakfast was served, items I hadn't ordered were included, and the owner insisted I take them, causing my bill to rise significantly. I didn't say anything and just paid. The next day, it happened again, and when I questioned him about the high bill, he insulted me, saying I ate too much. I had thought he was nice, but this showed a different side of him. Despite being a hardworking and respectful customer, I felt unwelcome. On my last visit, the owner was unfriendly from the start. He complained about my indecisiveness, even embarrassing me in front of other customers by saying if I found the prices too high, I could go elsewhere. This negative experience overshadowed what could have been a great diner, and I won't be returning.

Firstly and I consider this very important the man who runs this place is the nicest person. He…read moregreets you warmly and works hard to ensure you get what you want. His service stands out. Now for the food which is quite delicious. The ingredients are good and the dishes are well cooked. My wife and I typically get breakfast there. She loved the spinach and feta omelette. The fact that it is offered with rye toast is a delicious addition. I've tried the pancakes which are light, fluffy and tasty. I've also had the Italian omelette with the rye toast of course. It was delicious and fresh tasting. I highly recommend this place, anyone who treats his customers as warmly as this man does while serving good food deserves a lot of business.

The Coffee Club

3.2

(98 reviews)

The man and I were in the mood for diner food, but the diner closest to our house is basically an…read moreover-priced fast-food outlet. I came to Yelp to do some searching and up pops The Coffee Club. What the hell...We decided to give it a shot. We walk in and it's set up like an old school diner. Front-counter seats, and diner booths; Exactly what we were hoping for. We have a seat and start off with coffee while we browse the menu. I gotta be honest: The coffee was awful. It tasted burnt and acidic as hell. Ugh... Service was on point. There was one waitress taking care of absolutely everyone: Every booth and every customer at the counter. She had us all under control. Brava! The man ordered two eggs over easy, corned beef hash, potatoes, and rye toast. I ordered an Italian omelette, potatoes and white toast. The two eggs over easy were perfect. The corned beef hash was absolutely delicious. The potatoes had room for a little salt and pepper, but they were perfectly cooked. The Italian omelette was delectable. My potatoes and toast were just as perfect. The bill for both meals and (awful) coffee was $25. Incredibly affordable, extraordinary meals; Just need to order a different beverage, next time. Definitely planning on visiting again.

The customer service was horrible. The woman who was waiting on us around 6pm on Thursday, July…read more23rd was extremely rude and started yelling at us when we quietly brought up how we felt about how she was towards us. She then got on the phone and said I can't talk about this I'm on the phone. I was embarrassed and discussed by her.

Mirage Diner

3.2

(252 reviews)

Love this place I've been coming here 26 years no Joke…read more Place is spotless- reasonable and staff is Great. Prices are fair. Highly recommend

Mirage Diner is one of those places I end up at without planning it. Like you're in Midwood, you…read moredid a couple errands, everyone's getting cranky, and you're like "fine, diner." And it always works. What's funny is it never looks that busy when you first walk in. You sit down and you're like oh nice, plenty of space... then you look up and somehow every booth is taken and there's people standing by the front. It fills up outta nowhere. Food is what you want from a diner -- big menu, big portions, comes out hot. I mostly do breakfast stuff even if it's not morning (omelette/home fries/pancakes depending on the mood). The home fries are actually good, not those sad bland cubes. Eggs come how you ask. Pancakes are fluffy. Coffee is just coffee, but they keep refilling it so I'm not complaining. Service is straight diner energy. They're moving fast, not doing a whole friendly routine, but they're paying attention. If it's slammed you might wait a bit to get seated and they'll be kinda brisk, but you're not getting ignored. Not some "wow" meal, but it's reliable and filling and easy, which is honestly why I keep going back.

McDonald Avenue Diner

4.5

(18 reviews)

McDonald Ave Diner has great food and great prices along with great service! Like they say it's a…read moreno brainer!

l love traditional diners and I love friendly restaurants. So it was a no brainer that I was going…read moreto love the McDonald Avenue Diner which is conveniently located near the F train Avenue I station across the street from ShoprRite supermarket! Previously I had stopped in for coffee but finally today I met longtime friend here for a late breakfast. I had two scrambled eggs, well done home fries, rye toast with butter and regular bacon (with coffee of course!) while my buddy had two fried eggs, well done home fries, rye toast with butter and turkey bacon (with coffee of course :-). Both breakfasts were delicious! Service was friendly - in fact the entire staff made us feel welcome - the food was served as ordered and the prices were reasonable ~ so yes, this place has earned its five stars! My one regret is that my pal, the late Yelper, Jim D, was not still alive to read my review because the guy lived for great diners!

Pier 69 Market

4.2

(142 reviews)

Still a nice spot close to the pier to gran a bite to eat and coffee after run or race along the…read morepier. They offer up some fresh made muffins on site too, and a tasty egg on a roll.

Cute little cafe in Bay Ridge. Small menu, but good quality and food made right. Chicken parm…read moresandwich really tasty, buffalo chicken strips sandwich very good, not too spicy but a nice kick with good bread. Chicken avocado wrap also really good. Egg, potato, and cheese on brioche was very good too, they added a little spice to it and the potatoes had a nice amount of onions...all really delicious. Avocado toast has a good amount of avocado and is nicely made. Lattes good too. A good choice for a quick but tasty breakfast or lunch.

Ave R Mini Mart

3.7

(27 reviews)

I come here every time I want a delicious cold cut, a cold drink, and snacks. They have a wide…read morevariety of things to choose from, and I always find what I want. Definitely recommend this place.

I have bought food here Multiple times. I still have a half eaten muffin from them. Today, I asked…read morethem to please help me change my (1%) phone. I know they are not obligated to, as that is not a service they provide, but I think nuance and goodwill went out the window. The food might be good, but kindness, humanity and compassion - 0 stars. Capitalism is truly the devil.

Oasis Diner Restaurant

3.8

(268 reviews)

Great breakfast Will be coming back with the whole family…read more Can't wait to return and the staff is the best in the neighborhood

Visited this cute, cozy diner on New Year's Day and my party of three was seated immediately. I…read moreordered a crab omelette, which came with toast and home fries. The service was attentive, and we were able to place our order fairly quickly upon deciding. I knocked off a star because we ordered two pancakes for the table, but recieved three. When we immediately let the server know, she did not acknowledge the mistake or attempt to amend it. We already had a lot of food, so we ordered two because we knew we wouldn't be able to finish more than that. I did enjoy my omelette - I've never had a crabmeat omelette before and as a pescatarian, I was glad to see that option on the menu. It was flavorful and there was a substantial amount of crabmeat tucked inside. The pancakes were a bit dry and dense, so not our favorite. Overall, it was a nice, filling meal to start the year.

Perry's Restaurant

3.6

(123 reviews)

Perry's seemingly appeared out of nowhere. One minute I had been walking on a familiar street in my…read moreneighborhood, lost in thought on a cold, drizzly night. And then-there it was across the street, a glow emitting from the warm lights within. When you walk in, you immediately feel the comfort of home, like you are at an old relative's house. You don't quite know how, but you know whatever you get will be good and that there will be plenty to take home for later. If you are in the mood for breakfast, get the Spanish omelet. The stewed vegetables will remind you of your mother's soup, and that you should call her. In the interim, chew thoughtfully on the pickles and chickpea sides that is placed on your table. You will want dessert. Get a slice of whatever the waiter recommends. You will leave wondering if it had all been a dream, but a full stomach will remind you it had not.

We went in during weeknight dinner with the family and got a booth in the corner. This place isn't…read morereally busy on a weeknight dinner so we managed to feast in privacy. The waitress was cute and funny and took our order in Brooklyn fashion- kind and sarcastic. The inside looks like an old timey diner with lots of seating and room for people. I can imagine a lot of people come here for breakfast. The parking garage was quite full when we arrived but most people left after 7pm. We got a lot of things including: roast chicken dinner special, steak with shrimp scampi, filet Mignon, penne patraso, linguine bolognese, side of spinach, green beans for a party of 6 and when we received it it was so large I couldn't believe my eyes. For the price point the food definitely serves up the portions- and even more. I thought their pasta dishes were really tasty and the steak with shrimp scampi was really good- I think the filet Mignon was slightly undercooked but that's probably because they cooked it at once when we got TWO whole pieces. I didn't know their steak dishes had two full pieces. I think that's where I wish they have cooked each filet Mignon piece separately vs together. I think it would've made the steak much better cooked. Their roast chicken dish special was pretty much an entire chicken and I was a little shocked with the portions and super full to be thinking about extras however they didn't give us the dessert after the chicken but we were too full to think about dessert- basically we didn't make it through the meal! I definitely took some leftovers home and had an entire other meal for lunch the next day!

Boca Del Cielo

4.1

(76 reviews)

Boca Del Cielo - Bay Ridge Brunch Gem…read more I stopped by Boca de Cielo in the Bay Ridge area for brunch with the kids, and it turned out to be such a cozy and welcoming spot. You order your food at the front counter, and while we waited, the owner surprised us with a complimentary almond croissant since it was our first visit. It was absolutely delicious -- flaky, fresh, and easily one of the best almond croissants I've ever had. The menu has a great variety of options. We went with the steak and eggs and buttermilk street pancakes. The steak was tender and full of flavor, the home fries were seasoned perfectly, and the pancakes were fluffy and delicious. We also tried the Tropical Bliss Juice, a refreshing blend of pineapple, mango, and orange that's freshly pressed to order. From the warm decor to the amazing food and friendly service, everything about this place was fantastic. I can't wait to come back and try more items on their menu!

This place never misses. It's been a while since I have stopped by but finally had a chance today…read more Although the cooks are different the quality and taste of the food hasn't changed - still good, y'all! Today, I deviated from my norm and got the beet boost (the ginger shined through - which I loved); I got the steak wrap w/o tomatoes - definitely good. This came w/a salad (but your cheapy iceberg lettuce ;) and balsamic drizzle - all in all, a delicious meal. The seating has definitely changed the quality of the food and dranks are still fire

Savor Gourmet Market & Cafe

3.8

(19 reviews)